Wouldn't you enjoy seeing Captain America toss Wolverine out of a plane at 35,000 ft. over the Arctic Circle? Or watching Namor the Submariner conjuring lakes of fire over the skies of Wakanda? What about a giant mythical dragon (in combination with what is known as the cosmic Phoenix Force) embruing a young girl, Hope Summers, with the power of bad-assery to defeat a power-hungry, snarling Cyclops? I get it. You're incredibly confused, and you should be. This is the ridiculum of Avengers Vs. X-Men, or AvX, the recently completed Marvel Comics epic that sold over 1 and a half million issues over the 12-issue arc. Recently, Lauren Shuler Donner, producer of the X-Men series, said that she'd love to, "mingle them the way they were written." Obviously, with the success of 'The Avengers' and the looming possibility of a Justice League movie at Warner Bros. studios are buying into the more-the-merrier model that Joss Whedon's summer blockbuster readily captured. But the AvX series was nothing to write home about. Yes, it dominated in terms of sales, but it's not a series that translates into film. Despite that harsh reality and the difficulty of 20th Century Fox and Marvel ever coming together on a deal to actually get it made, there's still talk of a film adaptation nonetheless. So, due to my unrelenting, superhuman senses of spite and snark, I couldn't help but compile 5 reasons AvX shouldn't be brought to the silver screen.
5. It's Not Well Written
Something in the quote from Donner got me thinking. Something about the mingling of characters. AvX didn't mingle their characters terribly well. The plot, too ambitious (even for a comic book) and the scripts were disjointedly written by Marvel's best and brightest (at gunpoint, I assume). Theoretically, it's a great idea: Brian Michael Bendis, Matt Fraction, Ed Brubaker, Ed McGuinness, Joe Kubert, and anybody else Marvel can scare up, all writing a comic book together. I'm sold. In theory, I'm sold. But the practicality of having all those talents in one room (not in a Google chat, not on email threads) writing and workshopping the book is a superhuman feat in itself. And it probably happened once, if at all. So, to me, each individual's issue seemed to play too closely to their strengths. Brubaker was hard-boiled. Fraction was cosmic, spacey, and Iron Man centric. Bendis just wanted the Avengers to just get along, and show us how many puns Spider-Man can get in an issue. Everyone wanted their moment in the sun or in the caustic blinding light of the Phoenix Force, in this case. Imagine that mentality in a screenwriters meeting: pitting the best and brightest in comics' egos and narratives against one another, all the while trying to develop an intelligible story arc that translates into film. The overall arc in the comics, however, lacked luster, with throwaway plot points and a conclusion that left me wondering why I'd even followed the series. (Nova? He's your go-to-guy?). Iron Man's attempted solution to mitigate the Phoenix force: Screw it, I'll build a giant robot and we'll blow it up. Cable's lack of involvement in any substantial way most of his stories in the past 8 years have centered around protecting Hope Summers, the mutant messiah. The Phoenix Five and their astoundingly slutty choices in costuming, both male and female. Or maybe it was Hope's climactic transformation into Phoenix in the final issue, when she proclaims, "I am fire and life incarnate. Now and forever." Until about 10 frames later when she decides that it's not worth the trouble, 'cause she's, like, really good friends with Scarlet Witch now and she told her not to. In the end, there was little finality. Sure a major character died (I'm not going to ruin it for you, yet) and there was drama, albeit forced, but that happens to major characters in comics on an annual basis. It's easy to kill a good guy for taking his own sense of righteousness to its fullest extent. It's easy to forge an unquestionable, circumstantial martyr. But it doesn't make it good writing.
4. Studios Don't Share
Lauren Shuler Donner knows superhero movies. Her late husband, Richard Donner, was responsible for 'Superman: The Movie' and the world is a better place for it. It was an astounding success. Years later, Lauren Shuler Donner would embark on a cinematic superhero quest of her own, reigniting the caped craze with Bryan Singer's 'X-Men,' which she produced, along with every other X-Men film. In Donner's interview with Crave Online, she mentioned she had worked with Marvel Studios head Kevin Feige previously, and that if he was on board she would be as well. Despite their cozy relationship, the difficulty of this coming to fruition is close to zero. Fox has the X-Men franchise; Sony, Spider-man. And Paramount has the highest-grossing superhero movie ever in 'The Avengers.' It's a recession, why share the wealth? Hell it rarely happens in comics. Fans twisted Marvel and DC's arms for years to combine, and they have, with mixed results. Of course, this was before Marvel was acquired by Disney and thusly given the keys to the Magic Kingdom, budget-wise. The prospect of a three-headed behemoth of this sort is out of the question.
3. There Are Just Too Many Characters
Sure, AvX was utterly kick-ass. It chaotically combined more Marvel superheroes than you can spin a web at, all under one roof, where they usually beat each other to a bloodily impossible pulp. And there was some kiddie pool depth to the storyline I enjoyed the Black Panther/Storm rift and the inclusion of the mythical K'un Lun from Iron Fist mythos in particular. But therein lies the obscurity. Both Black Panther and Iron Fist are two of my favorite characters in the Marvel Universe, but they've never been addressed on film (which is reprehensible, if you're asking me). And they play a key role in the series. Their two homelands Wakanda and K'un Lun, respectively are backdrops for some of the series' most memorable scenes. But who outside of a comic convention's heard of K'un Lun and Wakanda? Characters have baggage. That's why we watch movies and read comic books. That baggage makes good drama. But it's damn near impossible to unpack baggage and establish characters like Giant Man, Magik, The Watcher, Legion, Vision, or Ms. Marvel when nobody's ever heard of them (we'll encounter this later at no. 1. ).
2. They've Already Killed Patrick Stewart On Film
Sorry, folks. Charles Xavier's dead. Cyclops killed him. For now, until Marvel needs to sell more books and they bring him back. You can't backpedal on film like you can in comics. (Or maybe you can? I'm looking at you Spider-Man reboot). Xavier died talking Cyclops down from turning the entire world into an irreparable fustercluck. He didn't succeed. Similarly, Sir Patrick Stewart's Xavier died on celluloid in the deplorable 'X3: The Last Stand,' and despite his resurgence in 'X-Men: First Class,' played adeptly by James McAvoy. He's out of the picture on film for a while, kind of. He's rumored to appear in 'X-Men: Days of Future Past,' due to a "time-travel element." But that doesn't count because those X-Men will not be fighting any Avengers, lets hope. Donner's X-Men films employ a hermetically sealed timeline free of Avengers and will continue to do so until someone else comes along to revamp the film mythos entirely; ala Christopher Nolan's treatment of Tim Burton's in the Dark Knight trilogy. Professor X served a meaningful, Obi-Wan-like role to Cyclops' (to quote 'Curb Your Enthusiasm') mopey dick Darth Vader. Cyclops kills Xavier and stoically repents, saying he'd want more than anything for their places to be switched. And I agree completely. In a perfect AvX, Cyclops would've been killed, allowing Marvel to re-invent a perennially, predictably stale character. But this is all a moot point. Xavier's dead. Sure, they could recast him, but why the hell would you go with anyone else besides Jean Luc Picard? I mean Patrick Stewart.
5. Civil War Is A Better Storyline
While the likelihood of AvX may be implausible, at best, the chances of seeing Mark Millar's 'Civil War' series on the silver screen may be in the near (speculative) future. Millar was recently signed on to Fox Studios to serve as a guide for their superhero films. Properties under the Fox flag include the Fantastic Four, Daredevil, and obviously X-Men. In the Civil War universe, X-Men, Fantastic Four, and Avengers members come to grips with the gravity of their powers after a nuclear explosion caused by a superhuman kills thousands. The U.S. government and S.H.I.E.L.D enact a superhuman registration act, dividing the superhuman community amongst those who see it as a burden associated with the responsibility of the superhuman and this that see it as an infringement and demonization upon their kind; hence, 'Civil War.' Millar wrote the series and is in creative control of the development of two majorly important groups in the series, with X-Men and Fantastic Four, so (with a lot of work) it's practical from a timeline standpoint. What I disliked about AvX was the part-and-parcel approach to creating the story, a patchwork compilation of a bunch of fight scenes with considerably less character development than 'Civil War.' There's moral ambiguity in 'Civil War,' each side with it's own flaws and failures unlike AvX's one-sided, simplistic villains in Cyclops and the Phoenix Five. The way I picture it, some Marvel Comics exec's sat down and Exec No. 1 said, "Okay, we've got Avengers and we've got X-Men. What can we do with those?" Exec No. 2 replies, "We could make them fight? That'd be pretty badass, right?" Exec No. 3 retorts, "Oh! This would give us a chance to make Cyclops 'edgy!' We've always talked about that!" And so it began. If Fantastic Four is successfully rebooted, and maybe 'Days of Future Past' establishes a rift or at least incongruity in their tired, hero-less universe, then the script could write itself and 'Civil War' could become a CGI-filled, superpower-packed reality. Of course, this is all speculative, as the studios would likely never (at least openly) discuss shared production rights, grosses, and credit. Would I see an AvX movie? Sadly, I probably would just to see what they came up with and to admire the exorbitant casting, budgeting, costuming, set designing and, of course CGI on the big screen. Could they actually write an AvX movie? Hell no. They had a hard enough time trying to make it interesting in comics.