10 Canned Sequels We Still Wish Would Be Made

By James Kirk /

Advertisement

There was a time in Hollywood where sequels to successful movies were the exception, not the rule. More often that not, if a picture was a success, like 1940's The Road to Singapore with Bob Hope and Bing Crosby, studios would reunite its cast for other stories or adventures that were not sequels in the true sense of the word. Bogie and Bacall. Martin and Lewis. Lemmon and Matthau. Abbot and Costello.

Sure there were film franchises like the Bowery Boys and Dagwood and Blondie, and later film series like the James Bond and Pink Panther films. But these took familiar characters and sent them on new adventures with each outing. The modern sequel continues the storyline of the original, and there are some fine examples like The Godfather Part II, The Road Warrior, The Empire Strikes Back and Aliens, all of which were worthy sequels and terrific films. Then there are those sequels that are but cheap, low-budget knockoffs of great films, often produced without the participation of the orginal cast or filmmakers. Does anyone remember The Sting II, Jaws 2 or Caddyshack II? Finally there are those sequels which were promised, teased or in development that never happened for one reason or another. Planned sequels are often canned because of lower-than-expected box office returns on the original. Or because key personnel become unavailable. Or because the planets are not in alignment. But whatever the reason, there are a number of mothballed movie sequels we would still love to see. Here are ten of them (and no, Catwoman 2 is not among them).

10. E.T.: Nocturnal Fears

Advertisement

While E.T. was still in theaters, one of its young costars, Drew Barrymore, became a media darling. Appearing on The Tonight Show with Johnny Carson, she revealed that director Steven Spielberg had spoken with her about a sequel to E.T. She coyly let slip that she wasn't supposed to talk about it with anyone.

E.T. was the biggest hit of 1982, and garnered nine Oscar nominations including Best Director and Best Picture. Rumors about a sequel continued to float around, and there was even talk about a possible script in the works by E.T. scribe Melissa Mathison. But despite all the chatter, a sequel was never made. Spielberg wisely chose not to compromise the magic of the original film with a sequel. Expectations from audiences would logically be very high, and a sequel would have to be a masterful piece of cinema to live up to those expectations. But what would an E.T. sequel have looked like? What has seeped its way into popular culture is a 10-page treatment called E.T.: Nocturnal Fears, written by Spielberg and Mathison and dated July, 1982. PDF's of this treatment are now floating around the Internet. While the treatment features the original cast, the tone is significantly darker. The aliens that land in the wooded clearing this time, in response to E.T.€™s "phone home" message, are bad aliens. The kids are kidnapped and Elliott is tortured. In the end, however, the beloved E.T. returns to Earth to save the day. A sequel to E.T., if made today, might not benefit from an appearance by the original cast. These kids are now in their 40s. Would audiences swallow a story with E.T. and a new cast of kids? Probably not. What about a reunion with Elliott, now grown and with children of his own? That holds some possibilities. Exploring the character of E.T. in a deeper way than the original was able to, revealing more about his people and culture, might prove interesting and nearly as magical as the original. Surely there is a story there. But would a sequel to E.T., particularly now, tarnish the magic of the original? We€™ll probably never know. At least, not in Spielberg€™s lifetime.

9. Flash Gordon II

Advertisement
When Flash Gordon was in pre-production, producer Dino De Laurentiis (King Kong) wanted Federico Fellini to direct. What he got was the director of Get Carter and The Terminal Man, Mike Hodges, and lead actor Sam J. Jones, whom De Laurentiis' mother-in-law spotted on an episode of The Dating Game. Released in 1980, Flash Gordon stayed true both to the original comic strip and to the popular Buster Crabbe movie serials of the 1930s. Ming the Merciless is given the planet Earth to destroy at his whim, but he doesn€™t count on Flash Gordon. Flash lands on the planet Mongo and meets a colorful cast of characters transported from the comic strips of old. The supporting cast, including Topol, Timothy Dalton and Max Von Sydow as Ming, are an asset to the film. And the soundtrack by the rock band Queen is today considered classic. The weak link in the movie was Jones, who played Flash Gordon. Two years before, Superman: The Movie benefited from casting an unknown actor as its titular character. The same cannot be said for Flash Gordon. Sam J. Jones as Flash €œsavior of the universe€ Gordon left a lot of people scratching their heads. Sure, he delivered a campy performance in a campy film. But as the film's lead character, he lacked a star€™s commanding screen presence. Jones' reported conflicts with De Laurentiis and Hodges resulted in his departure from the project during post-production, where nearly all of his dialogue was re-dubbed. Flash Gordon ends with Flash saving the day. Emperor Ming is gruesomely impaled by Flash€™s spaceship. But Ming€™s body vanishes and the filmmakers tease the audience with a possible sequel. The End? Despite a number of positive reviews, the film failed to meet expectations at the box office. Disappointing receipts, plus the unlikelihood of Jones returning for a second film, killed the possibility of a sequel. Yet since its release, Flash Gordon has developed a cult following. There€™s no doubt that a well-tooled follow up to Flash Gordon would have the support of movie geeks and sci-fi fans. The rich, colorful camp that defined the original probably wouldn't fly today, but production design is a minor issue. More than anything, it would be great to see what a truly gifted storyteller and filmmaker could do with this material. As Superman Returns loosely followed Superman and Superman II, a contemporary Flash Gordon sequel, with a new cast, could have the peaceful coexistence of Mongo and Earth disrupted by the return of Emperor Ming. In its haste to reboot any material with the potential to gross big money, I think it€™s inevitable that Hollywood will take up the material again. What it will look like is another question altogether.

8. Elf 2: Buddy Saves Christmas

Advertisement
James Caan, Bob Newhart, Ed Asner and Andy Richter, all backing up Will Ferrell in a whimsical holiday flick. How can it lose? In 2003€™s Elf, Ferrell plays Buddy, a Christmas elf who discovers he€™s adopted. At more than six feet tall, living and working among his tiny brethren might have tipped him off. So Buddy leaves the North Pole in order to discover his past in the real world, and the result is a funny, tender and very entertaining movie. Elf was a monster hit, quickly breaking the $100 million mark. Director Jon Favreau had just the right touch in balancing comedy and melodrama. Since its release, Elf has become one of those regularly viewed holiday films like Miracle on 34th Street and National Lampoon's Christmas Vacation. And in Hollywood a monster hit demands a sequel, and plans were soon underway. In 2006 Will Farrell reportedly turned down the role despite a salary rumored at $29 million, stating that he would be blamed if the sequel fell short of the original. And with sequels, particularly comedies, that€™s always a gamble. But what has historically worked with comedy sequels are a returning cast and a respect for the original material. Director Blake Edwards and the late Peter Sellers understood this, reuniting for five Pink Panther films over 25 years. An Elf sequel, were it to happen, would depend on Ferrell€™s involvement for its success. It would also be important for the supporting cast to return. Though something like Elf 2: Buddy Saves Christmas is, after so many years, somewhat doubtful, it is worth speculating as to what Buddy might be up to these days.

7. Unbreakable 2

In 1999 M. Night Shyamalan captivated audiences with The Sixth Sense, a spine-tingling paranormal thriller with a surprise ending that grossed nearly $300 million at the box office.

Advertisement
Shyamalan €™s The Sixth Sense was a remarkable film in a number of ways, and Shyamalan took his Sixth Sense star and his dark and paranormal brand of storytelling and prepped for another film. Shyamalan€™s much anticipated follow-up was Unbreakable, again starring Bruce Willis, a film about a man who survives a train wreck only to discover that he is, in fact, unbreakable. This makes him a super hero of sorts, but not in the traditional cape and tights way. A mysterious character named Elijah Price, played by Samuel L. Jackson, figures this out, and things get interesting. Bruce Willis was still on top of the box office at this time, and while Unbreakable was a success, there are a number of reasons why it didn€™t perform as well as The Sixth Sense. In Sense, the twist at the end was a Crying Game moment. Audiences left the theater shaking their heads in wonderment, having been so carefully manipulated by Shyamalan and his remarkable storytelling. With Unbreakable, expectations were so high that little Shyamalan could have done would match the power of The Sixth Sense. The film, while a disappointment to some, remains perhaps the best of Shyamalan€™s post-Sense flicks. And talk has persisted over the years about a sequel. As recently as December of last year, Jackson told the Huffington Post that an Unbreakable trilogy had originally been planned. €œI mean, he hasn't made a really good movie since ," Jackson said, when asked if a sequel would be made. And he gave no indication that a sequel was in development. Unbreakable is perhaps the one film on this list wherein a sequel after so many years might make perfect sense. It is also conceivable that revisiting this film could be a boost to the careers of both Shyamalan and Willis. There are myriad places that Shyamalan could take the characters of the unbreakable David Dunn and the mysterious Elijah Price, and Unbreakable 2 might yet become a reality.

6. Remo Williams: The Adventure Continues

Advertisement
In 1984, Dick Clark Productions introduced a cop (Fred Ward) whose death is faked so that he can work under cover for an organization called CURE as an assassin. There€™s really no more to be said, as the film was both a critical and commercial flop. The first mistake the filmmakers made was a title that assumed too much: Remo Williams: The Adventure Begins. It assumed the film would be a hit, it assumed the film would capture the imagination of audiences to such an extent that they would be clamoring for a sequel. No one clamored. The remaining mistakes include a lame script, a lackluster cast and surprisingly inept direction by Guy Hamilton, whose string of previous hits included four James Bond pictures. Why, then, would we want to see a sequel to one of the 80s most forgettable films? Perhaps to remind us that sequels are often not a good idea. Perhaps for the same reason we slow our automobiles in order to gawk at a car wreck. Perhaps because we here at WhatCulture are gluttons for abuse. Then again, perhaps not.

5. Buckaroo Banzai Against the World Crime League

The Adventures of Buckaroo Banzai Across the 8th Dimension is one of those 80s films that may not have attracted a large audience at the time, but those who saw it embraced it and it quickly became a cult classic.

Advertisement
The plot synopsis from the Internet Movie Database sums it up better than we could: €œAdventurer/surgeon/rock musician Buckaroo Banzai and his band of men, the Hong Kong Cavaliers, take on evil alien invaders from the 8th dimension.€ The movie stars Peter Weller, Christopher Lloyd, Ellen Barkin, Jeff Goldblum and John Lithgow. When it was released the film was something of an anomaly. It was original, offbeat, and not at all the type of adventure comedy Hollywood was churning out in those days, and in many ways it was ahead of its time. Not until the widespread acceptance of independent cinema did quirky, unusual movies that went against the grain of mainstream motion pictures find a widespread audience. The end credits of Buckaroo Banzai Across the 8th Dimension teased a sequel, Buckaroo Banzai Against the World Crime League, but nothing ever came of it. But given the original material's warped sensibilities, now might be the time to revisit the good doctor and his Hong Kong Cavaliers.

4. The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King

Advertisement
Long before Peter Jackson's epic trilogy made movie history, fans of The Lord of the Rings eagerly anticipated the 1978 big screen version by animator/director Ralph Bakshi. While hardly a perfect film, and certainly unworthy of comparison to the Peter Jackson trilogy, Bakshi€™s film was highly stylized, well produced and contained moments that inspired Jackson in his own interpretation. The buzz at the time had to do with Bakshi€™s rotoscoping technique; that is, filming actors and then having animators render the live-action footage frame-by-frame as animated cells. The idea was that the movements of animated characters would be more lifelike. The animation is, in places, quite exquisite, and audiences were initially enthusiastic. But The Lord of the Rings was open-ended, leaving out the storyline from The Return of the King. Its abrupt ending left many movie goers confused and disappointed, since the film was not titled or promoted as a €œpart one.€ The film was not a flop, earning more than $30 million at the box office. But it was obviously not enough for producers to foot the bill for the next one. Bakshi went on to do American Pop and Cool World, and what fans ultimately got was the tiring Rankin/Bass musical version of The Return of the King which aired on television. Until 2001 the animated Lord of the Rings was all fans had. It did well on videocassette and DVD. Yet it seems incomplete because it is, and it needs a concluding chapter. While highly improbable, it would be interesting to see The Return of the King in the style of the animated Lord of the Rings. Charles Dickens€™ A Christmas Carol has been made and remade over the years, live action and animated, so why not Rings? But for now, Bakshi's vision of Middle Earth remains an incomplete footnote in cinema history.

3. The Naked Gun 4 1/4

Advertisement
The minds behind Airplane and Top Secret took a short-lived television series called Police Squad and turned it into a successful film franchise beginning with The Naked Gun: From the Files of Police Squad. The films starred Leslie Nielsen as Detective Frank Drebin, an inept cop who bumbles his way to solving crimes. An American Jacques Clouseau, if you will. The rapid-fire gags that audiences responded to so well in Airplane were alive and well in The Naked Gun. Two sequels later, The Naked Gun franchise, while successful, seemed all but done. In 2010 Leslie Nielsen told the BBC that a fourth Naked Gun was in the works, but that he was not involved. The script treatment for the straight to DVD project was reportedly so funny that Paramount was looking to take it to the big screen instead. While the fourth film was subsequently scrapped, it goes without saying that a reunion film by Zucker, Abrahams and Zucker would be welcomed by audiences. Their brand of wacky one liners and slapstick storytelling still works if it's well done. But with Nielsen now dead, it€™s hard to imagine a Naked Gun without him. However, the brain trust behind the first three Naked Gun films are still active in the industry, so who knows?

2. Airplane III

Airplane, released in 1980, was a joke-a-minute sendup of disaster movies like Airport that were popular in the 1970s. The film featured an A-list cast known for more serious roles: Robert Stack, Peter Graves, Lloyd Bridges, Maureen McGovern, Ethel Merman and Leslie Nielson in his first comic role. Airplane grossed $83.5 million at the box office and a sequel was soon under way.

Advertisement
The three comic minds behind the original Airplane, David Zucker, Jim Abrahams and Jerry Zucker, were not a part of the 1982 sequel, aptly titled Airplane II: The Sequel. The second time out saw Ted Striker (Robert Hayes) piloting a space shuttle to the moon when disaster ensues. The all-star cast included Peter Graves, Lloyd Bridges, Raymond Burr and Chuck Connors. While Airplane 2 didn€™t quite live up to the expectations set for it by the success of Airplane, it still managed to have a more than its share of laughs. William Shatner provided some of the film€™s most memorable comedic moments. At the end of the film credits, audiences were treated with this teaser: €œFrom Paramount Pictures: Airplane III.€ But due to its poor reception by critics and audiences, Airplane III never happened. But it should. While we don€™t know where the plot would take a third installment, an Airplane III in the hands of Zucker, Abrahams and Zucker would be a welcome treat.

1. History of the World Part II

Advertisement

When History of the World Part I was released in 1981, Mel Brooks was in his prime. After a string of comedy hits in the 1970s €“ Blazing Saddles, Young Frankenstein, Silent Movie and High Anxiety €“ he turned his absurd comic style to world history. The result? Something of a Western Civ 101 class, Brooks style.

From the time of cave men through the Roman Empire, from the Spanish Inquisition to the French Revolution, History of the World Part I, not unlike the Monty Python films, was crammed full of sight gags, comic vignettes and hilarious musical numbers. At the film€™s conclusion audiences were shown coming attractions, a look at what History of the World Part II would have in store. The previews included the absurd Hitler on Ice and the Hasidic sci-fi adventure Jews in Space. We will admit here and now that the title History of the World Part I was part of the joke. But the film€™s success and the saterical, lampoonish comedy that Brooks was so famous for is ripe for a follow up. Perhaps segments featuring Columbus or set in Colonial America, or bits about the American Revolution or World War I would make for a funny film. And let's not forget Jews in Space. But Brooks, now 87, hasn€™t made a film since 1995€™s Dracula: Dead and Loving It. And it€™s doubtful we€™ll see Brooks behind the camera again. But wouldn't it be nice, just one more time?