10 Deleted Scenes Which Totally Change Classic Films

Batman is the bad guy?

By Tom Baker /

Warner Bros. Pictures

Films are a tricky business. They're less like an art form and more like a kind of clumsy alchemy, where a load of ingredients get thrown in a pot and it's never really obvious what the outcome will be. Everyone involved in the production of a movie does everything they can to ensure that the finished product will be as close to what they imagine as possible and, unlike a magician, they get to go over the end result before releasing it to the world. That means that in the long process of pre-to-post-production a film can totally change from its original script, as revisions and edits and the like can transform characters, scenes, or even entire plots and messages.

Advertisement

One of the most glaring pieces of evidence for the slapshot manner Hollywood movies are put together is the deleted scene. Previously the preserve of rumour and hearsay amongst hardcore fans, the advent of DVD and Blu-Ray special features means that your average Joe can get a peek into the filmmaking process, picking up scenes that were left on the cutting room floor and imagining how they would have fitted into the final film. In most cases deleted scenes were cut out because they didn't add much, or due to time, or they're simply alternate takes on sections that did end up in the final product.

In some cases, meanwhile, these excised portions of movie can radically change how you see the completed film. There are deleted scenes that genuinely would have totally transformed character motivations, important plot points and in some cases even the finales of some of the most famous big screen stories ever put out by Hollywood - here are ten deleted scenes which totally change classic films.

Advertisement

10. Superman II Doesn't End With Murder!

Warner Bros.

Zack Snyder's grimdark reboot of the Superman movie franchise, Man Of Steel, caught a fair bit of flack for the prototypical superhero and American icon killing so many people. Like, so many people. Well, we can't be sure that the climactic battle between Supes and evil Kryptonian General Zod across Metropolis definitely killed people, but they did level half the city. And then at the end he was forced to break Zod's neck before he laser beamed a nuclear family into oblivion. Why was it so contentious? Because Superman doesn't kill! Well, apart from all the times he has. Including the ending of Superman II, the classic Christopher Reeve film from the seventies which saw his big blue boy scout going toe-to-toe with Terence Stamp's version of Zod.

Advertisement

Whilst the neck-snapping of Man Of Steel was sadly befitting the more serious, gritty tone, the final slaughter in Superman II was totally out of nowhere. These are the movies sold with the tagline "You will believe a man can fly" - it's all whimsical and colourful and fun and comic book-y. Which means: no death. He flew backwards around the world to bring Lois Lane back to life in the first film, remember. Well, turns out that the reason Superman seemingly flung Zod and his depowered Kryptonian Kill Krew of a cliff - where they would surely die upon impact with the ground - was down to a scene lost in the infamously messy production.

Originally Superman II was to be helmed by Richard Donner, who directed the first movie and has also done basically every other amazing film you watch on a Sunday afternoon. Due to conflicts with the studio he was replaced midway through filming with Richard Lester, who did some Beatles films. This lead to the film being a bit of a tonal and narrative mess, and somehow lead to the deletion of a filmed scene where the police turn up at the Fortress Of Solitude to arrest Zod and pals, meaning they definitely didn't die! Hooray!

Advertisement

9. Why Do All The Terminators Look Like Arnie?

Sony

Remember there was a third Terminator film? And a fourth one? And a TV series? And - shudder - a fifth one? Well yeah we try and block all of that out as much as we can too (we recommend copious amounts of Ouzo) (our legal department is telling us we can't recommend that, and that we might be getting a little close to libel with our opinions on the Terminator series), but there have been a buttload of appearances by the iconic titular T-800 robot, played with impeccable icy calm by Arnold Schwarzenegger. It's probably the role the former Governor Of California - oh yeah, that happened, didn't it? - is best known for.

Advertisement

It also makes zero sense. Why would Skynet decide to send back robots disguised as Arnold Schwarzenegger to murder the various tricksy members of the Connor family? Arnie isn't exactly inconspicuous. He's a six foot tall body builder with a broad Austrian accent. And a penchant for leather. None of which adds up to "stealthy time travelling robot assassin" on paper, and yet we've just accepted it for four films and a TV series. You've not been hitting the Ouzo, right? Well, it turns out the whole thing could have been cleared up with a deleted scene from Terminator 3: Rise Of The Machines.

So there you go: the reason all the Terminators look like Arnie is because Cyber Research Systems, who later evolved into Skynet and basically secured a post-apocalyptic future for us all (jerks), modelled their new killer robots on a Chief Master Sergeant with a comical Southern accent. Then the voice came from a deceptively diminutive scientist with a cool, broad Austrian accent. So that's an explanation of the appearance, and possibly also a new person to blame for all the Terminator's shenanigans: William Cady, for being so admirably HUGE.

8. Mr Orange Knew Mr White Was A Cop Killer In Reservoir Dogs

Miramax Films

Quentin Tarantino is a meticulous screenwriter and director, who pours over multiple drafts of each of his films before release, and spends a buttload of time in the edit suite afterwards, making sure that his movies are absolutely perfect. Which we appreciate because, more often than not, they are pretty close to perfect! Except Death Proof. That's another of our big Ouzo targets. Anyway, QT is pretty brutal when it comes to excising unnecessary scenes and flab from his flicks - or at least he was pre-Kill Bill - which means that any missing parts of his movies are probably missing for a reason. Like this scene from Reservoir Dogs that would have changed its central, most tragic relationship.

Advertisement

Besides the violence, cool dialogue and banging soundtrack, the greatest triumph of Reservoir Dogs is that amongst all that style, there's a surprising amount of substance. Specifically the friendship between Tim Roth's Mr Orange and Harvey Keitel's Mr White. The film opens with the pair speeding away from their bungled diamond store robbery, Orange bleeding in the back seat and White taking on a paternal role, telling him he's going to be okay. From there all of White's actions are about trying to save Orange's life as he bleeds to death on the floor of their dusty safe house.

The tragedy of which is, of course, that Mr Orange is the undercover cop everybody is so sure ratted them out. White's concern for Orange's well being is real, but you know it would disappear as soon as he realised he was a pig. In fact, that's exactly what happens at the end! All of which would all have a different tone - and be slightly less believable - if Tarantino had left in this deleted scene. If Roth's character had known beforehand that Keitel's career criminal already had a few cop killings on his record, he might not have been so keen to cosy up to him - although it would also have ratcheted up the tension a fair bit...

7. Ripley Loses A Daughter In Aliens

20th Century Fox

James Cameron haunts this list like the spectral embodiment of the deleted scene. You only need to look at the titanic (snort) length of his movies and the amount of even-more-extended director's cuts he puts out to know that the dude leaves a lot of stuff on the cutting room floor. And, considering the sheer quantity of deleted scenes he's taken out of his blockbuster movies over the year, you just know some of them would have made significant changes to the finished films. Cameron's second directorial effort - after the first Terminator, no less - was Aliens, the action-packed sequel to Ridley Scott's moody sci-fi horror film Alien, and the reason we still remain somewhat excited about this movies even after Avatar.

Advertisement

From the outset Aliens manages to separate itself from the very different tone and directorial tone of the first film by literally separating itself from the first film by a good two hundred years. Having escaped the xenomorph nightmare that saw all of her employees slaughtered on the mining ship Nostromo Sigourney Weaver's Ellen Ripley entered hypersleep, remaining in suspended animation and floating across the universe in her escape pod until she got picked up by some nice folks at Weyland-Yutani.

She freaks out just a tad when she discovers she's missed a couple of decades whilst she was frozen, as we see in the final film, but it turns out she had an even bigger reason to be upset than just having hundreds of seasons of America's Next Top Model to catch up on - unbeknownst to the audience, Ripley actually had a kid back on Earth and, obviously, she's long dead by the time she gets woken up. As if the events of Alien weren't enough to make Ripley a tragic hero, you have to throw in a dead kid she never saw grow up, too. Which might not seem like such a radical change but it actually goes a long way to explaining why she's so protective over Newt, the orphaned girl she basically adopts when she and a bunch of marines get dropped onto an alien-infested planet.

6. Dudley Apologises To Harry In The Deathly Hallows

Warner Bros. Pictures

Let us tell you a magical story: a young boy is orphaned when he is a baby, his parents murdered in the line of duty whilst protecting the world from a fundamentalist terrorist. Thankfully he has an aunt and uncle that take him in rather than letting him be shuttled around child services his whole life, and they treat him like !*$% and keep him locked in the cellar. So not only is he an orphan but he's an orphan who is, essentially, a prisoner of his only living relatives. That's pretty bad. Don't worry, though, because this aunt and uncle have their own kid! Surely a child of the same age will be nice and sympathetic to his cousin? Nope. If anything, he's the worst bully of all.

Advertisement

That's the basic set up of the Harry Potter series, which we think is a magical and entertaining franchise of books and movies we think are suitable for children for some reason. It sounds more like a bleak kitchen sink drama to us to be honest, but that's mainly because we never go to the bit with the flying broomsticks and magic wands and Hagrid and stuff. Things get a different kind of bleak when we reach the final entry in the epic series, the two-part film adaptation of The Deathly Hallows, which sees Voldemort (that's the aforementioned fundamentalist terrorist, if you're unfamiliar) deciding to start up his war against, er, everyone once again.

Amongst all the loose ends the last in such an epic, ongoing and beloved series that need to be tied up - along with the actual plot - they actually ended up forgetting about the Dursleys and, specifically, Dudley, that little toe rag of a cousin that made Harry Potter's pre-Hogwarts life such a living hell. So whilst everything else works out nicely in the end - SPOILERS - Harry never actually gets any sort of closure from his crappy family. Except he did in this deleted scene when Dudley has a surprisingly touching interaction with his magical cousin, which makes things marginally less tragic for the Boy Who Lived.

5. Batman Is The Villain Of The Dark Knight Rises

Warner Bros.

Christopher Nolan's finale to his Dark Knight trilogy, which took the campy comic book Batman and shoved him right into the real world, drew more heavily on contemporary events than even the previous entries in the series - which had previously touched on modern issues like surveillance culture, drones and people in clown make up dressing as clowns and blowing up hospitals. Whilst Tom Hardy's Bane may have been about as believable as a real-life figure as his accent was comprehensible, his tactics when taking control of Gotham City had some precedents.

Advertisement

The comparison between his taking down of the banks and organising an uprising of the city's browbeaten working class with the Occupy movement were usually in the form of criticism, as many critics saw Nolan as drawing a direct comparison between a radical political movement and a supervillain as being mildly distasteful, but still - it's there. Then there are people who claim the director was simply drawing on some imagery and concepts we were seeing in the news at the time without providing any particular commentary on it which, considering The Dark Knight is pretty much a total metaphor for post-9/11 America, sounds like a load of bull to us.

Well, turns out, The Dark Knight Rises may have been just as radical as the protesters it seemed to be throwing under the bus by making unflattering comparisons with international supervillains. The film opens with Gotham flourishing under the Dent Act, which has supposedly made the city crime-free and Batman happy to enjoy his retirement. Except a deleted scene reveals that the new laws are totally repressive and see people thrown in jail without trial, with just one excised exchange between Commissioner Gordon and Batman Begins villain Jonathan Crane - aka The Scarecrow - tipping Nolan's hand and revealing that the whole thing has actually been a criticism of authoritarian regimes and not a celebration of them. Quite a big change, that.

Advertisement

4. Diane From Twin Peaks Is A Real Person

ABC

Before JJ Abrams was even born, David Lynch was the true proponent of the mystery box. Where the guiding light of Lost and Cloverfield has made a career out of films and TV shows built around slightly flimsy secrets that eventually get revealed - whether or not the explanation is satisfying doesn't really matter - whilst Lynch has made a even longer and more over-analysed career out of making films that have people trying to untangle them decades after the fact. Audiences are still trying to figure out what the heck went on in his debut Eraserhead, a nightmarish vision of life and parenthood in industrial Philadelphia, and that thing came out in 1977!

Advertisement

Perhaps the biggest mystery people have obsessed over in Lynch's career, though, is what's the deal with Twin Peaks? Early on in his career the, ahem, eccentric director teamed with Mark Frost to put together a crime drama-cum-soap opera-cum-supernatural horror that somehow became a ratings success on prime time ABC, despite the amount of metaphysical weirdness, ghosts and one-armed murderers that turned up. It's since become a cult classic, years after its cancellation, as fans pick apart the myriad mysteries that remained unexplained after its untimely demise.

Besides all the weirdness, one mystery has never been explained: who the heck is Diane? Kyle Maclachlan's charismatic FBI agent and Twin Peaks protagonist Dale Cooper is frequently seen recording messages on a portable tape player which he address to somebody called Diane. Is that the name of the tape player? His imaginary friend? His wife? Well, one of the biggest mysteries in Twin Peaks just got cleared up by a deleted scene on the recent Blu-Ray boxset. The brief exchange that originally appeared in the big-screen prequel to the show, Fire Walk With Me, saw Cooper leaning on a door frame in an FBI office and speaking to "Diane" in the room - we don't get to see or hear her but, presumably, she is a real person.

Advertisement

3. Boromir And Faramir Are Okay After All

Warner Bros. Pictures

It's hard to pinpoint where in his filmography the truism of "Sean Bean always dies" began but the first Lord Of The Rings film certainly seems like the moment we all noticed how susceptible the Yorkshire actor's characters were to the icy touch of the reaper. It also makes sense that he would perish in The Fellowship Of The Ring because he's the only member of Frodo's ring-ferrying entourage who seems to have less-than-noble intentions. Frequently Bean's character Boromir is openly critical about the plan to go and chuck the hobbit's magic ring into the fires of Mount Doom, and it soon becomes clear that he wishes to posses the enchanted jewellery himself.

Advertisement

At the end of the first of the JRR Tolkien adaptations sees Boromir redeeming himself for previously trying to snatch the ring from Frodo, as he dies during an orc attack whilst protecting other hobbits Merry and Pippin. If Peter Jackson had left in a little more of the character's background, however, the audience wouldn't have felt like Boromir needed redeeming in the first place. Thankfully, if James Cameron is the spectral embodiment of the deleted scene then Peter Jackson is the grand overlord, having released vastly extended versions of the Lord Of The Rings films that add in a bunch of excised scenes. Case in point:


That deleted scene, restored in the Extended Edition of The Two Towers, reveals that Boromir isn't just a power-hungry jerk. He's actually well-intentioned in his pursuit of the ring, if a little oblivious of the potential danger. It's up to a flashback via his brother Faramir that he just wanted to save his people from the obvious Bad Things prevalent in Middle Earth, which totally changes how you viewed the character in the first film. He wasn't a bad guy from the start, he was somebody trying to harness an evil power in order to do good. And maybe he got lead a little astray by the influence of the ring but, well, so did Frodo, and he's meant to be he hero!

2. Yoda Was Kind Of A Jerk

Lucasfilm

The original Star Wars trilogy has so many unresolved and overanalysed aspects that it's taken a prequel series, a galaxy of Expanded Universe Materials and now an upcoming bunch of movie sequels and spin-offs to properly explore every aspect of its fictional settings and characters. It's also pretty impressive that deleted scenes from the first three episodes in the epic series actually exist, considering the myriad controversial re-releases over the years which saw George Lucas cutting in new special effects, previously unreleased scenes and alternate takes from the original version audiences fell in love with at cinemas. And yet - and yet - there are a metric tonne of Star Wars scenes that disappeared in the editing room...until now.

Advertisement

So here's the mystery in question, first of all: how come Obi-Wan Kenobi just let Luke Skywalker believe that he was a simple farm boy, that his dad was dead, and didn't even bother to track him down when he probably knew that the kid would end up on the Galactic Empire's evil radar. Well, he did eventually show up to teach the cocky kid in the ways of the force and bequeathed him his own lightsaber but, for some reason, neglected to impart the rather important revelation that Darth Vader was actually Luke's father. Back in the day we could've believed that he might not have known, or forgot or something, but the prequel trilogy revealed they were pretty close during their years as master and padawan.

Kind of a douchey move to keep that from him, right? Well, yeah, but if you manage to unearth a particular deleted scene from Return Of The Jedi, it turns out that it was all Yoda's fault. The wrinkly green Jedi master had forbidden Obi-Wan for revealing the truth of Luke's parentage, so that he could be trained in the Jedi arts to kill Darth Vader without them having to worry about tricky feelings clouding his judgement. So with this deleted scene Yoda goes from elderly, kindly sensei to a manipulative, conniving machiavellian character who only cops to his true nature on his death bed. And no amount of hip-hop dancing can forgive that.

Advertisement

1. The Thing Definitely Has An Unhappy Ending

Universal Pictures

John Carpenter didn't play by the usual Hollywood rulebook, which might account for the decade or so he spent out of the directing chair, before his recent return with underwhelming slasher flick The Ward. Before everything went a bit !*$% up, however, Carpenter presided over some of the most entertaining and daring genre flicks to ever come out of tinsel town including - but by no means limited to - anti-establishment sci-fi action movie Escape From New York, a critique of eighties Reaganomics disguised as an alien invasion yarn in They Live, and he actually started the slasher genre in the first place with his early work Halloween.

Advertisement

Perhaps his masterpiece, though, was 1982's The Thing, a remake of the fifties B-movie The Thing From Another World. Well, it's a remake more in name than actual content, since instead of simply updating the plant-based hulking monster than menaces an Alaskan military base he completely changed it, hewing closer to John W Campbell Jr's novella source material. Instead the titular Thing became a shapeshifting alien that could take on the form of any organic matter, creating an incredibly tense horror film where a group of stranded soldiers and scientists, cut off from the outside world by sub-zero temperatures, are slowly infiltrated by a malevolent extraterrestrial who plays on their paranoia and turns them all against each other.

Besides some impressive and/or gross practical special effects (which still hold up today!) and genuine terror you feel whilst watching it, John Carpenter's The Thing is best remembered for its ambiguous ending. The main hook of the movie for the majority of its running time is that you're never sure who's a human and who's an alien impostor, the viewer feeling the same distrust as the characters do about their friends and colleagues. Eventually the group gets whittled down to just Kurt Russell's MacReady and Keith David's Childs, who have managed to capture the monster and blow it up - its only weakness is fire - and their base along with it.

The film ends with the pair of survivors slowly freezing to death in the cold of the Alaskan tundra, but happy that they've managed to contain an alien invasion that could have wiped out all of humanity, had it made it further than their group of doomed character actors. The ambiguity is in whether or not you believe they really are Childs and MacReady, or if they're "things" - an ambiguity totally ruined by a deleted scene from the finale which saw one of the monsters, disguised as a husky, running off into the world to cause havok. Which was apparently too bleak, even for Carpenter.

Advertisement

What other deleted scenes totally change classic films? Share any we missed down in the comments.