10 Actors Whose Movie Character Requests Got Rejected

Colin Farrell "fought valiantly" to have The Penguin chomp down on some cigars.

By Jack Pooley /

Filmmaking is an undeniably collaborative process in which directors must work with writers, producers, and hundreds of other crew members in the hope of delivering a quality end product.

Advertisement

But perhaps no relationship is more immediately important than that between a filmmaker and their cast. If the director and one of their actors - or, God forbid, multiple actors - aren't on the same page, it can spell disaster before even a single frame of film has been shot.

There's a sure push-and-pull between directors and actors, where they will ideally meet in the middle and form a compromise on their visions for the project.

And so despite most often being the face of their movie, actors can't win it all. They have to deal with the fact that some of their enthusiastic suggestions are going to be shot down - perhaps bluntly and brutally - by the director or producer.

That was ultimately the case with these 10 actors, each of whom made passionate suggestions while shooting some of their biggest movies - suggestions which were either ignored or actively rejected, for better or worse...

10. David Harbour Wanted To Speak Only In Russian - Black Widow

David Harbour gave a thoroughly entertaining performance in Black Widow as Natasha (Scarlett Johansson) and Yelena's (Florence Pugh) father figure Alexei Shostakov aka Red Guardian.

Advertisement

Harbour sports a Russian accent for the role of the Russian super-soldier, though during an appearance on Jimmy Kimmel Live the actor confessed that he asked Marvel's higher-ups if he could play the part entirely in Russian.

This being a big-budget blockbuster that they wanted to sell around the world, though, they flatly shot down his request. Harbour said:

"It makes no sense... So he's Russian. In Russia. He'd be speaking Russian. So the entire movie should be me speaking Russian with subtitles...[But] it's not the best look for a Marvel movie, like a PG-13 movie, you just reading subtitles the entire movie... Yeah, [the idea] was not well-received by the producers when I brought that up."

As neat as this would've been, the popcorn-munching masses aren't exactly known for their love of subtitles, so you can appreciate why Marvel played it safe and didn't go this route.

9. Harrison Ford Wanted Han Solo To Die - Star Wars: Return Of The Jedi

Though Han Solo (Harrison Ford) was eventually killed off in Star Wars: The Force Awakens, Harrison Ford had actually been lobbying for the character to die for literally decades prior, and reportedly only agreed to return for The Force Awakens on the condition that Han died during the film.

Advertisement

Ford originally campaigned hard for George Lucas to kill Han way back in Return of the Jedi, feeling that offing one of the series' three main heroes with a grand sacrifice would lend greater emotional weight to the trilogy.

In a 2010 interview with ABC News, Ford said:

"As a character [Han] was not so interesting to me. I thought he should have died in the last one, just to give it some bottom."

Obviously Lucas didn't take Ford up on his suggestion, and the reason, according to Ford himself? "George didn't think there was any future in dead Han toys."

Given that Ford's relationship with the Han character over the years has been famously "complicated," it was probably quite the relief when his request finally got granted in The Force Awakens.

He did, however, also agree to return for a brief cameo as a vision of Han in The Rise of Skywalker, presumably because it wasn't in any way attempting to resurrect the character. And a hefty mountain of cash probably didn't hurt either.

8. Sharon Stone Wanted To Wear Underwear For The Leg-Crossing Scene - Basic Instinct

Sharon Stone will forever best be remembered for the infamous, iconic scene from Basic Instinct where her seductive serial killer Catherine Tramell crosses her legs in the middle of an interrogation in order to toy with and distract the police officers questioning her.

Advertisement

The scene is well remembered for the fact that Stone didn't wear underwear while shooting it, causing her vulva to be momentarily visible to the audience.

Stone originally wanted to wear white underwear to film the scene, but director Paul Verhoeven claimed that the underwear would cause reflections on the camera lens, and so insisted that she remove them, which she reluctantly did. In Stone's own words:

"When we shot it, it was going to be a hint... but [Verhoeven] told me: 'You can see the white of your underwear, I need you to take it off.' He assured me that nothing would be seen. So I took off my underwear and put it in my shirt pocket... At that time, there was no high definition, so when I looked at the monitor, I really did not see anything."

Stone added that once she saw the final film on the big screen, she slapped Verhoeven, who for his part has maintained ever since that Stone consented to being filmed in this exposed way.

7. Gene Hackman Wanted Lex Luthor To Have A Big Mustache - Superman

Gene Hackman was an undeniably major get for the role of iconic supervillain Lex Luthor in Richard Donner's original 1978 Superman, but there was one snag: Hackman wanted to play the part with a big, bushy mustache, and had even gone to the effort of growing one out before shooting.

Advertisement

Given that Luthor wasn't exactly known for having a bush-lip in the comics, director Richard Donner had no interest in Hackman's suggestion. But because of Hackman's A-list status, Donner had to employ some genius subterfuge to get what he wanted.

Hackman, in a recent retrospective following Donner's death, recounted the incident:

"I showed up for the first day of makeup tests for Superman with a fine Lex Luthor mustache I'd grown for the role... Dick, wearing his own handsome mustache, told me mine had to go. He bargained to lose his if I did mine. True to his word, he celebrated my last razor stroke by gleefully pulling off the fake whiskers he'd acquired for the occasion... Dick made it fun, and that's why the films turned out that way, too."

Thankfully everything worked out for the better in this case: Donner used his creativity to wrangle his insistent A-lister, who thankfully saw the funny side of the ruse.

6. Nichelle Nichols Wanted Uhura To Be A Klingon Expert - Star Trek VI: The Undiscovered Country

Star Trek VI: The Undiscovered Country is generally regarded to be a return to form for the franchise, while offering an affecting farewell to the cast of the original Star Trek series.

Advertisement

However, Uhura actress Nichelle Nichols clashed with writer-director Nicholas Meyer over one major aspect of her characterisation in the film - her ability (or lack thereof) to speak Klingon.

The original script called for Uhura to use her expert grasp of the Klingon language to bluff the Enterprise out of a combat situation with the Klingons.

But script revisions saw this changed to a more comedic scene in which the crew hastily used translation books to communicate with the Klingons, resulting in Uhura speaking in sloppy, garbled Klingon instead.

Right up until shooting Nichols protested, explaining to Meyer that Uhura, being the Enterprise's communications officer, would reasonably have a strong grasp of Klingon, and demanding that the original version of the scene be restored.

Meyer refused to budge, and though the final scene is pretty funny, Nichols' frustration is also completely understandable.

5. Ryan Gosling Wanted To Play The Role Overweight - The Lovely Bones

Though you might recall that Mark Wahlberg ended up playing protagonist Susie Salmon's (Saoirse Ronan) father in The Lovely Bones, Ryan Gosling was actually originally cast in the part.

Advertisement

Gosling, who was just 26 years of age while preparing for the role, had major concerns about being too young to convincingly play Saoirse Ronan's father, and so undertook a comprehensive transformation to physically weather himself.

Gosling gained an astonishing 60 pounds of mass by drinking microwaved ice cream, and also grew a thick, dishevelled beard.

Unfortunately Gosling did all this without consulting director Peter Jackson, and so when he saw what Gosling had done shortly before shooting was due to start, Jackson swiftly fired him and drafted Wahlberg in as a replacement. Gosling said of the conflict:

"We didn't talk very much during the preproduction process, which was the problem... It was a huge movie, and there's so many things to deal with, and he couldn't deal with the actors individually. I just showed up on set, and I had gotten it wrong. Then I was fat and unemployed."

4. Scarlett Johansson Wanted To Be Topless For One Scene - The Island

While shooting her lead role in Michael Bay's The Island, Scarlett Johansson had to film a sex scene between her character, Jordan Two-Delta, and male lead Lincoln Six-Echo (Ewan McGregor).

Advertisement

Johansson was given a black bra to wear for the scene, but felt that her character actually wouldn't be wearing anything, and so suggested to director Bay that she simply shoot the scene topless for a greater sense of realism - ever the important thing in a sci-fi schlock-fest riffing on Logan's Run.

According to Bay, she emphatically declared she wouldn't wear the "cheap-ass bra," while Johansson herself later said, "Nobody wears a bra when they’re in bed... Who wakes up wearing a bra? It doesn’t happen!"

But Bay, constrained by the film's studio-mandated PG-13 rating, had to explain to Johansson that it simply wasn't possible for her to be topless in the movie without an R rating, which would've invoked the wrath of Warner Bros.

And while many fans might lament that Bay didn't acquiesce to Johansson's enthusiastic request, there's absolutely no way a topless scene would've ever made it into the final cut anyway. Bay made the only decision he could under the restriction of a PG-13 rating.

3. Jude Law Wanted To Act With An English Accent - Black Sea

Kevin Macdonald's 2014 thriller Black Sea stars Jude Law as Robinson, an underwater salvage expert who embarks on a mission to track down a sunken submarine said to be loaded with gold.

Advertisement

When Law signed on for the part there wasn't any specificity to the character's accent, and Law quite understandably assumed he'd speak with a variation on his usual English twang.

But Scottish filmmaker Macdonald "persuaded" Law to adopt a Scottish accent - Aberdonian, to be precise - while playing Robinson. According to Law himself, Macdonald's rationale was:

"[Macdonald] said there was something about the Aberdeen accent which was right for the character, it feels calm and without hurry and unflappable and even."

Ultimately despite praise for the film and Law's performance, his accent received more mixed reviews, especially from Scottish people. Macdonald, for his own part, downplayed the complaints:

"Everybody knows it's not his accent so you are fighting that, and you are thrown for a few minutes... But then you accept it and you see what that does to the character."

Either way, one suspects Law would've preferred to save himself a headache and just play the part with a more familiar English dialect.

2. Colin Farrell Wanted The Penguin To Smoke Cigars - The Batman

Colin Farrell gives a phenomenally transformative performance as Oswald Cobblepot aka The Penguin in Matt Reeves' The Batman, donning extensive facial prosthetics and a fat suit to alter his appearance beyond almost all recognition.

Advertisement

There's one aspect of the character's portrayal that Farrell wasn't quite satisfied with, however.

He fought hard to have the mobster smoke cigars throughout the film, as has been a common character trait ever since The Penguin's creation, only for Warner Bros. to outright refuse on moral grounds.

In an interview with YouTuber Jake's Takes, Farrell said:

"Big studios make big decisions around such things as the presence of cigarettes in films... I fought valiantly for a cigar. At one stage I said, 'I can have it unlit! Just let me have it unlit.' They were like, 'No.' [As if] a bunch of 12-year-olds are going to start smoking Cuban cigars because [the Penguin is smoking cigars in a movie]."

Farrell's performance is magnetic enough that it's easy to forget about the absence of the villain's signature cigars, but on the flip-side it does seem a tad excessive for Warner Bros. to have a blanket ban on smoking in all movies rated PG-13 or lower.

1. Sean Young Wanted Daryl Hannah's Role Instead - Wall Street

Sean Young had a small supporting role in Oliver Stone's Wall Street as Kate Gekko, the ex-wife of reptilian Wall Street trader Gordon Gekko (Michael Douglas).

Advertisement

Young, who was increasingly growing a rep for being "difficult" at the time, firmly believed that she was a better fit for the part of Bud Fox's (Charlie Sheen) materialistic girlfriend Darien Taylor (Daryl Hannah), even urging Stone to fire Daryl Hannah and give her the role instead.

Stone rejected Young's request, however, and due to her volatile and unpredictable behaviour on set - namely turning up late and unprepared, and also bristling with Charlie Sheen of all people - Stone ended up cutting her role down to a glorified cameo.

However, Stone admitted years later that Young was probably right: he didn't love Hannah in the role of Darien, and many of his crew even suggested that he fire her. Stone surmised that Young and Hannah would've been more effective by switching roles.

So, while Stone ultimately didn't grant Young's request, she at least ended up with something of a moral victory as her bullish instincts were eventually proven right.

Advertisement