Why The Comics Industry Needs To Change (Before It's Too Late)

The direct market is bad for business, but neither Marvel or DC will admit it.

By Ewan Paterson /

DC Comics

Comic books today are the most valuable resource when it comes pop-culture. Coveted by studios and dominant onscreen, the reign of the superheroes pervades across multiple mediums and doesn't show any sign of waining - at least not in the most obvious places.

Advertisement

Most, perhaps reasonably, would assume that a healthy box-office generated primarily by stories that originated in the comics medium would mean that the comics industry itself is also in a healthy place. That depends on who you ask, but while the industry is still going relatively strong, it's doubtful that there's anyone out there who doesn't think that things need to change. The onscreen popularity of the Marvel Cinematic Universe and, to a lesser extent, the DC Extended Universe, hasn't automatically engendered an uptick in sales on the comics side of things. The same old problems remain, and to many, the comics medium - certainly when it comes to DC and Marvel - is still relatively inaccessible.

How so? Well that comes down to a myriad of issues. For all that DC and Marvel have tried to jump in on the success sparked by big screen adaptations of their comics, only a few initiatives have really worked. Reboots and retcons net a short-term gain but risk alienating older readers, while newcomers may glance at the sheer number of relaunches and retcons and feel that there's no point in jumping in, lest they get invested in a particular continuity, only for either publisher to pull the plug in search of their next harebrained scheme to pull in more readers.

Advertisement
Marvel Comics

Comics creators themselves have bemoaned attempts from publishers to ape what the films do, and given how neither company looks like they're on the cusp of the next big comics boom, it's fair to say they may have a point.

But for all the reboots, retcons and relaunches, there's one glaring problem neither publisher seems particularly enthused about confronting. Those who don't read comics probably aren't even aware of its existence, but for longtime readers it's a name that needs no introduction - the 'direct market'.

Advertisement

The point is that the way comics are actually sold is holding them back, and with talk of publishers outside of the big two looking to divest from single-issues and adopt a collection-based, graphic-novel-style-only model, things could finally be about to change...

4. What Is The Direct Market?

Fox

For most people, the direct market is sort of... elusive? Most readers are aware of its existence, but tracking the logistics of how it all works can be tedious and somewhat confusing.

Advertisement

And therein lies the rub. The direct market is confusing, and there's no shame in admitting that! If you aren't involved in comics retail and don't know how sales figures are aggregated or how stuff gets ordered, the entire discourse can seem a tad intimidating. But it is still possible to unpack, and doing so should hopefully expose why the whole thing causes more problems today than it actually fixes.

So, the direct market. The whole thing was created in the 1970s by a man called Phil Seuling. Seuling's system initially comprised several different comics distributors that allowed retailers to make purchases straight from comics publishers, like Marvel, DC and others. This brought with it a whole host of benefits, as, essentially, retailers could relay to the publishers what their readers wanted more accurately. The more demand there was for a given comic, the more likely it was it would avoid cancellation or that a spin-off series would be released to capitalise on demand. It gave way to the rise of specialty comic book stores, and gradually, over time, comics left the stands of newsagents, supermarkets, and more traditional book shops.

Advertisement

All fine and dandy, you might think, but there were drawbacks. Unlike most other systems, products ordered under the direct market were non-returnable. This meant that most comics stores were left with a surplus of issues - 'back issues', as they're more commonly known - that they were unable to sell. This effectively meant that retailers had to gamble with every order. Order more of a given comic, and there was a chance that they could be left with surplus stock that they wouldn't be able to shift for years to come.

DC Comics

However much the risk weighed on certain businesses, the direct market still afforded opportunities to other publishers outside of the Big Two's (Marvel and DC's) control. Companies like Image and Dark Horse were two of the most successful challengers to the status-quo - a demonstrably good thing, I think most readers would agree - but that's not what's necessarily defined the direct market in recent times.

Advertisement

When we talk about the direct market today, it tends to be because of a few reasons. Either one: the rise of digital-only services posing a new challenge, like Comixology or Marvel Unlimited; two, the not-so-ethical practices of the big publishers, whether that's pandering to speculators in the nineties, flooding the market with variant covers or introducing draconian incentives for retailers to order more product; or three, the fact that the only guaranteed way to support a given comic just doesn't make any sense at all.

When taken together, all of these problems paint a decidedly grim picture of the industry. One that needs to change sooner, rather than later.

Advertisement

3. There's Only One Way To Support A Comic... And It Makes No Sense

DC Comics

In any other industry, sending a message to the decision makers at the top is fairly simple. If you like a given product, let them know by purchasing it. It doesn't really matter how you do (unless it's second-hand); whether you're lining up at midnight to see a film day one or purchasing it digitally months later, studios will have an accurate idea of how popular a given film is based on box-office performance.

Advertisement

TV is somewhat similar. If you like a show, tuning in when it airs terrestrially or by streaming it online is a great way to support it, as the more people who are watching, the more obvious it is for networks to keep it on the air.

Now, imagine that these traditional forms of support didn't exist, and instead, only pre-release tickets counted towards a film's box-office gross, or a given TV show's ratings. That would be wild, right? When these stories are told over a long period of time, with sequels and further seasons lined up, it wouldn't make any sense for producers to axe plans for a follow-up without having a full enough picture, and especially not when the majority of viewers haven't been considered during the decision-making process.

Advertisement
Marvel Comics

Well, that's currently how things are with comics. The only tangible way to support a series - and to let the powers that be know that there's demand - is to pre-order it through a specialist comic book store months before it's due to release. Under the current system, you could buy an entire series of comics lying on the stands, and if you hadn't pre-ordered them in advance, there's no way for publishers to tell that there's increased demand.

This is obviously a major problem. So many new readers are finding comics through different channels, whether that be digital sales, or even through trade collections after a given arc has wrapped up, but the direct market effectively ignores them! It's as if they're not even buying the series in the first place.

Advertisement

Consequently, we now have a situation where a comic could find an audience through trade, only for said audience to discover that what they're enjoying was cancelled months earlier. Couple that with other issues, such as the inconsistent promotion of certain titles, and it's far too apparent that the current system isn't fit for purpose.

2. How Marvel Take Advantage Of The Direct Market... For The Worse

Marvel Comics/Alex Ross

If an archaic ordering system wasn't bad enough, comics readers also have to contend with dubious tactics from some of the big publishers, none more-so than Marvel.

Advertisement

Depending on your familiarity with the industry, you may or may not be aware of the comic book crash that occurred in the 1990s. This developed for a myriad of reasons, but was primarily driven by an intense 'speculator boom' that occurred at the beginning of the decade. Speculators drove to comic book stores in the hope of finding the next Action Comics #1 or Amazing Fantasy #15, a comic that could, in the future, stand to net them a tidy sum. Marvel and DC duly reacted, relaunching comics with brand-new #1s to capitalise on the flood of new buyers. Other such gimmicks designed to get speculators to buy more comics soon emerged, with everything from character redesigns to shiny foil variant covers being deployed to ensure sales kept rising.

Eventually - and to no one's surprise - the speculator bubble burst, and very nearly caused Marvel to cease as we know it. It would stand to reason that such a chastening event would probably make publishers rethink their strategies, and while it's true that the gimmicks of the nineties are long dead (most of them), Marvel in particular hasn't been able to kick all their worst habits from that decade.

Advertisement

Relaunches and variant covers are the two biggest issues currently, and while both aren't just a Marvel problem, they're certainly the publisher who utilise both tactics the most. Relaunches have the adverse effect of putting off longtime and new readers (no doubt due to anxiety over investing in a series that may not even matter in a year's time), with Marvel seemingly preferring the short-term uptick in interest over retaining a long-term audience on certain books.

Marvel Comics

Variant covers, meanwhile, artificially boost the company's sales figures. They don't show the real extent of modern-day comics readership and they divert funds away from where they're most needed, like promotion, or in better compensating freelance talent.

Advertisement

But this isn't even the worst part. Variants alone are bad enough, but Marvel has also developed a knack for introducing 'incentives' for retailers to order more of them. Basically, if a retailer orders X amount of a certain comic, they'll be 'rewarded' with a special variant, encouraging stores to order more stock in the hopes that more speculators - NOT new or long-term readers - may pick it up.

It doesn't take an expert to know that this isn't a healthy strategy. While Marvel should be busy cultivating new readers, the publisher continuously pursues old gimmicks in search of its next short-term hit. If it's not a relaunch, then it's a crossover. If it's not a crossover, then it's a variant. And while all the blame can't go towards the direct market, it's still the case that it enables the aforementioned problems.

Advertisement

1. Why Trade Collections Are The Future

Image Comics/Babs Tarr

The intent of this piece isn't meant to prophesise doom for the industry. Comics have been around for decades and they'll be around for decades longer. It's more just that there are glaring issues that aren't being addressed, with the direct market being the most obvious example.

Advertisement

There are so many reasons to be optimistic about comics, whether that's just the sheer number of amazing books there are on shelves or the conscious effort being made by certain publishers to tap into the young adult and children's markets with new incentives. DC, which has both Zoom and Ink - imprints geared towards younger readers - deserves particular praise for doing just that, but their traditional comics are still in need of change.

This is where trade collections come in. Trade paperbacks and hardcovers - better known as 'graphic novels' - have a greater reach than single-issue 'floppy' comics. They don't have adverts everywhere, and - with the exception of Marvel, whose trades are bizarrely hit-or-miss in terms of quality - they all have better presentation. They're easier to store, less expensive, and some publishers are - slowly but surely - even electing to print entire runs exclusively through trades. New arrival TKO Studios has adopted this model, while Image has also shifted several of their books from single-issue, monthly releases to instead release them in trade collections, Motor Crush and Moonstruck two of the most notable examples.

Advertisement

Bleeding Cool reported just this January that over half of the top 100 selling graphic novels over the last decade were published by Image. The publisher clinched 51 spots on the top 100. Marvel and DC, meanwhile, lagged behind at 10 and 30 respectively. While it's still the case that the Big Two possess the lion's share of the direct market, it's clear that genuine readers are flocking to Image through their trades, which are not only sold at comic book stores, but at general book shops and high-street outlets.

Image Comics/Sana Takeda

Image's success in this regard may yet be a sign of things to come. In a conversation with Newsarama's Chris Arrant, Image publisher Eric Stephenson intimated as much.

Advertisement
"I think everyone involved [in the Image titles that are changing] agreed the monthly comics weren’t reaching the audience we wanted to reach, but the trades were doing well - and in the case of Moonstruck, markedly better in bookstores - so it seemed like the most logical step forward... If it makes sense for other books in the future, then great, but generally speaking, I don’t think comics and graphic novels should be treated as interchangeable. Comics should be written as comics, and graphic novels should be written as graphic novels."

One of the more interesting comments made in the above quote pertains to how writers go about framing story arcs. Stephenson argues that "comics should be written as comics", and vice-versa with graphic novels. It's the case today that a lot of comic book writers are effectively 'writing for the trade', ditching one-and-done issues to tell big, expansive arcs that are paced differently to how one may expect an average comic to read.

When so many creators are telling their stories to fit these trades in the first place, would it not make more sense for publishers to prioritise them? It seems as though that's where the most potential is. And even if retailers still have to go through the direct market to order these collections, trades still inhibit some of its most frustrating elements, specifically the saturation of variants, as well as the premature cancellation of under-promoted books.

Advertisement

It's not a case of one size fitting all, but it's so obvious that the current model isn't working. Why not try something different for a change?