10 Edgy Properties No Film Producer Dared To Touch

By Paul Woods /

8. The Room

When I read Hubert Selby Jr.€™s LAST EXIT TO BROOKLYN as a kid, it seemed like the ultimate unfilmable novel: vivid descriptions of a hooker named Tralala getting gang-raped and violated; straight guys having sex with transvestites; vicious tenement wives calling to a baby on a balcony to make him fall. That it made it to cinemas in a colourful late 1980s adaptation is a testament to changing times €“ as well as to how a book will highlight details that a movie can pass over. Selby, a moral and compassionate man compelled to wallow in the human undercurrents he€™d experienced, also came later to the screen via his REQUIEM FOR A DREAM: a searing account of addictions in a junkie and his mother, Darren Aronosky€™s 1998 film version indicting the American Dream and the chemicals that fuel it. (€˜They ought to show it in schools,€™ film writer Billy Chainsaw told Selby€™s editor, Ken Hollings. €˜Kids would never touch the stuff.€™) But it was in the decade between LAST EXIT and REQUIEM that Selby wrote his edgiest pieces. THE DEMON, which preceded REQUIEM in the mid-1970s, placed the reader in the head of a successful businessman obsessed with casual sex as a form of blasphemy, finally escalating to the point of murder. If it was brought to the screen it might play like a manic version of Steve McQueen€™s/Michael Fassbender€™s SHAME (2012), but with no casual opt-outs for the main character. But it was THE ROOM, which preceded it in 1971, which shocked even its own author. €˜I mean, it is really a disturbing book, Jesus Christ!€™ he later emphasised. €˜I didn€™t read it for 12 years after I wrote it...€™ The late rock poet Lou Reed, himself influenced by Selby€™s documentary realism, said THE ROOM put him in a place he didn€™t want to be with a character he couldn€™t get away from. It€™s not hard to see what he meant. The unnamed narrator is in a police cell for a crime he claims he didn€™t commit; he veers between moral self-righteousness, as he imagines himself a fighter against police corruption, and sick, sadistic fantasy when he fantasises about the torture and rape of a woman he knows. Both extremes exist in the same character€™s consciousness, making him all too recognisably human. If they ever filmed this one it€™d be so claustrophobically fetid that it€™d make LAST EXIT and REQUIEM, both controversial in their time, look like primetime family viewing. Tralala (Jennifer Jason Leigh) before her gang rape in Uli Edel€™s film of LAST EXIT TO BROOKLYN (1989).