Ranking Every Joker Origin Worst To Best
"If I'm going to have a past, I prefer it to be multiple choice!"
The Joker, to many DC's greatest ever villain and one of the most enduring cultural icons of the 20th century, is heading to the big screens once again this October. Only, in a different way to how audiences are most used to seeing him.
Todd Philips' upcoming film will detail the birth of the Clown Prince of Crime, this time played by Joaquin Phoenix, and will seemingly forgo typical interpretations to tell a story inspired by the classic Scorsese flicks The King of Comedy and Taxi Driver. It won't overlook the source material completely however, with the film's tale of an aspiring comedian turning to crime mirroring the one told in Alan Moore and Brian Bolland's seminal yet divisive text, The Killing Joke.
The thing with the Joker though - and this has proven to be a major source of contention for fans regarding the upcoming film - is that his past is meant to be a mystery. He even said it best himself in Moore and Bolland's comic:
"If I'm to have a past, I prefer it to be multiple choice! Ha ha ha!"
As such, while there has been no shortage of stories that've attempted to relay one possible explanation for the Joker's existence, none are definitive. The Joker's terror is inspired by a lack of motive, rhyme or reason, while the character himself has often been seen as a force against narrativisation.
Be that as it may, if he is to have an origin, then fans are spoiled for choice. Dozens of writers have optioned various origins for the character on and off the page, but how do they all stack up? Here are the most compelling origins of all...
13. Three Jokers
It would be unfair to place this particular origin theory any higher on the list, given how Geoff Johns is yet to elaborate on it in any meaningful way, but it is worth addressing all the same.
It's not unusual for comic book characters to change looks and personalities as they develop on and off the page, but the Joker is a unique case. He's gone from being a psychotic killer to a clowning prankster, back to a psychotic killer, and then to an actual sado-masochist in his later years. He's also changed visually more than most, and the original, perhaps more compelling explanation for said development arrived in the pages of Batman courtesy of writer Grant Morrison.
In Morrison's works, he depicts Joker not as someone who is typically insane, but rather 'super sane'. To him, the Clown Prince is so intelligent that he can effectively reinvent himself whenever he wants, providing a logical in-world explanation as to why the character just keeps on changing.
As it stands, that theory looks to be getting updated in the near future. Johns and artist Jason Fabok are set to helm a 'Three Jokers' book within the year, which could redefine how we look at the character once again.
12. Batman 23.1 - 'Aunt Eunice'
The New 52 changed a lot about what readers thought they knew about the Joker, introducing three potential origins over its five year stay on the stands. One such origin emerged during DC's Forever Evil event, where Joker took over the main Batman comic for a brief issue.
Written by Andy Kubert with art from Andy Clarke, Time to Monkey Shine showcased a detailed look at the Clown Prince's childhood - or at least, what he thinks to be his childhood in that exact moment. We see how J was raised by his cruel and mean-spirited Aunt Eunice, who abused him day and night.
The most shocking moment of all, however, comes when Eunice takes a scrubbing brush, some bleach, and cleans the child with it until his skin turns white. It's such a dark origin for the Joker to have, but there are still some telltale signs that it isn't the actual one - with some of the abuse being borderline cartoonish in places.
In the end, Joker's story of a childhood lost isn't anything knew. Some days it's his father, others it's Aunt Eunice. Don't expect this one to be heading to the big screen any time soon at least.
11. The Brave And The Bold - Small Problems
In potentially one of the most unexpected dives into the Joker's backstory, this J. Michael Straczynski and Chad Hardin comic sees The Atom enter Joker's mind to cure a specific disease.
While there, he encounters several painful memories that show the Clown Prince being chastised by his family - quite rightly - for killing animals. Joker then seemingly burns his parents alive for their troubles, which duly affects Ray Palmer while he's in his mind.
Whether this was an actual moment from Joker's childhood or just a series of memories he cooked up for his own amusement is unclear, but it did at least give fans the terrifying image of the Atom burning with a menacing Joker grin.
10. Zero Year
If anyone were to pick up on a divisive aspect of Scott Snyder and Greg Capullo's Batman, it would probably be Zero Year.
The duo fashioned a new origin not just for Batman, but for the modern day Gotham too. It was fairly controversial, and one of the biggest sticking points proved to be the introduction of a new Red Hood Gang, which of course came with a new origin for the Clown Prince of Crime.
The basic structure of the new gang was that each Red Hood received a numerical designation, with Red Hood One the leader. When Batman first emerges as a crimefighter, he shows an instant attraction to the character not unlike the Joker. At the same time, this version of the Red Hood is also drawn towards Bruce Wayne, and it was very much clear where this was all heading.
In the end, Red Hood One takes the big green acid bath and presumably emerges on the other side as the Clown Prince we all know and fear. Or at least that's one theory. The GCPD recovers the body of one Liam Distal from the water after the Red Hood falls into the vat, but it remains unclear as to what exactly happened, and who out of the gang really went on to become the Joker.
9. The Pale, Immortal Man - Endgame
So, the New 52. Scott Snyder and Greg Capullo introduced quite a few changes for Batman's world, and while the mythology they constructed for the Joker didn't last, it was certainly one of the more curious origins that's been conceived during the Dark Knight's modern years.
Snyder and Capullo's comic optioned the theory that the Joker was actually one of the oldest beings on Earth, likening him to Vandal Savage and Ra's al Ghul as an immortal - or at least as a figure able to cheat death. The story goes that Joker - also known as the "Pale Man" - has been using Lazarus Pits long before the Head of the Demon discovered them, and has in fact been wandering Gotham for centuries.
As with most origins it remains unclear as to whether or not the Joker truly is immortal, but given this storyline then fed into the Three Jokers theory mentioned earlier, it is possible that at least one of them is much, much older than we all originally thought.
8. Batman: Lovers And Madmen
Batman Confidential featured a series of stories situated throughout various points of Batman's crimefighting career, but only one dared examine the beginnings of the Joker.
Michael Green and Denys Cowan's comic picks up early on in the Dark Knight's career, and spotlights a figure called Jack. Jack is a bank robber, and one who's seemingly disillusioned with his line of work... until he finds Batman.
Batman comes into his life to foil his crimes and suddenly Jack finds renewal. The Dark Knight gives him purpose, and soon enough Jack embarks on his own wave of terror, and starts leaving calling cards for his new obsession. He raids a charity event with the sole intention of meeting Batman, and when he murders one of the socialites in attendance, the Caped Crusader hurls a batarang in Jack's direction, slicing his mouth and disfiguring him in the process.
Desperate for results, Bruce enlists the help of the mob to track Jack down - which they do. They plan to execute him at a chemical facility, but as Jack breaks free he stumbles into one of the vats, making it through a drainage pipe and emerging with bleach-white skin and green hair.
7. The House Of Hush
The House of Hush actually features a somewhat overlooked origin of the Joker's - or at least a story from his past. That sort of makes sense, given how Paul Dini, Dustin Nguyen and Derek Fridolfs' series was and still is today one of the more underrated comics of DC's recent past, but that's all the more reason to highlight its brief foray into the Clown Prince's genesis.
As the title may already suggest, House of Hush is all about Batman's history with Hush, aka Thomas Elliot. The final and third arc in the Streets of Gotham series delves deep into the past and extracts all sorts of dark and disturbing moments, but by far the most revealing pertains to a young boy named Sonny, who is hospitalised at Dr. Leslie Thompkins' clinic.
The story goes that the child, named Sonny, is infected with a virus by ruthless property developers determined to use the low-income area as a plot for their own businesses. The mobster responsible was named Sallie Guzzo, and - years later - the Joker kills Guzzo after repeating the words he told Sonny when they infected him with the virus all those years ago.
While it's unlikely said virus resulted in the creation of the Joker, this origin feels more genuine than others. Dini himself claims that Sonny was the Joker, and who are we to question him?
6. How'd He Get Those Scars? - The Dark Knight
Heath Ledger's Joker was a pure tour-de-force, and one that possessed a disturbing and now iconic 'origin' on screen.
The Dark Knight stands today as the second and most beloved entry in Christopher Nolan's eponymous Batman Trilogy, and while there certainly isn't a shortage of iconic moments from the sequel, almost everyone revolves around the Joker. Potentially the most iconic of all - aside from the famed interrogation scene - is where Ledger's character begins to make his move against Gotham's mob.
The sequence sees the Clown Prince gatecrash a hideout and hold one of his rivals at knifepoint, where he then regales him in a story about how he "got his scars" - a reference to the permanent smile etched into his ghastly face.
He reels off a story about how his dad was a "drinker and a fiend", and how he took a knife to his mouth at a young age. On another occasion, he tells a story about how he did it to himself after his wife was scarred by loan sharks, in order to cheer her up. Both are disturbing, and the film lends weight to neither scenario.
Nolan's Joker, just like the one from the comics, has no fixed origin. But that doesn't make his stories any less intimidating.
5. Mad Love
Batman: Mad Love is one of the all-time great Batman stories.
Told in the Animated Series style by Bruce Timm and co-written by fellow BTAS alum Paul Dini, Mad Love chronicles the origin of Harley Quinn and details her abusive relationship with the Joker in explicit detail. It reveals how, while working as a psychiatrist at Arkham Asylum, she was manipulated by the Joker to the extent that she fell in love with him, assumed the Harley Quinn identity and broke him out of the Asylum, believing Batman to be the true villain in the pair's near constant cycle of violence.
During their therapy sessions, and in a bid to charm Quinn, Joker recounts a story from his childhood. He claims his father was abusive, and that the only time he ever saw his dad happy was when they went to the circus and observed a clown performing a classic routine. The next night, eager to win his father's affections, the childhood Joker greeted him with his dad's pants on, reenacted the skit, and tore a hole in them, only to have his nose broken for his troubles.
Later, while tied up and at the mercy of Quinn, Batman reveals that it was all a lie, claiming that it was just another tall-tale in the Clown Prince's list of tall-tales.
He recounts the story about his abusive father, one about his alcoholic mom and another about him being a runaway orphan. All are said to be a ruse, but they go some way in speaking to the best Joker origin of all - the one that doesn't exist.
4. Batman '89
Batman '89 included a few controversial changes to Joker's backstory, and while fans can debate all day regarding the value of making the Clown Prince also the killer of Thomas and Martha Wayne, there's no denying Tim Burton and Jack Nicholson sold it well.
To many the proto-typical 'gangster' Joker origin, it's no surprise that '89 went on to influence various other Joker origins in the following years. Even the alias Jack Napier came from Burton's movie, while the film's impact on other aspects of Batman's world varies from Gotham's design to the Batsuit itself. In short, there's no overstating its importance.
Joker starts out Batman '89 as a mobster called Jack Napier. He serves under mob boss Carl Grissom, but it soon becomes clear that Carl isn't so keen on Jack, and is in fact looking to bump him off on account of him sleeping with his mistress. They head to Axis Chemicals, Batman intervenes, and soon enough poor Jack finds himself in a vat of acid for his troubles.
Of course, the biggest change of all is that a young up-and-coming Napier was responsible for the murder of the Waynes. It's a divisive change that's for sure, but there's still so much to praise about '89's origin - including the amazing moment Jack cackles after receiving surgery.
3. Case Study
Case Study is another origin inspired by Batman '89, but one that also brings together the considerable talents of Paul Dini and Alex Ross.
Dini and Ross' comic heralds from the same school of thought as Morrison's in that it hypothesises that the Joker isn't insane, and can therefore not be 'cured' of his insanity. It shows the perspective of two doctors at Arkham Asylum and one who has arrived at that very conclusion after glancing at a forgotten report, which also details a version of events that created the Joker we know today.
According to the report, the Joker was once a prominent criminal who eventually created the Red Hood persona out of boredom. He then ostensibly fakes his insanity after falling into a vat of chemicals (again, after being ambushed by Batman), wearing it as a 'mask' as a means of matching the Dark Knight and summarily avoiding any prospective capital punishment, should he ever be apprehended.
The doctors almost seem won over by the theory, until Harley Quinn gets dragged past and finishes the conclusion for them. It was Quinn's thesis while she was at Arkham, and the story relayed to her likely another made up fantasy.
2. Mask Of The Phantasm
Batman: The Animated Series is the definitive version of Batman past or present. It masterfully combined Burton's art-deco Gotham with the comics of yore to impart a truly compelling version of the Dark Knight's world - one that still manages to win affections today.
Sadly, the genius of BTAS didn't always go noticed. When Warner Bros. Animation released Mask of the Phantasm in cinemas in 1992, it bombed at the box-office. This, despite it also being up there with the greatest comic book movies ever made. (Return of the Joker slightly edges it in my books, but that's by the by.)
Anyway, MOTP - like Batman '89 - follows the same model of having the Joker start out in Gotham as a gangster. When a new vigilante known as the Phantasm rides into town, murdering Gotham's mob one by one, the Clown Prince himself becomes a target. During his investigation, Batman discovers that the Joker was a chauffeur for the Valestra crime family, and had in fact murdered the father of Andrea Beaumont, now revealed to be the eponymous Phantasm.
Mask of the Phantasm is the perfect Batman story, and while fans tend to prefer less concrete Joker origins, this one fits the context of BTAS perfectly.
1. The Killing Joke
The Killing Joke is one of the most controversial Batman stories of all time, and one Alan Moore - characteristically - wants nothing to do with. On one hand it exemplifies some of the most destructive tropes in the superhero genre (a torturous focus on the macabre and the fridging of women stand out the most), while on the other it perfectly nails the dichotomy between the Clown Prince and his greatest rival, right down to his complicated and uncertain origins.
But it's also a book of contradictions. While Moore reiterates in no uncertain terms that the origin optioned by the Joker shouldn't be taken at face value, it's also gone on to influence several incarnations of the character both on and off the page. It both is and isn't a representation of Joker's spontaneity, and that can make grappling with the book's legacy somewhat frustrating.
Either way, the origin optioned by The Killing Joke sees the Clown Prince as a failing comedian struggling to support his pregnant partner. Just when things are at their most desperate, the mob comes along with an opportunity for the comedian to make a quick buck, by pretending he's the Red Hood during a break-in to a chemical facility.
The rest of the story is fairly familiar. Batman shows up, Joker gets knocked into a vat of chemicals, and emerges as the Clown Prince. Or does he?
The genius of Moore and Brian Bolland's text is that it never once lends weight to the Joker's version of events. He could've had "one bad day" as he suggests, or this could be another sick fantasy he's concocted to rationalise his evil. In the end, however, it epitomises the rogue's appeal. There's simply no point trying to explain him, and the sheer array of origins on offer - along with TKJ - contributes to that chaos.
Why bother changing it?