Every Strange Academy Student Ranked Worst To Best

Which magical youngster reigns supreme in a school run by the Sorcerer Supreme himself?

By Sven Engvall /

If there's one thing that comic book publishers can't resist, it's a teen team. There have been so many, it's easy to get lost in Marvel's many variations. Something about putting young people in mortal peril just really works for them. But while teams like The Young Avengers and The New Mutants have always represented the youth movement for their respective subsections of herodom, the magical side of the universe has always lacked that same young presence. Cue, Strange Academy.

Advertisement

Strange Academy has been the breakout hit ever since it appeared on shelves in early 2020, and truthfully, how could it not be? Led by an all-star creative team of Skottie Young and Humberto Ramos, this riff on Harry Potter meets Marvel is an exciting adventure following 11 magical teenagers attending a magic school hosted by Doctor Strange himself. And of course, adventures and hijinks ensue.

With a large cast, it's only natural to have your favorites, but there is only one definitive list: this one.

So, now that the first run of the book is done, with a relaunch scheduled for the Fall, let's rank the students. Beware of spoilers ahead.

11. Calvin

Calvin is the worst. He is one of the three human characters (four if you count zombies) in the main cast, and by God, does he pale in comparison to the rest.

Advertisement

Calvin is an orphaned teen who was invited to Strange Academy because he found a magic coat. That's it. No magical ability, no wild lineage, just the coat. So when that coat was taken away, you can imagine this character might have been forced to grow. It could even be a blessing in disguise, allowing him to challenge himself in the face of adversity. It could have the impetus for an all new Calvin who earned his place at this school.

But not Calvin. No, Calvin becomes a drug dealer. Admittedly, he did try the hard way at first, but the pressure of being a nonmagical teen in a school full of innately gifted peers got to him. It's truly sad to see the wasted potential. Sure, he could be redeemed, but his true colors have been shown. He would rather cry about his problems and hope for divine intervention, than do something himself to fix it.

10. Shaylee

Shaylee is... exhausting. There isn't anything innately wrong with her, but boy does she seem like a hard person to be friends with. She never stops talking and what she says is almost always completely inconsequential. Even her own mother suggested as much when she came to visit the school.

Advertisement

Shaylee comes from Otherworld, a magical land most notable as a setting in Excalibur. She is a human-fairy hybrid and to call her impulsive would be an understatement. While on a school trip she talks about the romance of Asgard and how amazing and hot she thinks Toth is (like an uncomfortable amount of gushing). Then, seemingly linking the two thoughts together in the moment, she asks Toth to be her boyfriend. It's not that she is wrong in doing that, or feeling the way she feels, but anyone who has been around someone who cannot shut up knows how annoying this can come off.

To be clear, Shaylee is a good person. She is supportive and friendly, but needs to learn how to filter herself. Hopefully she can grow that in her time at Strange Academy.

9. Guslaug

What can you really say about Guslaug? No really, what can you say?

Advertisement

She is a frost giant and as such is, well, giant. Too giant for her classes. Most of Guslaug's appearances in Strange Academy are her peering into classrooms through windows and generally not saying much. You have to feel for her. Being left out or feeling on the outside, even if for totally logical reasons, has got to be isolating. Her interactions with her peers is friendly, but really it's the kind of friend that you say hi to while passing in the hallway, not the type of friend that you share your innermost insecurities and joys with.

Even when battling The Hollow, she is the one who runs to the teachers for support, as opposed to the others who must battle for their lives. It's sad to say, but she is almost an afterthought. Great for the atmosphere of a magic school, but as a character, a lot of development needs to happen before she can be considered a true character and not just window dressing.

8. Iric

In every teen story there has to be one rough and tough bad boy. The one who stirs up trouble. Who talks loudly and unapologetically pushes peoples' buttons. For Strange Academy, that is Iric. Typecast as the jock brother, he and his twin Alvi come from Asgard, and as it is later revealed, they have an interesting parental legacy.

Advertisement

The majority of his interactions are with Doyle and Emily. There is a pseudo love triangle there, but Iric seems more in it for the competition with Doyle than anything else. Brash, cocky, and strong willed, he and Doyle feud often, but an underlying friendship has begun to form due to Doyle keeping one of Iric's biggest secrets. They still maintain a heated rivalry, but a mutual understanding has been met.

There is definitely a place for Iric at Strange Academy and he could definitely learn a couple things beyond the magical curriculum. He is unafraid to challenge anyone for what he thinks is right, and that's admirable, but dude needs to learn to simmer down the alpha testosterone a bit.

7. Alvi

Alvi, the other Asgardian twin, is also on a mission to train up his magic. While Iric fits the typical Norse warrior mold, Alvi is a bit more balanced. He is still incredibly tough, but unlike his brother, he also possesses poise, intelligence, and empathy. Unfortunately, this gets him a reputation as the nerdy one, a moniker he probably doesn't deserve.

Advertisement

He is one to the top students at Strange Academy consistently prioritizing his studies. He is a diligent student and often acts as a voice of reason during his brother's tantrums. He has also grown close to his roommate Calvin, whom he acts as a sort of older brother figure, building his confidence and including him in activities. That is until Calvin lashed out at him, attacking him during a training exercise and claiming that Alvi only ever looked down on him.

In a lot of ways, Alvi is the perfect student. Almost too perfect. He doesn't seem to have any major flaws and has yet to develop many compelling characteristics. As a character, that's a little boring. Maybe down the line he can learn to get some of his brother's edge.

6. Toth

Toth looks weird and, as a representative of Weirdworld, that's pretty fitting. He is the son of Queen Blythir and a Man-Thing, which technically makes him a prince. But you wouldn't guess that from the way he acts. Toth loves to swim and will jump in any body of water the moment he sets his eyes on it. And to fully complete his surfer boy persona, his go-to outfit is a pair of board shorts and no shirt. Not exactly regal attire.

Advertisement

As a Crystal Warrior Man-Thing, Toth has an incredible design, really showcasing the creative team's skills. His body is a nest of pointed crystal which shows up beautifully on the page. It truly is amazing how much personality they've been able to give a mute character with limited facial features. Whether he is struggling in class or chilling during some downtime, it's always abundantly clear how Toth is reacting to a situation.

Unfortunately, the biggest role that Toth has played in a story thus far is the one where he is shattered into thousands of pieces. Don't worry though, he got better. As Strange Academy continues, hopefully Toth can continue to be a calming presence as times get dark.

5. German

German is Toth's roommate and, in a school filled with drama, that has to be the most relaxed dorm room around. German Aguilar is a Nahual, a being able to tap into an ancient form of magic tied to his homeland in Mexico. This means that he can summon animal projections made of green energy to surround him and attack.

Advertisement

And boy, can Humberto Ramos draw his animage state. The whole Strange Academy series is beautiful, but Ramos' artwork mixed with Edgar Delgado's colors goes a long way into making German shine. In this author's opinion, it is the best art in the series.

He seems well liked by his peers, but similar to Toth he has really only shown his personality as part of the background. He is definitely underutilized, a common theme among some of the more supporting players of the cast, and would benefit from a significant character arc that would define him more solidly. A brief interaction with Zoe explained his backstory, but other than that he really just pops into conversations to support when needed.

4. Zoe

Zoe Laveau had a secret coming in to Strange Academy. She is a zombie, and to prevent anyone from finding out, she wore an amulet that disguised her true self. That dream quickly dissolved though as Dessy, her roommate, saw through her disguise.

Advertisement

But while Zoe felt more comfortable as a generic human student, she sacrificed that security for the sake of her friends. While being attacked by The Hollow - a cult of nefarious trees in the swamps of Louisiana - she reveals her true self, much to her friends' surprise. She summons a horde of zombies to help stave off their advances. That sort of bravery is surely not lost on her friends and it shouldn't be lost on readers either.

Later, during parent's weekend, Zoe's parents insinuate that she has a crush on Dessy and the two more or less are coupled off, even if it isn't technically official. It's a cute romance that feels more earned than other pairings because of the mutual growth the two have helped each other achieve. Dessy makes Zoe feel more comfortable in her skin, and Zoe stays patient in helping Dessy acclimate to life outside Limbo.

3. Dessy

While Zoe is great, Dessy does edge her out as the better half of the couple. Dessy is a demon. More specifically, the daughter of the demon S'ym, the one-time leader of Limbo. Because she grew up in what is essentially Hell, sometimes, she often comes of as a bit strange, even at Strange Academy.

Advertisement

One of the first things Dessy reveals at school is that she knows Zoe Laveau's secret. But being from Limbo, she doesn't understand the concept of hiding herself the way Zoe is, and does a lacklustre job at empathizing with her situation. Nevertheless, Dessy tries to understand and listens to her friend, showing tremendous growth in the process. It takes a lot to navigate the difficult world of high school, and it's much harder if you're a literal demon without understanding of basic social mores.

Zoe's an adept magic user, saving the school against the evil Mister Misery showing true creative thinking in the process. She isn't perfect, but she is growing, and that's kind of the whole point.

2. Emily Bright

Many people may call Strange Academy Marvel's version of Harry Potter, and while it may not fit as a one-to-one comparison, there are certainly similarities. And if this is Marvel's Hogwarts, Emily Bright is their Harry Potter.

Advertisement

As a human teen unfamiliar with the wider world of magic, Emily sees this world through a child's eyes. Everything is new and at times she feels overwhelmed by her rapidly changing life. But that doesn't mean she's weak. No, Emily quickly establishes herself as a leader. She is recklessly heroic, exceedingly rebellious, and the closest thing to a main protagonist that the series has.

She spends the first half of Strange Academy's 18-issue run making friends and learning all magic has to offer. Then, she finds her footing, leading a school wide protest against the many secrets the teachers have been hiding.

She can come off as sanctimonious at times, but she believes in her ideals. Unfortunately, with where things left off at the end of the series, it seems Emily Bright may be in for a trip to the Dark Side. Hopefully, she can be redeemed when the series picks up again.

1. Doyle

Come on, from day one the kid with his fiery head was always a fan favorite. Being the son of Dormammu, one of the biggest Doctor Strange villains out there, certainly built a dramatic arc for Doyle, and he has lived up to it.

Advertisement

Doyle is more than meets the eye. While readers might have first taken him for a younger version of his father, he has blossomed at Strange Academy, showcasing an empathetic and even romantic side. Now don't get it twisted, Doyle still had a lot of growing to do. He is impulsive and full of self-doubt, but at his core he has the heart of a hero. He cares for his friends and has already sacrificed his life once to prove it.

Now, he struggles with his destiny. Is he destined to become evil like his father or is he something more? Can he save his friends from a dark prophecy? There are a ton of interesting plot threads to be resolved in Strange Academy: Finals, and Doyle is at the center of them all.

Advertisement