10 Excellent Films That Don't Actually Have A Plot

You might say that these films have lost the plot.

By Richard John Dorricott /

Sometimes a film is praised solely on the basis of its plot. In fact, sometimes it can feel like plot is the only thing anyone ever wants to discuss about film. Despite their cinematography and execution, their reliance on practical effects and visuals, films like Inception and Fight Club are only discussed in relation to their intricate and often incomprehensible plots of dual-personalities and dreams within dreams. This infatuation with plot also means that sometimes an audience can be stumped by a film that purposefully chooses not to have one, a film that shows no interesting at all in constructing a larger narrative. These films may have something to say, but their focus remains on characters and conversations, small details that don€™t paint a larger picture. The 2007 sci-fi film The Man From Earth would be a good example as it€™s essentially just a series of long conversations between different characters. There€™s no corporate espionage or acts of death defying heroism: it€™s just about people talking in a room for an hour and a half, and though it may not sound like it, it€™s still pretty riveting stuff. And that's the thing: if you don't like your films bogged down by complex plot, there are still some brilliant films out there you can love...

10. Lost In Translation (2003)

Director: Sofia Coppola Essentially about two lonely individuals who meet in Tokyo and form an unconventional friendship, Lost In Translation is a great example of a touching film that has absolutely no semblance of a plot. Instead, it€™s about chance encounters and the overwhelming sense of isolation that a person can experience in an unfamiliar setting, especially one as vastly different (to American eyes) as Japan. The cinematography alone makes this one worth seeing, but what really sells the film as an experience is the relationship between the two principle characters, played by Bill Murray and Scarlett Johansson. Though each protagonist evolves dramatically, their character arcs aren't motivated by dramatic moments of revelation or startling realisation, but rather mutual understanding. They come to sympathise with and relate to one another, and though the film teases a possible romantic dimension to their relationship, it never quite happens. It€™s this level of maturity that marks Lost In Translation as a stand out film. It€™s not about two characters who fall in love and begin an affair, run away together and take ownership over their lives, it€™s about being alone and coming to terms with that. At least, that€™s my interpretation.

9. Inside Llewyn Davis (2013)

Director: Joel and Ethan Coen Following a fictional folk artist, Inside Llewyn Davis is a film about financial and personal struggle in the pursuit of artistry. Set over the course of a single week, the majority of the film sees Llewyn homeless and reliant on his friends and family for support, bouncing between sofas as he tries to get his life together. Though the protagonist (Oscar Isaacs) certainly has a clear goal (that being to make it as a musician) his journey is less about acquiring fame or recognition, and more about all the many personal and practical issues that get in his way. Over the course of the film, he€™s beaten up, almost arrested and discovers that he might actually be a farther, all in the space of seven days. Though that may sound pretty bleak, there€™s actually a fair amount of humour that keeps the film from becoming melancholic, sprinkling in little comedic moments to keep the atmosphere light. Inside Llewyn Davis is essentially about a musician who can€™t quite catch a break, travelling throughout the city of New York with his guitar and learning a few things about himself along the way. The lack of conventional plot is actually what makes this film so enjoyable. It€™s a character piece in its purest form, an exploration of one principle figure who forms the foundation for the rest of the movie.

8. Un Chien Andalou (1929)

Director: Luis Buñuel A silent film from the late-twenties, Un Chien Andalou doesn€™t have a plot, or a story for that matter, at least not in the conventional sense. Based on a series of dreams that the director Luis Buñuel and collaborator Salvador Dali have had themselves, the film is essentially a series of unconnected images that are tired loosely together by a bizarre dreamlike logic. One moment you€™ll be watching two characters embrace on a balcony observing the moon, and in the next moment you€™ll be witnessing a women€™s eye being cut in half, or a man€™s hand erupting into swarms of ants. The film almost challenges you to try and piece everything together, but it€™s no use. Both Buñuel and Dali have stated that Un Chien Andalou isn€™t supposed to make any sense. It€™s just a series of striking images woven together like a dream, one shot to the next with little in the way of plot to justify anything that€™s happening. Good luck figuring this one out.

7. The Big Lebowski (1998)

Director: Joel and Ethan Coen Set in the early-nineties, The Big Lebowski is about Jeffery €˜The Dude€™ Lebowski (Jeff Bridges) who after being mistaken for a man with the same name becomes involved in the hostage ransoming of Big Lebowski€™s daughter, Bunny. Though that definitely sounds like a plot to the conventional eye, the events of the film are so randomly tied together that it feels more like a parody of storytelling than a genuine attempt at plot. As Joel and Ethan Coen have said themselves in the past, while The Big Lebowski does have a plot, it€™s a €œhopelessly complex plot that€™s ultimately unimportant€. It€™s there because it€™s expected to be there for this kind of film, but it€™s more of a formality than anything. The plot keeps the action moving and the characters motivated, nothing more. In fact, some of the events in the film are so arbitrarily connected that they may as well be completely random. At one point, The Dude is thrown out of a speeding cab after an argument with the driver. Coming to a stop on the sidewalk, he looks up and sees Bunny driving past in a red sports car, having evidently faked her own kidnapping. While technically these two events are linked, the sheer improbability of the encounter renders the plot completely irrelevant.

6. Clerks (1994)

A black and white comedy shot for just over $27,000, Clerks is about Dante Hicks (Brian O€™Halloran) who is called into work on his day off to cover another employee€™s shift. Set almost entirely in the same location, the film is essentially just a series of conversations broken up only by the very occasional scene transition. Though the characters and their relationships changes over the course of the film, eventually climaxing at the very end with an emotional confrontation, there is very little plot to speak of. After a series of screw-ups (like knocking a coffin over at a funeral), Dante is confronted by Randal over his lack of direction and ambition, the two characters fight and make promises to change the way they live their lives. While that kind of revelation is typically associated with the culmination of a plot, none of the events leading to this moment are connected in any meaningful way. All of Dante€™s terrible decisions are made because of Randal€™s influence, and Randal influences him to make bad decisions because Randal€™s a screw-up. It€™s a destructive circle that forms the basis of their relationship, one that the entire story is centred on. If the two characters stopped making poor choices then there would be no movie because the movie is about their poor choices, and that certainly isn't grounds for a plot.

5. The Breakfast Club (1985)

Director: John Hughes After being put in detention, five students from different cliques form an unlikely friendship after learning just how much they have in common. All of them are dealing with troubled home lives and all of them feel an enormous amount of pressure to act in a certain way. In detention, they€™re given the ironic task of writing an essay on the subject of €œwho do you think you are?€ which is essentially what the entire film is about, characters learning to know and accept themselves. Like Clerks, The Breakfast Club is set predominantly in a single location, namely the high school library. As the film progresses, the characters learn about each other€™s lives, sympathise with the difficulties that the others are dealing with and form close friendships, in some cases even romantic relationships. Seeing as how the film is predominantly about the characters themselves and their development, there€™s nothing really linking any of the scenes together, besides the general premise that they€™re all stuck together in detention. Besides their outlooks, nothing has really changed by the time we get to the end of the film. They€™re still the same characters with the same problems, only now they understand a little bit more about each other.

4. Napoleon Dynamite (2004)

Director: Jared Hess Though it has quite possibly one of the greatest soundtracks of all time, Napoleon Dynamite most definitely does not have a plot. The titular protagonist (Jon Heder) spends most of the film unsuccessfully campaigning for his friend Pedro (Efren Ramirez) for class president, only to finally win over his fellow students with a dance routine to the song "Canned Heat" by Jamiroquai. Unconventional, hilarious and often beautiful, Napoleon Dynamite is one of the best examples of just how exceptional a plotless film can be. It€™s an eccentric film of love and loyalty set in some kind of alternate dimension where people say and do peculiar things, act irrationally and love disco music from the 80s. The film definitely makes narrative sense, it€™s just so abnormal that it often feels like you€™re watching something written by an alien with only a vague comprehension of how human beings function. The film€™s set in the early 2000s yet everything from the music to the clothing is anachronistic, better suited the 1980s and 90s than more contemporary times. The weirdness of Napoleon Dynamite is part of the reason it€™s so beloved, and part of that charm comes from the film€™s lack of plot. The characters act strangely and eventually everything sort of comes together despite itself.

3. Her (2013)

Director: Spike Jonze Essentially a romance film between a man and his OS, Her is a great example of a film that might have actually suffered from the inclusion of a plot. After all, the story is about a man who is in love with his operating system, so there were already plenty of ways it could have been handled poorly. Imagine if someone had had the bright idea of turning Samantha (Scarlett Johansson) evil, Hal from 2001 style. Let€™s say her program malfunctioned, effecting her attitude, turning her into a paranoid, homicidal maniac needing to be shut down. It would have been awful. Instead, Spike Jonze demonstrates complete dedication to storytelling over plot, writing and directing the movie around universally relatable concepts such as love and heartbreak. Set in a futuristic Los Angeles, the film stars Joaquin Phoenix as Theodore Twombly, a divorcee looking for a love in a technologic future in which everyone dresses in a hipster chic and loves playing video games. His relationship with Samantha is almost completely accepted in this society (with the exception of his ex-wife), and while there are difficulties to their being in love, there are also no reasons why they can€™t be. The film isn€™t about overcoming adversity (or shutting down an evil AI gone vogue), it€™s about the processes of relationships, falling in love and having your heart broken. The lack of plot keeps the focus on the characters and their developing understanding of one another, teasing some larger implication to OS intelligence, but emphasising the human aspect to the film at all times.

2. Slacker (1991)

Director: Richard Linklater The first feature film of Richard Linklater (who would later go on to direct Boyhood), Slacker is an uncommonly structured film, following a whole host a characters as they go about their regular days. The characters include two conspiracy theorists, a women trying to sell a Madonna pap smear, an anarchist who befriends a man trying to rob him, and a talkative taxi passenger (played by Linklater himself). What€™s so great about Slacker is its lack of plot, the way it shifts focus every now and then to someone new, as if the filmmaker had suddenly gotten bored of the previous character and decided to pick someone else out at random and tell their story instead. No one in the film is ever given too much priority, all of the characters are seen in glimpses that refuse to linger for even a second longer than they should. At times, the film is like watching episodes from the worlds least plot orientated television series. Each moment is so estranged from the last that you start to wonder whether or not they€™re even set in the same universe, or whether or not it matters.

1. Eraserhead (1977)

Director: David Lynch Eraserhead is a strange and beautiful film from director David Lynch that tells the story of Henry (John Nance) who marries Mary X (Charlotte Stewart) and has her move in with him after inadvertently impregnating her during a fling. Sounds straightforward enough, right? Well, their child is far from normal. In fact, it resembles a grotesque lizard and spends a good amount of the film wailing uncontrollably, which would seem bizarre were it not for the abnormal atmosphere and fantastical events that engulf the narrative. The aforementioned infant is featured heavily throughout the film, tormenting its father with unbearable noises and strange visions. In fact, as the film goes on, you begin to grow accustomed to the sight of the child. You might even accept it as something rather ordinary, or even mundane. That€™s the beauty of Eraserhead; there€™s a twisted logic that pervades the film, a logic that you slowly come round to accept and partially understand. It€™s that acceptance of the extraordinary that€™s the most frightening aspect of the film. At some point while watching, that incongruous baby and those strange images will be accepted by a part of your brain €“ a small part, a part that barely has any influence over you, but you€™ll start to think that everything that€™s happening is perfectly reasonable, perfectly possible. Like Un Chien Andalou, Eraserhead almost dares you to make sense of what€™s happening. You€™ll inevitably try and piece all the parts together, to understand the reasoning behind what your seeing, but it€™s futile. There is no plot linking everything together, and the only logic is what you make for yourself. Which other plotless but brilliant films belong on this list? Share your own favourites below in the comments thread.