7 Reasons Why Age Of Ultron Failed

By Noel Thorne /

Advertisement
Ultron €“ an artificial intelligence robot created by Hank Pym who mapped his own brain onto his creation. Ultron fought back against Pym and developed beyond his capabilities, becoming deadlier, more intelligent, until he became one of the Avengers€™ greatest threats. Marvel's latest Event, Age of Ultron, featured an end of the world scenario where Ultron returned to wreak havoc on Earth€™s Mightiest Heroes and conquer the world. Issue #1 began in the aftermath of Ultron€™s invasion where his army of Ultron drones had killed a number of superheroes and driven the survivors into hiding. It€™s a great setup and the series looked very promising in the first couple of issues. Bendis€™ scenario was novel €“ we didn€™t see the main event, we jumped on right after €“ and the fight back against a super-powerful Ultron looked to be really something. But things dovetailed quickly as Bendis struggled to move the story forward, essentially treading water for 5 issues until he got to the main reason behind this Event, using that hackneyed narrative trope time travel. As the story veered off at alarming tangents, it resembled less and less a fight against Ultron and more an excuse to have a whacky time travel adventure with Wolverine and Sue Richards, as Ultron continually failed to appear until the final issue which came out last Wednesday (19 June). There were elements of the mini-series I enjoyed like Bryan Hitch and Carlos Pacheco's wonderful artwork and the first 5 issues reads like a really great hero story - at least until you realise it's not actually about Ultron but about time travel. I was also impressed with the publishing schedule that Marvel kept to - all 10 main issues along with the 8 tie-in comics were all released in the 4 month window, hitting all its deadlines. Although Age of Ultron started off well it ended up becoming another bloated, boring, and overlong Marvel Event that disappointed. While the mini-series was a commercial success with its issues frequently topping the bestselling comics charts of the month, it was a creative failure for many reasons. What were they? Reasons Assemble!

7. Supposedly Smart Characters Acting Really, Really Dumb

Advertisement
Earth€™s Mightiest Heroes are defeated €“ Ultron€™s drones have killed a great many superheroes and the remaining few have been forced to cower beneath the ruins of Central Park. So what€™s the next move for our heroes? Fight back! But how? Their opening gambit is to send two of their toughest heroes into the lion€™s den in a vague attempt to disrupt€ something€ Luke Cage and She-Hulk head into the heart of Ultron city, the massive structure dwarfing Manhattan, under the subterfuge that Luke Cage is bartering with Ultron by offering up She-Hulk. Once they are face to face, their non-plan goes, they will somehow run free and do irreversible damage internally so that externally the drones will all somehow be defeated and the rest of the heroes will have a chance at overcoming Ultron. Um€ what? No-one in this plan has any idea what Cage or She-Hulk should be aiming for or how long they'll be able to get before being subdued (which turns out to be not very far). And, considering the dwindling number of superheroes, the survivors really shouldn't be throwing away two of their biggest guns on what is essentially a suicide mission. They should've just headed to the Savage Land, like they do anyway, with Cage and She-Hulk as, when they get there, they find out what Cage discovers anyway - that Ultron is using Vision as a conduit from the future. After this plan fails, the heroes fly en masse to the Savage Land to regroup. Why hasn€™t Ultron taken over the Savage Land? Why give the heroes a safe haven to recuperate? No idea. You€™d think Ultron would be smart enough to leave no stone unturned in order to completely dominate the world. It€™s here in the Savage Land that the heroes decide to time travel to defeat Ultron using one of Doctor Doom€™s Time Platforms. Captain America and Nick Fury, two of Marvel€™s greatest tacticians, decide to lead a small group of heroes into the future where Ultron is holed up and fight him there. Except that makes no sense €“ if they can€™t defeat him in the present, what makes them think they could defeat him in the future? Do they honestly believe Ultron will be alone in the future? Because he's not - there are thousands of deadly Ultron heads flying about for his protection. Cap, Fury, etc. have no extra edge going into this encounter and even possess fewer numbers, so what makes them think this non-plan of charging toward Ultron in a naive attempt at destroying him is at all feasible? And yet Cap and Fury don€™t think of any of this at all and head straight to their deaths. Serves them right, the idiots! Meanwhile it€™s the least cerebral member of the Marvel Universe, Wolverine, who comes up with the smartest play €“ if time travel is on the table, why not travel BACK in time, kill Hank Pym (Ultron€™s creator) and thus avoid the end of the world by erasing the robot that caused it? Which is of course what he does. Wolverine outsmarted Ultron! Why didn€™t Ultron see this? The only reason I can see why none of the surviving Avengers suggest travelling back in time to kill Hank Pym is because there's a flashback scene in issue #5 between Tony Stark, Reed Richards, and Hank Pym as they gather around an unconscious Vision and talk about how much they love him - if Hank were killed in the past, he'd never create Ultron but then Vision wouldn't exist either as Vision was built by Ultron. Frankly, it's a lousy reason. So we have Ultron, Cap, and Nick Fury all acting out of character in order to facilitate the bungling plot €“ smart characters acting really, really dumb.

6. Time Travel Solves Everything! (Except When It Doesn't!)

Advertisement
Time travel seems to be Marvel€™s answer to originality €“ f*ck you, originality! All-New X-Men ironically riffs on the idea by starting off the new numbering by bringing back from the past the original X-Men cast members into the present. Captain Marvel also uses time travel as a big part of her storyline, and Bendis uses it as the central plot device to his Age of Ultron Event. Just when the story starts to get interesting around issue #5, Bendis introduces time travel and things take a nose-dive. Seriously, what was wrong with the original storyline? Sure, it felt stretched over 5 issues, but it was interesting - I wanted to see how the heroes would fight back against Ultron. Instead one group time travels in the future (Time Travel #1) while Wolverine and Sue Richards travel to the past (TT#2). After they travel back to the present (TT#3) and realise things have gone wrong, they travel back into the past (TT#4), and try to right things again before travelling back into the future one final time (TT#5). Generally, time travel completely ruins a good story. It makes the plot convoluted and confusing, the characters end up spouting the same drivel about butterflies, and it€™s a hack ploy in order to showcase €œexciting alternate€ characters and worlds €“ that are awful - before spiriting them away as quickly as they appeared. All of which happens in Age of Ultron. Time travel solves nothing but is repeatedly used in this storyline anyway. And it gets very annoying.

5. The Dragged-Out Story And The Tedious Tie-Ins

Advertisement
Looking at the Age of Ultron story as a whole, it's really a straightforward tale that€™s been as stretched out as Reed Richards. It€™s the classic Good Vs Evil story €“ the bad guy wins, the good guys lose, but that€™s how the story begins and the interest for the reader is seeing how their favourite heroes rise up and defeat the bad guy. Looking at how it was played out, it€™s really unnecessarily long as Bendis stretches what little happens to fill entire issues. Issues 1 and 2 could€™ve been easily compressed into one €“ all that happens is the aftermath of the invasion and the scale of the devastation. Issues 3 and 4 €“ the Luke Cage/She-Hulk non-plan to infiltrate Ultron City and do some damage - are utterly pointless and could€™ve been left out altogether or else dealt with in a page or two (€œwe tried this but it didn€™t work€ then show flashbacks of Cage and She-Hulk then move on). Issues 5 and 6 could€™ve been compressed into one issue where the heroes meet Fury, one group travelling into the future while Wolverine and Sue head into the past and kill Hank Pym. Issues 7, 8 and 9 €“ the alternate future storyline - could€™ve either been done in one issue or cut entirely because it doesn€™t matter. Overall, this arc is a mini-series but more of a 4 parter than a 10 part series. And that€™s not even counting the numerous, tedious tie-ins! We find out a little more about Black Widow€™s story, a little bit about Spidey€™s, there are glimpses of similar disastrous Ultron drone attacks happening elsewhere in the world, and a few random issues about characters who have no impact on the main story at all. But if you never picked up a single tie-in, you didn€™t miss anything important and the comics themselves €“ besides Fraction€™s Fantastic Four and Gage€™s Superior Spider-man €“ were pretty terrible. Age of Ultron is a decent story but if Marvel weren€™t going for the cash grab and were aiming for art, a 4 issue mini-series with no tie-ins would€™ve made this one of the story arcs of the year. As it is, stretched out over 19 comics, it became one of the stupidest arcs ever.

4. The Constant Bait €˜N€™ Switch

Advertisement
I actually quite liked the Event once it started. It began promisingly after the invasion by Ultron and after the heroes had been defeated. It was an interesting take, bypassing the excessive superhero action and seeing how our favourite characters dealt with loss and defeat. Even though after the initial dazzle wore off and the issues (specifically 3 and 4) began to drag their heels €“ as is Bendis€™ wont €“ I was still invested in the storyline. The glimpses of other heroes€™ struggles on the West Coast and in Chicago followed by the exodus from New York to the Savage Land, made for a compelling narrative €“ now that the disparate pieces were together, the fight back can begin! But it never happened. Issue 6 sees us abandon the main storyline for the time travel nonsense. So we follow two new story threads with one taking place in the future, and the other taking place in the past - except the one in the future is quickly abandoned after one issue. The one in the past leads to another story thread, the alternate dimension story where Stark is ruler of the world - but this storyline is also abandoned after 2 and a bit issues! So we€™re now onto a completely different story thread with Wolverine going back into the past again to stop himself from killing Hank Pym and changing the future one final time. The constant bait€™n€™switching Bendis plays with in this Event is too much and feels like a number of random storylines cobbled together rather than one coherent narrative. It becomes tiresome to constantly try to engage with one storyline only to have it discarded for another. And another. And another. Each time it restarts, you care a little less until, by the end, you don€™t care at all.

3. Terrible Storyline/Characters Replace Great Storyline/Characters

Advertisement
Much to my dismay in issue 6, the highly publicised apocalyptic scenario brought about by the robot was abandoned once Wolverine killed Hank Pym in the past, erasing Ultron€™s creation and the dystopian future he brought about. Ok - fine. But the first 6 issues show a great, interesting storyline that I was involved in and enjoying which is discarded in favour of a far worse storyline. The characters who were more interesting because they were down but not out? Replaced by weird yet strangely boring alternative versions of themselves. So instead of Cap, Spidey, Iron Man, etc. fighting back against Ultron, we have a storyline where a weird cyborg Stark is ruler of the world, the Avengers become the Defenders, and they€™re all fighting against Morgana le Fay! The storyline becomes cyborg overlord vs sorceress - I thought I was reading a series called Age of Ultron! What does this thread have to do with anything? The interesting initial storyline is supplanted by a far blander one. Then if that wasn€™t bad enough, your favourite heroes have been replaced with crappier versions who we€™re supposed to root for. Instead of Cyclops or Cable, we have a badly designed blend of the two; Janet Van Dyne/Wasp is Captain Marvel; Captain America is Colonel America, a mix of Cap and Nick Fury for some reason; and Stark is a dicktator. And if you thought the Thing couldn€™t look any weirder, check out those pock marks on his, er, skin? Those craters look like gross acne scars! The rest are made up of unchanged characters, like Hulk, Star-Lord and Doctor Strange. The point is, this new group, calling themselves the Defenders, aren€™t substitutes for the real Avengers, Cap, Thor, Hulk, Spidey, etc. These new characters are badly designed, they€™re not interesting, and I couldn€™t give a fig about reading a series featuring the Defenders over the Avengers. Issues 7 and 8 tell a supremely dull story featuring terrible new characters instead of exploring the Ultron storyline we€™re all looking to read featuring great characters with their backs to the wall. This was a really poor artistic choice by Bendis.

2. Sssh! Don€™t Mention The Plot-Holes!

Advertisement
This mini-series has even more plot-holes than Bendis€™s stories usually contain. The opening scene of the series is Hawkeye rescuing Spidey who€™s being held captive by a group of thugs who€™re on mutant growth hormones (giving them temporary superpowers, eg. strength, speed, the necessaries to capture Spider-man). The thugs are planning on bartering Spidey with Ultron because Ultron does that now €“ he lets some humans live in the ruins of New York but only so they can provide him with a steady stream of superheroes. Why? What€™s he doing with the superheroes? Is he simply killing them? If so, why does he need any help with that when his drones are super-powerful? We never find out. Despite the fact that whenever Ultron shows up he€™s always talking about wiping out humanity, he clearly lets large portions of the population to live. Again, why? Why, instead of destroying every single human, is he policing them with his drones? What€™s he getting out of this? What are his motives €“ isn€™t it simply the total annihilation of the human race? We never find out. After stalling for 4 issues, Cap finally comes up with a plan to save the superheroes from Ultron €“ retreat! He gambles it all on the Savage Land being unoccupied by the Ultron drones, which turns out to be exactly right! But why €“ why didn€™t Ultron send a patrol, or even just one drone, to the Savage Land? Knowing as much as he does about the superheroes, you€™d have thought he€™d know that this place is a frequent hangout for superheroes. Why is it so special as to be exempt from his attention? We never find out. During the first apocalyptic storyline there€™s a subplot where Red Hulk, Black Panther and Taskmaster are in Chicago attempting to capture an Ultron drone. Initially I€™d thought this was so that the heroes could examine a drone to find its weakness. But this idea doesn€™t play out once Red Hulk gets his giant hands on a drone €“ instead he simply wears it like a trophy pelt! Was that all that sub-plot was about €“ to give Red Hulk some bling to wear? 'Cos this is filler! Filler night! And speaking of Red Hulk, how did he know to meet everyone in the Savage Land? The main group of heroes knew because that was their plan; Moon Knight and Black Widow knew because they found a plan in Fury€™s San Francisco bunker that pointed them in that direction; Red Hulk? No clue. He just shows up in the Savage Land wearing his Ultron drone trophy. Is the Savage Land simply the logical refuge when an invasion of Earth happens? In the secondary main story where Wolverine and Sue travel to the now-changed present after killing Hank Pym, Cyborg Stark informs Wolverine that time is organic and can be torn if used too much. How does he know that? Has he been reading Bendis€™ script? And why does time decide that now is the moment it will tear and break apart? After decades of Marvel time travel storylines, why does Wolverine taking 2 trips through time change everything suddenly? Then we get onto the other time travel paradox of there being 2 Wolverines. They solve this problem by going into a cave together and one coming back out, claws dripping blood. That and the cover of issue #9 being one Wolverine stabbing the other through his chest implies that Wolverine was killed by the other Wolverine. How? Isn€™t Wolverine basically un-killable? Doesn€™t his healing factor miraculously heal him of the most extreme injuries? This is a guy who can regrow limbs! And yet a simple stabbing is enough to apparently put him down for good? He€™s been stabbed numerous times in the past, including with adamantium, and survived - what was so special about this time? We never find out. Factor in the characters acting out of character which I€™ve discussed in point 7 earlier in this list, and you€™ve got one hell of a mess in the story of this series.

1. Nothing Matters

Advertisement
The biggest complaint I heard while this series was coming out was that nothing mattered €“ big name heroes were dropping dead left and right and it was obvious that they would be back. Marvel putting Thor down for good? Never going to happen €“ especially not in the same year as a Thor movie is coming out either! In one of the AR pieces, Bendis talked about wanting to emulate Jim Starlin€™s epic Infinity Gauntlet storyline where you had all these heroes dying but were miraculously brought back at the end. That€™s fine if Bendis wants to do something similar. I mean, the heroes dying didn€™t bother me much so long as we got a good story out of it €“ and The Infinity Gauntlet is such an awesome book - but that€™s not what we got. Then the whole €œnothing matters€ complaint changed when it became clear that Bendis not only didn€™t care about killing off major characters (which would immediately be retconned) but that he really didn€™t care about telling a good story either. Age of Ultron to me is essentially issues 1-5 and then jumps to issue 10 €“ the rest is a separate storyline tacked on to this one to make more money by extending the run. Bendis discards one storyline for another before discarding that and replacing it with another, all the while each new storyine that appeared resembled the Age of Ultron Event we all wanted to read, less and less. It was clear that an Ultron-invades and kills a bunch of popular Marvel heroes storyline was never going to become canon as those heroes can€™t stay dead and Ultron himself will be back one day too (probably). But at least Bendis could€™ve committed to telling the main story instead of just the first act, especially when that is what Age of Ultron should€™ve been about. But really nothing that happened in this series mattered. The first arc and all those deaths, everything that happened? Didn€™t matter. The failed futuristic Ultron assassination attempt by Cap, Fury, etc? Didn€™t matter. The alternate present with all those killed by Morgana le Fey? Didn€™t matter. Even Wolverine€™s first assassination of Hank Pym didn€™t matter. Nothing that happens in this book matters at all because it€™s all preamble to the universe-shifting that closes out issue #10. Even though you could argue that nothing mattered in The Infinity Gauntlet because everyone who died came back at the end, at least that book told a good story. Age of Ultron tells a decent first act and then botches the rest of it. The rest of the series fails to entertain and becomes one big confusing mess of time travel anachronisms. The Event which this series centres around €“ the Age of Ultron €“ doesn€™t matter! Not one bit! Because! it! never! happened! Instead the only thing about the series that has any impact on anything is Wolverine jumping around tearing time, leading into Marvel€™s next Event €“ Infinity. That and introducing Neil Gaiman€™s character Angela into the Marvel Universe and kicking off Galactus€™ new series, Hunger €“ both of which could€™ve been done separately through other means rather than needing this poorly plotted Event to launch them. Age of Ultron should€™ve been a great Event in itself instead of being an extended prologue for Infinity, which is what it ended up being. Yes, you could argue that because of Ultron, Wolverine was forced to time travel €“ he and the others couldn€™t fight the Ultron drones because Bendis made them way too powerful €“ but that was more a means to an end. Get Wolverine to play around with time leading to time rifts leading to Infinity. That€™s a storyline that could€™ve been done separately rather than shoe-horned into Age of Ultron. Rather than that long-winded setup, it would€™ve been a far better Event if it had been about the heroes fight back against Ultron€™s reign. But that€™s not what we got €“ we got a jumbled mess of storylines and characters that doesn€™t hang together well. In other words, a modern Marvel Event. * Did you find Age of Ultron similarly disappointing or did you love it? Let me know in the comments below!