10 Actors Who Won Oscars For The Wrong Movie

Pity Oscars and unworthy victors.

By Aidan Whatman /

Whilst the Academy Awards have been in hot water over the years because of their lack of inclusion to minority filmmakers and performers, and their constant snubbing of acclaimed female directors, there is no denying that the annual ceremony is still a major part of Hollywood.

Advertisement

The Oscars given to actors are often the most talked about, but still the Academy has had issues when it comes to giving the statues to the right people. Or, in the case of this list, at the right time.

Now, that's not to say that every performance on this list wasn't deserving of the accolade - in many cases, the performances are very good. But looking at some of these megastars, it's clear to see that the role they won for was not necessarily their best effort. In a few instances, they won simply because they hadn't in the past, and the Academy realised they'd waited too long to award their work.

Whatever the case - be it nothing more than a pity Oscar or a confusing win brought about by a vicious Oscar campaign - here are ten actors who won Academy Awards for completely the wrong role.

10. Jack Lemmon - Save The Tiger

What is there to say to fully grasp Jack Lemmon's influence on cinema? A committed performer, born to act and with a rare mix of being a hysterical comedy actor and an effective dramatic performer, Lemmon won his second Oscar for the drama Save the Tiger. His first win came in 1955, for Mister Roberts.

Advertisement

Following Mister Roberts and before Save the Tiger, Lemmon gave two performances which are today seen as two of the greatest and most popular roles in cinema history.

In 1959, he starred opposite Marilyn Monroe and Tony Curtis in the romantic comedy Some Like It Hot, and in 1960, he starred in comedy-drama The Apartment as Calvin Clifford. Nominated for both performances, Lemmon somehow didn't win for either, despite the fact that both roles forced him to balance his dramatic chops with his comedic sensibilities into a grand balancing act of talent.

His role in The Apartment in particular is often cited as one of the greatest performances of all time. That said, he won his award for Save the Tiger - where he played a store owner considering burning his business down for the insurance money.

While this was well deserved, it would have made more sense to see the thespian win for his fan-favourite turns in the two romantic comedies that solidified his fame.

9. Denzel Washington - Training Day

Denzel Washington's impact on modern cinema cannot be overstated. Explosive, intelligent and utterly enchanting on screen, he's responsible for the careers of numerous Hollywood icons who have followed in his trailblazing footsteps.

Advertisement

Training Day won the actor his second Academy Award, following his supporting turn in the 1989 war drama Glory.

As is the case with several of the performances on this list, Washington's role as corrupt cop Alonzo Harris is not a bad one by any stretch. It's powerful, intimidating and constantly engaging.

But considering the fact that he won the Best Actor award for the film and beat out much stronger fellow nominees Will Smith (for Ali) and Russell Crowe (for A Beautiful Mind), it could be argued that the Academy dropped the ball.

As of this writing, Washington has been nominated for nine awards, a seriously impressive feat, and whilst it's amazing that he's one of the few performers to have won two Oscars, the Academy would have made a better move giving him his second statue for Malcolm X, The Hurricane, or Flight, which were without question much stronger performances.

8. Jack Nicholson - As Good As It Gets

Jack Nicholson is arguably the greatest of Hollywood's greats - an actor whose presence during the rise of New Hollywood helped pave the way for a whole generation of performers, and whose films have aged like fine wine thanks to his timeless on screen persona.

Advertisement

His role as Melvin Udall in As Good As It Gets won Nicholson his third of three Oscars, following One Flew Over The Cuckoo's Nest and Terms of Endearment. And though As Good As It Gets is not a bad role for the actor, he was far more deserving of an Oscar statue earlier in career, for such films as Easy Rider, Five Easy Pieces, Carnal Knowledge or The Shining.

His performance as Melvin allowed him to lean into his cynical, comedic side as well as giving him the chance to show off his typically strong dramatic chops, and the balance was brilliant.

But considering the longevity of his career and the numerous iconic roles he has played throughout it, to think he won an award for As Good As It Gets but didn't for any of his roles in the previously mentioned films, is a little bit of a disappointment.

7. Kate Winslet - The Reader

Making a name for herself as one of this generations most compelling actors, Kate Winslet's win for the 2008 drama The Reader was a long time coming.

Advertisement

Playing Hanna Schmitz, a woman accused of being a guard at a Nazi concentration camp during the war, Winslet eats up the role and secured her first (and so far only) Oscar win. It was a meaty and thrilling role, brilliantly performed within an otherwise messy movie.

Before her win, she had been nominated five Academy Awards. Her roles in Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind, Titanic and Iris were all acting masterclasses, all screaming out for an Academy victory, but alas it was not meant to be.

Her win for The Reader, then, whilst rightly earned, shouldn't have been her first win, and due to how much she'd put into her work before then, it's a shame that the win seems more like an award for her body of work rather than her performance in the winning film.

6. Whoopi Goldberg - Ghost

Whoopi Goldberg's extremely eccentric scene stealing performance as psychic Oda Mae Brown was very well received when Ghost was released in 1990, and outside of the famous pottery scene, it is Goldberg's performance most movie-goers remember from the film.

Advertisement

But it's not quite her best role, and shouldn't have led to her first win, given her powerful, career-making role in Steven Spielberg's The Colour Purple.

Her role as protagonist Celie still stands as one of cinema's greatest ever debut acting performances, and for good reasons. Goldberg was ultimately nominated, but lost to Geraldine Page in The Trip to Bountiful.

One good thing that came from Goldberg's belated Oscar win was the fact that it allowed her to become one of only sixteen artists to secure an EGOT (Emmy, Grammy, Oscar and Tony awards), and the first African American to achieve such a rare and impressive feat. It would have been better if she'd won for The Colour Purple, though.

5. Jeff Bridges - Crazy Heart

Crazy Heart is a brilliant film. Released in 2009, it follows faded country star Bad Blake as he attempts to fix up his life and get back to doing what he loves best: making music.

Advertisement

Truly, Jeff Bridges is a revelation in the film - flawed but likeable, powerful but subtle, moving and bursting with passion.

But it is by no means his most Oscar worthy performance. That honour goes to The Big Lebowski, a movie which has stood the test of time to become one of cult cinema's most popular and iconic surreal comedies. Bridges' role as The Dude is nothing short of cinematic brilliance, and it was the actor's relaxed, subtle and complex portrayal of him that made the film such a wild success.

Most tragically of all, Bridges wasn't even nominated for the film, and it wouldn't be until 2010 that he finally took home the Best Actor gong.

He should have won for Crazy Heart, but in this writer's opinion it really should have been his second statue.

4. Morgan Freeman - Million Dollar Baby

It's fair to say that Morgan Freeman was well deserving of his Best Supporting Actor gong for Clint Eastwood's boxing drama, as he did give a solid and affecting performance throughout.

Advertisement

Starring as Clint Eastwood's closest friend and former boxer Eddie Dupris, Freeman was required to be tragic and moral, and (of course) to narrate the movie through its ups and downs.

But this was Freeman's first (and only) Oscar win. Taking the award home in 2004, it had been nearly twenty years since his first nomination for the film Street Smart, and exactly ten years since his controversial loss for The Shawshank Redemption.

Playing Ellis "Red" Redding in the latter film, Freeman gave his most poignant, iconic and complex performance, portraying a murderer who is at once thoroughly likeable, morally questionable, brutally honest, and tragically written. He lost the award to Tom Hanks for Forrest Gump, and this snub is still seen as a sore spot for fans.

Freeman needed to win an Oscar during his career, that much is for certain, and although his win for Million Dollar Baby was warranted, it should definitely not have been his first win.

3. Judi Dench - Shakespeare In Love

Fun fact: Dame Judi Dench is in Shakespeare In Love for eight minutes. Outside of Beatrice Straight's six-minute role in Network, it is the shortest performance to ever secure an Oscar.

Advertisement

Now, Shakespeare In Love hasn't aged particularly well, no thanks to the vicious Oscar campaign Harvey Weinstein put in place to secure the film's Best Picture win over Saving Private Ryan and Gwenyth Paltrow's Best Actress win over the likes of Meryl Streep and Cate Blanchett.

But looking back, it really isn't too strong a movie anyway; historically inaccurate, self-indulgent and unsubtle Oscar-bait at its finest, the most exciting aspect of it is the controversial wins it secured in 1999.

Dame Judi plays Queen Elizabeth I, and though she does a decent job considering the screentime she received, whether it was a performance deserving of an Oscar or not remains a fairly cut-and-dry argument.

Her roles in Iris, Notes on a Scandal and Philomena were all much more effective, and it's a bit of letdown that someone with such an illustrious career and defining performances won for her most lacklustre and underdeveloped role.

2. Leonardo DiCaprio - The Revenant

Honestly, Leonardo DiCaprio deserved an Oscar win for anything other than The Revenant. Sure, it's beautifully directed and epic in both scale and story, and DiCaprio put an awful lot of work into it.

Advertisement

But, given the fact that he didn't even give the best performance in the movie (that honour goes to a career-best Tom Hardy), and that he barely speaks for nearly three hours, his win was without question a perfect example of Academy pity.

Before The Revenant, DiCaprio was the face of a number of memes about his lack of Oscar glory, having been nominated four times before he finally won.

But his previous nominations were all much more worthy of the award than the role he eventually won for. What's Eating Gilbert Grape was an early exploration of his mature and powerful acting style, and his role in Blood Diamond (arguably and tragically the least remembered of his Oscar-nominated roles) remains a career best.

He was slated to win for Martin Scorsese's Wolf of Wall Street, which saw him portray Jordan Belfort with complete conviction and an endless amount of energy, but he was beat at the post by Matthew McConaughey.

All told, The Revenant is two and a bit hours of Leo grunting in the wilderness, hunting for the Oscar that had long eluded him with overlong sequences of feigned pain and a croaky voice.

1. Al Pacino - Scent Of A Woman

In all of Academy history, no Oscar win has ever been so clearly a case of pity. Al Pacino is a monumental figure in pop culture, a Hollywood icon often seen as one of the greatest actors of all time. From The Godfather and its sequels, Dog Day Afternoon, Heat, Serpico, Donnie Brasco, The Devil's Advocate and so, so many more, there is a reason he has such a reputation.

Advertisement

But amongst his many credits and his seven nominations, he has only ever won one Academy Award, and the fact that it wasn't for any of the aforementioned classics is insane.

Be honest: What does anyone remember about Scent of A Woman? Nothing. That's right. One of the most forgettable dramas of the '90s, and all anyone is likely to tell you about it is Pacino saying "Hoo-ha" for a dismal two and a half hours. Oh, and Chris O'Donnell is there, because it was 1992 and he was still around.

Pacino is by no means bad as Frank Slade, but he does lean into his more peculiar and loud habits throughout the film's runtime, and given the fact that he lost for The Godfather and The Godfather Part II makes his win for the role even more nonsensical, and a clear case of the Academy realising they'd made a mistake with his earlier career going unrewarded.

Advertisement