Perception is pretty much everything when it comes to films, and our verdict on the quality of a movie is usually just an intellectual alignment often dictated by its box office success, or failure. However, some of the biggest box office hits in history are also some of the most awful movies ever made. Transformers: Dark Of The Moon, anyone? And let's face it, whilst Skyfall's box office peformance has earned it the title "Best Bond movie ever," it isn't a patch on From Russia With Love, or Live And Let Die. I find the stories surrounding Hollywood turkeys far more compelling than those of financial triumph. The making of notorious flops such as Cutthroat Island, Glitter and The Adventures Of Pluto Nash are ripping yarns that describe hubris and out of control ego and are usually more entertaining than the film itself. Sometimes, though, a box office bomb is a great film that just wasn't able to find its audience. Thanks to Blu-Ray and DVD these films have another chance to rise from the mortician's slab to be embraced by those who never got to see them when they first came out. Here are 10 movie bombs that I think are well worth checking out...
10. Heaven's Gate (1978)
Michael Cimino followed his Oscar winning 1978 movie The Deer Hunter with this movie starring Kris Kristofferson, Christopher Walken, Jeff Bridges and Isabelle Huppert. Cimino ignored all of the studio's financial constraints in his single-minded drive to create the definitive epic western. Production would be halted for hours at a time whilst he waited for the perfect cloud formation to roll into view. There's a point in the movie where a group of townsfolk tentatively creep into a hungover Kristofferson's room and attempt to wake him. Startled and disoriented he cracks a bullwhip at the timorous huddle. The whole scene doesn't last as long as it took me to type those two sentences and yet Cimino spent a whole day capturing it on film. Utter genius! Unsurprisingly the initial budget of $7.5 million spiralled to an eye-watering $44 million by the time of release. The critics were lying in wait and pounced mercilessly. Vincent Canby in the New York Times described Heaven's Gate as, "a forced, four-hour walking tour of ones own living room. Others were far more savage in their denunciation and, after withdrawing it to put together a shorter cut, the movie ended its short run having only earned $3.5 million. The intervening years have been pretty good to Heaven's Gate and it can now be judged on its own terms rather than as an affront to the rules of film-making. I recently picked up a copy of Criterion's digitally remastered director's cut and it's a bit of masterpiece. Cimino's insistence on perfection means that it's beautifully photographed, every frame looking like an oil painting and the story - dispossessed immigrants standing up to unprincipled landowners - in light of the Occupy movement, is very timely. At 3-hours-and- 36-minutes it's a bit long, but it's such an immersive experience the time whizzes by.
9. Hudson Hawk (1991)
In 1991 Bruce Willis was Hollywood's biggest action star following the box office juggernauts Die Hard and Die Hard 2. The previous year he'd starred in The Bonfire Of The Vanities which had crashed and burned at the box office. Brian De Palma's adaptation of the Tom Wolfe novel was positioned as a comedy, so normal Willisness would be resumed once he got back to his usual action movie duties. Hudson Hawk, directed by Michael Lehman who had delivered the deliciously dark Heathers in 1988, had the reassuring tag line "Catch The Adventure, Catch The Excitement, Catch The Hawk". However, what greeted the audience was an outrageous spoof of an action movie, with every detail dialled up to a hysterically shrieking 11. Imagine a Bob Hope and Bing Crosby road movie colliding with a James Bond flick. It's that good. Anyone can place the hero at the scene of a robbery, but it takes a genius to punctuate that robbery with a show tune or to have the female lead, Andie MacDowell, spend a good portion of the movie impersonating a dolphin. Its genuinely funny, an absurdist caper movie, with Richard E Grant and Sandra Bernhard vying for the title of campest villain of all time. Danny Aiello and James Coburn are eminently watchable, as always. None of which anybody expected, and as a result people stayed away in their droves. Even given his Hollywood title as the Smirkmaster General rarely has Mr Willis smirked so much, or looked as smug as he does in this movie, and rightly so, it's brilliant. Knowing one-liner after knowing one-liner (head on over to imdb and check out the very quotable quotes) batter you into submission until you love John McClane even more. I went to see GI Joe: Retaliation at the weekend and it was quite, quite awful, but Bruce Willis gave a couple of half-grins which reminded me of Hudson Hawk and all was right with the world.
8. The Adventures Of Baron Munchausen (1989)
Advertisement
I love Terry Gilliam's films. They're ambitious in scope and as deranged and delirious as his animation for Monty Python back in the seventies. Gilliam has made some astonishing movies: Brazil, The Fisher King and 12 Monkeys to name just three. One of his most spectacular achievements was this 1989 film about an old bloke with a penchant for outrageous exaggeration. Mired in production difficulties as a new executive team took over at Columbia, the film came in at almost twice its original budget. Terry Gilliam disputes this, suggesting that the new executives drove the estimated costs downwards in an effort to discredit the previous regime. What isn't open to question is just how incredible the movie looks and, as a result, it was Oscar nominated in four categories: Best Set Decoration, Best Costume Design, Best Visual Effects and Best Makeup. In German folklore Baron Munchausen struggled against the duplicity and conventionality of the world around him, which pretty much mirrors what Terry Gilliam had to endure from the studio. Despite this he was able to capture stunningly inventive visuals and coax fantastic performances from John Neville as the Baron, and a very young Sarah Polley as Sally Salt. Wonderful cameos from Oliver Reed, Robin Williams, Uma Thurman and Sting add to the effervescent quality of this magnificent film which features visual effects way ahead of their pre CGI time. Like all Terry Gilliam movies, it's enchantingly odd and, like the Spanish Inquisition as scripted by Monty Python, an unexpected pleasure.
7. xXx: State Of The Union
After the success of the franchise starter The Fast And The Furious, Director Rob Cohen and Vin Diesel went on to shoot xXx. It was a pretty formulaic actioner which was supposed to update the notion of the super spy for the new millenium. The only scene of note is Rammstein setting fire to a club as they perform Feuer Frei in the opening sequence. For the second movie in the series the director and its headline star had disappeared to be replaced by Lee Tamahori fresh from Die Another Day (possibly the worst Bond movie ever) and rap legend Ice Cube. Samuel L Jackson returned as Augustus Gibbons, a role which spookily foreshadowed his future outing as Nick Fury. Ice Cube's first four albums are angry, political classics: vital social documents which chart the black experience in a violent America. The grooves of each disc are so drenched in righteous indignation they make Rage Against The Machine sound like Justin Bieber. The fallout and flak from his being so outspoken saw him retreat to safe, party material for his subsequent albums and a filmic output which centred on sappy comedy, namely Are We There Yet?, Barbershop parts 1 and 2 and the Friday franchise. xXx: State Of The Union is a chance for us to see the Brotha ya love ta hate bringing it with attitude for 101 minutes in a far more coherent manner than that of its scattergun, stunt-for-stunt's-sake predecessor. Ice Cube oozes the same seething charisma which makes his early albums so essential. Strong supporting performances from Willem Dafoe, Scott Speedman, Peter Strauss and the peerless Mr Jackson make this a top quality action movie. In an interview on the DVD, Lee Tamahori says that Ice Cube "Never was a cop killer. He was just the irreverent rapper, raging against the machine." Now, if you know the difference between your Ice Cubes and your Ice-Ts, you'll know it was the latter who performed the song Cop Killer with his rock band Body Count, which suggests to me that Mr Tamahori didn't even know which rapper he was directing! That makes it an even better movie.
6. Event Horizon (1997)
I was in a band attempting to live the rock star dream when this movie came out. What I was unaware of at the time was that being a rock star means spending loads of time in hotel rooms not doing much at all apart from waiting for a phone call. We were recording our album in London and were given a day off. I went off to the Forbidden Planet megastore, which was on Tottenham Court Road back then, and bought myself a set of Donald Goines crime novels to help fill my time, whilst my room mate, Christian, went to the Odeon in Leicester Square to watch Event Horizon. He rang me, freaking out, a couple of hours later. He had been under the impression that the movie was going to be a gentle hour and a half of Star Trek type fare. Instead he got what he described as: "Hellraiser in space. It's horrific, Basil, and it's going to give me nightmares for ages." That was recommendation enough for me and I zipped over to catch an evening showing. I loved it! This film owes a lot to Ridley Scott's Alien, but it takes that template and then skews off into a completely different, and pretty creepy, direction. The impressive cast, Laurence Fishburne especially, sells the notion that there is some very scary stuff going on, and Sam Neill is more than convincing as his character gleefully rides the downward spiral into madness. It's odd that a director who was able to make a movie as accomplished as Event Horizon hasn't gone on to create anything of any worth since. Indeed he even managed to make a mess of 2011's The Three Musketeers. For a director who prides himself on making populist movies, it's ironic that everyone tries to avoid anything with which his name is associated. Everyone was very wrong on this one though. Event Horizon is a very good horror movie. Oh, and see if you can spot an uncredited performance by Teresa May, an adult film star who who went on to star in such titles as Teresa Takes 10 Inches, Horny Housewives on the Job and The Prodigy's Smack My Bitch Up music video.
5. Kingdom Of Heaven (2005)
I went to see this at the cinema in 2005 and was massively disappointed. It reinforced the notion that Ridley Scott's powers to enchant were waning after the sumptuously riproaring Gladiator. This was an action movie with not much action. Fairly early on there's a skirmish in a snow flecked forest which looks fantastic, but the movie never hits those heights of excitement again. It features an underwhelming central performance from Orlando Bloom as Balian, who transforms himself from humble blacksmith to Crusader hero. His cheekbones, as always, look fabulous, but he seems way out of his depth, his meagre skills too slight to shoulder the burden of a major movie featuring top-notch actors like Jeremy Irons, David Thewlis, Brendan Gleeson, Liam Neeson and Edward Norton. About 18 months later whilst shopping in ASDA I saw a 4-Disc Special Edition Extended Director's Cut box set of Kingdom Of Heaven on sale for £4 (!). Always seeking out a bargain, I purchased it. When I got home I drew the curtains and popped in disc 1 eager to find out what the hell had happened to make the original such a limp and insipid effort. What had happened, boys and girls, was 20th Century Fox had attempted to wring an action movie out of a considered analysis of religious conflict. This was never meant to be an action movie, instead it is a brilliantly observed exploration of the historical and political attitudes of Empire and religious tolerance as Christians battle Muslims for control of Jerusalem. This movie offers an objective, political examination of the origins of the difficulties in the middle east and suggests that Muslims, despite what the screeching mainstream media in the West might state, are actually human. It bravely helps make sense of the ongoing disputes in the middle east. With the film studio's sister company, Fox News, being a cheerleader for the illegal war in Iraq the intentions of the film were always going to be fudged. Orlando Bloom's uncertainty suddenly comes into a sharp focus against this much broader canvas. Unlike all the other protagonists, his character Balian isn't fundamentally religious, but is merely trying to find something which helps him make sense of his life and the deaths of his wife and child. Ghassan Massoud as Saladin gives a quietly authoritative performance which is totally captivating and steals the movie completely. I was completely taken aback by the experience and, revisiting this movie recently, I'm convinced that this may well be the best work in Ridley Scott's catalogue.
4. Punisher: War Zone (2008)
Advertisement
The previous cinematic outings of The Punisher in 1989 (starring Dolph Lundgren) and 2004 (starring Thomas Jane) had been fairly perfunctory. Indeed, describing them as distinctly average is probably being far too kind. This version released in 2009 stars Ray Stevenson as the vengeful vigilante waging a bloody one man war against crime. Although this was a reboot in what was the first outing for the more adult Marvel Knights movie imprint, it feels nothing like an origin story. Within five minutes of the credits The Punisher has decapitated a mafia crime boss, snapped his wife's neck and is hanging from a chandelier firing twin machine guns and eviscerating henchmen left, right and centre. It's a frenetic opening and the pace rarely slackens. Directed by Lexi Alexander, who made the awful Green Street, it perfectly recreates panels from The Punisher MAX comics. The relentless dark humour is pitch perfect. The gore, violence and bloodshed are wonderfully over the top and brilliantly tongue in cheek. The Punisher fixes his broken nose by snapping it back into place with a broken pencil, and the biggest laugh of the movie sees him expressing his disdain for Parkour through the use of a rocket launcher. Dominic West brings his accomplished actorly chops to his role of chief villain Jigsaw. He chews up the scenery with aplomb in an enthusiastic performance that's reminiscent of Jack Nicholson's Joker in Tim Burton's Batman. The critics gave this movie a unanimous thumbs down, and when I went to see it I was literally the only person in the theatre. Everyone missed that this was a deliberate throwback to eighties action flicks and, as a movie based on a comic book, it's a thrilling tribute to camp ultraviolence. This isn't Akira Kurosawa's Punisher: War Zone, or Terence Malick's Punisher: War Zone. It's easily one of the best comic adaptations of recent years.
3. Miracle At St. Anna (2008)
Back in 2008, just before the opening of his own Miracle At St. Anna, Spike Lee criticised Clint Eastwood for making two World War II movies which didn't feature one solitary black soldier as a character. Mr Eastwood may well be a giant of cinema, but, as we saw at the Republican Party Convention when he addressed an empty chair, he's as mad as the late Margaret Thatcher's left elbow. That would explain Eastwood's considered retort that Lee should, "Shut his face." Hundreds of black servicemen were involved in the attack on Iwo Jima depicted in Eastwood's films, and choosing not to make them part of the story highlights the undertow of discrimination alive and well in both society at large and Hollywood in particular. Miracle At St. Anna is an effort to redress the balance and is Spike Lee's "Thank you" to those who fought for their country and have had their contribution ignored. This is a movie that had to be made, rendering its box office achievements almost an irrelevance. The film itself is lavishly and exquisitely photographed and follows the Black, segregated Buffalo Soldiers 92nd Infantry Division who are stationed in Italy. The scene depicting the firefight as they attempt to cross the Serchio River whilst Axis Sally (a German radio announcer dispensing propaganda) asks them to question why they're fighting for an America that considers them less than human is right up there with the opening scene in Saving Private Ryan. This film looks at the war from a unique angle and tells a story that has been ignored for far too long. The scenes in New York which bookend the movie and feature top-notch performances from Joseph Gordon-Levitt and John Turturro, are thoroughly engrossing. It's a clever and well-observed film, and the euphoric ending wrong foots you. I was inspired to raise my right fist and yell, "Fight The Power!" which isn't necessarily what anyone in Wigan expects on a Tuesday afternoon.
2. Speed Racer (2008)
The Wachowskis are bulletproof in my book. They can do no wrong. 1999's innovative and inventive The Matrix allows them a free pass to do whatever they want and I'll go and see it having already made up my mind that it's brilliant. I love The Matrix Reloaded, The Matrix Revolutions, V For Vendetta and Ninja Assassin. I haven't seen it yet, but Cloud Atlas is bound to be a work of genius. Following the thread? Good. Speed Racer came out in 2008 and it's an extraordinarily stylised film which looks like a slow motion explosion in a Skittles factory (the rainbow confectionery rather than the bowling accessory). It's like nothing else that has ever graced the cinema screen: a visual banquet that will leave your eyeballs with a double-chin and a bit of a paunch by the time the credits roll. The CGI and animation send impossible cars and improbable race tracks corkscrewing into an azure blue sky or slicing through a cobalt black mountain. The detonation of primary colours evokes an idyllic 1950s cartoon aesthetic. The Matrix trilogy saw the complex layering of allegory, symbolism, erudition and narrative. Speed Racer is far simpler. Sure, we're rooting for the little guy fighting the big, evil corporate machine (Roger Allam at his slimy best), but it's all about how the film looks. The groundbreaking graphics, cheesy dialogue and hammy acting compliment each other perfectly and propel the story, which unfolds precisely as you would expect. There's a joyous innocence about this movie which is diametrically opposed to the knowing coolness of The Matrix and it makes you feel all warm and fuzzy inside. The critics who gave this film a kicking were merely angry that more films don't look as striking as this.
1. Alien 3 (1992)
Advertisement
Directed by David Fincher, his 1992 debut movie is essentially an arthouse study in existentialism which is officially the most hated movie in the Alien franchise, even by the director himself. Being a contrarian, it is one of my favourite films of all time. The shoot 'em up sensibilities of James Cameron's theatrical cut of Aliens, didn't work for me. It may as well have had Bruce Willis running around in a vest, or Arnold Schwarzenegger mangling corny one-liners in a heavy Austrian accent. The tone of Alien 3 is much more in keeping with Ridley Scott's original. It looks incredible. It sounds amazing (Elliot Goldenthal's atmospheric score melds seamlessly with the audioscape, it's difficult to tell where the score starts and the atmosphere finishes). It's adult. It's provocative. It's arty. It asks the audience to empathise with a bunch of rapists and murderers. It poses questions about sacrifice and redemption. Rarely for a summer blockbuster it credits you with a brain and allows you to appreciate the long, slow burn to the climax. Behind the scenes the production difficulties centred on the age old Art vs. Commerce debate. Back then Mr. Fincher was only known for the music videos he'd made for Madonna and Aerosmith and his sneaker ads for Nike, so whenever he insisted on his vision in an attempt at something gloriously ambitious he was summarily belittled by the studio: What are you listening to him for? Hes a shoe salesman! It's exhilarating that in a medium where the prime motivator is the selling of overpriced popcorn and fizzy drinks David Fincher attempted to create a beautiful, delicate china cup in a field full of beer mugs. His subsequent filmography vindicates his every decision on this movie. Like this article? Like any of these movies? Let us know in the comments section below.