5 Reasons The Joker Isn't The Greatest Comic Book Villain

Numerous villains can do everything the Joker can do and more - and that's putting it mildly.

By K.J. Stewart /

The Joker is a great villain - that is indisputable. But THE greatest? Come on. All too often the Clown Prince of Gotham and Batman's arch-nemesis appears at the top of those "greatest comic book villain" lists - and this is outright wrong for a variety of reasons. They're basing his placing on popularity and nothing more and, sure, he IS very popular - probably THE most popular comic book villain - but that doesn't make him the greatest. There are far more important factors, when it comes to naming someone the greatest at what they do, than popularity. Otherwise Cristiano Ronaldo would be one of the worst footballers in the world and David Beckham would be the best player who ever lived. Numerous villains can do everything the Joker can do and more - and that's putting it mildly. Despite what seems to be a common opinion, there isn't really a single aspect of the Joker's character that is the pinnacle of comic book examples. On that note, we're going to look at the specific things that show that the Joker is not all he is so often made out to be. Here are five reasons why the Joker is not the greatest comic book villain...

5. Clowns Are Lame

Joker's theme is essentially that of a clown. And, come on now, the clown shtick is old and lame. Granted, he's not your typical circus clown, but a gimmick that includes flowers that squirt stuff, Jack-in-the-boxes, hand buzzers and white face paint is as near as dammit to one of the most corny and annoying types of individual that exists in the world today. And sure, it's creepy, but it's just more silly than anything else. The Joker has certainly evolved over the years to become more sinister and murderous but, at some point, a complete reinvention may well be in order as the clown theme can't last forever before it starts to become ridiculous.

4. He's Not That Tough Or Powerful

Power isn't everything, of course, but when there are characters who have everything the Joker offers (an array of gadgets, a genius intelligence, a murderous personality etc) and power to boot, it's mad to say he's "better" than they are. Look at Doctor Doom - he's a mere human, just like the Joker. However, he has bettered himself to the point of wearing an advanced technological suit of armour (of his own creation) that essentially grants him superpowers. He has also learnt to use magic, which grants him further powers. And this is on top of the fact that his intelligence and ability to scheme and plan utterly dwarfs that of the Joker. As a result, Doom is a threat to far more powerful heroes and beings than the Joker ever will be. Basically, unless he gets his hands on some serious power (which, of course, he has done on one single occasion - in the "Emperor Joker" arc), he's really only a threat to street-level guys like Batman. If any of the big-hitters in the DC universe really wanted to get rid of him, they could theoretically do so in a heartbeat - and the only reason Batman hasn't done so is because, in his own weird way, he needs the Joker to represent his antithesis or anathema. In a sense, the Joker gives him an ongoing purpose. If Batman really wanted Joker out of the equation, he could have made that so by now. Joker can fight - no doubt about that - but there are countless human villains who could beat the hell out of him (Kingpin, Red Skull, Lady Shiva, the Mandarin - even without the rings - and Ra's Al Ghul to name but a few).

3. He Only Really Bothers One Hero

Okay, so this isn't strictly the case. He has bothered - and indeed killed other heroes (the Jason Todd version of Robin, for example) - but it's all with only one man in mind (Batman, of course). Truly great villains have bigger ambitions and are threats to entire teams of heroes and the universe as a whole. Even when Joker became all-powerful in the Emperor Joker storyline, he focused most of his cosmic abilities on torturing and killing Batman every single day. In other words, even when he's got the power to do whatever he wants, he barely knows what to do with it (not on the same level as certain other characters, anyway). Thanos, Doctor Doom, Kang the Conqueror, Darkseid, Apocalypse, Loki, Gorilla Grodd and Brainiac - for example - are a few villains whose schemes regularly cause trouble for entire teams of superheroes and some of those characters, when in possession of real power (such as the Infinity Gauntlet, the Power Cosmic or the Heart of the Universe), don't just focus the majority of their attention on one man, because they're bigger than that. Joker can cause - and indeed has caused - trouble for other heroes, but other villains do it better.

2. There Are More Intelligent Villains

As previously touched upon, the Joker is indeed renowned for his mind - scheming, planning, manipulation and psychological warfare - but he's not even close to being the most intelligent villain in comic books. He can build the most basic of gadgets, is an expert in the field of chemicals and can play very clever mind-games that expose Batman's weaknesses like a gaping wound - but his genius pales in to insignificance against the very best villainous minds in comics. The aforementioned Doctor Doom is an expert in all fields of advanced science and technology, as well as the mystic arts, while the High Evolutionary has evolved his intelligence to the upper limit of human potential, and is the only human whose intelligence and knowledge has been described as equal to certain cosmic entities. Darkseid and Thanos are experts in technology beyond the Joker's comprehension. Even Lex Luthor, who is merely a human just like Joker, deals with a far more powerful foe in Superman and creates far more powerful gadgets (such as his Power Armour) and has political and business genius in addition to his technological genius. Essentially, Joker's a clever guy - he's just nowhere near as clever as countless other villains and his repertoire of expertise is nowhere near as vast.

1. He's Not Even The Most Insane Comic Book Character

Most of what makes Joker so great is the sheer unpredictability that stems from his insanity. However, there are characters who are as crazy as, and even crazier than, he is. Sometimes a villain, Deadpool, for example, makes the Joker seem relatively sane. He's so mentally unstable that he talks to the reader - breaking the fourth wall - has imaginary friends and has actually thought that if he killed a man he would become him. That's crazy. Look at Red Skull. There's nothing remotely sane about holding a gun up to a baby's head and shooting it. And there's certainly nothing sane about being a Nazi all those years after World War II had ended. Look at Mad Jim Jaspers (the clue is in the name). He was a mutant with the power to warp reality on a universal scale (essentially the same power that the Joker briefly had as Emperor Joker) and this had the side effect of quickly driving him mad - being driven mad by a power capable of changing the universe... that's madness. And then there's the Green Goblin - so crazy that he split in to two personalities who talked to each other. The Joker was never driven that mad. Essentially, the Joker is insane - there's absolutely no doubting that - but it's hardly a unique trait and there are arguably characters whose craziness dwarfs even his. So there you have it - five reasons why the Joker is not the greatest comic book villain. Do you agree? What else could show that Joker isn't the greatest comic book villain? Are we completely out of order with this article? Let us know in the comments box below. And please feel free to follow me on Twitter!