10 Best Films Made From Black List Screenplays
From the Black List to box office hit.
Nope, not the Hollywood blacklist of the 1950s but an entirely different entity that actually helps filmmakers rather than branding them commie sympathisers, the Black List was founded in 2005 by studio executive Franklin Leonard as a way of raising the profile of the film industry’s most-liked but as yet unproduced movie scripts.
Twelve years on from its inception, the Black List is now one of the most anticipated annual events in the Hollywood calendar and can proudly boast that over 300 screenplays previously featured on it have now been made into movies.
Admittedly, not all of those movies have been great and perhaps should’ve stayed purely on paper (we’re talking about you, Dirty Grandpa) but a good few have been excellent. In fact, the list has spawned over 250 Academy Award nominated movies and a further 48 actual winners to boot.
We’ll be covering a few of those Oscar winners here, alongside a few movies that might not be award jury favourites but are still rather brilliant in our humble opinion.
10. Arrival
Already hailed as one of the best sci-fi films of the decade,
Denis Villeneuve’s Arrival hit cinema screens last year to rave reviews.
According to the director he had been itching to make a sci-fi movie for quite
some time – quite a departure from his usual crime thrillers – and when he was
handed Eric Heisserer’s script, which featured on the 2012 Black List, he was
smitten.
Adapted from Ted Chiang’s award-winning sci-fi novella Story of Your Life, the screenplay scooped Heisserer an Academy Award nomination for Best Adapted Screenplay. Unfortunately for Heisserer, he lost out to Moonlight but did beat both Doctor Strange and Rogue One: A Star Wars Story to scoop the Ray Bradbury Award for Outstanding Dramatic Presentation at the annual Nebula Awards.
Interestingly, Heisserer’s original script featured an ending that saw the visiting aliens leave a blueprint for a spaceship capable of interstellar travel but he and Villeneuve decided to change that finale after Christopher Nolan’s Interstellar was released in 2014.
9. The Wrestler
A touching tale of former pro-wrestler Randy ‘The Ram’ Robinson (played by Mickey Rourke) who returns to the game with a rematch fight between him and his old archenemy, The Wrestler appeared on the 2007 Black List with just five mentions – a relatively low ranking on that year’s list which was topped by Danny Strong’s script for critically acclaimed TV movie Recount about the 2000 presidential elections.
Penned by Robert Siegel, former editor in chief of satirical news website The Onion, the film boasted a career best performance from Rourke that cemented the actor’s Hollywood comeback and earned him a Best Actor nomination at the 2009 Academy Awards.
Funnily enough, king of overacting Nicolas Cage was originally on board to play the role of Randy ‘The Ram’ Robinson but dropped out and conceded the role to Rourke, director Darren Aronofsky’s ideal choice for the role – a twist of fate that was probably the best outcome for the film.
8. Juno
Shortly after publishing her memoir Candy Girl: A Year in the Life
of an Unlikely Stripper, Diablo Cody was encouraged by her manager, film
producer Mason Novick, to pen a screenplay.
Drawing on her friends’ and her own high school experience, she wrote Juno – on a laptop at a Minneapolis branch of Starbucks in just seven weeks, no less – which appeared on the first ever Black List back in 2005 with an impressive 24 mentions.
A friend of Novick’s passed Cody’s script onto director Jason Reitman who had just finished making his feature film debut with Thank You for Smoking and fell in love with Juno’s screenplay.
Though the film ran into a few delays along the way and Cody wasn’t sure her script would ever see fruition, it was eventually picked up by John Malkovich’s production company Mr. Mudd and Mandate Pictures and went on to win Best Original Screenplay at both the Academy Awards and BAFTAs in 2008.
7. Whiplash
Writer-director Damien Chazelle first got the idea for his
sophomore film Whiplash while trying to get what would become his third film La
La Land off the ground, later admitting he penned Whiplash’s script in
frustration at not being able to find a studio willing to finance his musical
so decided to write something on a smaller scale.
Drawing on his own experience as a drummer in what he’s described as a “very competitive” high school jazz band led by a tyrannical teacher not too unlike J. K. Simmons’ character in the movie, Chazelle penned Whiplash’s script in 2012 after which it attracted the attention of Right of Way Films and Blumhouse Productions who helped Chazelle turn around 15 pages of his script into a short film.
After a successful premiere at Sundance, Bold Films stumped up enough cash to turn the short into a feature length film and thus Whiplash – which went on to be nominated for Best Adapted Screenplay at the 2015 Academy Awards – was born.
6. Scott Pilgrim Vs. The World
Co-written by Michael Bacall and Shaun of the Dead director Edgar
Wright, Scott Pilgrim vs. the World’s screenplay first appeared on the 2006
Black List with four mentions under the working title ‘Scott Pilgrim’s Precious
Little Life’ after the first volume of the Scott Pilgrim graphic stories penned
by Bryan O’Malley.
According to Wright, O’Malley was very hands-on while he and Bacall were adapting his comics for the screen and as his Scott Pilgrim series was still ongoing at the time the movie went into production, O’Malley even borrowed a few lines from the screenplay for his comics too.
Wright and Bacall’s original screenplay had a different ending that saw Scott getting back with his ex-girlfriend Knives Chau, but after test audiences disliked that finale it was adapted to be more in line with the ending O’Malley had penned for his books in which Scott and Ramona do get together.
The pair also briefly entertained another alternate ending that pitched Scott as a deranged serial killer who thinks he’s in a video game but is actually going around murdering people at random. Thankfully they went with the ‘guy gets the girl’ ending we know and love.
5. In Bruges
Irish playwright turned Academy Award winning filmmaker Martin McDonagh’s In Bruges script first appeared on the Black List in 2006 and didn’t languish there too long before it was snapped up, filmed in just 12 weeks and released to critical and cult acclaim. Not bad considering it was McDonagh’s feature film debut.
Mining McDonagh’s theatrical background, the film takes inspiration from Harold Pinter’s play The Dumb Waiter which also focuses on two hitmen but features considerably less blood and swearing. Speaking of swearing, In Bruges is by no means the most profanity-laden film out there but does apparently contain an impressive 126 instances of the word ‘f*ck’ which equates to around 1.18 ‘f*cks’ per minute over its 107-minute runtime.
According to IMDB, there’s a few differences between the original script and the final cut including hitmen Ray and Ken originally being English and Ray surviving his wounds during the finale rather than his fate being left ambiguous.
4. Django Unchained
Quentin Tarantino’s highest-grossing film to date, Django
Unchained, first popped up on the 2011 Black List and went on to score the writer-director
a hattrick when it scooped Best Original Screenplay at the Academy Awards,
BAFTAs and the Golden Globes in 2013.
The seeds of the movie were planted in Tarantino’s head while he was writing a book about Italian director of uber-violent Westerns Sergio Corbucci and envisioned a Spaghetti Western set in pre-Civil War Deep South that dealt with America’s violent history of slavery – what he’s termed a ‘Southern’ rather than a Western.
The movie takes much inspiration from Corbucci’s 1966 Western Django, a similar tale of revenge and racism whose star Franco Nero makes a cameo in Django Unchained as slave owner Amerigo Vessepi. Other script influences include Richard Fleischer’s 1975 blaxploitation flick Mandingo and another Corbucci movie called The Great Silence – a ‘snow Western’ that Tarantino paid homage to in both Django Unchained and his later film The Hateful Eight.
3. The Wolf Of Wall Street
Adapted from the memoirs of the same name by real-life white-collar
crim Jordan Belfort, The Wolf of Wall Street first appeared on the Black List
in 2007 with a screenplay penned by The Sopranos and Boardwalk Empire writer
Terence Winter.
After spending a few years stuck in development hell, at one point with Ridley Scott attached to direct, the movie was finally greenlit in 2012 with Martin Scorsese directing and Leonardo DiCaprio starring as Belfort. The movie marks Scorsese and DiCaprio’s fifth collaboration since Gangs of New York in 2002 and went on to receive five Academy Award nominations, including a Best Adapted Screenplay nod for Winter.
If you thought In Bruges’ 126 ‘f*cks’ was impressive, then The Wolf of Wall Street’s 569 ‘f*cks’ (and other such f*ck-related derivatives) will blow you away. Apparently, that’s the most uses of the word in a non-pornographic, non-documentary film in cinema history.
2. Hell Or High Water
The screenplay for neo-Western Hell or High Water was already
snapped by production company Sidney Kimmel Entertainment in 2012 even before
that year’s Black List was even officially announced, but didn’t start shooting
until 2015. It’s a good thing it eventually did as it went on to rank as the
highest grossing indie of 2016 and received a total of four Academy Award
nominations including Best Picture and Best Original Screenplay.
Originally titled Comancheria – a name given to the west Texas and New Mexico region, the setting and filming location of the movie respectively – the script was penned by Taylor Sheridan. Although he’s probably best known as Deputy David Hale from Sons of Anarchy, he’s an accomplished screenwriter too having also written the script for Denis Villeneuve’s critically acclaimed crime drama Sicario.
Sheridan’s directorial debut Wind River, another crime thriller penned by his own fair hand, has already received very favourable reviews on the festival circuit and is due for release this August.
1. Zombieland
Although it didn’t appear on the Black List until 2007, Zombieland
actually started out life back in 2005 as a spec for a TV pilot penned by Rhett
Reese and Paul Wernick who would go on to write Deadpool’s screenplay a few
years later.
Zombieland’s director Ruben Fleischer helped flesh the script out into a full movie, resulting in one of the best zombie comedies in recent memory with all the ingredients a good comedy horror should have – laughs, gore and just the right amount of heart.
Funnily enough, even though Bill Murray was Reese and Wernick’s ideal choice for Zombieland’s celebrity cameo they didn’t dare pen him into the original script knowing what an elusive beast the actor is.
Early drafts of the script featured Patrick Swayze until the actor got ill, while later cameos featured Dwayne ‘The Rock’ Johnson, Matthew McConaughey, Joe Pesci and Mark Hamill. But thank god they did manage to snare Bill Murray because it’s one of the best parts of the movie, if not THE best.