10 Ambiguous Movie Endings That Had Ridiculously Simple Solutions
Reality or dream?
Once a films over, whats really going to stick in your head is the ending. Those last moments will be what you and your buddies discuss long after the credits have rolled and is why filmmakers put a lot of stock in those last few scenes. Itd be really easy to make an M. Night Shyamalan joke about now, but kicking a man whose career has had the same trajectory as a skydive without a parachute seems a little too far.
Besides, its more than just twist endings, which are becoming more and more ubiquitous in Hollywood cinema that I'm on about here. Teases for new movies, be it a sly line of dialogue or a post credit sting also work well, but if you really want to get audiences chatting, leave them uncertain. Nothing's going to make people recommend a film more than when they're not even sure if there's a twist at all.
After seeing the film whose ending is succinctly solved in the image above, the ending stumped me for months. I saw the film multiple times in cinemas, each time debating with my fellow cinemagoers over the increasingly high number of nuances we were picking up. Me and my friends would even spend nights out in the real world trying to get to the bottom of what we saw.
So without any more forced ambiguity, here's ten films that people constantly say have confusing, cryptic endings, but actually have pretty simple and obvious solutions. Hopefully you'll come away with feeling a little more certain about some classic films.
Warning - MAJOR SPOILERS for every film featured. Only a handful come from the past few years and most form a key role in popular culture, but better safe than sorry.
Watch the video version of this article above, or continue below to read the article.
10. 2001: A Space Odyssey
The Ambiguous Ending: Wait, what the hell just happened?
Less an ambiguous ending, more an ambiguous film, Stanley Kubricks pondering sci-fi still shows off some of the most revered special effects ever put to film, despite most of it going over the general audiences head. Even those who can understand the linkage of the monkeys and the purpose of the monoliths tend to lose it come the film's final act. Dave Bowman has successfully shut down the psychopathic/dutiful computer HAL and makes his approach to Jupiter and the newly discovered monolith. When he gets out, however, things start getting freaky. Through a desert of colour to an emotionless hotel, Bowman ages. Then theres a baby. What?
The Simple Solution: Follow the recurring theme. Or just read the book.
The real problem here lies in the scene so often being taken out of context of the film or viewers not grasping the overall themes presented in the previous two hours. Each section of the film thus far has shown some leap forward, be it the creation of tools, discovery of alien life or evolution of technology, so its not hard to take this final scene as such. With Bowman slowly changing its clear the implication is that hes slowly being transformed into the next level of humanity, just like the apes were at the beginning. This is greater expanded in Arthur C. Clarkes novelisation produced in conjunction with Kubrick during production. A cracking read in its own right, it provides greater knowledge of the purpose of the monoliths and more importantly verifies Bowmans forced evolution.
9. Lost In Translation
The Ambiguous Ending: What did Bill Murray whisper to Scarlett Johanssen?
As talented as she may be, theres no hiding the fact that Sofia Coppola is only a director because of her father. Its a good thing her directing career kicked off as assured as it did then. Following from the already well received The Virgin Suicides, Coppolas second film brought the house down and marked her as one to watch (well, were allowed to be wrong now and again). The brilliant film has one of the most talked about endings for an arthouse. After becoming close friends with Scarlett Johansson's young Charlotte against the alien backdrop of Tokyo, Bill Murrays Bob is returning to the US, but not before he stops her in the street and whispers something in her ear. What exactly, the audience cant make out.
The Simple Solution: It's in the movie (if you use computers).
Technically theres no answer; it was never scripted what Bob would whisper. But on set, Coppola let Murray improvise a potential line, which, through all the street noise, actually did make its way into the film. One intrepid fan messed around with the sound until you can sort of hear whats being said.
So what exactly did he say? I have to be leaving, but I wont let that come between us, okay? Which in all honesty just opens up questions towards their relationship in the future. Of all the solutions on the list, this is the only one I didn't want to know.
8. In Bruges
The Ambiguous Ending: Did Ray die?
I will never go to Bruges. Or to use its full name, F**king-Bruges. Such is the cultural impact of Martin McDonaghs breakthrough film, that the picturesque Belgian town has been ruined more than a scenery altering motorway. The films ending is a perfect culmination of every element of the plot, bringing together seemingly unrelated points in hilariously brilliant fashion. But once all the actions been had, theres one overriding question on our lips. Colin Farrels child like assassin has been the emotional heart of the film and its his fate thats left up in the air; the final scene being a POV of Ray in an ambulance could go either way.
The Simple Solution: The script answers it.
The film gives no pushing either way. We cut to the credits before we can get enough proof for either argument. But you dont have to go too far from the source to find an answer. The shooting script had an extra scene after what is now the films end. Zooming out from a newspaper clipping on the shootout, we see Ray alive but far from well back home in London. Not just removing ambiguity, the scene adds an extra layer of bleakness to the film; Harry's bullet didn't kill Ray, but in the last moments of the story his own does. The extra scene isn't overall required for the plot (aside from giving closure to the Ray-Chloe relationship) and you can see why McDonagh went with the less definite solution.
7. The Dark Knight Rises
The Ambiguous Ending: Did Bruce Wayne survive?
I think we all know the ending. The Dark Knight Rises divided many (particularly those on this site) when it was released last year. While the choice of villain and presentation of plot points had some up in arms, it was The Dark Knight Trilogy's final moments led to much of the backlash. Even though we've just seen The Batman fly off with the bomb, sacrificing himself to save Gotham, Alfred discovers that Bruce is actually alive and well. But the question remains how Bruce survived, prompting the notion that Alfreds just imagining his friend alive.
The Simple Solution: Of course he did.
Clearly some fans were watching the wrong Nolan film because to think Alfreds imagining Bruce means youre throwing out the realism of the previous two and a half hours (five if you count The Dark Knight). At no point in TDKR was anything other than it was shown on screen. In fact, the only moment stylised in any way was Bruce waking up groggy in the prison. But even if you think Alfred is imagining it, theres plenty more information in that final montage; the disappearance of the pearls, repairing of the autopilot and the new bat signal all point to Bruce being alive. I was initially unsure whether to put this entry in, but theres enough confusion out there for this clarification to be needed.
6. The Thing
The Ambiguous Ending: Is The Thing dead?
The real terror of The Thing is the lack of knowing. Until you hear that unmistakable screech (or see someones blood fly sky high), theres no way of knowing if youre with a human or an alien of unknown origin. Ignoring the silly remake/prequels (premake?) introduction of a weakness (it cant replicate inorganic matter so with leave behind fillings and earrings), its a totally formidable foe. Which is what makes the ending of John Carpenters sci-fi-horror so terrifying. Kurt Russels MacReady has seemingly destroyed the monster, but Keith Davids Childs has somehow survived. As their share a bottle of whiskey, the audience is left wondering if either one of these men is the thing from outer space.
The Simple Solution: Just watch the film.
Theres been this mystery since The Thing first morphed onto our screens in 1982. Now its easy to take the material produced in the world of the film after its release as proof; in the comics The Thing survives and in a 2003 video game we discover in the final level so did MacReady. But while that works as a good, if unofficial explanation, you dont really need to look beyond the film for a definitive answer. Again ignoring the remake, if the thing is alone with only one human itll immediately assimilate it. MacReady knows the rest of the team is dead, as would Childs if he was the thing, so the fact he stays human means that he is. The films own internal logic solves this one easily.
5. Memento
The Ambiguous Ending: What the hell happened?
Before he revolutionised Batman, Nolan was your typical indie upstart. His first film, Following, was just as perplexing as Memento, but as only seven people have ever seen that, lets look at what he did next. Famously, Mementos end is actually the beginning, showing Guy Pearces Leonard kill Teddy, giving us a film long grudge against this smiley character. At the narrative end (aka the chronological middle) we discover that Leonards quest to hunt down his wifes killer was actually resolved a year ago. With his memory stopping every five minutes or so, Leonard has just enough time to decide hed prefer to continue his hunt anyway and picks a new target; Teddy. But it still doesn't add up.
The Simple Solution: The ending spells it out for you.
No, wait. If you think about it for a minute it actually all makes sense. Leonards chosen a life of vengeance after forgetting the truth of his wifes death (he accidently killed her with insulin, something he holds onto with the Sammy Jenkis story). He does eventually find his attacker, after which Teddy starts using his friends quest to help him deal with various bad people. This is essentially what were seeing in the black and white portion of the film. The colour, backwards part then becomes pretty straightforward (if quite misleading). Due to the groundbreaking concept of the film, people failed to see this and instead thought they were missing something. As with all his later films, every clue you need to solve a Nolan film is right there on the screen.
4. Shutter Island
The Ambiguous Ending: Is Teddy insane or not?
Shutter Island took Scorsese fans by surprise. The king of the gangster movie took his high-end sensibilities and applied it to the typical B-movie format. Brilliance ensued. The film culminates with the disturbing discovery that Leonardo DiCaprios Teddy wasn't the Marshall he thought, rather an inmate of the institution on the titular island. The entire plot was a scheme to try and wake Teddy up from his madness, but when that failed the doctors had no other option but to lobotomize him. But in his last moments, Teddy gives a hint to his doctor that perhaps hes aware of his dangerous nature and in fact sacrificing himself.
The Simple Solution: The clue's in the film's closing message.
The big difference between the film and Dennis Lehanes book of the same name is the ending. In the novel, Teddys madness is a lot more clear cut, but the films introduction of the closing line which would be worse to live as a monster, or to die as a good man? left many confused. Those involved in production were either tight lipped or as confused as the rest of us. It was only when The Guardians David Cox asked James Gilligan, the films psychiatric adviser, we got a definitive answer; Teddy has indeed been cured, but cant deal with his violent past. Gilligan felt the film should draw focus to the amount of lobotomies conducted in the fifties and thus didn't have the same desire to keep quiet as the rest of the film's crew.
3. Total Recall
The Ambiguous Ending: Is Quaid asleep or not?
Were talking the original here; the ending of the remake asks a much simpler question, How did this get made? More than a typical Arnie/Verhoeven gore-fest, the entire film plays with the audiences perception of reality, everything occurring as predicted, but with the same level of realism (note: not much) throughout. The ending leaves it really open, with Schwarzenegger's Quaid saving the day with blue skies on Mars (exactly what a Rekall worker said earlier in the film), but without anything definitive either way.
The Simple Solution: The directors commentary answers it.
We cant really use the source as an explanation here, as the Dick short story is equally as ambiguous (although it does have the nice reveal that the protagonist's purity is in fact the sole reason aliens havent invaded Earth). A common argument for the entire thing being a dream is that the plots so outlandish it couldn't be real, but as this is an Schwarzenegger movie its not really a viable solution. What is a viable solution is what the director thinks. In the DVD commentary Verhoeven states that he believes everything to be a dream. Of course what the director thinks isn't always how the work will be regarded (just look at the insane theories about The Shining presented in Room 237), but its certainly a good answer to take for this film.
2. Blade Runner
The Ambiguous Ending: Is Deckard a replicant?
Whenever someone has says theyve seen Blade Runner, the first question theyll be asked is whether they believe Harrison Fords Deckard is one of the replicants he was tasked with hunting down. Theres plenty of clues that point in both directions; in one scene his eyes go red just like the androids, but in others he appears to have been around the department much longer than the standard five year lifespan. The specifics vary from version to version, but the films ending leaves this subplot deviously unresolved.
The Simple Solution: Follow the unicorn.
The reason for this ambiguity is the different versions of the film; it wasn't until the 1992 directors cut that the unicorn was introduced, marking Scotts change in view of the argument. Before then and in the years when the original still aired on TV, people picked up a skewed view of the film. In the end, theres one piece of overriding evidence that puts the ball in the court of Deckard being a replicant. Midway through the film theres a bizarre dream sequence with a unicorn, which gets referenced at the end when Deckard finds a origami unicorn left by surly colleague Gaff. Its not difficult to take from this that Gaff is telling both Deckard and the audience he knows his dreams and by extension hes a replicant.
1. Inception
The Ambiguous Ending: Is Cobb awake or not?
Nolan has a thing for ambiguous endings doesn't he? His third film on this list (although as I stated, The Dark Knight Rises depends on the person) is his most hotly debated. Inception had everything people wanted from a great blockbuster, including some brilliant post-movie conversation. The ending has an unbelievable happy ending, with Leonardo DiCaprios Dom Cobb succeeding in the inception and getting back to his kids. But in the final shot, with his totem still spinning, left viewers unsure if hed woken up. A film full of potential clues didn't help; could he have been asleep from the start, or halfway through. And through this all Nolan remained as tight lipped as ever.
The Simple Solution: It doesn't matter. You still care? Fine, then look at the ring.
Its something thats travelled around the Internet for long enough now that its no longer a shocking discovery. Cobbs totem wasn't the iconic spinning top, rather the presence of his wedding ring; its only on his finger in the dream (where hes not fully let go of Mal), but not when awake. In the final scene we clearly see Cobb definitely not wearing it. It took a long time for this to be discovered and even longer for it enter popular knowledge, hence why the ending is still met with an air of ambiguity.
As we all know, in the end it didn't matter to Cobb if he was awake or not, but I'll be damned if it isn't satisfying knowing the truth.
Are there any more endings people which cry ambiguity at, but you have solved? Still confused by one the examples in this list? Let us know in the comments below.