Discerning whether a film is worth watching has never been so easy. Whereas before you might have to wait for a narrow selection of reviews strewn across a publication's pages on a given date, you can now peruse the internet superhighway at your leisure for critics' views on tap. Yet despite a larger sea of voices, consensus tends to come easily. Whether through the film's actual quality or the easy suggestibility of reviewers, rubber-stamping whether a film is 'good' or not is a pretty clear-cut exercise. Of course certain sources can always be contrarian, but usually truth will out. The Dark Knight is awesome, Batman And Robin is terrible, and so forth. But certain films continue to defy explanation and criticism, and not in an ironic way. Not every effort can aspire to The Room's unintended brilliance most filmmakers just aim for a target and hope they've hit it. And with the lack of an actual critical dartboard (although that would be fun), deciding whether or not a film truly hit the mark is up for debate. 2013 was no different, and was rife with these troublesome entries. Loved and loathed in equal measure, it's hard to get a handle on exactly what side of the critical divide these films fall on. So with 2013 safely floated into the annals of history and the dawning of the new year, I'm going to see if I can mark out ten of last year's most divisive films. You can come down on either side about these films, so you can rest assured that I'll walk away with splinters, such is the fence-sitting I'm going to be doing.
10. Star Trek Into Darkness
Whether or not you truly like the rebooted Star Trek universe seems to hinge on whether you like JJ Abrams' own distinct visual and storytelling flair. Much like a tune is undoubtedly affected by the instrument, so too is a film by its director. They bring their quirks to the party, and it's fair to say that not since Tarantino's foot fetish has a director's techniques been pilloried so incessantly. Not everyone's enamored with the Mystery Box and lens flare approach, especially when it's being applied to one of the most beloved franchises of all time. And though Trekkies will always turn out in force to watch the new Star Trek movie, they damn sure don't have to enjoy it. And there was plenty to gripe about, Abrams staples aside. Furthering the process of throwing off the philosophising mores synonymous with the franchise for further lasers-in-space was anathema to some, as was liberally cribbing Wrath Of Khan until it cried uncle. Couple that with the having-your-cake-and-eating-it revelation that tribble blood effectively cures death, and you've got a recipe for outrage and a flaming bag of excrement on Damon Lindelof's doorstep. So for some, it just might be the case of right ship, wrong captain. But still, reviewers found something doggedly likable about Abrams' (very) shiny new version of the franchise. The operatic grandeur of it all is still nailed down pat, the cast remain uniformly excellent and the action sequences remain eminently watchable. If you were prepared to stymie the intellectual aspects of Star Trek for what was essentially a western in space, you'd have a whale of a time. But for a sizeable number of series fans that's not enough, and understandably so. Better that they made a franchise of their own than walk around in the clothes of another. Star Trek is too beloved to be treated flippantly Abrams took it just a step too far, and no amount of space-diving Benedict Cumberbatches could make that better.
9. Spring Breakers
Harmony Korine is pretty much the definition of a divisive filmmaker. Capitalising on the success of Kids, he broke onto the directing scene with the similarly controversial Gummo and his body of work has continued to provoke shock, thought and disgust in equal measure. To some, he baits controversy, and to others, he has important things to say, and does it in a distinctive style. This run continued with Spring Breakers, which played like an all-too-real horror film crossed with Girls Gone Wild. It was hedonism pushed to staggering lengths, from the former Disney Princesses bedecked in bikinis to the drugs, sex and violence punctuating its runtime. To some, this cocktail was intoxicating. Described by The Huffington Post as Scarface meets Britney Spears, the combination was unique and thrilling, helped no end by James Franco's tragic-comic turn as the rapper Alien. Yet to others, it was repellent. Like Gummo before it, it could be argued that Korine's take on Generation Y culture was a pandering, misogynistic piece of trash, crammed with voyeuristic shots of lithe, bikini-clad beauties. It was hard to question them subtext by its very nature isn't obvious, and it's entirely possible the film could be perceived not as a self-aware part of the solution, but an oblivious part of the problem. After all, when there's this much sex and violence on show, it's hard not to occasionally cock an eyebrow.
8. Anchorman 2
The inherent problem with sequels is that you're trying to re-bottle the predecessor's lightning without it seeming stale or rehashed. It's a precarious tightrope to tread, and it's even worse with comedies. Jokes just aren't as funny second time around, meaning re-visiting old material is fraught with peril. With Anchorman 2, this cut both ways fans were eager to see what the news team would do next, but also wanted the old magic back. Again, it's a hard task, and to some reviewers the sequel was a pale imitation of its predecessor new jokes didn't land as well as their forebears, and McKay and Ferrell seemed content to wheel out the classics when the script was looking thin. Plus there was that whole interlude with the shark, which was either freaking hilarious or downright baffling depending on how you sliced it. Yet we didn't want them to re-invent the wheel. It was just meant to be silly, brash and topple into the surreal at a moment's notice. Plus, the fact we even got to see Ron Burgundy back on screen was a treat in itself, diminishing returns be damned. Throw in some oddly well-placed on-the-nose social satire and you had a decent film which satisfied sequel-hunters, even as it occasionally divided critics.
7. White House Down
To describe White House Down as brash and stupid is to complain about the Earth for being round. It's a Roland Emmerich film if you came for nuance, you come to the wrong place. But still, White House Down copped some flak. Critics thought it was dumb, clichéd and generic, featuring a would-be novel premise already ground into the dust by the earlier, more po-faced Olympus Has Fallen. They probably had a point if you did come in expecting filet mignon, you might've been soured at the rump roast on offer. But to others, this was the point. They were more than happy to pick up their knives and have at this brutally ridiculous romp, accepting it for what it is, and more importantly for what it isn't. Emmerich's film was never going to win any awards, and whether or not you enjoyed it depended on just how much you were willing to suppress that critical eye. It's something of an acid test if you can accept the Presidency being passed around like a hot potato while the first incumbent wields a rocket-launcher on the White House lawn, Emmerich's for you. If not, you were going to hate this, and hate it utterly.
6. The Great Gatsby
It's a universal truth that Leonardo DiCaprio was nothing short of exceptional in the latest attempt to put F. Scott Fitzgerald's work onscreen. His was a bravura turn, rife with complexities and filled with grandstanding moments that usually result in award nods. Yet it won't, for a very specific reason Baz Luhrmann. The Australian's work is often polarising, with descriptions of his aesthetic running the gamut from the more charitable 'busy,' the mild 'messy' and the not-on-the-fence-at-all 'eye-meltingly horrific'. But his uniquely lavish brand of film-making was arguably perfect for The Great Gatsby's pure extravagance. Yet for some Luhrmann didn't have an off switch. Instead, he'd created something strangely polarising. His Great Gatsby can be described as pretty, yet weirdly empty, a cinematic oxymoron utterly at odds with its own source material. Where Fitzgerald provided a cautionary tale against overindulgence, Luhrmann's film made us fall in love with the bitchin' parties and the admittedly impressive, overripe cinematography. If there was satire, Luhrmann was speeding past it with little more than a wave in his rear-view mirror. Enjoying the film depended on whether you were overpowered by this aesthetic or whether you could accept it as part of a unified whole. Because there was thematic gold here, if only you could find it.
5. Pain & Gain
Can you glamorise the horrific? Pain & Gain thought so, and that was the stick you could beat it with. While the names had been changed, the real-life Sun Gym gang's crimes were indeed horrific. Understandably, some felt dressing them up in a tawdry, heightened-reality aesthetic and playing it for absurd laughs smacked of bad taste. And you know what? They're probably right. It is the height of bad taste to watch The Rock barbequing human hands, or to watch Mark Wahlberg torture a Tony Shaloub sporting panty liners as eyewear. It's perfectly understandable if you can't get past that as the film keeps telling you, this stuff happened, and it wasn't pretty. But if you approached it in a different way, it was possible to find a rare oxymoron at work an intelligent Michael Bay film. Yes, there were moments of lurid awfulness, but they were intentionally buttressed up against scenes of such mind-blowing, laughable stupidity. Apart, the film's dark excesses might've been unpalatable. Yet together, they made for a queasy, confusing experience you'd laugh, but you'd feel bad for laughing, for trivialising the horror. Bay was pointing out just how awful you were, and whether you enjoyed the film depended on if you could get on board with that. You had to externalise yourself from the acts occurring onscreen, and for some, it just couldn't be done. But for others, there was a sick, flagellating joy in doing so.
4. Don Jon
You could argue Don Jon was like a kid running in his father's shoes. It was Joseph Gordon-Levitt's first real crack at directing, and it showed. There were areas where he needed an editor, areas where he needed a re-write and further areas where he needed a steadier hand behind the camera. Regardless, it was an interesting debut which either left you cold or intrigued. I guess the best touchstone for Don Jon is Shame. Steve McQueen's altogether more harrowing desiccation of the male psyche insofar as Don, like Michael Fassbender's Brandon, suffers from a form of sex addiction, but McQueen has a steadier hand on the tiller than Gordon-Levitt, and the lighter tone to discuss a serious problem pornography's influence on the male mind seemed to jar incessantly. You could argue that it's a strangely more sanitised picture, especially when compared to its forebear. Yet still, not every film need be the best in its field. For those who get round what it wasn't, there was still plenty to take away from Don Jon. If you didn't expect something hard (stop it, you perverts) and serious, the light-hearted tone and convincing, strangely screwball performances made the whole thing seem weirdly likeable, in an odd way. Though Gordon-Levitt's Jon Martello was an odd, heightened-reality creation, he proved an excellent lead and you if you took the film on its own merits warts-and-all, you could certainly come away with new appreciation for JGL, if you didn't like him already.
3. Filth
Filth too shares the Gatsby conundrum, but also brings its own baggage to the party. That baggage was Trainspotting. Anything bearing the name of Irvine Welsh always struggles against such an imposing yardstick, and Filth was no exception. Trainspotting dominated popular culture by comparison, Filth came in with a whimper and went out with one, notable only for a totemic performance from James McAvoy. But still, much like Gatsby before it, McAvoy's turn as momentous sh*t Bruce Robertson definitely turned heads, easily taking pride of place as one of Welsh's most monstrous creations. And this is where the film shines by all rights Robertson should be a figure chronically incapable of audience pathos, but strangely, through McAvoy's performance, he is. Of course it helps the film doesn't have the novels worst excesses. But that's probably to be damned with faint praise, like saying applauding folk for not grunting at the porno theatre. It's still plenty nasty. But to others, this nastiness made it impenetrable. I know it's narrow-minded to bring up Trainspotting again, but what made Welsh's/Danny Boyle's opus stand out was that deep down and barring Begbie, everyone else had a core of decency. Not so, Filth. Eddie Marsan aside, almost everyone else is just as terrible as Robertson. But unlike Robertson, we don't have a window into their mind to see the depth. It occasionally became a lurid pantomime, drunk on its own, well, filth. I know its lashing the most lashed of dead horses to chide Welsh for this, but still this was Trainspotting without the heart, and whether you could get on board with that affected whether you could truly enjoy this film.
2. Man Of Steel
Man Of Steel was a divisive film. Now that's out the way, we'll continue. The problem was that when you're keeping so many different plates spinning, it's hard to not drop some crockery. Man Of Steel had to be so many things the starting gun for the DC Movie Universe, a grand return to form for an inconsistent film franchise, Warner Bros' new cash cow, and the stopgap before someone roused the Batman license from its much-deserved slumber. The anticipation was ludicrously, monstrously high, and when the stakes are so big, the criticism practically writes itself. It's a harsh rod to beat any film with, but when this juggernaut fell short of utter perfection, folk waited for it with brickbats. It didn't help that there was so much to pick apart, rightly or wrongly Kevin Costner's tornado-walk, the utter, avoidable destruction of Metropolis, the whole neck-snapping farrago, all lumbered with a grim, washed-out aesthetic that sucked the fun out of everything. Every writer's put Man Of Steel on the punchbag hook and gone ten rounds, and I include myself in that description. There was low-hanging fruit on offer, and damn it if we didn't all jump. Yet beyond all the easy targeting, the film retains its apologists, and they're not exactly thin on the ground. There's another way of looking at Man Of Steel, divorced from the hype machine, away from what it isn't. When you discard what you wanted it to be, Zack Snyder's effort still retained the original wonder of Superman, albeit in a more po-faced incarnation. Watching Henry Cavill take to skies with Hans Zimmer's score swelling all around him remains an awe-inspiring cinematic experience, augmented by terrific villainous turns from Michael Shannon and Antje Traue. And call me old-fashioned and narrow-minded, but I'm just happy Superman's back in any guise at all. He's too good a character to stay dead, and hopefully they can iron out the kinks in the Batman team-up. Well, a man can dream.
1. Only God Forgives
Nicolas Winding Refn's neon-soaked fairytale was possibly the most divisive film of 2013 stripped back and bare, boos rained down upon it. Refn's never been known for his accessibility, but many expected him to dilute his emotional coldness after Drive's monstrous success. Yet Refn didn't. Instead, he further swaddled himself in inaccessibility to the extent that the cerebral, uninviting Valhalla Rising looked like a bunting-laden reception by comparison. If his dedication to Alejandro Jodorowsky came at the start of Only God Forgives, we might've known what to expect. But we didn't. Instead, he shot emotional coldness writ large, giving you a film which kept you at a distance and featured few sympathetic characters. Between Ryan Gosling's ashen-faced, monosyllabic Julian, his oedipal nightmare of a mother and the impenetrable, one-track mind of the karaoke-singing Chang, there was no real 'in' for the audience. Bereft of meaning, many went away furious and appalled at the vengeance porn enacted onscreen. But still, it had its apologists. Led by The Guardian's Peter Bradshaw, a minority of critics felt it belonged in the same bracket as The Shining and Taxi Driver, a piece of formal brilliance damned in its own time. Yet much like most films on this list, it depends what mindset you brought to the screening. It demanded attention, and even then it could let you down. But to others, it was phenomenal, rife with harrowing symbolism and stellar, distinct performances. Of course, neither side knew what the other was going on about, but that's kind of the point, apparently.