The fame ladder is a harsh thing. A-list stars like Johnny Depp, Brad Pitt, and Julia Roberts (just to name a few) became famous for wowing audiences in supporting roles and later gradually built their reputations with starring roles in successful movies. Still, success can often be as much about luck as it is about talent because one bad role or box office bomb could have derailed the once-promising careers of any star. Because of that, there are many actors who seemed poised for stardom and touted as the next big thing by Hollywood only to see their careers fizzle out and die spectacularly. Some of these actors are just as talented as Hollywood predicts them to be, but whether it's due to bad role choices or off-screen behavior, these would-be stars soon find themselves wasting their talent in projects that are many steps below the ones they made their names doing. Here are ten actors who seemed hovering on the edge of Hollywood success whose later careers never matched their critical and commercial peaks expected of them.
10. Edward Norton
Ed Norton had an impressive series of movies during the 1990s, with Primal Fear, The People vs. Larry Flynt, Rounders, American History X and of course, Fight Club. However, after the turn of the millennium, the actor had several behind-the-scenes mishaps that hurt his reputation. Brett Ratner reportedly had difficultly working with him on Red Dragon and Norton publicly admitted that he only did The Italian Job because of contractual obligations to Paramount, which isn't exactly what a studio wants an actor to say when promoting a film. However, Norton's behind-the-scenes struggles culminated during the production of The Incredible Hulk. He agreed to star in the movie when he was given control over the script, which he continued to change during shooting. Norton was also reportedly angry that producers insisted the film be under two hours, so he did very little to promote it. Likely because of these issues Norton was replaced as Bruce Banner in The Avengers, and he missed out on a piece of The Avengers' billion-dollar box office. Norton has mainly appeared in low-budget indie films since except for a supporting role in The Bourne Legacy. Luckily for him he has become a member of Wes Anderson's reoccurring cast and will appear in his second feature directed by Anderson this year, but that connection alone can't recreate Norton's 1990s success.
9. Crispin Glover
Everyone thinks of Michael J. Fox and Christopher Lloyd when they think of Back to the Future, but just as important to the first movie is Crispin Glover and his amazing portrayal of George McFly. Unfortunately, Glover refused to return for the sequels because of a pay dispute, and in the meantime, during an infamously eccentric appearance on Late Night with David Letterman Glover nearly kicked Letterman in the face. As it turns out, Glover was doing an in-character performance of his character from the movie Rubin and Ed, but the movie was not released until four years after the interview, and the lack of context did terrible things for his image. Since then, he's mostly done a number of little-seen movies, and a few of them have been acclaimed. There's nothing wrong with Glover doing quirky indie movies if that's what he chooses to do, but along with his enjoyable oddball roles he has also appeared in terrible mainstream movies like Charlie's Angels and its sequel and Epic Movie, or under heavy makeup or special effects like in Alice in Wonderland and Beowulf. So it's clear that Glover is willing to do mainstream movies, but he makes very odd choices and prefers not to be noticed. But could you imagine what Glover could pull off in a movie with a cast as talented as he is?
8. Winona Ryder
Winona Ryder became a crowd and critical favorite after her starring role in Beetlejuice and went on to cement that profile by starring in popular films like Heathers, Edward Scissorhands, Dracula, Age Of Innocence, and Reality Bites. She was even supposed to star as Mary Corleone in The Godfather Part III and undoubtedly would have improved the ridiculed film had she not pulled out because of exhaustion. In the mid 1990s she starred in the box office bomb The Crucible and the disappointing Alien Resurrection, but with her talent Ryder could easily have overcome those setbacks. Butthen in December 2001, Ryder was arrested for shoplifting $5500 worth of clothes from a Beverly Hills department store. During the highly publicized trial Ryder was accused of being on various drugs to explain why a millionaire would steal clothing, and she was found guilty on most of the charges and had to serve probation. Though she has since worked steadily in lower budget films or bit parts in blockbusters (like 2009's Star Trek) her career has never recovered from the stigma of her bizarre crimes.
7. Mickey Rourke
Few actors were as highly praised in the early 1980s as former amateur boxer Mickey Rourke. After Rourke was personally selected by Elia Kazan to attend the Actors Studio, he burst on the scene in a variety of critically acclaimed roles, including Body Heat, Diner, The Pope of Greenwich Village, 9 1/2 Weeks, and Barfly. However, he did several odd films in the late 1980s like portraying St. Francis Of Assisi in the almost three hour Francesco, the nearly X-rated Wild Orchid, and the box office bomb Harley Davidson and the Marlboro Man. And then in his infinite wisdom, at the age of 38 he decided to return to boxing. While he was remarkably successful in the ring for a man of his age, injuries left his once-handsome face disfigured, and his concentration on the sport meant he had to turn down roles in many films that would go on to become classics, including The Silence Of The Lambs and Pulp Fiction. Rourke returned to acting full-time in the mid-1990s, and he looked like he was poised for a Robert Downey Jr. style career resurrection after acclaimed performances in movies like Sin City and The Wrestler (for which he was nominated for an Oscar). But Rourke has since had trouble finding meaningful roles, and several of his recent movies (such as Passion Play and Java Heat) were only released in limited theaters. He will appear in the Sin City sequel in 2014, but that's his first notable role in several years.
6. Val Kilmer
After strong performances in supporting roles and getting a reputation as a ladies' man in Hollywood, Val Kilmer was exposed to mass audiences in the 1986 blockbuster Top Gun, and received critical praise for his portrayals of Jim Morrison in The Doors and Doc Holliday in Tombstone. It all built to 1995, which was a huge year for Kilmer: not only did he star alongside Robert De Niro and Al Pacino in Heat, but he played Batman in Batman Forever. It doesn't get any bigger than playing the Caped Crusader, right? While it looked like Kilmer dodged a bullet by deciding not to return for the abomination that is 1997's Batman and Robin, his next film was the box office disaster The Island Of Dr. Moreau, which he actually wasn't awful in. And that was about the end of that. Since then Kilmer has been prolific, but not successful; for every good film he is in (Kiss Kiss Bang Bang), he seems to make a half-dozen bad ones. He appeared in seven movies that were released in 2009 and six that were released the year before, and a number of them were never even in theaters. His increased output also parallels his weight, which has ballooned significantly since his Batman days.
5. Katherine Heigl
The beautiful Katherine Heigl became a star on the TV series Grey's Anatomy, and while on the show she co-starred in the 2006 Judd Apatow comedy hit Knocked Up. Heigl seemed poised to follow in the romantic comedy footsteps of Julia Roberts and Sandra Bullock with 27 Dresses and The Ugly Truth, but she started burning her bridges by complaining about the writing on Grey's Anatomy and insulting Apatow by saying Knocked Up was "a little sexist." Somewhat unfortunately for her image, the comments gave Heigl a reputation for being ungrateful. The romantic comedies that she has appeared in since, including Killers, New Year's Eve, and One For the Money, have generally underperformed, and she also has the distinction of starring in the lowest grossing movie of all time, 2006's Zyzzyx Road (which grossed $30). Add to that the persistent reports that she and her manager (her mom) are difficult to work with and it's no surprise that her stardom imploded. Her latest work is a TV commercial for sleep medication, which sums up her current status appropriately.
4. Lindsay Lohan
Honestly, we don't have the space to go into detail about all of the chances Lindsay Lohan blew in her relatively short career. However, Lohan once appeared to be one of the few child actors destined for adult success when she starred in the box office hits Freaky Friday and Mean Girls. But since then, her off-screen legal troubles and addictions frequently derail any chance for her to capitalize on her few critical successes, like A Prairie Home Companion. In addition, her once pretty face has been ravaged by what appears to have been botched surgery. In 2013 she starred in what was considered her comeback movie The Canyons, which was controversial for being borderline softcore pornography (which probably surprised noone.) It was beset by on-set meltdowns, rejected by film festivals, and grossed only $51,000 in its short run. In other words, don't call it a comeback.
3. Halle Berry
When Halle Berry became the first African American to be awarded a Best Actress Oscar in 2002, it seemed like the gorgeous actress had cemented her role as a performer and sex symbol. In the years preceding she starred in the first X-Men movie and helped sell millions of tickets to Swordfish simply because she appeared topless in it. When Berry followed Monster's Ball with the box office hits Die Another Day, X2: X-Men United, and Gothika her position on the A-list seemed secured, and there was even talk of her starring in the first James Bond spinoff movie starring her Die Another Day character. However, Berry obliterated her reputation by starring in the critical and commercial failure Catwoman in 2004, and then after the third X-Men movie in 2006, Berry did not have a major box office hit until 2013's low-budget The Call and most of her movies, like Things We Lost in the Fire, Cloud Atlas, Dark Tide, and Movie 43, were major bombs. She is set to co-star in another X-Men movie later this year, which seems to be the one thing that has worked for her career this century.
2. Shia LaBeouf
After rising from a troubled childhood in poverty and becoming a teen star on the Disney Channel series Even Stevens, Shia LaBeouf appeared to be the subject of an inspirational success story. His first major role as an adult was the thriller Disturbia, and LaBeouf next starred in Michael Bay's huge budget blockbuster Transformers, which set his career wheels in motion. Transformers producer Steven Spielberg was so impressed that he cast LaBeouf in Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull and publicly touted LaBeouf as the next big thing even if most audiences and critics didn't agree. Numerous legal troubles made it clear that LaBeouf had personal issues, and his biggest issue was his mouth. He criticized both the Transformers movies and his Indiana Jones movie, earning the ire of the Hollywood heavyweights who had supported him. He was then fired from a Broadway play only weeks before the opening for his erratic behavior during rehearsals and publicly clashing with co-star Alec Baldwin. But that was nothing compared to his latest scandal. A short film that LaBeouf directed was discovered to be almost entirely ripped off a comic by Ghost World creator Daniel Clowes. The fallout over the scandal and his mocking of Clowes by suggesting he would plagiarize his work again has led LaBeouf to claim that he is retiring. From having Spielberg as your #1 fan to being ostracized in five years that's a colossal career meltdown.
1. Robert De Niro
Robert De Niro is rightfully recognized as being one of the greatest actors of the twentieth century for an astounding run of great movies from 1971's Mean Streets through 1997. However, the twenty-first century has been a different story: he went from being very particular about his roles to seemingly acting in everything he is offered, and he has already appeared in over thirty movies since 2000. Few of those films have been successful at the box office, and even fewer have received critical praise. In fact, twenty-five have been voted rotten on Rotten Tomatoes, which is an inauspicious accolade for such a critically acclaimed talent. Though De Niro is still highly regarded and even received his first Oscar nomination in twenty-one years for his supporting role in Silver Linings Playbook it's almost entirely for movies he made twenty years ago or more. We all want to see De Niro star in at least one more great film (and hopefully with old collaborator Martin Scorsese), but as he gets further from his glory years audiences wonder if he has anything great left in the tank. Which other wayward talents do you think deserve to be on this list? Share your own picks below in the comments thread.