"Listen, pal. I make an honest living. People only come to me when they're in a desperate situation. I help 'em out. I don't kick families out of their houses like you bums down at the bank do." - Jake Gittes, Chinatown.
In a world of cop shows and crime procedurals, is there anything more refreshing than a great private detective story? Seemingly out of fashion since their 1940s hay-day, every once in a while, a story comes along to remind us just how exciting a good mystery can be. Sometimes these stories are nostalgic odes to the original genre; other times they're a witty deconstruction of the tropes that have been rearranged into something new. This list is a collection of a few of the characters that make their stories work, whether they be classical in form or innovative re-imaginings. While some that made this list might not be Private Eyes in the strictest of senses, they all embody - or play off of - the classic archetypes of the genre. Of course, if you have any favorite private investigators that I happened to have left off of this list, feel free to start a discussion in the comments section...
10. Philip Marlowe - Murder, My Sweet
Murder, My Sweet might not have aged the best of all the classic Film Noir films, but it's strength is in just how classical of a Noir mystery it really is. Based on pulp mastermind Raymond Chandler's 1940 novel, Farewell, My Lovely, film executives changed the name to punch it up, hoping to draw in box-office business. It might not have aged as well as some of the others, but that's because this film is concentrated Chandler. Marlowe has had many incantations, most notably Humphrey Bogart in The Big Sleep, but there's something particularly enjoyable about this performance. Dick Powell takes on the role of Marlowe, playing very much against type, which was a big selling point. It was a successful turn and launched the next stage in Powell's career as a dramatic actor.
9. Harry Caul - The Conversation
Contention on this entry is also expected, if only minimally warranted. Sure, he's not technically a private eye in the strictest of senses, but rather a surveillance expert (isn't that really what a P.I. is, though?) highly regarded in his field. The brilliance of the character, in a script written by Francis Ford Coppola, is that he's conversely obsessed with his own privacy. Always the professional, Caul becomes racked with guilt when a conversation he records leads to the death of three individuals. After editing a series of recordings of the same conversation taken from different vantage points, Caul begins to notice tones and undercurrents that start to trouble him. Throughout the film, he continues to refine the recordings, uncovering new nuances in the conversation. When he uncovers the phrase "He'd kill us if he got the chance," Caul is placed in a moral dilemma and forced to ask himself if he can continue to keep himself removed from his work.
8. Max Cherry - Jackie Brown
Jackie Brown has become one of Quentin Tarantino's forgotten films, but unlike Death Proof, the movie deserves all the praise it can get. Along with the film, a lot of wonderfully colorful characters have been lost as well. One of these characters is Max Cherry, a bail-bondsmen, who - again not technically a private eye - finds himself on this list by fulfilling a more abstract set of character criteria, both classic and innovative. In a classical sense, his professional and personal experience have given him insight into human behavior. Like any P.I., this life-time surrounded by crime, violence, and disappointment has led to a hard-boiled, cynical outlook. He knows "the angles" and how to manipulate them in his favor. But, more importantly, he knows when doing so is worth his effort. His intuition is showcased in his tracking down of criminals on the run, but most fully illustrated in Jackie Brown through the way he navigates the landscape of criminals and Federal Agents for love. This is one of the more original and likable qualities of the Max Cherry character: Despite his cynical understanding of human nature, he's willing to fight for what he wants and believes in. Whilst also scraping a little extra off the top. Why not?
7. Rick Deckard - Blade Runner
Again, technically Deckard's job title is that of a Blade Runner (a.k.a. Bounty Hunter in the original novel), but at its core, Blade Runner is film noir parading as science fiction. Like Max Cherry, Deckard is a pillar of cynicism but also embodies the noir traits of the reluctant hero. Max Cherry sets his plan in motion for love, Rick Deckard is just doing what he has to do to survive. The character was originally written for the screen with anti-hero and film noir legend Robert Mitchum in mind, but eventually Dustin Hoffman was in talks to take on the role. After leaving the project for creative differences, Harrison Ford was cast. Upon seeing Ford's performance, Philip K. Dick - the writer of the original source material - stated: "Harrison Ford had not played that role, Deckard would never become an actual person. Ford radiates this tremendous reality when you see him."
6. Harry Lockhart - Kiss Kiss Bang Bang
What makes Harry Lockhart such an interesting Private Detective figure, again, is that he's not really a Private Detective. Based on the narrative structure of several Raymond Chandler novels, Kiss Kiss Bang Bang is about a NYC thief accidentally turned Hollywood actor who finds himself in Los Angeles and up for the role of a P.I.. He's paired with real-life investigator Gay Perry (Val Kilmer) for training when he unwittingly stumbles on a plot of murder and corruption. The role is notable for being a return to form for Robert Downey Jr., who'd spent the earlier half of the decade mired in scandal. His unique blend of neurotic confidence gives Harry Lockhart a pulse and makes the absurd story wholly believable.
5. Walter Neff - Double Indemnity
An insurance salesman with the mind of a detective, Walter Neff kicks off the top half of our list. Penned by Billy Wilder and noir mastermind Raymond Chandler, Neff is the perfect embodiment of early noir and the first on our list to fall tragically in love with a true femme fatale. He's also the sleaziest, most self-serving of any character to have made the list. Played wonderfully against type by rom-com favorite Fred MacMurray, Walter Neff is an insurance salesman with the intelligence and acumen of a detective. His co-worker, Barton Keyes (who is also played brilliantly against type by Edward G. Robinson, most famous for playing gangsters), recognizes his wasted potential and urges him to put his problem solving to use as a claims adjuster. Neff refuses, letting his desires set him down a slippery slope of criminal behavior. What's so much fun about Walter Neff, and Double Indemnity as a film, is that it defies you to root for the main character. Like any great noir protagonist, he knows the angles and knows what he's doing is wrong. Usually, a P.I. will find himself in the middle of murder and corruption accidentally, but Neff is the driving force of his own demise.
4. Philip Marlowe - The Long Goodbye
Philip Marlowe, another Raymond Chandler creation, was first made famous by Humphrey Bogart's portrayal in The Big Sleep during the hay-day of noir. True, there is something classic about Bogart's performance (he is the quintessential P.I., after all), but that's what make's Robert Altman's subversive re-imagining so great. In 1973, Altman set out to adapt Chandler's The Long Goodbye as a "send-up" of the classic 1940s detective character navigating 1970s Southern California. What makes this approach work is the abandonment of any "fish out of water" scenarios that might seem natural to this set-up. It's not tacked on, or even all that noticeable. The story, along with Elliott Gould's wonderful performance, are allowed to operate naturally within the conceit.
3. The Dude - The Big Lebowski
The Big Lebowski's The Dude (a.k.a Jeff Lebowski, His Dudeness, Duder, El Duderino if you're not into the whole brevity thing) takes the reluctant hero element inherent in the Private Eye story and spins it to a whole new level: "All The Dude ever wanted was his rug back (it really tied the room together)." What transpires is an absurdist concoction of ransom, lost homework, and acid flashbacks. The role is played to perfection by Jeff Bridges, who used a lot of his own wardrobe on the film. Bridges' performance brings a lot of humanity and authenticity to a character that could have been a one-note stoner joke (maybe not in the hands of the Coen Brothers, though). A true testament to the character, The Dude has gone on to inspire an entire "religion" of Dudeists who live to abide.
2. Jake Gittes - Chinatown
Filmed in the early 1970s, Chinatown is almost an essay, or cinematic study, on the film noir genre: everything about its creation is from the outside, looking in. First: even though the term "film noir" originated in France, it's a genre almost wholly American (at first). It would, however, go on to inspire a whole generation of filmmakers across the world. One of these is Roman Polanski, who helmed this brilliant genre study. At its heart is Jake Gittes, played by Jack Nicholson in one of his most defining roles. The Gittes character is one of the main reasons, apart from the villain and incredibly intricate plot, that this study works so well. He is the quintessential P.I. character with a reluctance to get involved and a moral code embedded in shades of grey. Incredibly slick when he needs to be and usually one-step ahead when it counts, he's one of those incredible characters you can't take your eyes off of.
1. Sam Spade - The Maltese Falcon
This is it. This is the role that started a genre and launched Humphrey Bogart, already well into his acting career, right into super-stardom. It's the first time Warner Bros. paired Sidney Greenstreet, Peter Lorre and Bogart together, all of whom would return in the seminal Casablanca. And without the role of Sam Spade, it all might never have happened. Here's the thing: Sam Spade is not really the best guy. He sleeps with his partner's wife, then shows little remorse for his death. Still, he was all about keeping up appearances. The character's creator Dashiell Hammett said of Spade that a Private Detective does not "want to be an erudite solver of riddles in the Sherlock Holmes manner; he wants to be a hard and shifty fellow, able to take care of himself in any situation, able to get the best of anybody he comes in contact with, whether criminal, innocent by-stander or client." This is truly why Spade rounds out the list. That description doesn't simply speak for him but for all the last nine characters as well, despite the semantics of their actual job title. Couple that with Spade being identified with such an iconic, hard-boiled noir actor as Bogart, and what is left is nothing short of definitive. Like this list? Who have we missed? Let us know in the comments section below.