Before Watchmen has come to an end (well, maybe, theres talk of a One Shot 'Epilogue' on the way to truly wrap up the series but with the gaps in the release schedule for this DC Comics event, I'm not waiting around for it). When first announced we all let out a gasp, shocked by the news that DC Comics would have the balls to go back to Watchmen, without the series creator Alan Moore on board. Alan Moore commented publicly about his indifference towards the new series and DC Comics' lack of fresh ideas and even Dave Gibbons hinted that whatever is in the pages of Before Watchmen isn't really considered Watchmen lore. Then, slowly the writers and artists of the new series got their say and artwork trickled out for the lazily named Before Watchmen event and bad feeling started to turn into intrigue. Could this actually be good? It would be good to hang out with Rorschach again wouldn't it? See more of the Minutemen? Find out why Silk Spectre is so narky all the time? The intrigue set in and as the first issues rolled in fear of disappointment slowly turned into relief because, yknow what, these Before Watchmen comics were pretty good, some even great. So here we are at the end of the Before Watchmen run. All of the mini series have ended, theres been a few extra One Shots and mini titles thrown in and now, despite huge gaps in the release schedule, were at the finish line. This week Comedian #6 finished the run and now its time to look back and see what worked and what didn't. Behold, Before Watchmen The Mini Series countdown from worst to best and then the all important final verdict. Was DC Comics' biggest gamble to date work out or was it a total failure? Here we rank the series from worst to best;
Before Watchmen: The Comedian
Writer: Brian Azzarello. Artist: J. G. Jones This six issue run charted the story of Edward Blake (The Comedian, as if you didn't know) and his time before, during and after the Vietnam War. There was a rather large spotlight on his relationship with the Kennedys and of course his slow descent from a guy fighting for his country to a guy finding the concept of society a pretty big joke. Comedian ranks at the bottom of the pile for me, largely because it didn't feel like it went anywhere. It had a solid start and the first couple of issues felt like the mini series was going to get inside of Comedians head a little and venture into the dark times for Eddie. Sadly, it just didn't do that, well not all that successfully anyway. I'm not the biggest fan of war based comics anyway, but this Vietnam based mini series really lacked personality when it needed it the most. All of the good stuff involved Eddie away from Vietnam, so the big chunk of the six issue mini series that spent time there was quite a slog. All in all the political drama within the pages of Comedian was solid, the Kennedy interactions even more so but Edward Blake just wasn't really explored enough and was better served in some of the other Before Watchmen titles, in which he was a regular appearance. This mini series played with clichés a little too much for me and other than maybe the first and last issue ended up being the low point of the Before Watchmen run.
Before Watchmen: Dollar Bill
Writer: Len Wein. Artist: Steve Rude This one shot focuses solely on the corporate-sponsored superhero Dollar Bill, the ill fated hero that we knew one day would have problems with his cape. Theres not really much to say about this one, other than it was a short and sweet exploration of a Watchmen supporting character and gave us another insight into the costumed crime fighting of the Minutemen era. A sponsored superhero is quite a cute area to explore and the character of Dollar Bill was yet another face in the Watchmen crowd that had a complicated past and dreams of being a better man. This one felt a little shoe horned into the Before Watchmen run, with lacklustre art work and a very linear storyline. Even with that said, it was quite fun to read and it is of course a character we all knew, even from his limited panel time in the original Watchmen. When this single issue was released, it raised the question of Could there be more Watchmen comics focusing on the background characters? and I still think theres scope for that.
Before Watchmen: Ozymandias
Writer: Len Wein. Artist: Jae Lee This six part series starts just before the final events of Watchmen takes place. Ozymandias sits in his Antarctic fortress of Karnak completing his personal journal of the events that led to his master plan. With the Ozymandias mini series, I'm still on the fence regarding just how much I liked it. A large amount of that is because much of the ground here is already well trodden in the original Watchmen. Additionally for all the time spent on Ozy building his financial empire, hating Edward Blake and recounting how he continually betters himself, I often wished more time was spent with the building of the squid, taking out Edward Blake or the specifics of his plan. I know, its a little unfair to criticise a title for whats NOT on the page, even more unfair considering all of the stuff I wanted more of is still explored quite well enough but thats how I always felt with Ozymandias. It always seemed like we were running out of time to delve into the good stuff or hovering around minor incidents for a few too many issues. With that said, I loved how the comic looked. Jae Lees art was perfect for Ozymandias. Also how Len Wein wrote Ozy was spectacular in places. His tension around Dr. Manhattan was perfectly played and his frustrations with Edward Blake even more so. I said in my original reviews, Ozymandias is a title that works better when read in one long sitting as opposed to the monthly (or more) gaps between individual issues and while it doesnt quite achieve everything I feel it could have, it still ends up being a fine companion to the original Watchmen, especially for those that want more Ozymandias as his master plan plays out in the original series finale.
Before Watchmen: Moloch
Writer: J. Michael Straczynski. Artist: Eduardo Risso The two issue mini series of Moloch took a closer look at the golden age villain turned victim of the original Watchmen series. This heartbreaking tale watches the pawn in Ozymandiass grand plan grow up in a world of hurt due to his looks, find a place as foe against the Minutemen and then turn over a new leaf, only to be screwed over in the worst of ways. I really enjoyed this little run. The first issue was largely backstory that didnt really better the character of Moloch all that much but the moment he met up with Ozymandias and the final chapter in his life began, this got very interesting. Seeing the events from the original Watchmen from the point of view of Moloch was interesting stuff. His work with Ozy is a series of dark and sad events. Molochs feelings on where his life is now is pretty gut wrenching considering we all know what really going on with his health as Ozymandias secretly poisons him and as we head into the Rorschach meets ups and of course the Comedian crying at the end of Molochs bed, its good to see events never seen in the original Watchmen happening within the pages of this short series. Moloch was always a key but understated character to the events in Watchmen and seeing his story, told this well was a much deserved late entry into the Before Watchmen run. This wont be the first time I praise Straczynskis work in this article but he did such a great job with this unexpected side order.
Before Watchmen: Rorscharch
Writer: Brian Azzarello. Artist: Lee Bermejo Now here's the first real shocker. Rorschach, a character that couldn't be in any considered Watchmen sequels could only come back to our comic book page as via a prequel. We all imagined it would be awesome, Rorschach in his prime in pre-Watchmen events. It couldn't fail, right? Thankfully it doesn't fail as such but here it is, midway through the list. Not at the top, not second, not even third but fifth on my list of Before Watchmen titles. Hurm. Despite the beautiful artwork from Lee Bermejo, that perfectly captured the seedy side of 80s New York city and its neon lit streets. Rorschach ended up being a title that aimed for bigger things but ended up fizzling out. Telling the tale of a Rorschach up against a particularly nasty New York gang, the story also has sub plots involving a serial killer, a potential love interest for Rorschach and a whole lot of beat downs. There's also a cameo from a certain Travis Bickle-esq 'Taxi Driver' in here too, which I'm still unsure of if it works or not. Basically, this is a well written series, full of all the stuff we love Rorschach for (he does one particular thing with a broken bottle that was a Rorschach classic) but despite the violence, the diary entries and the beautiful artwork this one just ended rather drably On the plus side, it felt like a title that could rinse out more mini series' going forward, largely because this four parter really only focused on one event in Rorschach's career, so there's plenty more room for exploration of that. Don't get me wrong, I enjoyed this mini series but it felt like a bit of a non-event when it wrapped up and other than more than its fair share of 'Wow' moments and good looks I didn't feel there was much to get excited about.It also didn't help that Rorschach was getting better page time elsewhere... more on that soon.
Before Watchmen: Silk Spectre
Writers: Darwyn Cooke. Artist: Amanda Conner From early in the Before Watchmen marketing campaign, the prospect of Darwyn Cooke and Amanda Conner combined for a Silk Spectre mini series was too good to be true. In fact, Conners promotional art was probably the first thing that warmed me to the idea of going back to Watchmen. The pair show us a Miss Jupiter back story thats full of charm, sixties nostalgia and gives us a Laurie Jupiter that goes through the highs and lows of love, sex, drugs and thigh high boot crime fighting. Theres some cute famous face nods in here, a great cameo from Comedian and a nice bit of expansion on Sally Jupiters strict monitoring of her daughter. Amanda Conner has become one of my favourite comic book artists of late and her work with Laurie was fantastic. The swinging sixties really comes to life and within this back story she really fleshes out Lauries changing personality with her artwork. Equally Cookes story manages to make Lauries mini series feel like something different in the Before Watchmen run. Sure it ties in with the characters we know and love but Silk Spectre would work as a standalone ongoing comic way more than all of the other titles in Before Watchmen line up (and I'd buy it too!). I'd happily see the continuing adventures of Laurie Jupiter with this talented duo behind it and this mini series totally offered up a different flavour to the largely dark events the rest of Before Watchmen served up.
Before Watchmen: Nite Owl
Writer: J. Michael Straczynski Artists: Andy and Joe Kubert Around the web, Nite Owl got its fair share of mixed reviews but I have to say that within the page of J. Michael Straczynski mini series lay some of closest genuine Watchmen feeling stuff in the entire Before Watchmen run. I realised early on that the era of Nite Owl and Rorschach crime fighting duo is some of my favourite stuff in Watchmen. Having a story set around these two in New York made for pure delight and Straczynski nailed Rorschach better in these pages than he was handled across the rest of Before Watchmen. In fact in one scene he introduced Rorschach in such a classic way, it almost felt Batman good. Elements like Nite Owls relationship with Twilight Lady and the beginnings of Nite Owls love of getting it on in costume was one thing but fleshing out his back story, his path to becoming Nite Owl II and some of the darker paths both he and Rorschach walk down in these pages just made for good times all around. Sure, I would have liked to have seen a bit more focus on the Keane Act and how that affected our two main heroes but the crazy priest stuff was twisted enough to make the mini series work anyway (again Rorschach gets some great panel time with this stuff). Also the relationship between Dan and Hollis was a nice addition and at its core the Nite Owl mini series reminded me just how much I like the character, his insecurities, his wide eyed enthusiasm for the costume and of course how the world of Watchmen chips away at him enough to make him second guess his actions.
Before Watchmen: Minutemen
Writer/Artist: Darwyn Cooke From day one, Minutemen seemed the title the would work the best in Before Watchmen. In fact for years there were hints that this would be the only ever Watchmen expansion in comics, so really we were all semi-prepared for a Minutemen comic at some stage. Anyway, golden age costumed heroes + Darwyn Cooke = match made in heaven, right? Cooke makes all of his work immediately easy to fall in love with. Those classic looks, the period dialogue and writing, the obvious admiration for the original Watchmen. It all seeps out of the pages of this book and becomes a volume of work that could quite respectfully sit on the your bookshelf next to the original Watchmen (is their higher praise than that?). Basically Cooke has taken all of the Hollis Mason Under the Hood stories featured in Watchmen and expanded on them. Really not a lot happens here that you didn't know about already but when this is all cobbled together as well as this and we begin to see the real story of the Minutemen, this mini series comes into its own. Hollis Mason is a character that shows us the glory of what costumed crime fighting could be and of course he also shows us the effect of events when they darken that dream. Glory becomes half-truths or all out lies. Secrets behind the masks begin to bear down on everyone and the dark side of costumed crime fighting as well as the evil it never really considered having to go up against really becomes the focus. Minutemen really does take a dark path as Holliss career travels forward and having the story skip between modern Hollis remembering the events and back to costumed Nite Owl living them really generate a sense of history and depth to the tail. Minutemen proved to be an all-round delight, even if its one that never quite achieves classic status.
Before Watchmen: Doctor Manhattan
Writer: J. Michael Straczynski. Artist: Adam Hughes No one really knew what to expect from Doctor Manhattan in this mini series. I mean, in in the original Watchmen, Doctor Manhattan was astounding. The way his story was told was so unique, his part in the Watchmen world so beautifully told and of course his back story was presented in such a great way as we travelled through the blue guys relationship with time that it will always be a consideration as the one of the greatest chapter in comics. But where next? What would Straczynski possibly do with a character we literally know all the ins and outs of and has set a benchmark so high in story telling, pop culture is really only just catching up with it. Well Straczynski took hold of Doctor Manhattan and ran with it in a big bad way. To boil it down to the basics, he essentially offered up the concept that while on Mars, Manhattan dissembled time, looked at every possible outcome of multiple realities, tore them apart, largely due to their devastating outcomes and focused on the reality hes in now. That is really a simplistic description of events because what Straczynski actually did was provide one of the best comic book mini series of 2012/2013 and wasnt afraid of the character he chose to do it withs limitless boundaries. Pinning much of this to the idea that until a box is opened it is full of limitless possibilities, Doctor Manhattan sees his life through many changes. What if he didnt go back for the watch and walked out of the box unchanged? What would happen to his family, his friends or indeed the world? Straczynski wrote all of this beautifully, studied the tiniest of moment and grandest of universal events all within a few panels at a time and Adam Hughes made all this all the more beautiful with some absolutely stunning artwork right across the board. Arguably Straczynski broke some rules about the Docs powers, though I for would argue Manhattans powers always seemed limitless to me and everything within the pages of this mini series worked for this long time Watchmen fan. Really each and every step of the way Straczynski sells his concept, he re-defines the rules and achieves the impossible of actually doing Doctor Manhattan justice without watering down the vast possibilities on offer via the big blue guy. Doctor Manhattan ends up not only being the best thing about Before Watchmen for me but one of the best things about comic books in quite a while.
Before Watchmen: The Final Verdict
Through all of my individual Before Watchmen reviews I made sure to put a score of where my feelings for Before Watchmen as a whole were each week. This had a ton of ups and downs but remained largely positive and I think this shows that Before Watchmen proved to be worth the shot DC took on it even if it wasn't always consistently convincing us of the fact. I think the biggest issue that Before Watchmen had was that within pretty much every story, we knew all of the details already. Minutemen was great but offered up very little that we didn't read about in Watchmen, same goes for Ozymandias and Comedian. The best of the run still suffered from this problem but overcame the issue by focusing on a specific event or period. Nite Owl, Silk Spectre and Rorschach all just centred in on small period for the most part and delved into the character at the chosen moment in time, which I think wound up being a much better pursuit. Another issue and probably the biggest thing holding back Before Watchmen from being anything really special was we all know what comes next in Watchmen. Every step in most of these mini series titles were on the path towards Watchmen and unfortunately for the writers, Watchmen is such a complete piece of stand alone work that it pretty much covered every beat that would lead to the events within its pages. Trying to write in more stepping stones didn't always work and when they did they only really added some spice to an already perfect soup. Oh and one last negative. The Corsair story at the back of the Watchmen books proved to be pretty pointless. At two pages an issue it was hard to really fall for and while I'm sure their was a point to it all, it didn't really connect. (I know, I know that's what a lot of people say about Black Freighter in the Original Watchmen but those people are also idiots because Watchmen fans know just how important that story within a story really is). The rumoured Epilogue comic coming in seems to be the end of this tail but I can't say I'm all that fussed about seeing how it ends at this stage. But thats the negatives, Before Watchmen also offered up a great deal of positives. For starters the talent involved here totally stood up to the challenge of returning to Watchmen. There's some artwork within these pages that give us a nice modern spin on the imagery of Watchmen. Adam Hughes, Amanda Conner and pretty much every artist that got to have a spin on Watchmen have brought their A-Game and for many that alone would make this project worth the attempt. The same goes for some of the writing. The talent may have had their hands tied in regards to genuine twists and turns but most of them expanded our beloved Watchmen characters to their limits and in Straczynski's case smashed through them and went somewhere else. So in the end was it worth it? I'd say I'm 60/40 as the final page closes on the final mini series. Before Watchmen provided nothing that was all that required to either expand or better the original Watchmen and given just how perfect Watchmen is, we always knew that would probably be the case. At its best highs, Before Watchmen was compelling, vastly enjoyable and at its core a fan service of the highest order, giving us more of the characters would otherwise never get to spend time with again. At it's worst Before Watchmen was repetitive and largely redundant due to the complete nature of the original work on Watchmen. On a personal note I had a whole lot of fun with it for about the entire first half but when the release schedules slipped and the less good titles felt like a grind , the limitations of Before Watchmen began to show more. At the end of it all, none of these titles are an embarrassment to DC comics and even the hardest of fans should find something to appreciate within at least a couple of minis. Additionally for anyone wishing to catch up with Before Watchmen now its all done. I'm sure in their collected forms, they will read much better within their complete runs (though I have to say the double title collections is NOT how I want to own these collections and I'm hoping for an collection of individual mini series collections later down the line). Before Watchmen arrived with a bang and left with a whisper but at the end of the day it's more Watchmen and that's been revealed as a good thing. So the dust has settled, so we ask, what's next DC? AFTER Watchmen?.... watch this space.
Overall Before Watchmen Rating:
Advertisement
It's been a blast Watchmen fans and thanks for everyone that read and commented on the reviews over the past year.