8 Insane Times Comic Villains Took Up A Hero's Mantle
They say imitation is the sincerest form of flattery. These villains take that to the next level.
The battle between good and evil is an ongoing one in the pages of most comic books. With super villains running rampant with nefarious plots, many comic readers have wondered why most heroes refuse to kill their notable arch rivals.
Well, besides crossing a line that would ultimately make them villains themselves, heroes usually believe in redemption, or the ability of one to atone for their past sins. Regardless of how dastardly the bad guy, nearly all heroes believe that anyone can turn a new leaf, and make up for their past indiscretions.
Some villains - like Deadpool and Quicksilver - do eventually redeem themselves, choosing to remain morally ambiguous in the process. Others, like Pied Piper and Clayface, got their act together and work alongside heroes for the greater good.
Then there are some who believe they can lead by example, determined to show they are better at saving the world than most heroes are. These villains take cosplaying a bit too far, as they discard their wardrobe and take up the mantles of regular heroes. It's time to take a look at those who went out of their way to prove once and for all that being bad, is very much the new good.
8. Jason Todd Becomes The Dark(er) Knight
Jason Todd is probably the most insane member of the Bat Family. Todd, as the second Robin to Bruce Wayne’s Batman, was killed in horrific fashion by the Joker, only to be resurrected as the cold blooded vigilante called the Red Hood.
As the Red Hood, Jason feels that Batman’s refusal to kill is his true Achilles’ heel. Opting to go where Batman won’t, Red Hood uses his mercenary skills to be judge, jury, and executioner in the streets of Gotham.
When Bruce Wayne is thought to be dead after the events of Final Crisis, Jason sees this as an opportunity to pick up the cape and cowl, and do things his way. With no permission at all, Jason shows up in a custom Batsuit, and dual pistols, claiming to be Batman. This does not sit well with Dick Grayson, the first Robin, who isn’t aware that Todd has stolen the mantle.
Appalled by this Batman’s violent crime-fighting methods, which include the murdering of criminals, Grayson faces off with his former ally Jason, winning the ensuing battle and stripping Jason of the mantle. With Todd out of the picture, Grayson adopts the Batman moniker, keeping it safe for Bruce’s return.
7. Kraven Consumes The Spider
Kraven The Hunter is one of Spider-Man's oldest foes, appearing in Amazing Spider-Man #15, in 1964. He has fought the web-slinger on many occasions, but his most famous encounter comes from the story arc Kraven’s Last Hunt.
It is the quintessential Kraven story, as it takes a deep dive into the convoluted mind of the hunter, and what makes him tick. Kraven - feeling like he has done all there is to do in life - decides to set his sights on Spider-Man and end his feud once and for all. He tracks down the wall-crawler, and the two do battle, with Kraven getting the better of the web-head by shooting him.
Having defeated his greatest foe, Kraven buries Spidey alive, and dons a version of his iconic black suit.
Under the guise of Spider-Man, The Hunter patrols New York City and stops various criminals using rather un-Spider-like means. When Spider-Man escapes his early grave, he confronts Kraven who then refuses to fight the hero.
Kraven explains that he already won, as he achieved his goal of defeating and becoming Spider-Man. Truly feeling as though his life is fulfilled, Kraven returns to his quarters and commits suicide, in one of the most haunting comic book panels ever.
6. Eobard Thawne Gets A New Origin
The Reverse Flash wasn’t always hell bent on destroying Barry Allen’s Flash. In fact, according to his origin in DC Rebirth, Eobard Thawne was a Flash fantastic from the 25th century, who was obsessed with the Scarlet Speedster at every turn.
The Flash amazed Thawne, and he spent his life becoming a historian on all things Flash. When he receives one of Barry’s old suits in a time capsule, he is able to use the residual traces of speed force energy to replicate the incident that gave Barry his powers. With speed force energy now running through his own body, Eobard dons the old costume and hits the streets as The Flash.
Determined to be the Flash of his timeline, Eobard began to engineer situations that put people at risk, only to be the one who saves them. Thinking he was helping the city, this 'new' Flash actually endangered the public with his antics and, after a brief travel through time, Barry Allen confronts Thawne in the future, defeating him in the process.
Forever scarred by his hero, Thawne never dons the red and yellow again, opting for the reverse color scheme, cementing his role as Flash’s number #1 nemesis.
5. Jason Todd Takes Over Nightwing
Not again, Jason!
In the story One Year Later, Dick Grayson (also known as Nightwing), leaves the streets of Bludhaven for New York City. Hoping for a fresh start, Dick is startled to hear that Nightwing has been spotted in NYC, and has been murdering criminals.
Confused by this malicious doppelganger, Grayson uses his detective skills to figure out that his imposter is Jason Todd, the villainous Red Hood.
Furious at what a mockery Jason has made of the Nightwing legacy, the two duke it out on the rooftops of New York. In the scuffle, Todd reveals that he thought Dick’s methods weren’t good enough, and that the citizens of New York preferred his version of Nightwing better.
He knocks him off a building, and when Grayson manages to hold on to a fire escape, Todd slices his hand, letting Grayson fall. The two meet again, with Jason defeating Grayson for a second time, before the two reluctantly join forces to defeat a common enemy. Todd sacrifices himself in the struggle, never to be seen in the Nightwing suit again.
4. Victor Von Doom... The Invincible Iron Man?
As far as villains go, Dr. Doom is one of the most diabolical. As a master of sorcery and strategy the Latverian dictator has brought the world to the brink of destruction on many occasions.
Few have faced the ruler of Latveria and lived to tell the tale - that’s why the world raised a collective eyebrow when rumors began to circulate that Victor, of all people, had his eye on the Iron Man mantle. With Tony Stark incapacitated due to events in Marvel’s second Civil War, the role of Iron Man seemed vacant.
That is until Doom assumed the role, becoming the Infamous Iron Man.
What sets Dr. Doom’s tenure as Iron Man apart from others on this list is, he really attempted to redeem himself and make up for his crimes. While on his path to make amends, he is met by heroes who refuse to believe Dr. Doom is serving the side of good. Instead of proving them right, Victor continues to apprehend criminals and assist the government, just like any hero would.
His time as Iron Man was relatively short but Infamous Iron Man showed us a sensitive side of Dr. Doom, one that would rather be remembered as a hero than a monster.
3. Lex Luthor Becomes Superman
Since his inception, Alexander “Lex” Luthor has always had it out for Superman. He believed humanity’s reliance on an alien to be unnatural, and detrimental to the success of the human race.
After years of trying to expose Superman as a fraud, or a being with ulterior motives, Lex decided to place power in his own hands. When the sadistic Crime Syndicate arrives, and defeats the Justice League, Luthor finds himself on the side of good, doing his part to defeat the Syndicate and save the world. Shortly after, Lex is invited to join the Justice League, proving Luthor had changed, even if it was just a little.
When the New 52 Superman is killed in action, Luthor assumes the role of the new Man of Steel, cape and all. With his battle armor now modified by Mother Box technology after a brief stint in Apokolips, the Lex Luthor of old is gone. The new Lex stands to defend Metropolis from all enemies, foreign and domestic. He even got Superman’s approval!
Inspired by all the admiration and good will the Man of Steel managed to garner while alive, Lex aims to honor that memory and be the hero humanity truly deserves.
2. Doctor Octopus Takes Over Spider-Man
There were many thoughts in Dr. Octopus’ mind as he awaited his death from a terminal illness. He wondered if he had lived a full life, or whether or not he would even be remembered at all.
Worried that his legacy would be incomplete, Octopus uses his vast intellect to switch bodies with Peter Parker, leaving Peter to die in his disease ridden body. With Peter Parker gone, Otto begins to explore his memories, and feels a strong sense of power and responsibility. Feeling this new sense of duty, Otto promises to honor Peter’s memory, by becoming a better Spider-man than even he was!
As the new, more Superior Spider-Man, Otto uses his technology and 'spider-bots' to watch over the city like Peter never could. In his off- time as Peter, Otto went back to school, all so Parker could receive his PHD, and even created his own tech startup company, called Parker Industries.
Those close to Peter loved the change in attitude, but those close to Spider-Man became suspicious of his deadly methods. Otto eventually relinquishes control of Peter’s body to its rightful owner, but in the end, we will always remember who was really superior.
1. Norman Osborne's Dark Avengers
When the shape-shifting alien race known as the Skrulls used their abilities to impersonate members of the Avengers, the entire world was put on notice.
The Marvel Universe became engulfed in a witch-hunt as superheroes lost the ability to trust one another, in fear that their comrades might be aliens in disguise. Once the Skrull Queen is found, it is Norman Osborne who delivers the killing blow, ending the secret invasion once and for all.
Although he spent many years as the Green Goblin, Norman was now treated as a national hero, and given Tony Stark’s reigns in the Avengers. Seeing the previous team as untrustworthy, Norman is allowed to assemble his own Avengers - one distinctly more villainous than its previous incarnation.
Using villains to fill familiar roles on the team, Osborne reinvented Earth's Mightiest Heroes. He chose to merge Iron Man and Captain America’s role into one, becoming the Iron Patriot and leader of the Dark Avengers. He recruited villains Moonstone and Venom, to play Spider-Man and Ms Marvel. He allowed Ares to be his Thor, Daken played Wolverine, and Bulleye became his Hawkeye.
With the erratic and unpredictable Sentry as his proverbial watchdog, Norman’s Dark Avengers took being bad to a new level.
Are there any other villains who took over as a hero? Be sure to share them in the comments below!