10 Biggest Mistakes Made By MCU Heroes

From deadly AI to poor self-control, relive the MCU's messiest mistakes!

By Tim Hand /

The heroes of the MCU have saved countless lives during their careers, and the entire universe owes them its survival. However, that doesn't mean that they always make the right call. Even the most selfless and powerful Avengers have been prone to grievous mistakes, that ultimately endangered the lives of those they sought to protect.

Advertisement

Of course, no hero is without flaw, but some mistakes are bigger than others. While several errors of judgement were prevented from spiralling out of control thanks to timely interventions (such as Iron Man coming to Spider-Man's rescue at the ferry in Homecoming), others had dire repercussions for the MCU's inhabitants. In some cases, mistakes made by heroes resulted in numerous casualties and terrible suffering.

The following blunders will be ranked according to their inherent stupidity, the consequences resulting from them, and any extenuating circumstances that were affecting the heroes' judgements at the time.

On the subject of extenuating circumstances, actions that were the result of brainwashing or childhood indoctrination won’t be counted (in other words, Bucky Barnes and Natasha Romanoff won’t be featured here for their pasts as assassins).

With that, it's time to abandon reason, and relive some of the biggest foul-ups in Marvel history!

10. Baiting The Mandarin

Tony Stark's initial decision to give his address to 'the Mandarin' and call him out on TV was understandable; one of his friends had almost been killed, and he was already dealing with psychological issues. However, his utter failure to prepare for an attack is far harder to overlook.

Despite being aware of the ruthlessness and intelligence behind the Mandarin campaign, Tony made the classic mistake of underestimating his enemy. He failed to make use of his numerous resources and allies, ranging from a vast armada of suits to his fellow Avengers, the aid of which would have made easy meat of the helicopters sent to Malibu.

Tony's failure to prepare was particularly highlighted by his dismissal of Pepper's desire to evacuate, not to mention the fact that he only realised what was going on when Maya Hansen - someone working with Aldrich Killian - pointed out an approaching missile to him on TV! Had the lasting consequences of Tony's mistake not been confined to the loss of his house, this one would have ranked much higher.

Advertisement

9. Steve's Secrecy

It's never easy to tell someone that your childhood best friend might have killed their parents. So, it's understandable why Steve Rogers failed to tell Tony that Howard and Maria Stark had been murdered by HYDRA, and that there was a possibility that Bucky had been involved.

Nevertheless, Tony undeniably deserved to know the truth about how his parents had died, and Steve himself confessed at the end of Civil War that his motivation for hiding the truth had ultimately been selfish.

Instead of learning the truth from a friend and being given time to process it, Tony found out when the vengeful Baron Zemo showed him video footage of the brutal killings. Unsurprisingly, he didn't take the news well, and almost murdered Bucky in retaliation.

While Bucky survived the vicious fight at the climax of Civil War, it destroyed Tony's trust in Steve and left a painful schism between them. This ensured that the Avengers would be divided and disorganised when Thanos made his play for the Infinity Stones.

8. Stark Industries' Arms Dealing

Tony made no attempt to change Stark Industries' business model after becoming its CEO. On the contrary, he threw himself into the role wholeheartedly, designing ingenious new weapons like the Jericho missile.

Sadly, Tony's brilliance in creating weapons was not matched by his efforts to ensure that they didn't fall into the wrong hands. Thanks to Tony's failure to keep track of his weapons, not to mention his inability to realise that his business partner Obadiah Stane was corrupt and ruthless, Stark Industries' weapons were used against civilians and US soldiers.

Tony was forced to confront the truth behind his success and riches when he learned that Stark weapons had fallen into the hands of the Ten Rings, and experienced first-hand the harm they could do.

Even after learning from his mistake and putting Stark Industries on a new course, the legacy of Tony's arms dealing would return to haunt him when Wanda and Pietro Maximoff joined forces with HYDRA and Ultron to avenge the deaths of their parents, who had been killed by a Stark explosive.

7. Rocket's Batteries

With the exception of Gamora, the Guardians of the Galaxy are far from the MCU’s brightest heroes, generally triumphing through courage and improvisation instead of good decision-making. But even by their haphazard standards, Rocket’s decision to steal the Sovereign’s Anulax batteries was a costly error. The fleet dispatched by the furious Sovereign would have wiped the Guardians out had Ego not intervened, demonstrating just how foolish the needless theft had been.

The consequences didn’t stop there. Ayesha’s bounty provoked a mutiny amongst Yondu’s Ravagers when their captain refused to capture the Guardians. The Ravagers loyal to Yondu wouldn’t have been cruelly murdered by Taserface’s mutineers if Rocket hadn't made an enemy of the Sovereign.

Yondu himself would pay the price for Rocket’s theft, as the Sovereign fleet’s intervention in the Guardians’ struggle against Ego destroyed the team’s Laser Drill and rendered Mantis unconscious, which awakened the sleeping celestial.

Although Rocket was able to make the best of his mistake by using the batteries as a bomb to kill Ego, Yondu would have survived had the initial plan with the drill succeeded and Ego remained asleep.

6. Westview

If not for some particularly extenuating circumstances, this one would be near the top of the list. Wanda’s attempt to create an idyllic sitcom lifestyle for herself and Vision was accomplished at the cost of condemning Westview’s inhabitants to horrific torment.

Although Wanda wasn’t fully aware of what she was doing when she first established the Hex, she maintained it even after being confronted with the consequences of her actions by Vision.

Deprived of their free will, separated from their loved ones and forced to experience Wanda’s nightmares, the people of Westview were in constant pain until the Hex was eventually taken down. Even the sympathetic Monica Rambeau described the experience as “excruciating, terrifying, a violation.”

However, the fact that Wanda was experiencing severe mental health problems at the time means that she deserves some leniency and understanding. She had seen Vision die for a second time after having been forced to kill him, and had then been confronted with the ghoulish sight of his dismembered body thanks to the heartless reptile known as Tyler Hayward. Her mistake was the result of terrible grief and loneliness, and she ultimately did the right thing and ended the Hex, despite having to sacrifice her only family once again.

5. "You Should Have Gone For The Head"

The stakes were incomprehensibly high when Thor confronted Thanos during the Battle of Wakanda. The Titan had finally obtained all six Infinity Stones, and was ready to wipe out half the universe. Thor’s sudden arrival seemed to save the day when all hope had been lost, as he sent Stormbreaker hurtling into Thanos’ chest, overpowering the completed Infinity Gauntlet in the process.

However, Thor’s decision to draw out Thanos’ death and make the Titan suffer proved to be a dreadful error when Thanos snapped his fingers and decimated the universe.

By choosing to prioritise vengeance over saving lives, Thor enabled Thanos to completed his murderous mission. In terms of consequences, they don’t come bigger than this!

That said, it’s hard to be too harsh on Thor. He had single-handedly turned the tide during the battle, having put himself through an agonising ordeal to create Stormbreaker, and he came closer to killing Thanos in Infinity War than the rest of the Avengers put together.

Thor’s judgement was also severely impacted by trauma, since he’d just witnessed the deaths of his brother, one of his closest friends and half of his people. Given that he had every reason to want Thanos to suffer, Thor deserves some forgiveness.

4. E.D.I.T.H.

You’d really think that Tony would have learned his lesson concerning dangerous AI after Ultron. But no! Not only did Tony create another AI, complete with an armada of lethal drones, he then gave full control of it to a teenager!

While Peter Parker is undoubtedly a true hero, the power to kill anyone, anywhere, at any time is arguably too much for anybody, let alone someone who’s still at school. Peter’s decision to relinquish E.D.I.T.H. was perfectly understandable – a certain quote about power and responsibility comes to mind, and the responsibilities involved with E.D.I.T.H. were simply too great for Peter to bear.

Tony’s inability to learn from his previous mistakes almost caused catastrophic harm. Peter was tricked into ceding control of E.D.I.T.H. to the unscrupulous Quentin Beck, who used it to fake a super-powered attack on London, with minimal regard for casualties. Beck also came close to murdering Peter and his class in his attempt to preserve his heroic image.

Although Peter and his allies were able to defeat Mysterio, the whole situation could have been avoided had Tony not been so utterly foolish.

3. Drax Summoning Ronan

Drax had made it his life’s goal to slay Ronan the Accuser and avenge the deaths of his wife and daughter. Unfortunately, this desire for vengeance led to disaster when he impatiently summoned the Kree war criminal to Knowhere. Ronan arrived with a huge army, easily overpowering Drax and obtaining the Power Stone.

Instead of destroying Ronan, Drax gave him the ability to commit genocide on a planetary scale.

While Drax acknowledged his blunder and managed to stop Ronan from destroying Xandar, his mistake still had terrible consequences. Ronan used the stone to slaughter vast numbers of Nova pilots during the Battle of Xandar. In addition to representing a huge loss of life, this severely weakened the Nova Corps and left Xandar far more vulnerable.

Had Ronan not been able to use the stone, Xandar would have stood a better chance when Thanos arrived to decimate it a few years later. Furthermore, even if Thanos had still triumphed there, his forces would probably have been considerably reduced in the process, giving the Avengers a better chance of victory in Infinity War.

2. The Creation Of Ultron

Terrified of another alien attack, Tony convinced Bruce Banner to help him use the Mind Stone to create an AI, and thereby ensure "peace in our time." They ignored the warnings of countless sci-fi movies in the process.

In a plot development that pretty much anyone else could have seen coming, Ultron decided to rebel against his creators and wipe out humanity. He came perilously close to succeeding. His attempted genocide resulted in the deaths of Pietro Maximoff and many civilians, and the survivors of Sokovia were left without a homeland when their stricken country was cannibalised by its neighbours.

Although Tony and Bruce had good intentions, their decision reeked of folly and hubris. Ignoring the fact that the creation of artificial life posed an enormous risk and represented an ethical minefield, Tony arrogantly dismissed potential dissenting voices as “the man was not meant to meddle medley."

The two scientists also failed to disclose their experiments with the stone to their fellow Avengers, further highlighting their arrogance and unwise lack of trust. Ultron's legacy continued to haunt the team in the form of the Sokovia Accords, which fostered division between them and branded numerous Avengers as criminals.

1. Almost Everything Star-Lord Did In Infinity War

With Thanos threatening to extinguish half of all life, the universe needed defenders that were truly selfless, level-headed and heroic. Unfortunately, it got Star-Lord, too.

Despite being aware that there was only a one in 14,000,605 chance of victory, Peter Quill lost control when he learned of Gamora's death and started beating Thanos, breaking Mantis' hold on the Titan in the process. Had he kept himself under control for a few more seconds, Iron Man and Spider-Man would have been able to remove the Infinity Gauntlet.

Although Star-Lord's judgement was undeniably affected by the loss of Gamora, it's hard to be very sympathetic, given the shockingly crass way that he'd belittled Thor's trauma earlier. Indeed, he seemed to do his utmost to be a liability throughout Infinity War, whether through his inability to lead his team on Knowhere or his pathetic, insecure efforts to assert his superiority on Titan.

In stark contrast to Thor at Wakanda, Star-Lord was quite literally begged not to lose control by Tony, and he knew that his actions would have dreadful consequences. Instead, he gave into his rage and impatience, and the universe paid a terrible price. Star-Lord will have an awful lot of work to do in future appearances to become a true hero once again after such a titanic failure.

Advertisement