What Does The Final Image Of The Killing Joke REALLY Mean?
"I've been thinking lately. About you and me..."
No Batman comic is able to boast a legacy as controversial as Alan Moore and Brian Bolland's The Killing Joke. Publicly derided by the former in recent years, the eighties' most divisive Bat-comic always seems to be in the spotlight in one way or another, whether it be because of the release of a new edition (FYI, yes, the original colouring is superior), a bungled animated adaptation, or rumours that it'll inspire a story in Warner Bros.' tempestuous DC Extended Universe.
One instance a few years ago did, however, inspire renewed debate in regards to the comic. Appearing on Kevin Smith's fantastic Fatman on Batman podcast, writer Grant Morrison (the mastermind behind Arkham Asylum: A Serious House on a Serious Earth, Batman & Robin, Animal Man and other such books), optioned a theory regarding The Killing Joke's ending. Speaking to Smith, Morrison argued that:
"Killing Joke’s good. And I kind of like Killing Joke’s… we talk about this, no one gets the end, because Batman kills the Joker… that’s why it’s called the Killing Joke. The Joker tells the killing joke at the end, Batman reaches out and breaks his neck and then the laughter stops, and then the light goes out, because that was the last chance of them crossing that bridge.Alan wrote the ultimate Batman Joker story, because he finished it… the laughter stops, it abruptly stops. It’s quite obvious."
Morrison certainly wasn't the first to discuss this theory; Bolland himself had teased it in the afterward to the comic's 2008 re-release, saying that:
"Speaking of which, it's time I revealed what really happened at the end of The Killing Joke: as our protagonists stood there in the rain laughing at the final joke, the police lights reflecting in the pools of filthy water underfoot, the Batman's hand reached out and..."
There are two potential avenues to go with that tease: one, that Bats extends is hand out and cuffs the Joker for the GCPD prowlers speeding onto the scene; two, that he reaches out and, in some twisted moment of clarity, kills him. There's enough evidence in the comic to substantiate either claim, but in capturing the themes of the novel, which is the more authentic?
At its core, The Killing Joke is a comic all about the cycle of violence that both characters - Joker and Batman - perpetuate in their own way. It's a conflict of escalation, and in that respect, The Killing Joke represents the only logical conclusion of the Clown Prince's seventies rebirth, where his violence manifests in the most abject way imaginable. Batman, at the start of the novel, is already aware of how this story ends, with either one of them (or both) dead - it's why he reaches out in a moment of desperation during the comic's opening.
This intro, combined with the Clown Prince's closing anecdote, provides the thematic foundations for Morrison's interpretation. And while it's certainly a controversial one, it isn't without merit...
2. There Were These Two Guys In A Lunatic Asylum...
So, does Joker actually die in The Killing Joke? There's no definitive answer, and examples from the text could be considered circumstantial at best, but the crux of the argument lies in the joke the Clown Prince tells in the book's final few panels.
After sincerely informing Batman that he can't, in fact, be saved, Joker does what he does best and begins to tell a joke. This one revolves around 'two guys in a lunatic asylum', and how, one night, they decide to make a last ditch attempt at escaping. The two actors in this anecdote are clearly meant to be Batman and Joker, with the Dark Knight being the one who promises to shine the flashlight across the buildings so they can escape, and the Joker being the one too afraid to make that leap.
Here, Joker acknowledges that he, like Batman, wants to escape this cycle - he's just too afraid to do so. The importance of the anecdote is hammered home further through Bolland's use of light; Joker, right as he approaches the concept of freedom in his joke, looks to the moon. As he continues, the lights of some nearby police cars cast a thin light on the deepening puddle beneath the two characters. It's the same light from Joker's story, promising both he and Batman a life free from their twisted fellowship. Like the actors in his joke however, neither he or the Caped Crusader are able to mount the escape they want to, with the light closing just as Joker's laughter - and the police sirens close by - come to a sudden end.
Is this closing of the gap - as Morrison claims - confirmation that Batman kills Joker? It makes sense, especially since - in Joker's story - Batman represents the one character who's already made that leap to freedom. Joker not joining him then could have - as Morrison's theory goes - forced Batman's hand; their one last chance to escape was over.
Batman killing Joker also ties into Batman's earlier interrogation with the fake Clown Prince, where he proclaims that the pair will kill each other eventually. "Perhaps you'll kill me. Perhaps I'll kill you. Perhaps sooner. Perhaps later." In The Killing Joke, Batman's worst adversary commits his most heinous crimes, and in attacking those closest to the Dark Knight, it would make sense that the ending he prophesied at the beginning of the novel would come to fruition - perhaps sooner.
Add to that the sudden end of Joker's laughter, and there's a solid case to be made that Joker's last laugh was had in Moore's comic.
There is another interpretation however, and one that, in many respects, is even more tragic than Morrison's own. In this case, the anecdote's importance remains the same, but the closing of the light doesn't (immediately) bear the lethal consequences of that other one. Rather, it consigns both actors to their relationship ad infintium. Joker and Batman are doomed to repeat this cycle forever, with no logical end in sight. It isn't triumphant, but it denies Joker his victory, with Jim and Barbara Gordon both rubbishing the notion that all it takes is 'one bad day' to experience the reality the former Red Hood does day in, day out.
There's also the simple fact that, after The Killing Joke, the character has made plenty of appearances. Were we to take Moore's comic as Morrison does however, as the 'last' Batman story, it would still leave the Clown Prince's fate in the balance, irrespective of Bats' own no killing rule.
1. We're Going To Kill Each Other, Aren't We?
While the Joker's 'death' in The Killing Joke can be debated endlessly, one thing that can't is that the crux of the comic lies directly in the cycle of violence both he and Batman partake in. It only seems to get worse every year, and Batman - acknowledging the dangers of continuing to play such a game - understands that it can only end one way.
In The Killing Joke, it could be argued that Joker gives Batman no alternative but to kill him. The Dark Knight has exhausted all his options in attempting to bring him back from the brink, but in a moment of brief clarity, the Clown Prince concedes that he's beyond redemption. What, then, is Batman supposed to do with that knowledge? Does he continue to play the game and hope that this is the last time Joker breaks free? Or, acknowledging that rehabilitation is no longer an option, does he end the cycle then and there, as those who subscribe to Morrison's theory claim he does?
At the very least, Morrison's idea of The Killing Joke being the 'last' Batman story in the vein of Moore's Whatever Happened to the Man of Tomorrow? provides finality to that cycle. It might not adhere to the format of that comic, but in looking to address Batman's most definitive relationship, Moore may have also found a way of closing the book on it in a satisfying, albeit ambiguous manner.
The truth about The Killing Joke's ending is that there is no truth. Literal interpretations of the text would read that, because the Joker made subsequent appearances in mainstream DC continuity (and because the comic is a mainstream DC book), he didn't die. To the same degree, conceptualising the comic as the 'last' Batman story allows the character to pass on in a fitting and all too tragic manner, with all other options exhausted. It allows the Joker to both live and die, and while that might seem like a weak answer, there is no authoritative conclusion to posit.
In the end, The Killing Joke is coy in its finale. Most signs, and the thematic core of the novel, point towards a moment where Batman and Joker will be forced to confront their own relationship. It is up to the reader, no matter how inconclusive they may be, to decide what form it takes.
What do you think the ending of The Killing Joke really means? Be sure to let us know in the comments below!