8 Reasons Why Secret Empire Didn't Work
Secret Empire may be over, but why did it fall apart so quickly?
Secret Empire, Marvel's big summer event by Nick Spencer and a cavalcade of artists, told the story of Captain America - Steve Rogers - having been revealed as a secret Hydra agent, who (unbeknownst to us all) had been planting the seeds to start a full-scale fascist regime in the land of the free since the end of WW II.
In the process, he killed friends, endangered others, and started everything from book burning, re-education centres and even internment camps for Inhumans.
Yet through all of it, Marvel and Spencer himself tried to argue that Hydra were not Nazis, that this was the real Captain America, and urged fans and readers who were vocally offended and outraged by the story to give it a chance and wait until the end.
Well, the story is now over, and ultimately, it did not work. The story was a mess, with little in the way of a through line, and had an ending that left many feeling lied to, hurt or just outright bored.
There are many reasons for why people didn't like it, just as there are those that did, but here's a few of those reasons for why Secret Empire ultimately failed as a Marvel comics event.
8. It Didn't Change Anything
Just what was the change that this event brought?
Normally, when a Marvel event comes around, it promises us that 'nothing will ever be the same again'. And certainly, sometimes, the status quo of Marvel is changed up. Rarely for good, usually things will eventually revert, but you will get some sweeping changes afterwards.
Civil War led to the Superhuman Registration Act and the Initiative happening for a while, Secret Invasion led to Dark Reign and so on.
Secret Empire hasn't really changed a thing. Although Marvel is going into its new Marvel Legacy publishing plan come September, it's hard to say that this is connected to any changes brought about in the Marvel heroes.
Certainly, the final issue of Secret Empire tried to suggest that the heroes were renewed in purpose, but frankly, if they weren't committed to the purpose of fighting Nazism wherever it raises its ugly head in the first place, then they weren't heroes to begin with.
So in Secret Empire's case, prior to the event, the Marvel heroes wanted to fight evil and Hydra... and after the event they want to fight evil and Hydra. It's literally unchanged, bar a few major character deaths and the destruction of a US city and millions of inhabitants (though they kinda glossed over that, and in another Marvel book the city seems completely unharmed).
7. It Didn't Know What Kind Of Story To Be
A political thriller? A superhero slugfest? A quest? Just why couldn't it stick to one story structure?
Throughout the series, Secret Empire went through a number of different structural directions, as though it couldn't really decide what kind of story it was from the get-go.
Initially starting out like a summer blockbuster, then becoming more of a political thriller, then becoming a quest story - at times humorous, at times dire and serious - and ending on a superhero slugfest, Secret Empire switched tracks and beats as quick as its issues were released.
It felt like it could never decide how to tell its own story, or perhaps more accurately Spencer or Marvel were unsure how it should go.
This was exacerbated by extending the series past it's already long nine-issues to an extra tenth issue, the constant adding or changing up of artists throughout, and a frankly ludicrous amount of tie-ins and spin offs in other titles, some of which actually (and annoyingly) held important plot points you'd really be better off obtaining from the main story.
In the end, Secret Empire just felt like a mess of ideas, too big for its creators to control, and winding up thrashing all over the place.
6. It Lied To The Fans
Misdirection is an important tool for a good writer who can wield it well. In Secret Empire, we saw it used poorly.
Naturally, when writing a comic or story of any kind, you don't want to show all your cards up front. You hold things back and tease things out at a pace to serve the story.
Secret Empire however decided to purposefully hold back information at several points that would have been beneficial earlier, purely to help create shocking imagery month by month.
The goal seemed to be create a shock moment each and every issue, regardless of how this could be taken by the fans, or misconstrued by other parties.
For example, earlier in the series, in the events Free Comic Book Day entry, the Hydra Captain America lifted Thor's hammer effortlessly, seemingly suggesting he was considered worthy. This shocked and angered fans, as you can imagine, but what's more, many far right groups took the image of a fascist Captain America lifting Thor's hammer as an image of support for them. These organisations already try to appropriate Norse imagery and mythology, so to have the Hydra Captain America do this - regardless of Marvel's intent - seemingly emboldened these groups.
However, in the final issue, we get a blink and you'll miss it scene showing that in that battle way back towards the start of the event, Madame Hydra used a chunk of Cosmic Cube to alter the spell on Mjolnir, making it possible for Hydra Cap to lift it in the first place.
By this point, the damage was done, but it seemed that the writer and Marvel purposefully held back on this key piece of info not to aid the story, but to create a shocking image that would incite a reaction in fans.
Similarly, outside of the event itself, Spencer and Marvel and its editors routinely seemed to lie to the audience. They said the event would not see the Cosmic Cube fix things in the end (even using this comment days before the final issue in a spoilerific New York Times article), and yet the final issue saw Kobik, the living Cosmic Cube, fix things and save the day.
Telling fans to wait and see is one thing, but lying to them is quite another, and ultimately it only served to create an air of bad blood between Marvel and their many supporters.
5. It Messed Up Its Own Symbolism
Secret Empire's main symbol of hope spent over half the event petulantly not wanting to take part.
A lot more attention and focus seemed to be paid to Hydra Captain America, not only to strongly show him as a fascist dictator, but also to seemingly show how he was having a hard time with his new status as Hydra Supreme Leader, and the fact his closest allies (gasp!) couldn't get passed it.
However, by the final issue, we are meant to believe that the character that was meant to be the series' main symbol of hope was in fact Sam Wilson, the former Falcon and also a current Captain America.
The only problem with that is Sam Wilson had quit being Captain America because there was backlash to his role as the hero within the Marvel universe itself. When Secret Empire begins, Wilson has decided he doesn't want to be part of the fight against Hydra at all, and is content with helping facilitate people passing across the border into Canada.
When the Underground Avengers come to get him, Wilson wants nothing to do with them or the fight, but gets dragged into it. He eventually dons the Captain America costume again, but by the end, he didn't really do a great deal. The other heroes may have rallied around him, but it was kind of tough to see why.
Moreover, in the final issue, he doesn't do much, but then, neither do any of the heroes beyond a copy of Steve Rogers created out of the memory of what he was like before Kobrik got involved (yes, it's confusing, we'll get to that).
When Marvel Legacy starts, Sam Wilson will be ditching the Captain America mantle yet again, this time to once again become the Falcon. So if he was the symbol of hope we were all supposed to rally around, why did he come across as being so whiney? That, and why is he not continuing that legacy going forward? He's clearly a better candidate than Steve at this point...
4. We All Knew How It Would End From The First Issue
No matter how much Spencer and Marvel assured us otherwise, we all knew where it was going.
From the moment we learned just how Captain America became an agent of Hydra way back in Steve Rogers: Captain America #2, almost a year before Secret Empire began, readers and critics alike knew exactly how it would all end.
In that issue, we learn that Kobik, a living Cosmic Cube who looks like a little girl and introduced in a prior Marvel event, was manipulated by the Red Skull into altering Steve Rogers and his history so that he was always a member of Hydra.
As soon as we knew that, we knew that the way it would all end is Kobik (the Cosmic Cube), would reverse what she did.
Immediately, Marvel and Secret Empire writer Nick Spencer kept insisting that the Cosmic Cube would not fix everything, that what we all thought would happen wouldn't happen, even banging on this promise in a spoiler-article Marvel did with the New York Times days before the final issue.
Problem being: it was exactly what happened.
While sure, the people who died still died, and the things Hydra Cap did still happened, it was the Cosmic Cube, Kobik, who restored a version of Steve Rogers with his original history and intentions intact, and saw to the defeat and reversal of the changes wrought by Hydra Cap himself.
Ultimately, this meant the ending of the series felt completely weak, because we all saw it coming long before the series even began.
3. The Heroes Don't Save The Day
Heck, a bunch of Marvel's heroes straight up joined the Nazis, including the Punisher.
Ultimately, Secret Empire didn't end with the heroes beating Hydra Cap and Hydra itself and taking back America from the fascists.
Yes, a mix of heroes from the X-Men, Avengers, Defenders, Inhumans and more (including a bunch who'd been swayed over to the side of the Hydra Avengers) did come together to face-down the bad guys by the end, and they do get a few good punches in, but it wasn't them who beat Hydra Cap in the end.
Ultimately, they got defeated, easily I might add, by the now god-like Hydra Cap in his Cosmic Cube empowered armour. It was in fact Kobik, the living embodiment of the Cosmic Cube (who, yes, Bucky and Ant-Man helped make whole) who defeated Hydra Cap by undoing what he did, restoring the Marvel heroes and even rebooting a brand new Captain America who has the old operating system before she mucked about with it in the first place.
The heroes were barely part of the final battle, with Sam Wilson Captain America even holding them back when they wanted to help Good Steve in his fight with Hydra Steve.
As much as the narration would like us to believe otherwise, the Marvel heroes didn't really save the day...they just kind of stood there and watched as a magic MacGuffin did their work for them.
2. The Win Wasn't Earned
How do you kill a good ending and strong message? Throw in the deus ex machina!
As mentioned previously, Kobik the Cosmic Cube ultimately saved the day, and did so in the comic equivalent of a click of her fingers.
She created a duplicate of Steve Rogers based on her memories of him before she altered his history (which I still find troubling, as they spent about five minutes together before she altered him), let him have a good beatdown on his evil doppelganger, and then did a wax on, wax off and made it so Hydra was no longer in charge, Hydra Cap's changes to history were erased, and things were back to normal (though she left a great deal of the destruction caused by her initial manipulations around, so thanks for that half-job Kobik).
It was an ending that we all saw coming, it was an ending that brought the whole sprawling event over in seconds, and no one really had to fight for it. It just happened.
She even sent the heroes away for a split second into weird past and future adventures (which absolutely did happen yet absolutely did not, so thanks for that confusion too, Marvel) between panels, in order to explain Marvel's tangentially linked event of one-shots, Generations.
None of it felt earned. The heroes didn't triumph over adversity. Instead, a magic pixie kid with god-powers sorted it all out for them, and left the audience wanting and wondering what the hell this was all for anyway.
1. It Made Captain America A Nazi
Marvel seems to not understand the importance of their own symbols, because you simply do not turn an anti-fascist hero into a f***ing Nazi!
Ultimately, so much of why Secret Empire didn't work can be boiled down to the original conceit that led to the whole event.
Making Steve Rogers, the Sentinel of Liberty, a hero that is the literal embodiment of the American ideal for fighting for what's right, fighting fascism and democracy into a literal fascist was a short-sighted idea to begin with.
The fact that the fictional fascists were quite clearly modelled on the Nazis made it even worse, and it doesn't matter how many times Marvel and Spencer tried to argue Hydra weren't Nazis, if they got into bed with the Nazis, then they are just plain Nazis.
Secret Empire could have still existed without this aspect of the story. It could still have been a powerful and poignant story about how dangerously easy it is to see a fascist regime rise, right before our eyes without us realising or believing it could possibly happen here, and yes, one that would have been incredibly timely right now - it could have been all of that without Captain America as the symbol of that fascist regime.
Keep Captain America as the one fighting the good fight, no matter how hopeless. Make the fascists someone even he could not have seen coming. That would have been just as powerful, and still had a stronger sense too with Steve Rogers being able to play that symbol of hope effectively, and wouldn't need a convoluted and incredibly obvious background behind it.
Instead, Marvel and Spencer went with an exploitative, shock-chasing, confusing and ultimately obvious conceit that did nothing but anger, annoy and bore fans. Thank Kobrik it's over.
-
What did you think of Secret Empire? Are you as happy to see it end as we are? Let us know in the comments below!