10 Abandoned Scripts Better Than The Finished Movie

A Jurassic World with human-dino clone soldiers? Much less bland.

By Kenny Hedges /

The story is when author William Faulkner left Hollywood, they cleared out his desk only to find dozens of empty liquor bottles and page after page, Shining-style, of the same words over and over: "Boy meets girl. Boy meets girl. Boy meets girl."

Advertisement

There's a reason screenwriter characters in movies are often portrayed as sad sacks, struggling artists turned jaded by a Hollywood that buys up their material only to butcher it. It's an old cliche, the writer who comes to Hollywood thinking he's made it, only to find the property shallow, incapable or uninterested in original thought.

And there are countless examples of scripts that showed promise only to be rewritten, altered or filmed in ways disrespectful to the words on the page. The script and screenwriter are often just tools for the filmmaker to get across what they want.

Other times, the script is changed or rewritten because the studio got cold feet on the project and, hoping to make whatever they can off their purchase, retooled it to fit in with whatever was trending at the time.

Either way, there are dozens of unused drafts of scripts that we're sure you can find in any Starbucks recycling bin. Here are the ones we wish we got to see.

10. Alien 3

The history of the production, scripting and marketing surrounding the third entry in the Alien franchise serves as a word of warning about truth in marketing and the importance of forethought. Not only were ads running before a script was finished, advertising that the xenomorphs have finally entered our atmosphere, but the finished product didn't even approach earth.

Advertisement

There are several abandoned drafts of Alien 3, possibly the most famous being sci-fi writer William Gibson's contribution. Gibson worked enthusiastically finished a drafted that hewed closely to David Giler and Walter Hill's initial ideas; an action-oriented script that focused on Michael Biehn's Hicks from the previous film and the notion of the evil Weyland-Yutani company breeding xenomorphs as bio-weapons. So popular was Gibson's draft that it has been adapted into a graphic novel.

After the writer's strike, Gibson was asked to make rewrites but instead walked away from the project, frustrated with producers stalling. The project passed to horror writer Eric Red, who was rushed and focused the action of his draft on a bio-dome-in-space environment meant to ape small town America. He disowned the draft.

There were other drafts, each incorporating ideas from the previous and also pulling away from other aspects, until somehow we were left with a script set on a monastery-like planet made of wood that mistakes the alien for Satan and Ripley as its harbinger.

This was eventually changed into an ultra-religious, weaponless prison planet, and with a director in a young David Fincher, Fox set about shooting the unfinished script, writing it along the way.

9. Ken Russell's Dracula Would Have Been Much Crazier Than What Killed It

Ken Russell, notable enfant terrible of cinema, has made some truly incredible films, but he's certainly an acquired taste. The Devils, Altered States and Tommy are all works of art, but they're often considered too extreme to sit through. That's to say nothing of Lisztomania, a film about composer Franz Liszt whose opening scene is a nausea-inducing single shot of the man's (Roger Daltrey) hedonistic lifestyle.

Advertisement

So it makes sense that he approached Bram Stoker's classic horror novel, with a cast that would include Oliver Reed in the title role, Peter Ustinov, Mia Farrow, James Coburn, Peter O'Toole and Mick Fleetwood (one of these things is not like the other).

Russell's take on the count was not unlike his portrait of Liszt. "If you lived for centuries," Russell wrote of the potential film, "would you go weak in the knees at a picture of a dull clerk’s fiancée and lock yourself away in a gloomy castle? I wouldn’t. I’ve come up with a reason why Dracula would want to live forever." Apparently, however, much of the origin and debauchery featured in Russell's script was more autobiographical than faithful to the source.

That it began its existence as a proposed ballet speaks to just how garish and over-the-top Russell intended the film to be. But the success of John Badham's adaptation with Frank Langella ultimately killed the project. Russell's biographer, in the introduction to the published script, has since accused Francis Ford Coppola of plagiarism for his 90s version of the novel. And Russell himself did re-visit the vampire genre in 1988 with Lair of the White Worm.

8. Child's Play Was More Of A Psychological Thriller

Until the remake, Don Mancini had been the brain behind every Child's Play film. He and Brad Douriff, the voice of the murderous doll, stuck through the franchise's darkest eras, went meta, managed to get positive responses to Direct-to-VOD releases and created a horror icon that has lasted three decades. Even his meta-phase is largely well-regarded amongst fans, having fun with its notoriety.

Advertisement

But Chucky wasn't always a corny, one-line delivery machine with a knife. Mancini initially envisioned the film as a psychological thriller, with one questioning the sanity of Chucky's new owner Andy. There's some of that in the produced film, but it's only the first act. The original script called for the Chucky reveal to only occur in the third. It was director Tom Holland, coming off the surprise success of Fright Night, who suggested the change.

What we got was great, but something more insidious certainly would have been interesting during the golden age of dime-a-dozen slashers.

7. Brainscan Didn't Have A Freddy Krueger Knock-Off

Another in a long line of films that should have taken the less is more approach, Brainscan is director John Flynn's attempt to cash in on the mid-90s virtual reality craze - a curious craze considering it never caught on in reality, only in pop culture - using a cheap horror film. One of the goofiest additions to the tech-gone-awry subgenre of horror was that of Trickster, a VR Freddy Kruger-like gaming avatar that drives player Edward Furlong to murder and bodily dismemberment.

Advertisement

But the original draft barely featured Trickster, leading viewers to question Furlong's sanity. Before T. Ryder Smith was cast in the role, he was just a 2D face on a screen. Once Flynn saw a hair metal burnout at auditions, Smith's role was expanded before he was even told.

This was an early script for Se7en and Sleepy Hollow writer Andrew Kevin Walker, so its darker implications are more in line with the goofball finished project.

6. Live Free Or Die Hard Pulled Every Punch... And A Lot Of Blood

At the turn of the millennium, the suits in Hollywood realized they could manage to milk more profit from a PG-13 rated film than a hard R. Thus we were subject to a few dozen lightweight entries into franchises that tried to be pre-teen friendly - PG-13 Scream knock-offs and action sequences that packed no punch.

Advertisement

Live Free or Die Hard is a special example, as the studio didn't even bother to tell director Len Wiseman that they were turning the fourth Die Hard film into a PG-13, muting the infamous "Yippie Kay Aye Motherf****r" with a gunshot and removing a lot of blood with CGI.

It's worth noting that, until the unspeakably awful fifth film, no Die Hard had been an original script. The first was based on a novel called Nothing Lasts Forever, starring a character formerly portrayed by Frank Sinatra in The Detective. The second is based on a novel called 58 Minutes. The third was a spec script called Simon Says that was originally the basis for a Lethal Weapon sequel. And Live Free was based on a script that was inspired by an article in Wired entitled "A Farewell to Arms."

It's somewhat of an irony that this is the action franchise that would pull back, given that its survival was based on expansion (building

Alas, the draft by Mark Bomback had much more violence and swearing, and even the unrated director's cut only restores blood with CGI. We'll never get a hard-R John McClane again, we'll get Bald Terminator surfing on F-14s all the while careful not to make a swear.

5. Jurassic World Was Way Cooler When Raptors Had Machine Guns

There were many theories about the future of the Jurassic Park franchise after the third film performed to an underwhelmed audience and critical appraisal. But the effects were good enough to convince Steven Speilberg, who walked away from the franchise after The Lost World, to start scouting a fourth film.

Advertisement

Spielberg again turned to John Sayles and future Departed scribe William Monaghan. And though some of their ideas sort of appear in Jurassic World, Colin Trevorrow's tonal disaster of a sequel sounds like a weak compromise compared to what Sayles intended.

And what had he intended? Well, human-velociraptor hybrids with guns, that's what. Have I got your attention?

Though Jurassic World does float the idea of training dinosaurs to be military weapons, it's not the main thrust of the film, which would have taken place on the mainland. Sayles' entire script focuses on the elusive shaving cream bottle of dino DNA that Denis Nedry tried to get off Isla Nublar in the first film and weaponizing dinosaurs. A new character, an ex-Navy SEAL named Nick Harris would eventually develop into Chris Pratt's raptor-wrangler.

But that's as close as the finished film gets to Sayles' knowingly silly B-Movie level fun. The franchise had already jumped the shark after the T-Rex arrived in San Diego in the last act of The Lost World, and rather than pull back, Sayles dove headfirst into camp.

The series seems to have course-corrected, with the next sequel featuring a planet overrun by loose dinosaurs, but they won't be packing heat.

4. Jade Could Have Been As Big As Basic Instinct

Jade was a failed attempt to re-live the success of the Joe Eszterhas-scripted Basic Instinct. All the allure, taboo and lurid exploitation of Paul Verhoeven's erotic crime thriller would this time be in the hands of legendary director William Friedkin.

Advertisement

But in the early 90s, the director was in a bit of a rough patch. One would think hot property material like an Eszterhas script would be his ticket back into industry, but his most recent output had been largely maligned, the one factor each film had in common was Friedkin's tooling with the screenplay.

Films like Rampage and The Guardian were trashed in the press, and Friedkin took his red pen to Jade as well. Eszterhas, while not revealing much of what was in his draft, recalls reading negative reviews that bashed the film's screenplay, putting most of the onus on the printed word. "When I read the review," he wrote in his memoir American Animal, "I got nauseous. Because I agreed."

Friedkin admitted he made drastic changes, but he would later come out on top with films like the critically acclaimed Bug and Killer Joe. The last credited writing Eszterhas has done was An Alan Smithee Film: Burn Hollywood Burn.

3. Wes Craven Presents Was The Matrix With Monsters

They came and went out of theatres with little to no fanfare, one of the few films under the banner of "Wes Craven Presents". Though Craven's involvement was little more than funding and licensing his name, They does seem like a project that would attract the director; like A Nightmare on Elm Street, it focuses on people suffering from night terrors that turn out to be much more than just bad dreams.

Advertisement

Unfortunately, what killed you were anonymous boogeymen afraid of the light. But that wasn't always the case. Orginally, the 2002 film was written by Brandon Hood with a concept that sounds very much like The Matrix, but horror.

Hood's script explained where "They" took their victims: They are godlike, organic beings that exist just beyond our world and harvest our organs and limbs for spare parts.

Alas, the studio rejected any sort of explanation and had the script rewritten from scratch.

2. Hancock Was A Hard-R Superhero Film About Alcoholism And Suicide

Hancock was made in an era when Superhero films were just starting to be taken seriously by producers. It came out the same year as Iron Man, when superheroes were still a tad on the cartoonish side but also included some authenticity. The DC Universe had yet to get too gritty, and the world wasn't ready for Vincent Ngo's Tonight He Comes, the dark, hard-R script that would eventually turn into Peter Berg's wildly uneven film.

Advertisement

Producer Akiva Goldsman liked Ngo's script, which he first read in 1996, but had no place for it. It wasn't until 2002 that it was rewritten by John August and Breaking Bad creator Vince Gilligan that a ten-page treatment was handed to Will Smith. The script retained a lot of Ngo's bleak superhero movie, which featured a vulgar, hard-drinking Superman, which original director Michael Mann described as "a scathing character study" and compared the tone to Leaving Las Vegas.

Alas, by the time director Peter Berg got hold of it, "We thought the idea was cool, we just wanted to lighten it."

Read: Neuter it.

1. Body Snatchers Had More Of A Statement About Military Vs. Civillian Life

The third film adaptation of Jack Finney's novel is one of director Abel Ferrera's least controversial films, and while critics like Roger Ebert hailed it as the best yet, others derided it as inane, claiming that setting it on a military base - where everyone is supposed to act the same anyway - takes away from the insidious terror of a foreign invasion.

Advertisement

Whatever your opinion, and whatever the filmmaker was trying to say about the military, sounds like it was better and more clearly expressed in earlier drafts. Originally written by Stuart Gordon and Dennis Paoli of Re-Animator film with assistance from Larry Cohen, it took place just outside the military base, putting small-town average citizens in focus once again.

Advertisement