Batman: Ranking Every Robin Worst To Best

From Dick Grayson to Damian Wayne, which Robin comes out on top?

By Dalan Overstreet /

No character embodies the spirit of the trusted companion better than Robin, Batman's ward and right-hand for over seven decades. Since 1940, Robin has fought with Batman against all threats to Gotham and the world at large, becoming one of the most cherished characters in DC's catalogue.

Advertisement

The Robin identity is well-known, but that mantle has been held by several characters. Each of these characters' tenure as the Dark Knight's sidekick were different, and have subsequently sparked debate in the fan community.

But which Robin is the best of all? No less than five have taken on the identity in the mainstream DC Universe, and with each experiencing varying degrees of success, it's only natural that some Robins are better than others.

6. Stephanie Brown

Stephanie Brown is probably best known as Spoiler, but for a brief period she was Batman's protege following the resignation of her then boyfriend, Tim Drake. Bruce Wayne was hesitant to take her under his wing as she wasn't as adept at crimefighting as previous Robins - an instinct he probably should've trusted.

Advertisement

Stephanie's term as Batman's field partner was as short as it was tragic. After a falling out that led to her dismissal as Robin, Brown stole some of Batman's plans to deal with the entirety of Gotham's criminal syndicates in one blow. This was an obvious mistake to everyone but Stephanie, but she was determined to prove herself worthy of the uniform.

To no one's surprise the plan ended up being botched and then led to an all out gang war. It also resulted in Stephanie being tortured and mortally wounded by Black Mask.

Of course Stephanie was revived because this is comics and no one stays dead. She would return as Spoiler, but her death marks another failure for Bruce Wayne and drove Tim Drake away from Gotham - at least for a period of time.

5. Carrie Kelley

Carrie Kelley made her debut in Frank Miller's classic graphic novel, Batman: The Dark Knight Returns. Although the works are non-canonical, they are considered some of the best written pieces in the medium and one of the defining stories in Batman's history. For this reason, it is hard to ignore the novels, therefore hard to ignore Kelley.

Advertisement

Carrie was one of the most memorable elements in Miller's Dark Knight saga. With an origin rooted in neglect instead of loss, unlike Dick Grayson and Jason Todd before her, she began to admire Batman after he saved her from a mugging.

In a world of batarangs, grappling guns and Batmobiles, Kelley's weapons of choice included a sling shot and some firecrackers, reinforcing her childlike innocence in a story that was otherwise dark and brooding. She also saved Bats from the Mutant Leader and briefly aided him in the fight against Superman.

Ever since, Kelley has been written into DC continuity during the New 52 revamp, but her invaluable role as Robin in what is widely accepted as the best Batman story of all-time earns her a spot on this list.

4. Jason Todd

Jason Todd was introduced in Batman #357 in 1983 and was given an almost identical backstory to Dick Grayson - his parents were circus performers that were murdered by a violent criminal, and he was then taken in by Batman.

Advertisement

After Crisis on Infinite Earths, an event that allowed DC to retcon specific parts of their universe, Jason Todd's backstory was changed, with the character becoming an orphan Batman discovered attempting to steal the Batmobile's tires. That moment exemplified Todd perfectly: skilled, bold and reckless.

Jason went from a Grayson copy to his exact opposite, and so too did Robin, going from lighthearted and ingratiating to stubborn and combative. Fans never responded to Todd, so when given the opportunity to decide his fate, they voted to kill him. Todd was then brutally beaten by Joker and left in a warehouse as it exploded.

Jason Todd was resurrected and took the identity as the Red Hood, a title once held by the Joker. The persona change mirrors Bruce Wayne's logic of adopting the image of a Bat, using his phobias to spark fear in others. Needless to say, Todd as the Red Hood has been far better received by fans than his time as the Boy Wonder.

3. Damian Wayne

Although Damian may not be the best Robin, he perhaps has the best claim to the Batman mantle. Damian is the only son of Bruce Wayne, first appearing in Batman #655 in late 2006.

Advertisement

Damian is the son of Talia Al Ghul, who birthed him in an artificial womb using her & Bruce's DNA. This means he is the grandson of Batman's nemesis and former tutor, Ra's Al Ghul.

Being the grandson of the Demon's Head means you're going to train with the League of Assassins. Under the tutelage of Ra's, Damian became an expert fighter, a skilled swordsman, and acquired various other skills needed for ninja activities.

The League are not exactly diplomats, so Damian has a history of violence and even murder, which often puts him at odds with his father. He also has a far more arrogant demeanor than previous Robins. Still, Damian has his bright spots as a capable businessman and lover of animals.

2. Dick Grayson

Dick Grayson has been the definitive Robin since his debut in Detective Comics #38 in April 1940. Carrying the mantle for over 40 years, Grayson has followed Bruce Wayne across comics, television and film. He is the standard to which all other Robins have been compared.

Advertisement

Batman's first sidekick began as a circus performer alongside his mother and father as a member of the Flying Graysons. This was until the family act was sabotaged by gangsters, leading to the death of his parents. Batman, who happened to be tracking the criminals, told Dick about his own loss and took him under his wing. In Grayson, Batman was given the opportunity to be what he needed after his parents' murder.

In his four decades as the Boy Wonder, Grayson proved himself to be a worthy alley to Batman. Youthful and optimistic, he became a glimpse at what a Batman alieved of his tragedy would be.

Over time, Grayson has become not only the best acrobat in the World, but also one of the best detectives and hand-to-hand combatants in the DC Universe.

1. Tim Drake

Following the death of Jason Todd, DC was unsure if readers had grown weary of Robin. When Tim Drake was introduced in Batman #436 in 1989, he was a bit of a question mark. Those concerns would not last, as Tim went from a creative uncertainty to the best to ever character wear the red, green and yellow of the Robin costume.

Advertisement

Drake became enamored with Batman and Robin at a young age, deducing Batman's secret identity before the age of 10. Turmoil finally brought them together, as Bruce was still reeling from the brutal murder of Todd and Tim had lost both of his parents (a common occurrence in Gotham, it appears).

Tim is widely regarded as the most intelligent of the Robins, displaying detective abilities that have rivalled even Batman's. He has expert knowledge in various scientific fields and speaks several languages fluently.

No one has commanded more respect as Robin than Tim Drake. More pragmatic than Grayson and less hostile than Todd, Drake presented himself as a mature middleweight between the two. As Robin, he led the Teen Titans, co-founded Young Justice, earned the respect of Ra's Al Ghul, and even won the trust of the Man of Steel himself, Superman.

He may not be the defining version, but no character gave more legitimacy to the mantle of Robin than Tim Drake.

Watch Next...

Advertisement