5 Reasons The Emotional Spectrum Ruined Green Lantern Comics
Waste the Rainbow.
Superstar writer Geoff Johns owes a lot of his current power in DC Entertainment to his seminal run on Green Lantern, starting in 2004 with Green Lantern: Rebirth and continuing through such beloved events as The Sinestro Corps War and Blackest Night. While “Green Lantern” is a title that has belonged to many different characters over the years since the 1940s, Johns specifically salvaged Hal Jordan’s reputation with his work.
In 1994, Hal was turned into the villain Parallax due to an editorial mandate because the character had gotten rather boring over the years. (The most interesting development at the time was that he was starting to go gray.) He was replaced by Kyle Rayner, a novice ring-wielder who was a good contrast to “Greatest Green Lantern” Jordan. In retrospect, Kyle is very guilty of Spider-Man syndrome and a lot of his positive attributes can be traced back to Peter Parker, but his role as the everyman made him a great fit on Grant Morrison’s JLA team. Still, there were elements of the Green Lantern mythos that had been abandoned to pave the way for Kyle: The Corps and the Guardians of the Universe were gone. These were features that made Green Lantern feel unique and different from other superheroes and they were missed. In fact, they even started to slowly creep back in: Kyle tried to re-establish a new Corps with disastrous results and later gave up his flashy powers as Ion to bring the Guardians back to life.
To paraphrase Peter Sanderson’s “Rubber Band Theory,” the Green Lantern concept could only be pulled in one direction so far before it eventually snapped back to its natural state. Kyle’s tenure as sole Green Lantern lasted about a decade before Johns brought back the Corps, the Guardians, numerous fan favorite alien corps members, and of course Hal Jordan, whose complicated path from Parallax back to hero is best saved for a wikihole. Rebirth was a blockbuster hit that reinvigorated the franchise and put Johns on the map like never before. While it’s a stretch to say Green Lantern is a household name (and if it is, that household is probably thinking of John Stewart from the Justice League cartoon show), we most certainly would never have gotten a Green Lantern movie in 2011 if not for the staggering popularity of the comics.
Johns asked and answered questions about Green Lantern no one had ever dealt with before and made us all feel like idiots for never asking them. Prior to Kyle, every Green Lantern’s ring would not affect the color yellow. At the time of the character’s creation in the Silver Age, it was felt that a hero needed an easily understood weakness (the Golden Age Green Lantern’s ring refused to work on wood), but Johns actually devised an in-story reason for it. He asked the simple question: “why aren’t there rings for the other colors?” and gave birth to the Emotional Spectrum, with each color corresponding to an emotion and each emotion providing the power for its ring. A splash page toward the end of Sinestro Corps War showed all the different Lantern corps fighting each other and it felt like a veil had been lifted. Red Lanterns? Blue Lanterns? It all felt so amazing.
But then, time went on. Blackest Night came and went, but the other corps stuck around. The success of the concept may have been its greatest injury. The assorted rainbow corps became a permanent fixture of Green Lantern comics, weighing down each subsequent story arc with more and more nonsense. In many ways, Green Lantern has yet to recover and now, almost a full ten years after the concept’s introduction, we are still dealing with the War of Light in some way, shape, or form and the books are suffering.
5. The Concept Is Loaded With Flaws
Green Lantern’s ring runs on willpower. The user has to imagine what he wants to create and then concentrate or “will” it into existence. It’s like trying to quit smoking times a million. We as readers can easily comprehend how such a weapon would work. We’ve all had to impose our will on the world in some form or another, even if it’s just resisting a late night cupcake, but do you understand how to weaponize love? Or greed?
The emotions of the spectrum are supposedly what power their respective rings, but the more you think about this, the less sense it makes. First of all, can willpower even be defined as an emotion? If a loved one dies, I will become sad, automatically; there’s no effort - it just happens. Emotions are out of our control, for the most part (see: the entire antidepressant industry), but willpower is essentially just extremely focused concentration. It hardly counts. And yes, the text tells us that Green, being in the center of the ROYGBIV spectrum, is the most stable emotion, unlike Red anger and Violet love, but that just seems to make the case that willpower is not an emotional at all. You can be consumed with rage or lust, but how often do you find yourself suddenly consumed with will? You might as well say boredom is an emotion, or apathy (these were often featured in parodies of the concept).
To reiterate, it’s simple to understand that Green Lantern wants to make a giant boxing glove, so he pictures it in his mind, concentrates, and creates a construct. But other rings can make constructs as well; is willpower not involved for those? How does the fear ring work, precisely? Does the wielder have to be afraid of her creation? Some of the rings sidestep this problem by changing the functionality. Red rings turn the wielder into a mindless, acid spitting goon. Blue rings of hope can only work if they’re close to a green ring, because “hope is nothing without the willpower to enact it.” But, both rings are capable of giving the user the power of flight and a protective aura which makes no sense. Green Lantern wills his ring to make him fly, to provide the aura. How does a Red Lantern, who is blind with rage, make his ring fly? By yelling at it? Does a Blue Lantern just really, really hope that his ring will let him fly to another planet and that his aura won’t vanish and expose him to the vacuum of space? But we were just told hope can’t do anything without willpower!
Also, the Emotional Spectrum has managed to cheapen the very concept of emotions, in general. Have you been wronged in a significant way? Well now your entire life is dominated by anger and revenge; you’ll seemingly never feel another emotion again. Wonder Woman was chosen by a violet ring to become a Star Sapphire because she is just so filled with love. I’m sure she felt a lot of love for Maxwell Lord as she snapped his neck leading up to Infinite Crisis. No wait, that didn’t happen anymore - or did it? Dammit, DC! Anyway, people are capable of complex emotions. You can, perhaps, be very angry with someone you love very deeply. You can be really hopeful that your enemy dies in a fire. The Emotional Spectrum promotes one-dimensional characters and that’s never good.
4. It Limits Stories
Practically every Green Lantern comic for the past decade has had some element of the Emotional Spectrum. Everything that happens seems to be the result of some ancient prophecy or conspiracy of the Guardians. It’s like a snake eating its own tail. There was a time when Hal could go out into deep space, deal with some new and interesting alien menace, perhaps with the help of another corps member or two, and then come back home after it was all wrapped up. Now, everything is another step toward another crossover event that’s about some new wrinkle to the mythos. While modern comics are currently obsessed with long, epic narratives that take place over dozens of issues, Green Lantern is practically the only superhero still dealing with plot elements from 2007. (Is it a coincidence that Johns spent years as Chief Creative Officer of DC Entertainment AND his stories are still around? More on that later…)
This is like if the X-Men were still dealing with the fallout of M-Day or if Ultimate Spider-Man was still dealing with his clone saga (Ultimate Peter’s not even alive anymore - the Ultimate Universe isn’t even a thing anymore!). The reason Green Lantern comics have yet to move on is because the Emotional Spectrum is deceptively restricting. It feels like it should open up a whole universe of possibilities, but it actually ends up making things seem small and cramped. Now we’re locked in the house and all we have to eat is what we can find in the pantry. Sure it’s a mansion, but we can never leave. Years ago, Johns said that he would eventually address the aspects of the electromagnetic spectrum that human eyes can’t see, i.e. an Ultraviolet corps and an Infrared corps, which I’m sure he’s long since forgotten now that he’s consumed with making sure the Justice League movie isn’t a total piece of garbage. Johns probably had a lot of big ideas for the Emotional Spectrum, but maybe he became distracted with all of the other responsibilities he has and never got around to them. Maybe he was satisfied just maintaining the story until he left the book, dangling plot threads be damned.
And though this isn’t strictly comic related, the Green Lantern movie was weighed down by the spectrum before it could even properly address it. The movie was so busy laying the groundwork for Johns’ ideas that it dropped the ball on being good in its own right. Did Deadpool spend half the movie trying to get us excited for Cable? Nope. But the Green Lantern movie tries to get your excited about eventually seeing the Sinestro corps when you barely give a crap about the GL corps. Even the Green Lantern animated series had to deal with Red and Blue Lanterns. Is it really a shock that it was canceled before the other corps could be properly dealt with? The Emotional Spectrum concept is so limiting that it actually limits stories told in other media!
3. It Cheapens The Green Lantern Concept
The elevator pitch for Green Lantern is: “a man gets a space ring.” Most strong character concepts can be explained very simply. Superman: last survivor of alien world comes to Earth and becomes a hero; Batman: orphaned rich kid grows up and dresses as a bat to punch criminals in the face. This is true even outside of superheroes. Look at Sherlock Holmes, who can simply be defined as “super observant genius solves crimes with his intellect.” But what if, at a certain point, Sir Arthur Conan Doyle decided that there should be a Holmes-like consulting detective in every major country? What if we met the Sherlock Holmes of America, or China? Wouldn’t Holmes start to feel a lot less unique and subsequently a lot less interesting?
Yes, Hal Jordan is one of over 7000 Green Lanterns in the corps, but that doesn’t work against the character per se because he’s the first human being to be a member. Maybe having other human Green Lanterns like Guy Gardner and Simon Baz is what really cheapens the concept, but one could argue that’s an expansion of the original premise. Instead of the first human Green Lantern, you have the first human Green Lanterns. It satisfyingly answers the question: “Why am I reading about this?” But with all of those corps competing with each other, you have to wonder why Green Lanterns are worth following.
There is a difference between “Green Lantern” and “Green Lantern, one of over six different types of Lantern to choose from.” It constantly begs the question, “What are the other corps up to right now?” Green Lantern (as a concept) becomes part of a larger framework and, as a result, can no longer stand on its own.
Look at James Bond for another analogy. We know that he is 007 and that there are at least six other agents who do what he does, but we don’t see them (with rare exception). Imagine if, every time you wanted to see a movie about Bond, you’d also have to see 001-006. What if their stories became so intermingled that telling a simple narrative with only Bond became impossible? What if you heard conversations like “Sure, I like 007 and all, but 004 is really my favorite. Why don’t they tell more stories with him?” It’s not that the other Lantern corps can’t exist, it’s that we need to be able to move on and continue with other stories despite their presence.
Green Lantern is long, long, long overdue for a “back to basics” reset. It doesn’t have to be as drastic as what happened with Kyle, but there needs to be a return to the simple concept of “Space Cop saves the day.” Seriously, Green Lantern has the potential to be a kind of “Law & Order in Space,” a procedural where Hal has to stop and solve crimes on alien worlds, with unfamiliar cultures and environments. It could keep things fresh and still provide opportunities for longer running arcs. When being told stories about an intergalactic peacekeeping force with sci-fi magic rings, the last thing we should be feeling is monotony.
2. It Makes The Character Impenetrable To New Readers
Oh, the fabled “new reader.” Both DC and Marvel search for her high and low, like an explorer seeking the fountain of youth. Yet, their decisions always seem to contradict that goal. If you want to start reading Green Lantern right now, you need to read about a decade’s worth of comics before any of it will make a lick of sense to you. That’s a problem for many reasons, especially with this dying industry that will probably collapse entirely once the Baby Boomers shuffle off, but mainly because it prevents Green Lantern from once again becoming a smash success.
Rebirth had the benefit of being a reboot and provided a great jumping-on point for new readers - not necessarily people who were new to comics, but new to the character. Right now, Green Lantern is being written for people who are already invested in Green Lantern. When we think of a great run on a comic, we don’t often think of a lot of built-up mythology. Nobody says, “Here, read Brubaker’s run on Captain America… and here are the years of comics you need to read first for it to make any sense!”
This is not to say that long form storytelling is inherently bad. Look at Morrison’s JLA and Doom Patrol runs or Chris Claremont’s Uncanny X-Men saga. But even though Claremont wrote the X-Men for like twenty years, he still found ways for growth and change to occur on the page. He found ways to encourage newcomers to stick around. It’s not like they fought the Sentinels for ten years.
1. It Only Works When Geoff Johns Does It
If Green Lantern: Rebirth is any indication, DC: Rebirth will eventually lead to a narrative that is great as a pitch, but will ultimately peter out without any satisfying resolution when Geoff Johns has to turn his attention to some other aspect of DC Entertainment, or the universe gets rebooted again. Those first few years of Green Lantern comics showed such promise, similar to how electrifying the DCU is with all of this possible Watchmen talk, but it’s clear that things got away from Johns as time went on.
In the last couple of years leading up to his departure from the title in 2013, it seemed like Johns was just dragging out what few ideas he had left, but lacked the time to really flesh out - sort of like the DC equivalent of Brian Michael Bendis. The more influence he had over the line, the more events he was tasked with writing, the more Green Lantern suffered. We had one opportunity for things to be reset in a more workable fashion in 2011 when The New 52 debuted, but Johns used his editorial power to completely spare his work from any changes, aside from adding more Jim Lee lines to the costumes. But even though things were starting to head south leading up to him leaving, when we read what happened after he left, it was clear we had no idea just how bad things could get. In the hands of other writers, Johns’ ideas led only to garbage.
There’s no doubt that Johns did Green Lantern a tremendous service. If you look at the state of things in 2004 and compare them to now, yes, things are much better for the character and franchise as a whole. But if you look a little closer, you can see the real problem: Geoff Johns fixed Green Lantern by breaking it all over again. It’s like how you introduce foxes to your ecosystem to kill an overpopulation of rabbits. Now the rabbits are all gone, but the place is crawling with foxes. Johns managed to reintroduce the tentpole elements of the Green Lantern concept, but he accidentally forced all of this detritus to accumulate that no one else can utilize. By most accounts, the current Green Lantern books are seeing improvement, but that kind of feels like the sentiment of an abused housewife who believes things are getting better because she didn’t get smacked today.
Maybe Johns should never have left the title. Maybe he should’ve written it for damn near twenty years like Claremont. If you look at Johns’ career, a lot of his decisions seem to be motivated by a desire to make the DC Universe look more like it did when he was growing up. Maybe some new hot shot writer will come along and systematically dismantle all of Johns’ work to make the Green Lantern comics look more like they did when he (or she) was a kid. Maybe that writer will be put in a position of strong creative influence and bite off more than could be chewed. And maybe ten years after we’ll be complaining about it.
Are you tired of the Rainbow Corps? Or do you love them and hope they never go away? Was their creation a mistake or the best thing to happen? Hash it out in the comments!