I absolutely love any film or TV programme set in prison. I am the proud owner of all 692 episodes of Prisoner Cell Block H on DVD boxsets. I have a real dread of ending up in prison - not because I commit crimes, but because I fear being framed or caught in the wrong place at the wrong time. The idea of prison has captivated the cinematic imagination for decades and it has produced some very decent films - among them, some of the greatest films that have been made. These films deal with the misery of being confined all day, the deep friendships and bitter rivalry that can develop between prisoners, saintly or sadistic screws, the Darwinism of prison that only the strong survive. Prisons are definitely hotbeds of drama, cruelty and also transcendence. I have listed 10 prison films that captured my imagination below. Please add your own favourites.
10. Stoic (2009)
Four prisoners are playing a game of poker for cigarettes. What becomes a bet for Mitch to eat toothpaste if he loses, erupts into a case of severe bullying, harassment and violence as his three other cellmates force him to eat the toothpaste. This is followed by forcing him to drink various liquids - including faeces and urine from the toilet bowl. When Mitch is sick after drinking this putrid concoction, he is forced to lick up his vomit. After a failed escape attempt by Mitch, one of the cellmates anally rapes him. They then shove a broom handle up his rectum and sodomise him with it, forcing the broom handle into his mouth when it is covered in faeces and blood. Mitch goes catatonic. His cellmates decide to hang him and make it look like suicide as this trauma might result in a lowering of their sentences. So they do this, press the emergency button and put on an act of shock and upset. The three cellmates are interviewed about Mitch and they display various amounts of remorse. The notorious Uwe Boll has a sudden change of direction in his career with Stoic, instead of making Z grade video game adaptations he turns to art house prison based fare. Stoic is brutal, harrowing and gruesome. The squeamish viewer may find themselves feeling thoroughly nauseated by the events in the film. However, Stoic is not a run of the mill film, it is distinguished by its probing of peer pressure and it is also very well acted by an ensemble cast which features Edward Furlong. What happens in the film is horrific but it is also compelling to see just how far the cellmates will sink in their depravity and to which degree will they show individual contrition about what happened. The group dynamics are fascinating to watch - how people can be egged on to do dreadful things by each other. That is what lies at the heart of the film. All the grotesquery with broom handles etc. is just a byproduct to shock the viewer out of complacency. I cannot say that I enjoyed it, but it was different.
9. Scrubbers (1983)
Two young women - Carol and Annetta - escape from an open borstal for girls. Carol wants to be sent to a closed borstal to be with her lover Doreen. Annetta wants to visit her baby daughter who is being raised in an orphanage. Carol ends up in prison but Doreen has a new lover. Annetta is arrested at the convent and blames Carol when she is brought to the same borstal. She is hellbent on revenge but an inmate called Eddie, who is a pretty tough woman, falls for Carol and they become girlfriends with Eddie protecting Carol. But eventually Eddie leaves borstal and also leaves Carol to an uncertain fate with Annetta on her tail. Directed by Mai Zetterling, Scrubbers is the female answer to Scum which was made a few years before Scrubbers. It is a very absorbing film but it isn't in the same class as Scum. Nevertheless, it is a gritty look at what goes on in Women's prison with lots of same sex relationships - however, it must be said that the film doesn't exploit this theme to reel in viewers. The central story of Annetta's revenge on Carol drives the narrative forward. It is tragic because Annetta is driven by fierce maternal love - we can see this in the scenes where she has to be sedated and she hallucinates that her child is in the cell with her. Carol is merely a scapegoat into which Annetta pours her frustration. Kathy Bates turns up in an early role as a borstal girl and Pat Butcher out of Eastenders plays a warden. I watched the film the other day and you could spend 90 minutes watching something a lot worse.
8. Yield To The Night (1956)
The beautiful young Diana Dors, Britain's foremost sex symbol of yore, gives an amazing performance as a young woman - Mary Hilton - convicted of murder, and serving out her last days before she is hanged. Much of the advertisements for the film capitalise on Dors' sexy image by labelling the film 'Blond Sinner'. This is really selling the film short - Diana puts in an immaculate and heart rending turn of a woman, who perpetrated murder and must face the consequences of the time. She is not a glamour figure in the film - she wears no make up and she sports prison clothing. The film was loosely based on the Ruth Ellis case - the last woman to be hanged in Britain - who committed a crime similar to the one of Mary Hilton in the film. The film is very strongly anti capital punishment - reflecting a general surge in the unpopularity of the death penalty in 1950s Britain. The depiction of the penal system is very realistic with a door at the bottom of Mary's cell where she knows she will go through to die. It taunts her everyday. Mary Hilton builds up relationships with the prison wardens who look visibly pained when the appeal goes against Mary - there are no evil screws in this film. Despite its anti death penalty tone, the film is never didactic in its message. At the beginning we see her calmly and coolly murder her love rival. The murder is predetermined and callous. However, despite your views on capital punishment, you will admire the film either way for Dors' tour de force acting skills and the well executed (pardon the pun) direction.
7. Midnight Express (1978)
Whilst in Turkey, Billy Hayes attempts to smuggle hashish out of the country. Bad move. He is arrested and questioned by the police. If he can track down the taxi driver who gave him the hash, they will release Billy. He points out the taxi driver and stupidly tries to run away. He is locked away in a Turkish prison where he is surrounded by Westerners who warn him of the evil Turkish ways and he is told never to trust them. In 1974, Billy is given a thirty year sentence and his life goes down the swanny. He is beaten and tortured by the screws. Billy has a breakdown and attacks his cellmate Rifiki - biting off his tongue. Because of this, Billy is sent to a ward for the criminally insane and has a rough time there. Things start to improve for Billy when he sees his girlfriend Susan who gives him money and tells him to escape. Billy gets his wits together and crosses the boundary from Turkey into Greece. The film has an awesome score by Giorgio Moroder which won an Oscar. Midnight Express stoked up considerable controversy on its release - mainly because it took liberties with the book it was based on. The movie was also charged with having nothing interesting or useful to say about the penal system, or what inmates go through. Instead it is a piece of xenophobic anti Turkish garbage which portrays Turkish people as violent savages without exception. They were used to sensationalise the film. In 2004, screen writer Oliver Stone apologised for the portrayal of Turks in the movie. Looking beyond the negative portrayal of Turkey and Turkish people in the films, there is a clear sense that Western values are superior and humane. It is a very well made and involving tale by director Alan Parker but I would dispute its veracity and its exciting ending comes only after an entire nation is slandered.
6. Birdman Of Alcatraz (1962)
Robert Stroud is imprisoned for killing a man in Alaska. He is very rebellious and cannot stand authority figures of any kind. He gets into a fight with a warden over his mother's visiting rights and the man dies. Stroud is imprisoned for the rest of his life in solitary confinement. Somewhat bored, Stroud keeps a sparrow as a pet. This love of birds balloons until there are caged birds of every variety in his cell. He is particularly good at treating ill birds and he becomes an authority on bird diseases. He meets Sally, a fellow bird expert, and they marry. He is transferred to Alcatraz where is is denied access to birds. Still rebellious after all these years, he stokes up anti-authority feeling in Alcatraz and after a while, he is transferred to another prison and eventually paroled. Robert Stroud was a real life being, portrayed as largely an average, albeit gifted, man by Burt Lancaster. However, people who knew him say he was a giant douche and the film did not portray the real character of Robert Stroud. After all, the man was a murderer and not the saintly rescuer of sick birds that he is in the film. However, despite the real life version of Stroud coming to light, Birdman of Alcatraz is a compelling film with Burt Lancaster giving an excellent performance as only Burt Lancaster can. It is quite a long film for a man to be so enamoured of birds and devote so much time to this, but the supporting cast in the film - including Telly Savalas, Karl Malden and Betty Field - is very strong and they add to the film's depth. Whatever Stroud's character, the film is a testament to a man who had an unbreakable spirit and managed to achieve great things for the world of ornithology despite being locked up from the world. As I am a cage bird enthusiast, I loved the movie and I was very touched by the scenes of avian first aid. It is a very moving affair and the end of the film is upbeat. Maybe Stroud was a jerk, but Lancaster does an amazing job of wresting compassion towards the character.
5. Papillon (1973)
Henri 'Papillon' Charriere is a safecracker unfairly convicted of murder in 1930s France. He is sent to the infamous French penal colony - Devil's Island. He makes the acquaintance of fellow convict Louis Dega, who hires him as a bodyguard, but they eventually become friends. A sadistic screw attacks Dega and Papillon defends him. He thus gets thrown in solitary where Dega smuggles him food. Papillon is caught with the contraband food but refuses to implicate Dega. Papillon is then deprived of food by the screws. He is driven to eat insects and he spends two years in solitary where the screws torture hum. When he is released, Papillon and Dega plan their escape. Andre Maturette, a gay orderly, insists on escaping with them. They bribe a guard into giving them a boat but when they escape, Dega breaks his ankle and the boat is not sea worthy. Furthermore, there are bounty hunters waiting for them. It seems the prison sets up prisoners like this quite a lot. After a trapper kills the bounty hunters he refers the escapees to a leper colony where they get a boat and supplies. When they arrive at the main land, soldiers open fire and shoot Maturette and capture him along with the injured Dega. Papillon seeks refuge with a native tribe for a while but eventually they move on and leave him. He further seeks refuge in a nunnery but they turn him over to the police. Papillon spends five years in solitary but he is then reunited with Dega and the pair have the last laugh at the prison. The film boasts excellent performances from Steve McQueen as Papillon and Dustin Hoffman as Dega. The movie could be a contender for McQueen's best ever performance and Hoffman gives his customary amazing portrayal of a complex character. McQueen has to endure a lot of torture and suffering in the movie and he is convincing in his agony and despair in a very demanding role. The score to the film is very good and the movie is well paced. Those looking for a lot of prison based mayhem may be disappointed by the film's pace but it is realistic in showing the viewer the repetition and boredom of prison life. You will never forget the scene at the end in which Papillon urges Dega to jump off the cliff with him. We have the final satisfaction of Papillon triumphing over the prison which is a tribute to his indomitable character.
4. Scum (1979)
New inmate Carlin arrives at a borstal for beating up a warden in a previous borstal. He wants to keep a low profile about this but the prison's 'Daddy' Banks finds out about this and starts bothering Carlin. Eventually Carlin snaps at Banks' bullying of the timid and vulnerable Davis. In the film's most iconic scene, he puts some snooker balls into a sock and beats up Banks and his crony. Carlin is now the prison 'Daddy'. Life under his regime is much better in the prison - there is less bullying and racial crimes. The governor of the institution is impressed with Carlin and they begin a semi-cooperation. However, a major spanner to prison cohesion is thrown into the works when Davis is raped in the greenhouse by a couple of inmates whilst a warden just stands there smoking a cigarette and smirking. Obviously this act has a massive emotional effect on Davis and that night, he cuts his wrists. He presses the emergency button but the screws ignore it, only to find him dead in a blood soaked cell in the morning. Of course, there was a serious dereliction of duty regarding the treatment of Davis by the screws. Carlin instigates a prison riot at lunchtime for the inmates to express their disgust. The film ends with a moment's silence for Davis. The script for Scum was rejected for being too violent for the BBC in the 1970s. It was eventually aired on Channel 4 in 1983, after the reform of the penal system. It is indeed a shocking film with lots of violence, rape and indifference of the wardens. Ray Winstone gave a very auspicious performance as Carlin - showcasing his amazing acting talent and giving us a taste of the brilliance he would lend to various films over the years. The film has a very naturalistic, almost documentary like feel to it, this makes what happens in the movie all the more alarming because it isn't just a piece of fiction, this is what borstal life was really like - stupid, sadistic screws, bullied inmates, sexual abuse, fighting over who runs the prison - it is obvious from the film that Scum is just presenting the facts. There is no rehabilitation in the movie - just punishment, boredom and violence to pass the days. Forty years later the film loses none of its ability to shock and distress.
3. Dead Man Walking (1995)
Matthew Poncelot has been on death row in Louisiana six years for killing a teenage couple. He approaches Sister Helen as the date of his execution looms to help him with his appeal. She assumes that he will come across as arrogant and cocky, but instead pleads his innocence saying that a man called Vitello did the murders. Sister Helen has faith in Matthew and gets a lawyer to take on his case for free. She develops a deep relationship with Matthew and on a wider scale with his family, as she champions Matthew's cause for life imprisonment rather than execution. The victims' families are not impressed by this. Her crusade is crushed and Matthew asks her to be his spiritual advisor on his final day. He makes a confession that he killed the boy and raped the girl after Sister Helen tells him he must be truthful in order to be redeemed. Just before he is executed, he confesses all to the families and says that he hopes his death will bring them peace. He is executed and then buried. Thank goodness, given his well known left wing political beliefs, Tim Robbins did not use the film as a soap box for his own agenda. The film is, instead, subtle and nuanced. Pro capital punishment viewers will not be offended, and neither will anti capital punishment folk. The film is a detailed study of both sides of the argument - showing Matthew's ultimate confession that he was guilty of the crimes and the devastation of the families whose lives his murderous actions have impacted on so dreadfully. Both Susan Sarandon and Sean Penn give amazing performances. Sarandon's Sister Helen shows compassion for Matthew even whenever he reveals himself to be the killer. He let her be led on by him feigning innocence and then he practically takes a dump in her mouth by his confession of guilt. But she still has compassion for him no matter what he has done or said. Sarandon deserved the Oscar for Best Actress.
2. The Green Mile (1999)
Paul Edgecomb, resident of a Louisiana nursing home, begins to cry when he sees the film Top Hat played on the TV, his friend Elaine asks him what is wrong and he tells her the saga of John Coffey who was a prisoner on death row where Edgecomb worked. Coffey was sent there after being found guilty of the rape and murders of two white girls. He is a shy and sensitive man who demonstrates amazing healing abilities. He heals the governor's terminally ill wife, resurrects a mouse and cures Paul's UTI. Meanwhile, a sadistic guard called Percy joins the staff. Everyone hates him, but he has family ties to the governor. A prisoner called "Wild Bill" Wharton arrives in death row. He grabs John's arm and John psychically senses that Bill is responsible for the crime John is going down for. In a display of master class telepathy he makes Percy shoot Bill and go into a state of catatonia. Edgecomb asks him how he does this and John takes his hand and gives him 'A part of himself' so he can see what happened to the girls. John is offered freedom by Edgecomb but says he is too weary and sick of the world. As a last request before his execution, John watches Top Hat. So that is why Edgecomb is depressed. Plus John is 108 years old. He was given this longevity by absorbing some of John's energy but he has outlved everyone he loved and that is his punishment from God for letting an innocent man die. Frank Darabont does an amazing job to bring Stephen King's novel to life. It is a great story which makes for a great film. It is long at over three hours - which reflects the slow passing of time in a prison, but it is never boring. It is definitely more character than action driven, and the acting is astounding. We are talking flawless here. I am not a fan of Tom Hanks or the kind of movies he appears in, but he does acquit himself admirably in The Green Mile. As do the rest of the cast. The setting of the movie could have been quite claustrophobic - death row is not exactly spacious - but Darabont uses interesting and unusual filmic techniques to flesh out the setting. Michael Clarke Duncan who plays John Coffey is a real revelation here in a very moving performance. He almost out acts Tom Hanks, but Hanks with his compassionate approach to his death row inmates and his thorny moral dilemma about putting to death an innocent man carries the crux of the movie with panache.
1. The Shawshank Redemption (1994)
In 1947, Andy - a banker - is sentenced to two consecutive life sentences in Shawshank Penitentiary for killing his wife and her lover. He maintains his innocence. He quickly befriends Ellis - a smuggler who brings him in pictures of Hollywood screen Goddesses such as Rita Hayworth and Marilyn Monroe. He is however, given wide spread trouble by Bogs and the Sisters, a bull queer gang. After Andy gives the chief prison officer some useful financial information, Bogs is severely beaten and is no longer a threat. The governor sends Andy to the library where he cooks the prison's books and launders the prison's money. He is placed in solitary after Tommy, a new prisoner tells him of an identical murder to that of Andy's alleged crimes. Andy goes to the warden with this information but is held in confinement and Tommy is killed. After he is released, he tells his good friend Red about a Mexican resort he wants to go to and he tells Red that if anything happens to him that there is a package in a field in Buxton waiting for Red. Andy disappears. The governor is irate because all of these years, Andy has been burrowing away, making a tunnel for his escape. He goes to the various banks and retrieves the prison's ill gotten gains. He gives the newspaper details of prison corruption and the governor kills himself when he is exposed. Red receives parole after 40 years and finds it difficult to adjust to the outside world. He remembers Andy's instructions about a package in a Buxton field. He retrieves it and finds loads of money and directions to Mexico, where is is reunited with his old pal Andy. A true contender for the Greatest Film of All Time contest, The Shawshank Redemption was not a box office hit but become a home video/DVD sensation through word of mouth recommendation. There is not much action in the film - mainly prisoners talking to each other - but it is richly packed with humour, drama and the message to never give up hope in the face of adversity. Andy is such a wily character, he takes on streaks of genius - tunnelling through his prison cell wall and throwing all of the prison's financial corruption - that they enforced him to take part in - back in their face. We endure the vicissitudes of prison life in which prisoners are treated like meat and must comply with a rotten regime only for Andy to make a successful bid for freedom. Undoubtedly, some of the prisoners must have been bad boys to end up there but despite their crimes, they are portrayed fairly as human beings who form friendships and care about each other. Extremely highly rated for a film - 9.3/10 in the IMDB and receiving virtual universal acclaim, The Shawshank Redemption proves that Hollywood can really pull its head from its ass and produce perfect films.