10 Actors Who Get More Hate Than They Deserve

By Sol Harris /

There is a particular breed of actor that cultivates universal contempt. Sometimes this is completely justified because the actor is as talented as Keanu Reeves, or sometimes it's completely justified because the actor is O.J. Simpson. Sometimes, however, you get actors who receive universal hatred despite seemingly having done nothing wrong. This is my attempt at defending 10 actors who are constantly given a hard time, but really aren't that bad. As I'm sure we can all agree, if there's one thing that these multi-millionaires need, it's for me to stick up for them on the internet. Cut them some slack, will you?

10. Hugh Grant

Hugh Grant is hated by many and for many reasons. He's that annoying, posh celebrity that your circa-1994 girlfriend likes more than you, or worse, he's that annoying, posh guy in all of those terrible romcoms that your circa-1994 girlfriend makes you endure with her. But wait a second: Hugh Grant "knows his place," so to speak. For the most part, he stays well within the realms of romantic comedy because that's what he's good at. For what they are, Notting Hill and Four Weddings and a Funeral aren't terrible films. They're not great, but you could do a lot worse than to take one of those in. Plus, as I said, he is good at them. About a Boy is a real gem of a film and it proves that Hugh is capable of - if nothing else - some fantastic comic timing. It goes beyond that, though. If you, like myself, despise the corruption wrought within the news media, then Hugh is an ally - and a pretty hilarious one at that. He got into trouble in 2007 when he threw a tuppaware container full of baked beans at a paparazzo. Technically, it's assault, but it's only assault against a member of one of the scummiest professions on the planet, so it doesn't really count. If Hugh is harassed by some idiot with a camera to the point that he wants to retaliate, then that's understandable, and if he chooses to retaliate by throwing baked beans at them (rather than taking the Russell Crowe approach, for instance), then it's a peaceful protest which is even better. He stepped up the ante, in 2011, when, sick and tired of his treatment in the press, he essentially single-handedly brought down an entire newspaper by turning their own wire-tapping tactics against them. And you know what? Anybody who wants to stick it to Rupert Murdoch is OK by me.

Advertisement

9. Robert Pattinson

I, like anyone else with taste, am instantly primed to dislike this guy purely because of his association with the Twilight franchise. If you actually do a little digging, however, it soon becomes clear that he hates it as much as we all do, if not, more. Seriously, just read this quote he gave about how he got the part:
"When you read the book, it€™s like, €˜Edward Cullen was so beautiful I creamed myself.€™ I mean, every line is liked that. He€™s the most ridiculous person who€™s so amazing at everything. I think a lot of actors tried to play that aspect. I just couldn€™t do that. And the more I read the script, the more I hated this guy, so that€™s how I played him, as a manic-depressive who hates himself. Plus, he€™s a 108 year-old virgin so he€™s obviously got some issues there."
They certainly don't sound like the words of a fan. What we have, here, is a clear case of someone that was handed a truck-load of money to do a relatively cushy job (and it's not like his performance doesn't do Edward justice); all with legions of women throwing themselves at him in the process. It's not his fault if he's remarkably fortunate. Hating him is like hating someone for winning the lottery. It's not even like he was selling out by taking the role in the first place, seeing as he didn't have much of an established career before hand. Michael Sheen, on the other hand, is a supremely talented man and should have known better.

8. Seth Rogen

Seth Rogen complaints seem to largely be down to people tiring of him playing a loser, stoner with an unbelievably attractive girlfriend in all of his films. Fair enough, that's true of Knocked Up, Zack and Miri Make a Porno and Pineapple Express, but if we're being fair, then you have to acknowledge that those are all perfectly solid movies. They might not be genre re-defining, but they're all good fun and - more importantly - his appearance doesn't harm or diminish them. But let's dig a little deeper. Seth Rogen has a nice, little 2nd career going as a writer (usually with writing partner, Evan Goldberg). Among his many projects are Superbad (one of the best comedies of the last decade), Da Ali G Show (one of the best comedies of the last decade), and the upcoming This is the End, which looks hilarious. Who knows? Maybe it'll be one of the best comedies of this decade. Oh, and he, like most people in Hollywood, dabbles in producing. Seth Rogen was instrumental in getting hard-sell cancer-comedy 50/50 off the ground and the end result was a wonderfully touching comedy drama that worked on pretty much every level.

7. Seth MacFarlane

Whilst not primarily an actor, Seth MacFarlane (a.k.a. "that Family Guy guy") pops up in minor roles in films from time to time, regularly voice-acts in a variety of TV shows and films, and will reportedly fill the lead role in his upcoming sophomore feature: A Million Ways to Die in the West. Perhaps it's a testament to how unlikeable the man is that he can summon such a huge degree of negativity from a career largely behind the camera. Or, perhaps, we should examine this more closely. Firstly, Seth MacFarlane is a supremely talented man who's earned his career legitimately. He studied animation at college, made a short film, got a low-level job at Hannah Barbera off the strength of it, and worked his way up from there. There are no obvious lucky breaks or favours, here - just hard work. Secondly, he's behind a lot of quality products. Family Guy may not be the show that it once was, but the first few seasons were smart and - while not original in premise - were extremely original in tone. More importantly, though, they were actually funny. Hilarious, in fact. Yes, the writing can be frustratingly lazy, but the show has one of the best laugh-to-gag ratios that I've ever seen on TV. You can enjoy it in the same way that one might enjoy a quality sketch show. Plus, despite the baffling misconception that Seth writes and animates every single episode himself, he actually has a huge team of writers under him that actually do the writing. Seth hasn't written an episode of the show since the pilot way back in 1999. If you're sick of jokes making fun of your faith or Conway Twiggy cutaways that last ten times longer than they have any right to, then take it up with the actual writing staff. More importantly, though, this list is about him as an actor. Seth is primarily a voice actor and, to give him his dues, he's phenomenally talented at it. He's up there with the very best of his field. Peter Griffin, Brian Giffin, Stewie Griffin, Stan Smith and Roger the Alien are all hugely distinctive vocally - and he gets a lot of genuinely wonderful performance into those characters.

Advertisement

6. William Hurt

This one is a case of I simply don't understand it. I know people who venomously despise William Hurt. I've heard a number of negative reactions to films such as under-rated Ed Norton gem, The Incredible Hulk, justified purely "because William Hurt." I should probably confess that my knowledge of the man boils down, more or less, entirely to The Incredible Hulk, Into the Wild and Altered States - it's far from his entire filmography, but shouldn't three performances be enough to tell if someone can act or not? I have actually seen him in a great deal of other films, but I didn't even realise that it was him in those roles until I checked his IMDb profile whilst researching this article. That might suggest that he's forgettable - which, to be fair, isn't exactly a good thing as an actor - but it also suggests that he's not actively bad enough to stick out to me. A poor actor in a quality film sticks out like a sore thumb and I really like some of the films in question. In the three films that I do remember him in, he gave perfectly fine performances. None of them blew me away, but they were all nothing short of completely acceptable. General Ross was all that I need from a villainous army-general-cum-protective-father-of-the-female-love-interest, Walt McCandless was all that I need from a stuffy old father who disapproves of his hippy son and he was pretty good in his breakthrough movie, Altered States, where he plays a mad scientist who accidentally causes his DNA to regress backwards through time, causing him to keep transforming into a neanderthal. He fully throws himself into what is quite a physical role and he does a good job of it. I just don't understand why people don't like him. Plus, his name is hilarious in a completely childish "my willy am hurt" kind of way. Right?

5. Johnny Depp/Helena Bonham Carter

I've included these two as a pair because their criticism tends to stem from the same place: Tim Burton. Both of them have absolutely wonderful careers under their belts even if you cut and paste their Tim Burton movies into a filmic netherworld. Helena Bonham Carter was Oscar-nominated for her leading performance in The Wings of a Dove in 1997 - four years prior to the release of her first project with Tim Burton. Is that not enough for you? Try her phenomenal turn in Fight Club two years prior. But perhaps more importantly, I can't recall a case of Tim Burton ever miscasting her. She's great in Big Fish. Hell, she's the best thing in Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street, which is saying something because that film stands up as, perhaps, the best adaptation of a stage-musical prior to Les Miserables coming along and blowing everyone out of the water (and she's also in that one). And even in the poorer collaborations of theirs, there's nothing wrong with her acting. Dark Shadows, for example, wasn't bad because of Helena Bonham Carter - it was bad because of an awful script and a muddled tone. Another complaint seems to be that she plays nothing but alternative, kooky characters designed to appeal to insecure, teenage goths, but again, it's simply not true. She's good at playing roles like that so she does it a lot, but she's also capable of gorgeously nuanced and subtle performances such as that in Conversations With Other Women. She's just an all-round bloody fantastic actress. Johnny Depp receives pretty much the same criticism, except slightly worse because men seem jealous of the way that legions of women are madly infatuated with him. Depp has, pretty much, the exact same arguments in his defence as Helena, too. He has three Oscar nominations to date; two thirds of which are for non-Burton efforts. And, as with Helena, his repeated casting is never a hindrance to the film. The one exception to the rule is Alice in Wonderland, but that film was terrible from start to finish, so it's not like Depp's half-baked, confused performance really did it much damage. It's not as if the director/actor collaborative team is something specific to Johnny Depp and Tim Burton, either. Scorcese repeatedly worked with De Niro, but people didn't complain about it. Hitchcock repeatedly worked with Jimmy Stewart, but people didn't complain about it. Wes Anderson repeatedly works with Bill Murray, but people don't complain about it. Film is a collaborative medium, so when two talented people decide that they're comfortable enough with each other to want to work with each other repeatedly, then surely that's a good thing for everyone involved, including us, the audience?

4. George Clooney

Advertisement
As with many of the actors so far on this list, I feel that George Clooney was a victim of his own status as a heartthrob. It may have faded somewhat now, but initially, he was "that guy from E.R." that lots of girls liked. Such is the hatred for the man, that it even inspired an episode of American Dad! entitled Tears of a Clooney. "That arrogant, overrated, memo-writing bastard! He's not even an actor! He just does the same cheesy move every time. Looks down, then looks back up, squinting underneath his eyebrows. And everybody's buying it!", Francine says; but in that very same episode, it turns out that Clooney is so great that even Stan can't resist his charms and then, Francine realises that she was just projecting her own inadequacies onto him. Not that I'm saying that everyone who dislikes Clooney is just using him as a hate-absorbent projector-screen. It's just that the simple fact is that Clooney has given some great performances in some fantastic films: The Descendant, Up in the Air, O Brother, Where Art Thou?, to name but three. Also, he's a damned fine director. The Ides of March wasn't just directed by George Clooney, it was stylishly co-written and directed by George Clooney - and it's a great film on its own merits. Still not sold? Without George Clooney, there would be no South Park. As you may well know, South Park originated as a short film by Trey Parker and Matt Stone in which a snowman magically comes to life only to turn into a gigantic monster, killing people including a prototype Kenny. Clooney saw a copy of the film and loved it so much that he commissioned another for use as a Christmas card. He sent a few hundred copies out to friends of his and, understandably, this got the pair a lot of Hollywood buzz which later led to the card getting a spin-off show by the name of South Park. In the early days of the show, Trey and Matt were inundated with requests by celebrities to do guest appearances on the show. Finding it funny, the duo usually offered the celebrities tiny bit-parts. Jerry Seinfeld was offered the role of Turkey #2 in the episode Starvin' Marvin, for example. Most of these roles were declined on the grounds that they were beneath the star in question, but Clooney graciously accepted the part of Spark, Stan's gay dog in the episode Big Gay Al's Big Gay Boat Ride, vocalising a number of canine grunts as his character was, at one point, masturbated to completion by a small child. Clooney didn't see that beneath him because Clooney is cool.

3. Shia LaBeouf

Shia LaBeouf's hatred seems to be because Steven Spielberg is inexplicably infatuated with the guy. As well as being responsible for almost all of his "big break" roles, he - also rather inexplicably - cast him in the role of Indiana Jones' son. But look: it's not Shia's fault that Kingdom of the Crystal Skull sucked. That pretty much entirely comes down to George Lucas. In fact, Shia is quite open about how much of a misfire that that film was and it's his general openness towards this sort of thing that makes me think that the guy is actually quite switched on. I found this quote is in an article about how Shia says stupid things, but if you ask me, he comes off quite well:
On all the money he made from blockbusters: €œIf I could give the money back and get all the credibility in the world that I€™m seeking, I would do it tomorrow. In a heartbeat.€ - USA Today
What's wrong with that? He took the money and now he regrets it because he acknowledges that he's starred in some pretty shoddy movies. I can completely empathise with that. Yeah, he sold out a bit, but can you honestly say that you wouldn't have done the same thing in his shoes? And hate Transformers 2? So does he:
On the Transformers franchise: €œThere are a lot of people that liked the second one, but I hated it. I just didn€™t enjoy it. I thought we missed the mark. I got confused, I couldn€™t see what the fuck was going on, you know with certain robots€ I couldn€™t decipher what was happening. There were storyline paths that I just wouldn€™t have gone down.€ - FHM
These might not be the most wonderful, profound quotes in the world, but remember that I took them from an article that had specifically collected 11 quotes designed to make Shia look as bad as possible. If that's the worst you've got on him, then I think I'm on his side. Shia's recent filmography has taken a sharp, rapid turn of upward quality and his next project is the lead in a Lars Von Trier movie which pretty much proves that he's out to make art now, as opposed to money.

2. Michael Cera

People love to hate Michael Cera and the reason for that hatred seems to be almost completely down to the way that he essentially plays the same character in all of his films. So what if he does? Most actors play what is essentially a version of themselves in everything. The ones that don't are usually character actors, confined to supporting roles in comedies. Take Jack Nicholson for instance - he's a wonderful actor with many wonderful films under his belt. How many of his performances can you honestly say aren't just variations of himself? His Joker in Tim Burton's Batman is just himself, but in makeup. His performance in The Shining is just himself in a bad mood. I'm not saying that he never breaks away from this mould (he absolutely does), but it's a rare occurrence. Actors rarely step away from playing themselves and that's because the real art of acting usually comes down to the ability to portray yourself in different situations as though they were happening to you, as opposed to transforming yourself into someone else altogether. There are very few Daniel Day-Lewises out there. Perhaps Michael's role as the living blue-prints for Jesse Eisenberg, an actor who started similarly but has since gone on to play a far more diverse pool of characters, has magnified the strength of this complaint. It certainly makes Michael look worse by comparison, but it's not his fault if someone else is more talented than him, is it? I'd argue that Kubrick was a better director than Scorcese, but that sure as hell doesn't make Scorcese anything less than a genius. Michael Cera has given perfectly adequate performances in every film I've seen him in to date, and a lot of those films are very good. Plus, he does this a lot and I find it funny.

1. Nicolas Cage

Advertisement
Nicolas Cage is awesome. People complain about him due to the myth that he's a bad actor - a myth perpetuated by his insistence on doing lots of terrible, big-budget movies such as Bangkok Dangerous and Ghost Rider. The thing is that Cage is bankrupt and he needs to make these movies in order to feed his ridiculous (but awesome) money-spending habits. The man built a miniature pyramid in his back garden to be buried in, just because. That sort of thing doesn't come cheap. Plus, he's clearly always looking for an excuse to ride a motorbike, whilst wearing a suit. Then there's the odd occasion where he actually puts some effort in. When this happens, he usually demonstrates that he can act phenomenally well. Watch Leaving Las Vegas or Bringing Out the Dead before you criticise him based on acting ability. Did you know the man has won a Best Actor Academy Award? Even in defence of Cage's poorer efforts, he's consistently incredibly engaging and captivating. Vampire's Kiss may not be a good film by any stretch of the imagination, but you can't argue that Cage didn't throw himself into it head first and bring something to the film that would otherwise be completely lacking without him. It's an extremely watchable movie and that's purely down to Cage. Anyway, this is moot because you're not supposed to love Nicolas Cage because of the actor, you're supposed to love him because of the crazy. The man is a constant source of bizarre and surreal entertainment. Like this list? Agree or disagree? Let us know in the comments section below.