8 Real-Life Events That Forced Comics To Change

Watergate caused major problems for Captain America.

By James Egan /

Even though comic books are meant to be a source of entertainment, they have caused a stir from time to time. Occasionally, the writers will produce a story that irks long-time readers, creates a storm on social media, or gets mentioned on the news.

Advertisement

But every once in a while, there is a comic that proves so controversial, the creative team behind it are forced to make changes. Altering a plotline may sound drastic but sometimes, it's the right move. If a story has eerie similarities with a recent tragedy or a political incident, it's sensible to remove certain elements. There are other times where a storyline can't be told the way it's intended because it violates the rules of censorship.

But every once in a while, readers have such umbrage with a specific plot or character, they've threatened the publishing company with violence or a lawsuit. In situations like this, the publisher has no choice but to revise or pull the plug on the entire story.

Here are the eight times where real-life events forced comic books to change their stories.

8. The Creation Of The CCA Derailed Mystique & Destiny – X-Men #141 (1981)

In 1978, the X-Men clashed with the shapeshifting mutant, Mystique, who went on to become among their most recurring enemies. The metamorphosing menace became more dangerous when she allied with a precog called Destiny. But because Mystique spoke to her telepathic ally in an affectionate manner, some readers were under the impression the pair weren't just partners-in-crime - they were lovers.

Advertisement

According to Mystique's co-creator, Chris Claremont, that was always the intent. Not only that, Mystique and Destiny were supposed to be the biological parents of the X-Men's Nightcrawler. Mystique was meant to use her shapeshifting powers to turn into a man and impregnate Destiny, who would then bare their child.

Sadly, this idea was abandoned because of the Comics Code Authority. Since this association's inception, it's cracked down on any material in comics that was regarded as inappropriate. The CCA was so unfairly stringent, it banned words like 'weird' and 'werewolf' from comics! Since the company was against comics depicting same-sex relationships, portraying Mystique and Destiny as a couple was out of the question.

Although the two supervillainesses' relationship was acknowledged after the CCA became defunct decades later, the idea that Mystique was Nightcrawler's 'father' was scrapped.

7. Musician Forced Marvel To Change Cover - Doctor Strange, Sorcerer Supreme #15 (1990)

In Doctor Strange, Sorcerer Supreme #15, our hero allies with Clea, Morbius and a minotaur (don't ask) to stop his brother, who has been turned into a vampire.

Advertisement

At a glance, there's nothing out of the ordinary with this story (at least, by Doctor Strange standards). However, this issue got Marvel into a bit of hot water since it used an image of musician, Amy Grant, for the cover to represent Stephen Strange's lover, Morgana Blessing.

Because Marvel could've used anybody on the planet as the model for Morgana, it wasn't a good idea to use the likeness of a famous musician without her permission. But that wasn't the only problem. Since Grant was deeply religious, she found it very disrespectful that her face was used to sell a comic that revolved around black magic and demons.

Even though her attorney failed to get the comic banned, Marvel was forced to pay Grant an out-of-court settlement for misusing her likeness on their merchandise. When the comic was republished the following year, the cover was redesigned so Amy Grant's face was entirely absent.

6. A Name Was Changed Because It Sounded Like A Slur – Captain America #334-341 (1987-1988)

When Steve Rogers stepped down as Captain America, the US government felt crime could get out of hand unless the people had a symbol to rally behind. As a result, government operatives urged an US army veteran called John Walker to become a new hero called Super-Patriot. After Walker took the country by storm, he was officially designated as the new Captain America and his best friend, Lemar Hoskins, became his sidekick, Bucky. Because Lemar was the first African-American to take on the mantle of Marvel's oldest sidekick, head writer Mark Gruenwald thought this was a great milestone for the company.

Advertisement

Sadly, this decision completely backfired. Only after Lemar debuted as Bucky did Gruenwald learn that the word 'Buck' was a slur towards Africans. To make matters worse, Lemar was part of the military squad, Bold Urban Commandos, which can be abbreviated as BUCs. On top of that, Lemar was described as being illiterate, amplifying the ignorant stereotype that dark-skinned people are less educated.

Not wanting to upset readers, Gruenwald changed Lemar Hoskins' codename to Battlestar soon after and his illiteracy was never mentioned again.

5. The Black Panther Party – Fantastic Four #119 (1972)

In October 1966, Bobby Seale and Huey Newton formed a Black Power movement called The Black Panther Party. The organisation encouraged their members to carry firearms in public to avoid police officers from misusing their power against African-Americans.

Advertisement

Because the Marvel superhero, Black Panther, shares the same moniker as Seale's group, many readers assumed he was deliberately named as a reference to the BPP. But since the king of Wakanda debuted in the comics months before The Black Panther Party was founded, there's no question their shared name is, in the words of Stan Lee, "a strange coincidence".

But by 1970, the Party had offices in 68 cities and thousands of members, causing people to associate the term "Black Panther" more with the political movement than the superhero. To distance themselves from the BPP, Marvel decided to change T'Challa's superhero name to Black Leopard. However, to avoid having to explain over and over why his name was changed, T'Challa was usually referred to by his real name.

As The Black Panther Party's influence declined in the 1970s, T'Challa took on his former title once more.

4. The Atomic Bomb – Superman #38 (1946)

In the story Battle of the Atoms, Lex Luthor tried for the bajillionth time to take over the world. After Superman foiled his nemesis' evil plan, he approached Lex, ready to send him to jail. In a panic, the bald supervillain chucked a combustible pellet at the Man of Steel, which proved to have little effect. After handing Lex over to the authorities, Supes flew off, content he'd saved the day once again.

Advertisement

Even though this sounded like a pretty standard story, it was the first Superman comic ever to be censored! You see, the ineffective weapon that Lex hurled at his mortal enemy was called an 'atomic bomb'. The writers coined this term at random, oblivious that officials overseeing the Manhattan Project were constructing a nuclear weapon with the same name.

Despite the fact Lex's weapon had no resemblance to a real atomic bomb in appearance or power, the US Defence Department forced the comic to be delayed. What's worse is that the publishers of DC Comics weren't told why the story was pulled since the Manhattan Project was top-secret! Only after the US dropped the two nuclear weapons on Japan were DC Comics given permission to release the issue.

3. A Bomb Threat – Web Of Spider-Man #19-21 (1986)

Like any fictional series, comics regularly incorporate topical news stories into their plotlines to stay current. But sometimes, this practice causes more trouble than its worth. In 1986, Marvel prepared to write a Spider-Man story revolving around the unrest in Northern Ireland at the time. Since this conflict's origins go back centuries, it's an extremely touchy subject for anyone with ties to this territory.

Advertisement

So, when Web of Spider-Man #19 kicked off with a bombing that led to the death of a young girl, it was no surprise that many readers were outraged. Days later, a bomb threat was made on 387 Park Avenue South (where Marvel Comics office was based), forcing everyone in the area to evacuate.

Editor Jim Owsley hired writer Len Kaminski to revise the second half of this story arc so the bomb was set off by Roxxon employees who were pretending to be Irish and English agents.

Even though Web of Spider-Man was meant to focus on more controversial topics, that idea was abandoned after this incident, causing the comic line to become a generic Spider-Man series.

2. Challenger Plane – Man Of Steel #1 (1986)

John Byrne is known for two things - being an awesome comic book collaborator and predicting tragedies in his storylines.

Advertisement

In 1977, he wrote a Spider-Man comic about a blackout in New York the same week the city suffered an electricity malfunction. In 1978, he wrote an X-Men issue where Japan was hit by an earthquake months before it actually happened. Three days after writing a comic where Wonder Woman, aka Princess Diana, dies, the real Princess Diana of Wales died.

Another freaky coincidence like this happened while John Byrne was preparing the 1986 Superman reboot series, Man of Steel. Months before the comic was published, the Canadian artist had prepped a drawing of Superman flying into the sky to save a NASA space shuttle.

On 28 January 1986, NASA's Challenger exploded almost immediately after launch, killing all the passengers onboard. Not wanting readers to relive this horrific tragedy, Byrne redrew the vessel that Superman saved as an 'experimental space plane'. Although the vehicle bared no resemblance to a space shuttle, Byrne knew having a more realistic ship would have been in poor taste.

1. The Watergate Scandal – Captain America #175 (1974)

During the 1970s, Captain America faced off against The Secret Empire - a cabal who overthrew the government after using mutants to channel their doomsday weapon. When Cap unmasked the organisation's leader, Number One, he learned The Secret Empire was run by a government agent. Steve Rogers was so disillusioned that a high-ranking figure would take over his own country, he quit being Captain America.

Advertisement

Even though it was astonishing to watch the star-spangled superhero hang up the tights, the story was supposed to be far more shocking. Originally, Number One was meant to be none other than President Richard Nixon. But since Nixon had resigned from the presidency one month prior, writer Steve Englehart thought this big reveal would be inappropriate. As a result, he rewrote the story's climax so the Secret Empire's leader was an anonymous agent, whose face is never shown.

Despite this change, many readers still speculated that this comic was an allegory to Watergate. To reassure fans that this wasn't the case, Englehart wrote in the letters section that this plotline began development one year earlier, meaning that any similarities in the story with real-life events were coincidental.

Advertisement