How Batman Would Defeat Each Member Of The Avengers

Breaking down how Batman would beat Captain America, Iron Man, Thor, Hulk and Co.

By Andrew Pollard /

Few comic book characters prove to be as forever popular as Batman. Since debuting in Detective Comics #27 way back in 1939, this creation of Bill Finger and Bob Kane has gone from strength to strength, becoming an icon of not just comic books, but of film, TV and video games too.

Advertisement

One of the elements of the Batman character that makes him stand out from the pack is the rogues gallery that the Caped Crusader is tasked with battling. Many have said that a great hero can only be a great hero if they've got a great villain to go up against - and in Batman's case, he's got what many would deem the absolute best array of rogues to face off with.

Of course, Batman is famed for living up to his World's Greatest Detective moniker, with his smarts meaning that he can come up with the perfect strategy to beat any opponent that decides to step up to the Dark Knight.

Not just villains, mind, for Batman has also bested some of DC's finest heroes at certain times.

How about the greatest heroes of Marvel Comics, though? If confronted with the Avengers, here's how Batman would (probably) stop the long-standing mainstays of Earth's Mightiest Heroes!

10. The Hulk

One of the fiercest, most problematic threats facing anybody who dares go up against Earth's Mightiest Heroes is, of course, the Hulk.

Advertisement

Ever since making his comic book bow in 1962 - another character brought to life by the iconic pairing of Stan Lee and Jack Kirby - the Green Goliath has proven to be an unbeatable, unrelenting force of nature that some of the most powerful entities in the galaxy have failed to put down.

How would Batman take out the Hulk, then? The key to this battle for the Dark Knight lies in catching the Jade Giant when he's at his weakest - when he's in the everyday form of Bruce Banner.

For Batman to get Hulk to that state would require the World's Greatest Detective to put his brain into gear. The options on the table are to either concoct a tranquilizer strong enough to quell Hulk's rage, ambush Banner when he's not expecting it, or to outlast one of Hulk's frenzied rampages in order to tire the brute out so that he reverts to his human form.

However Batman gets to it, when he is confronted with plain ol' Bruce Banner, it's there that the Caped Crusader would deliver the finishing blow.

9. Hawkeye

Hawkeye wasn't quite a founding member of the Avengers, but he was a part of the second wave of formal recruits who joined Earth's Mightiest Heroes shortly after the group was founded.

Advertisement

Clint Barton is a great character who brings so much to the table with his prolific aim, his impressive hand-to-hand combat and the sheer imagination he has in turning everyday objects into deadly weapons. But for Barton, the sad truth of the matter is that Batman would find him the easiest Avenger to take down.

The Caped Crusader is frankly better than Hawkeye on too many levels for Clint to stand a chance against him. We've seen Batman battle and beat Green Arrow in the pages of DC Comics at times over the years, and any such fight with Hawkeye would go the same way.

Without trying to dismiss Hawkeye as a total loser, Bruce Wayne is simply smarter, stronger, more bullish, has a wider array of gadgets available to him, and is a better stand-up, straight-up fighter than Hawkeye.

In terms of the reality of it, Bats would look to get close to Barton, minimalizing the chance for Hawkeye to use his eagle-eye to pick the Dark Knight off. The excessive ninja training of Bruce means that he's able to perceive shots at a slower pace than your average superhero, so that's in his favour when faced with Hawkeye's attacks - and once he gets in close, it's game over for Clint.

8. Black Widow

For decades, the characters of Marvel Comics and DC Comics have been continuously compared. And where it comes to Black Widow, Natasha Romanoff has so often been compared to DC's Lady Shiva.

Advertisement

On the surface, Widow and Shiva are two badass female assassins who can kill a person in numerous ways, and all in the blink of an eye.

Diving a little deeper, and there are notable differences between these characters. For Shiva, she edges it as the better hand-to-hand fighter, with her mastering of multiple martial arts going in her favour. But where Natasha is concerned, Widow has a better catalogue of gadgets and tools up her sleeve.

Famously, Lady Shiva is one of those rare characters to actually get the better of Batman in a fight, with her knowledge of different fighting styles being even more extensive than the Dark Knight's.

Using his Shiva battles as a measuring stick, Batman would be able to beat Black Widow in a straight-up fight, while one would imagine that Bruce would also have more than enough gadgets to nullify any tricks that Natasha had up her sleeve.

If we're talking a longer game chase scenario, Widow's methods of stealth and disguise can come into play. But then, Bruce himself has been known to employ similar techniques himself - hey, Matches Malone! - and the mixture of his tracking tech and the smarts that have labelled Wayne the World's Greatest Detective, means that any stealth-based situation usually tends to go in his favour.

7. Ant-Man

The Hank Pym incarnation of Ant-Man was one of the founding five members of the original Avengers, and Pym remains one of the outright most fascinating characters in all of comics.

Advertisement

But when faced with Batman, Hank Pym is destined to end up on the losing side of things. Regardless of which persona he's taking on - be that Ant-Man, Goliath, Giant-Man or even Yellowjacket - the Caped Crusader will be able to deal with what Pym offers up.

The scanners built into the Batsuit would pick up on Hank should he shrink, while the suit's impenetrability means that Pym couldn't get inside it. Should this founding Avenger opt to go big and embrace his more Giant-Man side, that simply gives Batman a bigger target to aim for.

Should Giant-Man be the order of the day, you can't put it past Bruce to pull an Empire Strikes Back manoeuvre and utilise the Batwing to tie this enlarged Hank Pym up in knots, sending him tumbling to his downfall.

If we're talking the Scott Lang version of Ant-Man, that's a different fight - in that Scott isn't as smart as Hank Pym, but he is better at thinking on his feet - but it's a fight that Batman would still win.

6. Wasp

When talking about Ant-Man, particularly in regards to being a founding Avenger, it's impossible not to talk about Wasp.

Advertisement

Like Hank Pym, Janet van Dyne is another who founded Earth's Mightiest Heroes, and similarly she has the ability to shrink in size. Granted, Wasp does have the ability to fly and to project energy blasts, but those additional powers wouldn't cause Batman all that much grief.

For a Batman vs. Wasp fight, the Dark Knight would very much pull on the same plan of attack that would be used on Ant-Man. Janet has no way to get under Batman's skin due to how solidly built and protected the Batsuit is, and the small stature that Wasp has so often used to her advantage wouldn't be a problem for Batman - with him able to track her and keep a constant monitor on her whereabouts.

When it comes to any attacks Wasp launches his way, Batman has proven time and time again that his reflexes and dodging ability is enough to outmanoeuvre some of the most powerful beings in the galaxy. Throw in how the Caped Crusader has used his grappling gun to evade otherworldly beasts, such as Doomsday, then he would stand a fine chance of avoiding any of Wasp's attacks - to the point where Bats could edge in closer to Janet, which would then be game over for her.

Should Wasp foolishly decide to go toe-to-toe with Batman, that would obviously end in utter failure. Not only has Bruce got the physical advantage and exceedingly better fighting skills, even the skills that make van Dyne so unique would be rendered useless by the technology that the World's Greatest Detective has to his name.

5. Quicksilver

Like his sister Scarlet Witch, Quicksilver was one of the second batch of heroes to join the Avengers. Despite previously being a villain, Pietro Maximoff eventually settled into using his powers for good - although Quicksilver has admittedly floated between hero and villain in the decades since first joining Earth's Mightiest Heroes back in 1965.

Advertisement

When it comes to a possible fight with Batman, readers of DC Comics will already have an idea of how the Dark Knight could stop Quicksilver and he superspeed that her brings to the table.

Being the ever-prepared soldier that he is, Bruce Wayne has the perfect way to stop somebody with the abilities of Pietro. It's an utterly brutal reality, but Bruce has a vibratory projectile already in his arsenal.

That weapon was put together by Batman should he ever have to stop the Flash, and the purpose of this projectile is to send a speedster into multiple convulsions akin to gargantuan epileptic seizures being experienced at the speed of light.

Batman hasn't actually had to use this weapon yet, although Ra's al Ghul did once use it on Wally West - with Wally confessing to his fellow Justice Leaguers that he was begging for his death after the vibratory projectile was lodged in his spinal column.

4. Thor

When it comes to being a bona fide god, there really are no weaknesses whatsoever for someone like Thor.

Advertisement

Here, we're talking about a character who has lived for over a thousand years and has stood up and toppled opponents with unimaginable power. Even on those rare times when Thor has been beaten, the Odinson still manages to eventually dust himself down, refocus and return to fight another day.

In the world of Batman, the World's Greatest Detective has faced the god-like Superman on several occasions, and Bats has usually won out during these confrontations. The thing with Superman, though, is he at least has the weakness of kryptonite.

Beating Thor sounds like an impossible task for Batman. For the Dark Knight, he could play up to Thor's competitive nature and engage him in a never-ending fight simulation, ala the plans Bruce had made for Wonder Woman in The Tower of Babel.

The Insider suit would be another wise choice for Batman here, providing him with the combined powers of the Justice League's heaviest hitters. Likewise, getting hold of a radion bullet would work wonders, with radion having helped bring down Darkseid in the past - and if it's good enough for a New God, chances are it'll do some damage to the God of Thunder.

Another option, of course, is to somehow manipulate Thor to carry out an act that would make him unworthy of wielding Mjolnir.

3. Captain America

When looking at the mainstays on the respective rosters of Marvel Comics and DC Comics, the two most impressive strategists who jump off the proverbial and literal page are likely Captain America and Batman.

Advertisement

If given notice, the World's Greatest Detective and the Sentinel of Liberty are capable of mapping out a plan to take down any threat, exploiting even the most minute of vulnerabilities in order to benefit themselves and their teams.

The pair's minds may be alike, but Cap has the added advantage of the enhanced abilities bestowed upon him by the Super Soldier Serum. Where Batman has an edge, though, is in basic physical combat.

Sure, Captain America is a brilliant hand-to-hand fighter, yet he doesn't have the extensive skills or knowledge of Bruce Wayne - with Bruce having travelled the globe, mastering a multitude of different fighting disciplines that have helped him to become one of the very best hand-to-hand combatants on the entire planet.

In that regard, a victory for Batman over Captain America comes down to simply engaging Steve Rogers in a basic, fundamental fist fight. Granted, Cap can hit like a truck, but Batman's mastery of technique will ultimately shine through in this battle, given he has succeeded against similarly powered characters in his own adventures.

Another plan of attack would be to make Rogers hallucinate, as Batman has done in a previous battle with Deathstroke - who is essentially a DC spin on the 'super soldier' figure.

2. Iron Man

While Batman shares so much in common with Captain America, he likely shares even more similar traits with Tony Stark.

Advertisement

Stark is essentially Bruce Wayne with the ego turned up to 11 and a greater appetite for advanced technology. Iron Man obviously has a tech advantage over Batman in terms of Shell-head's vast array of suits and the accompanying gadgets that each outfit brings with it, but Stark isn't facing some everyday villain were he to come up against with the Dark Knight.

With Bruce Wayne, you have a character whose greatest attribute is his mind and his ability to carve up the absolute perfect, tailored strategy to take down any foe - from all-powerful god, to mutated monster, to deranged criminal mastermind, to those with a vast array of swanky tech at their disposal.

The question of who has the greater mind between these two is likely too close to call, but one way in which Batman clearly edges out over Iron Man is in his sheer strength and physicality. If the Caped Crusader can play to Stark's ego, making him irate by poking the bear, that would draw Iron Man in to where Bruce could get hold of his opponent and physically dominate him.

Of course, you also can't rule out the wonderful toys that Batman himself can bring to the table to neutralise Stark's suit, particularly if an EMP rifle was to hand. And without his suit, Iron Man is nowhere near as imposing a threat.

1. Scarlet Witch

The obvious first issue to address if confronted with Scarlet Witch, is the ludicrously powerful magical abilities at Wanda Maximoff's fingertips.

Advertisement

Much like key to Batman defeating the Hulk is to take away the actual Hulk element, the pivotal part of being able to stop Wanda is to neutralise the powers that make her such an imposing figure.

For Scarlet Witch, she's a character who is often as erratic and insane as she is powerful - and considering this is someone who's one of the most powerful beings in all of comics, that should give you a good indicator of how unhinged Wanda can be.

If Batman is to have any chance of beating Maximoff, he has to play a little dirty. That means playing on Wanda's insecurities, pushing her to the edge of insanity, forcing her to become her own worst enemy. Should the Dark Knight get Wanda to become frazzled, that's when she may let her magical guard down, in turn making her an easy target for Batman to physically stop.

The problem is, Wanda's powers are so extreme that she could erase the Caped Crusader out of existence just by wishing it so. On the chance that he caught her on one of her more forgiving days, Batman could even come to Scarlet Witch in peace, much like he did to Ace in the Justice League Unlimited series. There, Batman made himself completely vulnerable as he approached the all-powerful Ace - with her realising that he had a pure soul and good intentions, which in turn allowed Bats to reach out to her and connect with Ace on a personal level.

While this article is all about how Batman would beat the Avengers, the reality of a fight with the Scarlet Witch is that Bats could well find himself faced with a task potentially too impossible even for him.

Advertisement