Spider-Man: 10 Dumbest Creative Decisions The Comics Have Ever Made
Earth-616 Spidey just can't seem to catch a break...
Spider-Man is, without a doubt, Marvel's greatest character. Even if that's not a sentiment you can agree with, the wall-crawler is certainly the House of Ideas' most iconic creation, and he's been through a lot since swinging into the pages of Amazing Fantasy #15 in 1962.
There are a lot of amazing, spectacular, and downright astonishing tales to be found featuring the webbed wonder, but some creative decisions made over the years have just been plain dumb. Recently, it was revealed that Harry Osborn is demonic new villain Kindred, and while it's too soon to say whether that's a good or bad decision, it's certainly one that could flop as hard as those listed here did.
Whether it's Spider-Man acting completely out of character, his villains doing some seriously weird sh*t, or the random resurrections, deaths, and plot twists that plague comic book storytelling to this day, the web-slinger has seen it all.
Things have definitely been looking up for Spidey in the main Marvel continuity these past few years, but for the most part, it's been one misfire after another.
10. Radioactive Sperm Killed Mary Jane Watson-Parker
Spider-Man: Reign is one of many Marvel stories set in a possible future, and there are definitely some good ideas to be found here. Written and illustrated by Kaare Andrews, this tale takes place in a New York City which has fallen under the control of a fascist government (and superheroes are no more).
Peter Parker is now in his 60s and seemingly not all there, and while things do get a little too weird and silly with the addition of a zombie Doctor Octopus and the return of the Venom symbiote, there are some strong ideas to be found.
However, the biggest creative failure comes when the cause of Mary Jane's death is revealed.
It turns out that spending years having sex with Peter and, ahem, sharing his "DNA" led to MJ suffering terminal cancer.
The wall-crawler's radioactive... fluids... killed his wife, and learning that led to him giving up being Spider-Man. This was just too strange, and a ridiculous way to push poor Peter over the edge.
9. The Lizard Eats His Son
Zeb Wells and Chris Bachalo's "Shed" storyline ran from Amazing Spider-Man #630 to issue #631, and it's actually pretty great. Taking a deep dive into the mind of Dr. Curt Connors and what it means for him to share that with the Lizard, the mild-mannered scientist is eventually overwhelmed by his other side, and murders his son in the process.
The line was blurred here between Curt and the Lizard in a big way, and while the story itself was effective enough, there were better ways to handle this than having him kill his young son.
The Lizard quite literally eats poor little Billy, and had this led to big things for the villain, it might have been easier to justify. Instead, Curt would eventually regain his mind, reunite with a cloned, Lizard version of his son, and then go on to return to his old status quo in Nick Spencer's current run.
Making a hard-hitting creative decision like this should change everything. Instead, it was just another throwaway tale in the "Brand New Day" era which is only remembered for the shock factor.
8. Superior Spider-Man
Awful. Just awful.
It's hard to think of another word to describe the decision to have Doctor Octopus take control of Peter Parker's body and live his life as the "Superior" Spider-Man. Along the way, he creepily romanced Mary Jane while pretending to be Peter, killed criminals, and ruined the wall-crawler's relationships with some of his greatest allies.
Had this been a storyline lasting for just a few arcs, it might have been easier to digest, but this went on for years.
The story ended with a whimper when Ock just decided to hand control back to Peter because he couldn't defeat the Green Goblin, and if you're that desperate to check this one out, you'd be better off with Christopher Yost's Superior Spider-Man Team-Up.
This was a dark time for Spider-Man, and it's a story which did nothing for Peter in the long run.
7. Everything About "Sins Past" (Seriously, Everything)
J. Michael Straczynski was on track to go down as perhaps one of the greatest Amazing Spider-Man writers of all-time, but he really lost the plot near the end (that's still a title he deserves if you just stop reading after John Romita Jr. left the series).
For proof of that, look no further than "Sins Past." When Peter Parker is attacked by two masked assailants, he unmasks one of them and finds Gwen Stacy's face staring back at him. As the story unfolds, it's revealed that Spidey's lost love had an affair with Norman Osborn, and fled to Europe after falling pregnant.
There, she gave birth to Gabriel Stacy and Sarah Stacy, two children who rapidly aged to adulthood thanks to the Goblin serum coursing through their father's veins. Gabriel becomes the "Grey Goblin," while Sarah becomes friendly with Peter. It was just weird and terrible, and sullied The Night Gwen Stacy Died storyline by revealing the real reason Norman killed Gwen was because of said affair.
Both characters have mostly been forgotten since, and while the story hasn't exactly been retconned, it's unlikely to ever be referenced again.
6. Spider-Man Joins The Avengers
Prior to "Sins Past," J. Michael Straczynski's Amazing Spider-Man run had started dipping in quality with the decision to have Spidey join the New Avengers. That wasn't a choice he made, though, and it instead unfolded in the pages of Brian Michael Bendis' Avengers series when the web-slinger joined his fellow heroes in stopping a breakout in The Raft.
Previously portrayed as a loner, Spidey suddenly became a key member of the team, but always ended up being treated as something of an afterthought.
Living in Avengers Tower, his friendship with Iron Man would ultimately see him unmask in the pages of Civil War. Bendis - who had done such a fantastic job with Peter Parker in Ultimate Spider-Man - didn't even give him the chance to shine during Dark Reign and Siege, two stories revolving around his greatest nemesis, Norman Osborn.
It was a strange dynamic, and one Marvel Comics has mostly moved away from in recent years. Spider-Man still gets involved in big events, but not as a spare part Avenger.
5. Peter Parker's New Organic Web-Shooters
These days, it's pretty common for what happens in the movies to influence the comic books. The trend really started with the release of those early X-Men and Spider-Man films, though, and a big change was made to the wall-crawler to line up with Sam Raimi's onscreen vision.
In his trilogy, Peter Parker had "organic" web-shooters and didn't create them himself, an idea deemed unrealistic for a teenager in the world those movies took place in.
Crossing paths with a weird new villain called the Queen, a kiss leads to Spider-Man transforming into a spider, though he starts by growing extra arms and eyes. From a body horror point of view, it's not bad, but things get incredibly dumb when it's revealed the giant spider he's become is pregnant with the Queen's offspring. Before giving birth, though, he curls up and just...dies.
With that, a naked Peter bursts out of the carcass, revealing that he now has insect telepathy (no, it hasn't been used since) and organic web-shooters - a convoluted and frankly unnecessary change.
4. Mary Jane Dies (And Aunt May Returns)
It's no secret that the nineties were not a good time for Spider-Man fans, and Marvel Comics were big on shocking readers at the time. They were also determined to end Peter Parker's marriage to Mary Jane... by any means necessary.
The supermodel and actress is being stalked by a mystery assailant, and ends up "dying" after boarding a plane that randomly explodes in mid-air. With that, Spidey is a widower, though it's later revealed that MJ's mutant stalker faked her death and held her captive. When she returns, she decides to leave Peter, and everything about this story - which played out over two years - was just plain daft.
It was around this time that there was another big change to the webbed wonder's life, though. With the signs pointing to his and MJ's stillborn daughter May still being alive, Spider-Man broke into Norman Osborn's home to retrieve her. Instead, it's revealed that it's his Aunt May, who is back after dying in Amazing Spider-Man #400.
It turns out that May was an actress who had undergone plastic surgery and changed her DNA.
Really.
3. One More Day
One of the most hated Amazing Spider-Man stories of all-time among comic book fans, "One More Day" is also undeniably stupid.
After Peter Parker reveals his identity to the world, but turns on Iron Man's pro-Superhuman Registration Act forces, he becomes a wanted fugitive. Seeking to take the ultimate revenge on his old enemy, the Kingpin puts out a hit on Spidey and his family, and poor Aunt May ends up taking a bullet. Long story short, she's dying, and Peter is forced to take drastic measures.
After everyone he turns to makes it clear that they can't help, the Marvel Universe's version of the devil, Mephisto, offers Peter a deal: his marriage in exchange for his aunt's life. Peter and MJ accept, and what followed was a new status quo for the web-slinger which regressed his character development by a good 20 or 30 years.
"One Moment in Time" attempted to make sense of this baffling story, but it appears Marvel Comics has finally seen sense and are allowing Nick Spencer to undo this during his current run.
2. Tony Stark-Lite
At the end of Dan Slott's Superior Spider-Man run Amazing Spider-Man was relaunched, and Peter Parker was ready to take full advantage of everything Doctor Octopus had done while in control of his body. As the CEO of Parker Industries, the web-slinger became Tony Stark-lite, a billionaire businessman with a tonne of gadgets and an entire company at his disposal.
It wasn't good however, and the fact it ended with Peter losing everything and once again reverting to his "loser" status quo just made the entire endeavour feel like a huge waste of time.
The biggest, dumbest issue here, however, was the fact that a wealthy Peter with everything he could ever want at his disposal just didn't feel like a natural progression for the character. Yes, it was a rather refreshing change of pace, but the series just couldn't manage to stick the landing.
Peter being a struggling photographer who can't pay his rent is old hat, but everything from the skyscraper to his new suit just made him feel like a wannabe Tony Stark, and that has never been what this character is truly all about.
1. The Clone Conspiracy
"The Clone Conspiracy" revealed that there was a new Jackal in town who was cloning all of Peter Parker's fallen friends and enemies. While the story was cleverly used as a way of resurrecting some familiar faces who were overdue a return, writer Dan Slott dropped the ball in a huge way when it came to reuniting Spidey with the likes of Uncle Ben and Gwen Stacy (which didn't need to happen).
However, by far the dumbest idea on display here came with the reveal that it was Ben Reilly beneath the Jackal's mask. Peter's clone from the nineties and the Scarlet Spider, Ben was massively popular, but everything here was basically just a character assassination.
This direction made zero sense for Reilly - who at one time even replaced Peter as Spider-Man in the comics - and it's a shame Marvel has sidelined him ever since.