10 Best Joel Schumacher Films

Ranking the finest works of the late director. Batman need not apply.

By Josh Mills /

The late Joel Schumacher was a colourful character - a teenage tearaway and drug abuser, he found work as a production designer at the start of the 1970s and there embarked on a long and mixed career in the movie business.

Advertisement

Schumacher tried his hand at most genres, but was a thriller man mostly, ranging from taught, high concept works to lengthy, often serious and even sociopolitical legal dramas. He had an eye for a great cast and coaxed what could be argued as career best performances from some of his leads.

He also had a dud in him. Not what you’d call a man of refined tastes, Schumacher’s films leaned towards the glitzy and impactful - he wasn’t one for subtlety, for better or for worse, and his brace of Batman films did serious damage to the superhero genre for many years (which is a plus or a minus, depending on your opinion).

At his best, though, he was a cinematic dynamo, an audacious director whose gleeful lack of care for taste or grace made for explosive, exciting cinema. He’ll certainly be missed - and his best works will continue to stand the test of time.

10. Flawless

Flawless begins much like a lot of Schumacher’s ‘90s films, with a focus on a hard boiled man of action (Robert De Niro as cop Walter Koontz), but quickly shifts into an outlier in the director’s canon: a slow burning, sensitively drawn buddy movie between an intolerant middle aged man and his vivacious drag queen neighbour, Rusty.

Advertisement

It’s the latter character who really lifts the film, portrayed as he is by the late Philip Seymour Hoffman. You’d be hard pressed to name a single bad Hoffman performance, and the actor was on a hot streak here. He dips into stereotype on occasion - Rusty is tough, but he’s also exceedingly camp - but as per is more than capable of finding the depth in his character.

Schumacher, an openly gay man for most of his life, clearly connected to the material, and the New York LGBT scene is handled well, especially for the time. The film isn’t the most exciting of his oeuvre, and De Niro has done better work (his character suffers a stroke, and the actor’s commitment to the affected speech is at times detrimental), but Flawless is worth checking out for Hoffman alone.

9. 8mm

Nicolas Cage and Joel Schumacher are match made in heaven, or possibly the other place. Both are capable of thoughtful and effective work, but have a tendency for going to the extremes which can lead to critical maulings.

Advertisement

Their sole collaboration was 8mm, and it is essentially exactly what you’d expect: a murky, often gross exploration of snuff films, with Cage a combustible private investigator at the dark heart of an unfurling mystery.

Written by Andrew Kevin Walker, of Seven fame, this is an exercise in depravity, but with a solid moral core in the form of Cage. He plays a resolutely decent man, who refuses to let himself get dragged down too deep into the murk, and yet can’t tear himself away from the mystery.

With support from Joaquin Phoenix and James Gandolfini, 8mm boasts one of the best casts Schumacher has had at his disposal, and he utilises them well. It can be an off putting film for some due to the extent to which the director dwells in its horrid subject, but it’s not exploitative - there’s a method to his muck.

8. Tigerland

Schumacher’s 2000 Vietnam war film showed that there was still life left in one of the most cinematic conflicts in American history. The underrated Tigerland takes place in a US training camp, rather than the jungles of ‘Nam itself, but feeds on the moral ambiguity and wildness of the era to create an original and underrated film with a cast that largely went on to great things.

Advertisement

Chief among them is Colin Farrell, shortly prior to his breakthrough but clearly a commanding screen presence even this early in his career. He’s hugely charismatic as Private Bozz, a reluctant soldier who specialises in helping deserving colleagues find their way out of service. He takes a trope-like character - the cynical soldier with a heart of gold - and injects it with his movie star intensity to elevate the role, and the film.

It’s not the most fleshed out of Schumacher’s films, but with quality turns from some other now-familiar faces (Michael Shannon, Shea Wigham, Nick Searcy from Justified) and some of the least welcoming army barracks scenes since Full Metal Jacket, Tigerland is an effective evocation of a strange time and place.

7. The Client

A particularly dark entry in the Schumacher canon, The Client is a tale of political ambition run wild, mob justice, and attempted child murder. Brad Renfro got his big break in a fantastic turn as 11 year old Mark, who witnesses the suicide of a mob lawyer, which leads to the child becoming the target of local gangsters, and a possible pawn in the career goals of a U.S attorney.

Advertisement

The ever reliable Tommy Lee Jones (as pushy lawyer Roy Foltrigg) and Susan Sarandon (as kindly lawyer Regina Love) give The Client a major boost. This is Schumacher’s first adaptation of a John Grisham novel, and the source material has a little more focus on the intricacies of the law itself, which Schumacher, probably wisely, cuts for the more cinematic game of cat and mouse.

Renfro in particular dazzles in this film. The actor lived a brief and troubled life, and seems old before his years here, taking on troubling and complex material and rising to the task with aplomb. There’s a lot to like in this deeply cynical and pacy thriller.

6. St. Elmo's Fire

Probably the most important ‘80s coming of age movie not directed by John Hughes, St. Elmo’s Fire helped to make big time stars of Rob Lowe and Demi Moore, and temporary stars of the usual brat pack suspects: Sheedy, Nelson, McCarthy, Estevez.

Advertisement

A film about self absorbed, good looking young folk making a melodramatic mountain out of some pretty standard problems, St. Elmo’s Fire is very much of its time, in the dress sense, the music, and the complete self absorption of the Me Decade.

But it’s an undeniably effective film, with Schumacher, no spring chicken by this time, able to tap into that youthful exuberance, when every issue seems earth shattering, and the idea of proper, responsible adulthood utterly chilling. It’s a film that highlights the generation gap expertly - contemporaneous critics hated it, either because they couldn’t recognise themselves in the self obsessed characters, or because they could.

St. Elmo’s Fire is not as fondly remembered as the likes of The Breakfast Club, but for fans of the Brat Pack oeuvre, it remains essential, for the sheer star power (regardless of subsequent fade) on offer.

5. Flatliners

Joel Schumacher proved repeatedly in his filmography that he can make a lot out of what might seem quite a thin premise, and this is never more apparent than in Flatliners, a psychological drama that attempts to tackle the big questions of life and death. It doesn’t quite achieve this lofty goal, but like much of Schumacher’s work, it’s a blast, bolstered by a talented and giving cast.

Advertisement

Medical student Nelson (Kiefer Sutherland, something of a lucky charm for Schumacher) fixates on the realm beyond life, and convinces his malleable pals to help him investigate. The crew take it in turns to “flatline”, dying for a minute or two, before being brought back.

Needless to say, the crew see things no mortal should be seeing, with each of the titular flatliners haunted by visions of their past - their sins, mostly, along with distressing moments, loved ones lost whose ghosts won’t let go.

It’s all about the concept here, and while there’s an argument to be made that the film doesn’t do quite enough with it, the atmosphere and the talented cast (including Kevin Bacon and Julia Roberts) make up for the big questions that go unanswered in spite of the director’s laudable ambitions.

4. Phone Booth

Phone Booth’s central conceit - a man trapped in the titular telecommunications box due to the threats of an external figure - was conceived in the 1960s. Writer Larry Cohen wanted Alfred Hitchcock to direct; Hitchcock was keen, but the idea was never quite ironed out. Cohen couldn’t figure out just why this man was trapped in the booth.

Advertisement

When the script finally came together, Hitchcock had passed on, and there’s an argument to be made that cell phone technology made the whole thing a little redundant - but the idea was well worth digging up all the same. This is a taught thriller that stays just on the right side of plausible, bolstered by sterling work from Colin Farrell.

Phone Booth is a morality play - Farrell’s Stu has been philandering, and unless he changes his ways, the unnamed caller (Kiefer Sutherland) will blow him away. At under 90 minutes, the film smartly resists overstaying its welcome, mining as much tension as it can from its gimmick before getting out of there.

A big deal at the time, Phone Booth isn’t talked about so much these days (likely due to the increasing irrelevance of its setting), but it’s well worth returning to.

3. A Time To Kill

Sandwiched between his two glossy Batman movies is perhaps Schumacher’s most serious film. Based on the novel by John Grisham, A Time To Kill is a stifling courtroom drama which tries, for the most part successfully, to examine racial prejudices at the heart of America’s legal system.

Advertisement

After his young daughter is beaten and raped, Carl Lee Hailey (Samuel L. Jackson, rarely better) has little faith in his family’s ability to obtain a fair trial in small town Mississippi, so takes the law into his own hands, shooting the assailants in the courthouse. Attorney Jake Brigance (Matthew McConaughey) is brought in to defend the grieving father.

A splashy and sensational tale, this is bolstered by great performances across the board, with Sandra Bullock and Oliver Platt joining McConaughey’s legal team, and the always enjoyable Kurtwood Smith as a KKK leader.

The oppressive heat of the setting serves to ramp up the tension as Schumacher makes an admirable effort to examine the prejudicial environment Hailey finds himself fighting in, and against. Subtlety was never the director’s strong suit, but with a setting and subject as evocative as this, blunt force does the job well.

2. The Lost Boys

It’s surprising that a film so quintessentially 1980s as The Lost Boys has aged so well. A bloodthirsty retelling of the Peter Pan story, The Lost Boys isn’t the only film to posit vampires as the rock stars of the supernatural world, but it might make the most convincing argument.

Advertisement

The plot is delightfully simple: a family moves to a small town which quickly turns out to be infested by motorbike riding, leather clad vampires. Older brother Michael falls in with a bad crowd, as ‘80s teens are wont to do, and young Sam must free him from the clutches of the fanged fiends.

The Lost Boys combines the talents of Coreys Haim and Feldman with Jason Patric and Kiefer Sutherland in another of his swaggering bully roles that he excelled in throughout the decade. With Dianne Wiest and Edward Herrmann gamely playing the adult roles, it’s a particularly stacked cast (at the time, anyway - some of the above didn’t find much to do the following decades).

It’s a young adult movie that doesn’t skimp on the scares or gore, with a killer soundtrack and one of the funniest ending jokes in cinema. Like its sunlight dodging subjects, it’s ageless.

1. Falling Down

Years before Breaking Bad took their protagonist and slowly turned him into the villain, Joel Schumacher did a far more efficient job in his timely masterpiece Falling Down. Starring Michael Douglas as William "D-Fens" Foster, a man who’s mad as hell and isn’t going to take it anymore, this is part early ‘90s satire, part descent into madness.

Advertisement

Stuck in traffic on a baking hot day, D-Fens reaches his breaking point. He abandons his car and storms through L.A, settling petty gripes with fast food workers and golfers, and causing untold damage with his growing cache of weapons.

There’s a video game logic to Falling Down, but more depth than is immediately apparent. D-Fens is a cog in a wheel, a working man deemed redundant, and in a city already on the edge of collapse (we’re not even a year distant from the L.A riots), he’s combustible in the extreme.

Douglas is career best here, ditching his slick persona and bringing real pathos to D-Fens as he realises that his supposedly moral crusade has turned him into the bad guy. Falling Down is an evergreen classic.

Advertisement