10 Critically Reviled Horror Movies (That Weren't Actually That Bad)

2. The Tall Man

Okay before we go on, it’s worth noting that Martyrs director Pascal Laugier does deserve a lot of the ire sent his way. Whilst Martyrs made an undeniable impression even in the cluttered cinematic landscape of New French Extremity with its unforgettable torture sequence, bleak ending, and intense imagery, its plot was paper thin and didn’t hold up to much scrutiny.

In contrast Laugier’s first English language film was widely derided by critics upon its 2012 release as un-scary and overlong, as well as being plagued by an incomprehensible plot.

But the critics in question overlooked the film’s twisted fairy tale atmosphere and its clever twist, a thoughtful turn for viewers paying attention which takes it out of strict horror territory and into more morally complicated places. The flick is tense and chilling, doubly so upon a re-watch once you understand the true motivations behind the character’s actions, and as implausible as the plot may be, a pair of fine central performances from Jessica Biel and Jodelle Ferland, along with some stunning British Columbia scenery, make this well worth a watch.