Although the likes of Michael Bay and Roland Emmerich aren't exactly critical darlings, they make movies that audiences generally can't get enough of, which has seen their combined filmographies take over $8bn at the box office. But on the other side of the coin, there are many directors who are consistently rewarded with expensive projects despite the vast majority of their big-budget output being nothing short of terrible. In recent years, a number of untested directors have been given the reins of blockbuster movies with decidedly mixed results: Joseph Kosinski, Rupert Sanders and Noam Murro have all successfully made their feature debuts armed with budgets of $100m and above, while Carl Rinsch fared much, much worse with 47 Ronin. The temptation is always to reward a young, upcoming director with a massive budget after an initial success: Gareth Edwards and Colin Trevorrow both made their first movies for a few hundred thousand dollars, before quickly moving on to $150m blockbusters Godzilla and Jurassic World respectively. With that in mind, this article will look at 10 directors who simply can't be trusted with giant budgets. It is a list that includes successful directors that failed to make the leap to more expensive fare, respected auteurs that saw an increase in funds result in sheer over-indulgence and several names that are somehow rewarded with a ton of money to make a string of blockbusters of ever-declining quality.
10. Shawn Levy
Let this sink in for a moment; Shawn Levy, director of Cheaper By The Dozen and The Pink Panther remake, is one of the most commercially successful filmmakers of this century, boasting a resume filled with bland studio fare has seen the combined earnings of his movies top $2bn, eclipsing that of both Martin Scorsese and Quentin Tarantino. Credit where credit is due, you have to admit. Breaking through to the mainstream with Big Fat Liar and Just Married, Levy then lamentably teamed up with Steve Martin for a pair of critically-reviled, yet commercially successful 'comedies'. Rewarded with a blockbuster budget, the director then delivered the two tedious Night At The Museum movies at a combined cost of $260m, with the franchise so far earning over a billion dollars and a third scheduled for release this December. The $110m Real Steel provided yet another saccharine dose of family entertainment that grossed just shy of $300m, while Levy also directed disappointing comedies Date Night and The Internship. There is nothing offensively bad about Shawn Levy's movies, but in an industry that seeks to merge art with entertainment the director disappointingly delivers consistent mediocrity that audiences lap up, with The Internship ending a run of seven consecutive movies that earned at least $100m. As a director there is no distinct style or flair to his efforts, just a series of by-the-numbers projects approved by studio committees, and in a medium as visual as cinema, isn't that just as bad as making a terrible movie?
9. Stephen Sommers
After making his feature debut in 1989 with the $800,000 Catch Me If You Can, Stephen Sommers moved on to write and direct well-received literary adaptations The Adventures of Huck Finn and The Jungle Book for Disney. His next movie, the $45m horror Deep Rising, began a long affinity for poorly-structured genre fare that relied too heavily on special effects. The movie earned just $11.3m at the domestic box office, but despite that disappointment Sommers' convincing pitch to Universal executives saw him given $80m to resurrect the studio's long-dormant Mummy franchise. Earning over $415m worldwide, The Mummy is a strange beast; an old-fashioned adventure that manages to be equal parts entertaining and empty. The movie's success guaranteed a sequel, and The Mummy Returns upped the budget to $98m and essentially delivered more of the same. Still, the movie out-grossed its predecessor, and Sommers decided to continue his relationship with Universal's classic stable of monsters and moved on to Van Helsing. A great idea poorly executed, the unlimited potential of the premise is swallowed up in a bloated $160m blockbuster. Intended as a franchise-starter, lukewarm reception and disappointing box office returns nixed the idea. Sommers' last big-budget release was the unintentionally hilarious GI Joe: Rise of Cobra. Basically a $175m live-action remake of Team America, the movie suffers from the same problems as most of the director's output; poor writing, a nonsensical plot and an over-abundance of visual effects. Barely squeaking past $300m worldwide, Sommers was replaced by John Chu for the sequel. Despite a career as a critically-derided purveyor of vapid studio fare, his movies have nonetheless grossed over $1.5bn at the box office. Ironically his latest movie, Dean Koontz adaptation Odd Thomas, is his cheapest effort in nearly 20 years but legal troubles have seen the movie shelved indefinitely in the States.
8. Joel Schumacher
Although his entries in the Batman franchise have seen his reputation tainted in the eyes of many cinema-goers, let's not forget that Joel Schumacher is capable of making great movies with the right material. Despite being the man that put nipples on the Batsuit, his filmography also includes The Lost Boys, Falling Down, A Time To Kill, Tigerland and Phone Booth. After Tim Burton opted against returning to the franchise, Schumacher made his studio blockbuster debut shouldered with the $100m budget and huge expectations that came with Batman Forever. Taking the series in a radically different direction, Schumacher's movie does feature some stunning production design but is also a dumbed-down, over-commercialized version of the universe Burton had established. The infamous Batman & Robin upped both the budget and the camp factor, and is one of the worst blockbusters ever made; scenery-chewing performances, gratuitous butt-shots and an aesthetic closer to the 1960s TV series effectively killed the franchise, and the $140m production became the series' lowest-earner at the box office. Since the vitriolic reaction to Batman & Robin, Schumacher has tended to stay away from big-budget fare, and with good reason. The lamentable Jerry Bruckheimer-produced Bad Company was a box office flop, with its $66m worldwide gross failing to even cover the budget while his $70m adaptation of The Phantom Of The Opera earned over $150m, but was all style and no substance. It's been a decade since Joel Schumacher even made a good movie so there's little chance of him being handed a hefty budget anytime soon, especially with his past transgressions against blockbuster cinema.
7. Lee Tamahori
After his theatrical debut, 1994's Once Were Warriors, was a huge success in his native country New Zealander Lee Tamahori quickly headed Stateside, with his first Hollywood picture being so-so noir thriller Mulholland Falls, before survival drama The Edge fared much better both critically and at the box office. Moving into more commercial territory, Tamahori was given the job on Along Came A Spider, the $60m sequel to Kiss The Girls that saw Morgan Freeman return as James Patterson's Alex Cross. Despite poor reviews, the movie earned over $100m worldwide and led to Tamahori being chosen for the momentous 20th entry in the iconic James Bond franchise. Armed with a budget of $145m, Die Another Day suffered from a distracting overuse of CGI and ludicrous action scenes that saw the franchise veer dangerously close to Roger Moore territory. Still, the enduring popularity of the Bond series saw it become the highest-earning outing for 007 yet with over $430m worldwide. Next up was xXx: State of the Union, a $110m sequel that substituted Vin Diesel for Ice Cube and tanked at the box office, earning just $71m. Tamahori's last big-budget offering was the turgid Next, a laughable sci-fi that just about clawed back the $70m budget and was easily overshadowed by Nicolas Cage's mullet. Going back to the drawing board, Tamahori's The Devil's Double was his cheapest movie in almost two decades at $19m. Despite being his best movie in years and boasting a brilliant lead performance from Dominic Cooper, it earned less than $5m worldwide. After some questionable decisions in his personal life, it is unlikely that Lee Tamahori will be entrusted with another big-budget movie. Which is probably for the best, because he isn't particularly adept at making them any good.
6. Rob Cohen
Beginning his career in the 1970s as a producer, Rob Cohen moved into directing via television before hitting the mainstream with his theatrical debut Dragon: The Bruce Lee Story. A critical and commercial hit, the movie opened at the top of the domestic box office and would go on to earn $63.5m worldwide against a $14m budget. Cohen would then assume the role of studio hand-for-hire, a role he continues to this day. Moving into studio film-making, Cohen's follow-up was the family adventure Dragonheart, a $57m fantasy that earned an Academy Award nomination for Best Visual Effects. Then came abysmal Sylvester Stallone disaster vehicle Daylight, which suffered from disappointing returns given the $90m budget. After unintentional hilarity with The Skulls, Cohen inadvertently started the most lucrative franchise in Universal's history when The Fast And The Furious earned over $200m worldwide; creatively, this would be the peak of the director's career. Cohen would then re-team with Vin Diesel for the $70m spy movie xXx, which was a commercial success despite being incredibly loud and just as stupid, and then came the ludicrous Stealth, a bloated $135m misfire that became one of the biggest box office bombs in history, earning just $76.9m. After that catastrophe, the director was somehow handed a $145m budget to take the reins of The Mummy franchise. Based on name value alone, Tomb Of The Dragon Emperor earned over $400m worldwide but the final product was nothing short of terrible, and failed to resurrect the already tired series. Cohen's most recent effort saw him working with a smaller budget for the first time in over a decade and Alex Cross, starring a woefully miscast Tyler Perry, was panned by critics and failed to even recoup the $35m production costs. The only logical explanation for Rob Cohen's continuing stream of big-budget movies must be his connections at Universal Pictures, who distributed most of his output. In his eight movies since The Bruce Lee Story, only his collaborations with Vin Diesel and involvement with the already-established Mummy franchise have yielded financial success. The rest of his career is filled with mediocre genre pictures that haven't exactly set the box office alight or warranted much critical praise.
5. Michael Cimino
In one fell swoop Michael Cimino managed to kill his credibility as a film-maker, derail his entire career, almost bankrupt a studio and deliver one of the biggest box office bombs of all time, and almost 35 years on, the debacle of Heaven's Gate remains a shining example of Hollywood excess at its worst. Breaking through with 1974's Thunderbolt And Lightfoot, a prototypical buddy movie starring Clint Eastwood and Jeff Bridges that earned $25m against a $4m budget, Cimino really hit the big time with The Deer Hunter. A critical and commercial success, the movie won five Academy Awards including Best Picture and Best Director, and is rightly regarded as one of the greatest movies ever made. With his clout at an all-time high, Cimino resurrected a project he had been developing since 1971. An iron-clad contract gave the director complete autonomy on the project, which turned out to be a disastrous move. Originally given a budget of $11m, Heaven's Gate ended up costing over four times as much, which is over $125m when adjusted for inflation. The tales of excess during the production have become Hollywood legend, and when the movie was finally released in November 1980 it tanked horribly and earned less than $4m at the domestic box office. The fallout saw United Artists sold to MGM, and ultimately led studios away from original director-driven fare to the easily marketable blockbusters that would begin to dominate theaters. With his reputation damaged beyond repair, it was five years before Cimino released another movie. Between 1985 and 1990, the director's three theatrical releases were all commercial failures and his final effort, 1996s Sunchaser, ended its brief run with less than $30,000 in box office takings. The ridiculously over-indulgent production of Heaven's Gate began the sad decline of a talented director that had let his ego get the better of him.
4. Jan De Bont
After over 20 years as a cinematographer that had lensed studio hits including Die Hard, The Hunt For Red October, Basic Instinct and Lethal Weapon 3, Jan de Bont stepped behind the camera and made one hell of a directing debut. Made for just $30m, Speed would go on to earn over $350m at the box office and establish itself as one of the greatest action movies ever made. Sadly, from here there was nowhere to go but downhill for the Dutch film-maker, with his last three movies earning a combined 16 Razzie nominations. A hot property after the success of Speed, de Bont's next effort was the similarly high-concept $92m blockbuster Twister. As pure spectacle it is a serviceable piece of hollow, effects-laden entertainment that would go on to become the second biggest movie of 1996 with almost $500m in box office takings, seemingly turning de Bont into the go-to guy for studio tentpoles. And then came Speed 2, which earned less than $165m on a $110m budget, and earned its reputation as one of the worst sequels ever made; poorly written, badly acted and thoroughly tedious. Deciding to switch genres, de Bont next directed the $80m remake of The Haunting and managed to waste a massively talented cast in a laughably cliched 'horror' full of admittedly-impressive effects but thin characters and awful dialogue. Despite these two notorious misfires, de Bont was then hired to helm the $95m video game sequel Tomb Raider: The Cradle Of Life. Poor reviews would see the movie gross almost $120m less than its predecessor, and 11 years on de Bont is yet to release another feature. For a man that saw the total cost of his post-Speed output reach $377m in studio funds, the end results weren't great.
3. M. Night Shyamalan
It's hard to think of a high-profile filmmaker that has suffered a fall from grace quite like M. Night Shyamalan in recent times. A mere fifteen years after The Sixth Sense was nominated for Best Picture, Best Director and Best Original Screenplay and saw the writer/director lauded as the most promising talent of his generation, his last four movies were widely panned and have been racking up nominations at the Razzies instead: a return to smaller-scale film-making is well overdue. Made for $40m, The Sixth Sense would go on to earn $672.8m at the box office and infiltrate popular culture in the process. His next two movies, Unbreakable and Signs, would each cost around $75m and bring in a combined total of over $650m, along with positive critical responses. From here, things would go downhill as Shyamalan's penchant for over-indulgence would often get the better of him. The Village did solid business despite middling reviews, but the pretentious Lady In The Water would earn only $72.7m worldwide before the unintentionally hilarious killer plants of The Happening would see his stock plummet even further. The $150m Last Airbender is undoubtedly one of the worst blockbusters in recent memory, which nonetheless did decent business at the box office before Shyamalan swept up at the Razzies. After Earth was almost as expensive and just as dull, a relentlessly po-faced sci-fi that placed charisma-free Jaden Smith at the forefront in a show of Hollywood nepotism at its worst. Shyamalan is a talented director, but as a writer he just can't reign in his self-indulgence. Hopefully his currently shooting micro-budget effort Sundowning will refresh his creativity because the man has proven he is not to be trusted with a blockbuster budget.
2. Renny Harlin
The man born Lauri Harjola has spent the better part of four decades working as a studio director for hire, bouncing across multiple genres. After making his debut with the curious-sounding Finnish action movie Born American starring Mike 'Son Of Chuck' Norris, Renny Harlin made the jump to Hollywood where his career has been interesting to say the least. Harlin got his crack at blockbuster film-making with $70m sequel Die Hard 2, which based on the goodwill to its iconic predecessor grossed over $240m at the box office. His next effort, $65m Sylvester Stallone vehicle Cliffhanger, was another commercial success that seemingly positioned Harlin as a safe pair of hands when it came to making studio blockbusters. Unfortunately, his next movie was Cutthroat Island. One of the biggest flops in history, the movie earned just over $10m worldwide against a $98m budget and served as the final nail in the coffin for struggling Carolco Pictures. Harlin would never again reach the heights that his career had enjoyed in the early 1990s following the Cutthroat Island debacle. In fact, the $165m gross of Deep Blue Sea remains the last hit of his career, and that was 15 years ago. The underrated Long Kiss Goodnight was a commercial disappointment, while the $72m racing drama Driven, $80m horror prequel Exorcist: The Beginning and this year's $70m historical actioner The Legend Of Hercules all failed to even recoup their hefty budgets at the box office. The Legend of Hercules was the director's first theatrical release since 2009's 12 Rounds, a $22m movie that still failed to earn back its low production costs, and his first big-budget effort in ten years. Based on his track record over the last two decades, its unlikely that Renny Harlin will be trusted with another expensive movie anytime soon.
1. McG
As well as having quite possibly the most pretentious moniker in the entire industry, the former producer and music video director turned big-budget film-maker is also responsible for some of the most vapid, lifeless studio fare to hit multiplexes in recent years. Ironically considering the title of this article, his most recent directorial effort, Taken-lite 3 Days To Kill, is both his cheapest and least commercially successful endeavour. Awarded a $93m budget for his directorial debut, McG bestowed the world with Charlie's Angels. Although the cast seem to be enjoying themselves, no plot, no drama, no tension and poorly-written characters are the order of the day in this slice of slickly directed high-camp that made almost $265m at the box office. The $120m sequel made almost as much money, but was a great deal worse, an exercise in style over substance that landed seven Razzie nominations in the process. Trying his hand at drama with We Are Marshall, inspired by a true story and featuring a talented ensemble cast, the movie failed to even recoup its $65m budget at the box office. So naturally someone decided he was the right man for directing the $200m Terminator Salvation. A couple of good set-pieces and impressive effects fail to cover up the fact that this was the worst entry in the franchise by far, and one that saw disappointing box office returns of $371.4m. McG's next effort was This Means War, an awful $65m spy caper that wasted the talents of Tom Hardy, Chris Pine and Reese Witherspoon but alarmingly did solid box office business. After 14 years, six features and over $570m in production costs, the troubling fact remains that McG is still yet to make a good movie. Do you agree that these directors should be kept away from big-budget movies? Are any of these names being treated harshly by their inclusion? Are there any other directors that you would have chosen? As always, mouth off in the comments below.