10 Crazy X-Men Ideas Fox Had Before Marvel Got The Rights Back
Now the X-Men are coming to the MCU, these are the Fox movies you'll never get to see...
It's taking longer to happen than most comic book fans hoped, but following the Disney/Fox merger, the X-Men are set to make their debut in the Marvel Cinematic Universe. It goes without saying that Marvel Studios will reboot the characters, and that closes the door both on the previous versions returning, and the long list of movies 20th Century Fox had in the works before it took place.
With a lack of leadership and a seemingly constant failure to understand the source material, these ideas weren't exactly great, but there were some which had real potential (even if they wouldn't have lived up to what fans are used to seeing in the MCU).
The chances of Marvel Studios running with any of them are slim, though, and some will probably make you glad that the Disney/Fox merger happened. Honestly, there are some downright crazy ideas here, and while some were only ever in the very early stages of development, others very nearly happened before Disney made its acquisition of Fox final.
Now, the X-Men are going to get the big screen treatment they deserve (alongside the Fantastic Four), but it's definitely interesting to think about what might have been in Fox's "X-Men Universe."
10. Gambit
Gambit was first introduced in 2009's X-Men Origins: Wolverine played by relative newcomer Taylor Kitsch. While that movie was a disaster, there were rumblings that the character would get his own spinoff, but there was no mention of that until it was finally revealed during Comic-Con in 2015.
The key difference was that it was now Channing Tatum who X-Men producer Lauren Shuler Donner was eyeing for the role, and a 2016 release date was set. Multiple delays followed, and Fox went through a number of directors - Rupert Wyatt, Doug Liman, and Gore Verbinski - who all ended up departing the project over creative differences.
Plot details were never revealed, but several leaks indicated that it would have been an origin story dealing with both the Thieves and Assassins Guilds. Mister Sinister was going to be the villain after first being teased in X-Men: Apocalypse, and while it could have been a fun ride, it probably would have ended up underwhelming fans.
Plus, no one beyond Donner and Tatum ever actually seemed to want a Gambit movie...
9. Multiple Man
Announced in late 2017, Multiple Man immediately grabbed the attention of fans by attaching James Franco as both the title character and a producer. The prospect of seeing the actor play countless versions of this hero (who often have vastly different personalities) was exciting, and while no one was crying out for a solo adventure, it was a fun sounding project.
Multiple Man was used as a villain in X-Men: The Last Stand, but his screentime was minimal, so there's certainly a lot a movie like this could have done with the X-Factor Investigations leader.
Rumour has it that it was going to be R-Rated, and that makes sense given Franco's past work. It would have also likely been a comedy, though there were mixed reports about how close to the character's comic book adventures and origin it was going to stick. Instead, it sounds like Franco just felt it would be fun playing a number of versions of himself.
8. X-Force
In Deadpool 2, the Merc with the Mouth assembled a team of mutants to take on Cable, but none of them lasted particularly long. It was a comedic sequence, but not the version of the group fans hoped to see on screen. Well, that was supposed to come in the form on an actual X-Force movie from director Drew Goddard.
He was once attached to helm Sinister Six for Sony Pictures, so a comic book team-up is clearly something the filmmaker was keen on being involved with. It was never clear whether this was meant to come before or after a third Deadpool movie, but the lineup was set to include the likes of Cable, Domino, and potentially Negasonic Teenage Warhead and Colossus.
Wolverine sadly wouldn't have factored into proceedings after Hugh Jackman hung up his claws following Logan, but this is one project fans were actually anxious to see. The hope is that it could happen at Marvel Studios, but there's no guarantee.
7. X-23
Logan brought Wolverine's story to an end, and Hugh Jackman's tenure as the character also concluded there. That robbed fans of a team-up with Deadpool, of course, but it didn't close the door on another clawed mutant being part of the X-Men Universe.
James Mangold announced that he and Craig Kyle were developing a solo X-23 film shortly after Logan was released, but his commitments to other projects (and Dafne Keene signing up to star in HBO's His Dark Materials) killed the movie's momentum. However, there were also rumours that the character was set to play a role in the aforementioned X-Force spinoff.
Either way, it clearly wasn't meant to be, and the pieces never fell into the right places. It certainly would have been interesting seeing what came next for X-23, while having Wolverine's legacy continue in this way was a smart move on Fox's part, especially as replacing Jackman was always going to be hard. However, Marvel Studios is bound to give it a good try...
6. Kitty Pryde
Dubbed "Movie 143" when it was first announced, it was soon revealed that this feature was going to revolve around Kitty Pryde (played by Ellen Page in X-Men: The Last Stand and X-Men: Days of Future Past). It was widely assumed, but never confirmed, that a new actress was going to be cast in the role.
Deadpool director Tim Miller was attached to direct, while X-Men, Ultimate Spider-Man, and Superman writer Brian Michael Bendis was going to pen the screenplay. Plot details have never been revealed, but the creative time was a definite bonus for fans, even if they couldn't really figure out why this character was getting her own solo adventure in Fox's X-Men Universe.
Unfortunately, Miller committing to Terminator: Dark Fate postponed the start of production, and by the time he was ready to begin, the Disney/Fox merger had happened. That killed this project, and it's a shame non-disclosure agreements mean Kitty Pryde's first movie is likely to remain a mystery.
5. X-Men/Fantastic Four Crossover
Back in 2010, Fox started putting plans in place to adapt the Civil War comic books (beating Marvel Studios to the punch by six years) in a film pitting the X-Men against the Fantastic Four. Daredevil and Deadpool were also set to be included, but the project never got off the ground, and the studio instead decided to move forward with X-Men: First Class.
Despite it stalling, plans for some sort of crossover remained in place, with The Thing once set to appear in Deadpool 2. 2015's Fantastic Four flopping didn't help matters, of course, but it's believed that chatter about some sort of versus movie continued behind the scenes, and likely would have happened after Marvel's First Family were rebooted again.
Honestly, it's shocking that Fox failed to make this crossover happen in all the years they held the rights to the two teams, but there's no denying that had it eventually taken place, it had the potential to be a fun, weird movie...which probably would have been only okay in the studio's hands?
4. Deadpool 3
The first two Deadpool movies were a massive critical and commercial success for Fox, and helped breathe new life into their Marvel properties. Despite Ryan Reynolds' busy schedule, a third instalment was in the works before the merger, though it was never revealed whether it was going to lay the groundwork for X-Force or pick up with Wade Wilson following that team-up.
Now, Marvel Studios is obviously in control of the Merc with the Mouth, and it's believed that Deadpool 3 is in the works from them. Former Disney CEO Bob Iger has said it will be an R-Rated movie, while Reynolds has been spotted at the studio's HQ after no doubt meeting with Kevin Feige.
The problem is, mutants need to be rebooted, and that means Deadpool can't show up until they do. That massively delays this threequel, and whatever form it takes will be drastically different to what Fox had planned. After all, there's no way Reynolds is going to miss out on the opportunity to team Deadpool up with some familiar MCU faces!
3. The New Mutants Sequels
The New Mutants was originally delayed by Fox when they decided reshoots were needed to change the movie's tone and add some more characters. Due to the Disney/Fox merger, those never ended up taking place, and now the movie (which has been postponed several times since) is coming out this August in its original form.
Fans have questioned why it hasn't been put straight on Disney+, but an old Fox deal with HBO means that cable service has exclusive rights to the film on the small screen, hence why it's still coming to cinemas.
Regardless of what version of The New Mutants Fox planned to release, director Josh Boone has confirmed that he had an entire trilogy planned, and that a post-credits scene introducing a villainous take on Sunspot's father played by Antonio Banderas never ended up being shot. Had this merger not taken place, it seems fans would have been in store for a series of films revolving around this group.
It wasn't meant to be, though, and The New Mutants will now be a one and done standalone feature.
2. Alpha Flight
It remains to be seen how many Marvel projects fans will learn about over the coming years which never saw the light of day at Fox, but it was in February 2017 that Dark Phoenix director Simon Kinberg dropped a bombshell about a couple of movies in the works. Those were "X-Flight" and "Exiles."
The latter is a team of mutants who travel between different dimensions on a variety of missions, and it was surprising to even the most hardcore fans that they were being given their own solo outing.
As for "X-Flight," Kinberg was more than likely referring to Alpha Flight (hey, it's pretty clear he's never paid much attention to the comic books during his tenure at Fox), a Canadian team of mutants who work for Department H in the Great White North. Wolverine's origin story is tied closely to them, and while it's doubtful he was set to appear, this is a movie which could have really been a hit.
However, it seems this was another idea the studio just threw at the wall to see what would stick without ever really putting in enough effort to make it a reality.
1. Dark Phoenix Sequel
Dark Phoenix was supposed to be a two-parter, but Fox made director Simon Kinberg scale back his ambitious plans, and his story was crammed into a single, terrible movie. However, a big part of why it flopped is because promoting it was never a high priority for Disney, especially knowing Marvel Studios had plans to reboot the franchise.
Throw in the fact that fans didn't care about seeing these characters again when a new take is in the works, and the odds were always stacked against it. With that in mind, it's unlikely it was always destined to flop, and you'd best believe there would have been another X-Men movie after this one.
With Dark Phoenix, the action had moved into the 90s, but a sequel likely would have lined up with the timeline of the original trilogy. Beyond that, all that's really known is the cast would have returned (minus Jennifer Lawrence's Mystique). Dark Phoenix even ended by teasing further plans for Jean Grey following her fiery transformation, none of which will now ever be explored.