10 Deleted Scenes That Actually Improve Movie Characters
Deleted scenes that improve movie characters - Spider-Man 2, Harry Potter & more!
Too often our favourite or most reviled characters are left feeling unfinished.
Audiences come away from a movie wondering why a character suddenly fell out of the story, without any idea of the hidden delights intended to be in the finished film that were ultimately doomed to a dark existence on the special edition's second disc.
But fret no more!
That's right - we are here to pop open the old movie chest and fish out the finest character-building deleted scenes never to hit the screen. These are the unfortunate slip-ups of the biggest editors in the business, and defy the callous way in which they were discarded!
Some give villains their redemption, some bring back lost heroes' humanity, and others simply colour an extra panel in an already three-dimensional performance.
It's time for our characters and actors to have their due. Regardless of whether this means a split-second, game changing shot or a rich and well paced five-minute sequence, a dark, green-screened disaster that looks like it was filmed on your first flip phone, or a fully-fleshed out scene - all are accounted for, and none will leave you hanging.
Here are 10 deleted scenes that actually improve their characters.
10. Saruman's Demise - The Lord Of The Rings: The Return Of The King (2003)
Moviegoers of 2003 were baffled when they showed up to cinemas for their final hit of magic in Middle Earth with the concluding Lord Of The Rings entry: The Return Of The King. That's because, for reasons best known to the editors, Saruman - a primary antagonist of the trilogy - was missing from the theatrical release.
The extended (and definitive) edition of the film shone some light on why this was, as, in this deleted scene from the beginning of the film, Aragorn and co ride into a desolate Isengard and face off against the defeated Saruman, who is then shockingly slain by Grima Wormtongue's knife.
His death should have been included in the film no matter what, but somehow it was disposed of in the edit and we were left to believe that he was defeated elsewhere, off-screen - and we all know what happens when a character dies off-screen.
Most viewers see Saruman as a malevolent and deeply evil character, but this scene allows us to witness the tragedy in his tale. In defeat, Saruman is bedraggled, lost and alone, and, unwilling to concede and turn back from this path, the true depth of Sauron's grip upon his spirit is laid bare. In his death, we finally see the man amongst the corruption.
9. Miranda's Thanks - The Devil Wears Prada (2006)
As predictable as the plot is for a mid-2000s New York comedy, The Devil Wears Prada has earned its place as a mainstay of guilty pleasure viewing the world over. This is thanks to an always-reliable Anne Hathaway as Andy Sachs, and Meryl Streep as Miranda Priestley, in a performance so acidic it makes The Iron Lady look like Barney.
Priestley is the cruel editor-in-chief of Runway fashion magazine, Andy her subordinate, and the two women duke it out throughout the film as Andy attempts the time-honoured tactic of smothering her with excellence. Unsurprisingly, Miranda refuses to budge.
In this deleted scene at a black tie event in Paris, Miranda's husband drunkenly approaches a group of industry high-flyers and proceeds to insult the CEO of the company that publishes Runway. Miranda deals with him while Andy distracts the CEO, and the two share a moment in which Miranda mouths "thank you".
We know by the film's conclusion that Miranda didn't hate Andy, but it is never shown directly. Thus, this scene is a touching moment of validation amidst an otherwise fairly relentless onslaught of toxicity in an apparently HR-free workplace.
Some fans have rallied against this scene, saying that it betrays Miranda's character. However, affording this cold, sharp shell of a woman the opportunity to overtly display just a scintilla of tenderness, rather than keeping her distant and unloving to the end, seems more than justified.
8. J Jonah's Secret Suit - Spider-Man 2 (2004)
JK Simmons surprised us all in 2019's Spider-Man: Far From Home with his return to the Spider-Verse as DailyBugle.net host J Jonah Jameson.
But once upon a time he was part of the glue that held web-slinger filmmaking together, as the editor-in-chief of New York's biggest tabloid newspaper, The Daily Bugle, in Sam Raimi's Spider-Man trilogy. Believing him a ne'er do well of the highest order, Jameson wants nothing more than to see the end of Spider-Man, and is willing to publish anything to discredit him.
In a deleted scene from the much beloved Spider-Man 2 - one of the front-runners for best Spidey film ever to make it to the silver screen - we get to see precisely what Jameson does when Spidey's reign is over and he has his suit in hand: prance around his office wearing the thing, of course!
This scene is a rare insight into Jameson's complex relationship with Spider-Man's mythos, showing that his obsession is rooted in envy and perhaps even admiration. At the same time, it's a lot of fun, casting a camp and comic light on an otherwise butch and brash 'man's man'.
7. Regina George's Forgiveness - Mean Girls (2004)
One of the best - and most quotable - teen comedies ever committed to celluloid, Mark Waters and Tina Fey's Mean Girls defines high school politics in the pre-social media era, following Cady Heron (a pre-incarceration Lindsay Lohan) who transitions from home to public schooling at the tender age of 16.
This deleted scene takes place during the dance, after queen bee Regina George (Rachel McAdams) has been taken down a peg or two (primarily by a bus). Here, Regina provides some insight into why she did what she did (photocopying hateful pages from her Burn Book and spreading them around the school, leading to cat fights, chaos and criminal charges).
Although Regina retains her typical catty demeanour, and doesn't go all warm, gooey and weak at the knees, she and Cady manage to share a real moment, talking things over, laughing and communicating like human beings rather than the sneaky, backstabbing, underhand interactions typical to 'girl world'.
It's another humanising moment for a pretty unforgivable character and, while not strictly necessary, as all the girls find common ground with Cady's tiara-breaking actions at the dance, this scene shows Regina's change in more depth.
If that's not just so fetch, we don't know what is.
6. Donnie Is Off His Meds - Donnie Darko (2001)
Richard Kelly was restricted by the studio when making Donnie Darko, strong-armed into cutting the film under two hours and making it as accessible and digestible as possible, which makes the sheer density of the theatrical cut all the more puzzling.
Is it the end of the world or is Donnie himself hallucinating, dreaming, or in another dimension?
The director's cut threw another spanner in the works in a deleted scene with Donnie's therapist. Before he leaves her office (2:48 in the accompanying video), she tells him he can stop taking his medication, as they are placebos. She goes on to talk to him about atheism, agnosticism and God, but the important moment is that initial one.
We know that Donnie is deeply troubled from the outset, with the doctor herself identifying him as a paranoid schizophrenic, but as the film proceeds we are asked to believe in the increasingly strange occurrences around him - big bunny visions, temporal worms, etcetera. And the objectiveness of these occurrences is supported by the medication he is taking to negate any purely psychological (rather than metaphysical or supernatural) manifestations.
So, for such a small, seemingly insignificant scene, this one has huge implications for Donnie as a character and the film as a whole: the simple fact that Donnie has not been taking anything at all calls into question his very sanity, makes his character ever more complex, and casts doubt on the legitimacy of every single dark thing he has done.
5. Bail Organa And The Alliance, Star Wars: Episode III - Revenge Of The Sith (2005)
In the Star Wars prequel trilogy, Bail Organa (Jimmy Smits) is little more than moving wallpaper, and many casual viewers may not even know his name. Revenge Of The Sith shows him involved with the senate, Padme and Yoda throughout the film, but there is never an explicit connection made as to why he's there.
Surprisingly it is one of this film's slower deleted scenes that holds the key to understanding the character of Bail Organa and his importance to the events of the entire series.
Here we see him gathered with Padme Amidala and a handful of other members of the Galactic Senate, discussing the corruption of Chancellor Palpatine and potential downfall of the Republic. Padme interrupts Organa before he can say what kind of organisation he and Senator Mon Mothma are putting together, but avid viewers of the saga will know from the original trilogy that this is the beginning of the Rebel Alliance.
Not only does this establish the birth of the rebellion, as well as setting up Padme, Obi-Wan and Yoda's reason for trusting him (with Anakin Skywalker's newborn, on top of everything else!), but it clearly shows us where the seeds of his adopted daughter Leia's rebellion were planted.
4. The Origins Of Joker & Harley Quinn - Suicide Squad (2016)
It is well known by now that vast swathes of Jared Leto's Joker scenes never made it to the big screen, as 2016's Suicide Squad was hacked, whacked and chopped into pieces by David Ayer and the music video editors Warner Bros hired to make the final product look more like the trailer...
One of many rescued from the big editor's bin in the sky, this scene works double-time, giving us insight into both Harley (Margot Robbie) and the Joker with one quick character-driven scene.
Having been seduced into helping Joker escape Arkham Asylum, psychiatrist Harleen Quinzel tracks him down on a motorbike and insists he take her with him, leading to her first kill in his name.
The fact that Harley is still going back for more after she has been betrayed and abandoned by the Joker says a lot. It speaks to her dedication for this toxic man and just how profoundly he drove her crazy, as well as the lengths Joker is willing to go to get what he wants, treating all others as mere means to his ends.
Both characters are provided with the depth and depravity they deserve, and this would have set up Joker's later betrayal of Harley - as Ayer originally intended - before their abusive relationship was cut in such a way as to appear romantic.
Aw shucks.
3. Ripley's Dead Daughter - Aliens (1986)
A deleted scene from the 1986 theatrical version of James Cameron's all-out, guns-out sequel Aliens (which was included in the subsequent special edition release) reveals that Ellen Ripley (Sigourney Weaver) has a daughter, Amanda.
In a scene that was perhaps the genesis for a similar sequence in Christopher Nolan's Interstellar, Ripley is handed a photograph of her now-deceased daughter as an old woman. In a tragic twist, Ripley reveals she promised to be home before Amanda's eleventh birthday, prior to the events of Alien (1979).
Granted, this is not a paradigm-shifting revelation for Ripley as a character, as through the series we see her show grit, compassion, love and a ship's-load of vengeful anger, but it does supply an additional dimension.
For Aliens, it provides the drive for Ripley's seemingly impulsive actions throughout the rest of the film, as well as shining a light on an additional facet of her maternal relationship with Newt - the young girl who is the sole survivor of a Xenomorph-infested colony on the moon Acheron (LV-426).
As a little extra salt in the wound, this revelation of Ripley's daughter also makes Newt's death at the beginning of Alien 3 all the more tragic.
2. Malfoy's Redemption - Harry Potter And The Deathly Hallows: Part 2 (2011)
Harry Potter And The Deathly Hallows: Part 2 is full of twists, turns, deaths and redemptions, but one of the most important of all is the one we never got to see.
We all know Draco Malfoy (Tom Felton) was never truly evil, but this scene puts a definitive stamp on the matter. In Hogwarts' courtyard, as Voldemort (Ralph Fiennes) taunts the remaining fighters, a supposedly dead Harry makes a break from Hagrid's arms. In the confusion, Malfoy sprints ahead of Voldemort and tosses Harry his wand to defend himself.
There are unfortunately only rough clips of the moment, as the sequence was not even committed to the editing process (check out the background green screens and Voldemort's nose) - and so was never fully considered for inclusion in the film.
And it isn't hard to imagine why: the Dark Lord would likely have blasted Blondie Jr out of the way as he advanced, ending this purebloodline in its tracks.
Regardless, this would have proven Malfoy was not a self-serving coward to the end, when he finally stood up for what was right and helped Harry in a moment of dire need, rather than just skulking up the hillside with Mother and Father as the battle raged on.
1. Boromir's Humanity - The Lord Of The Rings: The Two Towers (2002)
The Lord of the Rings extended editions may now be the definitive versions of the trilogy, but it is easy to forget that these are not the films we saw in the cinema - and just how much was lost as a result.
Ending Fellowship as an ultimately redeemed but still somewhat monstrous man who attempted to steal the One Ring from Frodo, Boromir (Sean Bean) was somewhat doomed in the eyes of the viewer, destined to be remembered more for his misdeeds than who he was as a man.
In this extended edition deleted scene, we see a flashback to Boromir's glory days, at the retaking of Osgiliath, rousing Gondor's armies, leading men and taking names. It allows him shared screen time with his younger brother Faramir (David Wenham), an outcast and tragic figure, and shows their love for each other.
This is the scene that humanises Boromir, giving depth to him as a man, a brother and a son, as well as setting up the tension between the unloved Faramir and their father Denethor. Try as he might to raise emotional barriers between them, Denethor could never break the brothers' deep fraternal bonds.
As an extra arrow in the chest, these events take place just prior to Boromir's journey to Rivendell to guard the One Ring, and show Boromir's self-awareness: strong as he was, he knew his capacity to be corrupted by the ring's power.