10 Film Documentaries That Accidentally Uncovered Major Scoops
Government corruption, murder, sex scandals - some documentaries uncover more than they intended.
The documentary film genre is an extremely flexible one. It can be tackled with million-dollar budgets, zero-dollar budgets, and in countless different styles - at the end of the day, all that's required is a camera, and a story.
Some filmmakers rely heavily on reconstructions and dramatisations, while others take it upon themselves to dive head-first into an investigation, bringing a camera along for the ride. Some documentaries might feature personal matters that directly involve the creator, while others choose to explore more globally-relevant topics.
But no matter the style of documentary you're talking about, one thing that always holds true is that the filmmakers can't possibly predict how the story they're investigating will grow, and what revelations they might uncover along the way.
Over the decades, we've seen various documentarians encounter surprising events, shocking turns, and other real-life "plot twists" (if you will) while putting their films together, from smaller reveals that don't affect their respective documentaries in a major way, to earth-shattering scoops that force the filmmakers to completely change the narrative they're attempting to convey.
Either way, the results are truly fascinating.
10. Gimme Shelter - The Death Of A Young Rolling Stones Fan
The original idea for 1970's Gimme Shelter was to follow rock legends The Rolling Stones through the final stages of their 1969 United States tour, showing the band performing at Madison Square Garden, and the Altamant Speedway.
The filmmakers probably weren't expecting the finished documentary to be serious or shocking in any way, but when events took a disturbing turn at the aforementioned Altamant concert, that's exactly the result they got.
While the Stones were performing their track Under My Thumb, 18-year-old audience member Meredith Hunter attempted to barge his way onto the stage, only to be knocked aside by someone who was guarding the band. In response, Hunter pulled out a revolver, only to be stabbed - and killed - by one of his attackers.
By chance, this entire incident was captured by the documentary crew.
When the final product was screened for audiences, Hunter's stabbing quickly became the most talked-about scene in the film, completely changing the much lighter documentary the filmmakers had originally intended to make.
9. Marjoe - The Manipulative, Shady Underbelly Of Evangelism
Marjoe Gortner had a difficult upbringing. He suffered abuse at the hands of his parents, who trained him to become a preacher from an early age. Travelling across the U.S., he delivered many sermons, where - at the behest of his parents - he conned people into buying items that could supposedly heal injuries, and even prevent death.
Marjoe became something of a child celebrity, until, in his late teenage years, he decided to abandon his preaching career - but this wouldn't last forever. A few years later, he returned to the scene, culminating in a final tour which was recorded by a film crew for the Oscar-winning documentary, Marjoe.
That was the initial pitch for the film - to follow Marjoe on his 1971 tour, watching how he conducted his sermons. The directors certainly accomplished that goal, but they also got more than they bargained for in the process, with the film also exposing the manipulative, shady underbelly of the evangelist lifestyle.
At one point, Marjoe explains that he's actually a non-believer, while other scenes detail how preachers successfully con people into giving them their money. At one point, the camera captures a minister (who isn't aware a mic is in the room) counting a huge pile of cash while bragging about the day's earnings.
As she explained in a 2014 interview, co-director Sarah Kernochan had no idea she was going to capture such revealing footage, which ended up turning the film from a profile centred on Marjoe, to an exposé of the industry as a whole.
8. Icarus - The Russian Government-Backed Doping Program
Jumping ahead to a more recent event, the 2017 Netflix documentary Icarus centres on sports doping - the practice of athletes using illegal, performance-enhancing drugs, in order to boost their chances of winning.
Before filming began, the premise was for director Bryan Fogel to investigate this shady business with the aid of Russian scientist Grigory Rodchenkov, who would show Fogel a way of taking these illegal drugs that makes them difficult to detect.
However, the production then took a seriously crazy turn.
Throughout the course of shooting, Rodchenkov ended up revealing the existence of a government-backed doping program, one that was built to allow the Russian team to cheat at the 2014 Winter Olympics. This confession (which was eventually verified by the World Anti-Doping Agency) placed Rodchenkov's life in danger, forcing him to be hidden from the Russian government via protective custody.
It's a wild ride from start to end, with Fogel accidentally stumbling across the scoop of a lifetime while producing his relatively simple documentary.
7. Hitman Hart: Wrestling With Shadows - The Montreal Screwjob
Released in 1998, Paul Jay's Hitman Hart: Wrestling with Shadows stumbled across absolute pro wrestling gold.
Intended to follow the legendary Bret Hart as he entered the final year of his contract with Vince McMahon's then-WWF, this documentary ended up spotlighting one of the most controversial moments in wrestling history.
After McMahon backtracked on a life-long contract offer to Hart, he encouraged the Canadian to sign with rival promotion WCW. Reluctantly doing just that, the Hitman's last match was him defending the WWF Championship against Shawn Michaels at the 1997 Survivor Series PPV in Montreal, Canada.
With Bret contractually able to decide the fate of his on-screen persona, he decided that he didn't want to lose his title in his home country to real-life bitter enemy Shawn Michaels. And so, the decision was made to have the match end in a double DQ, with Hart then handing over the belt the following night.
Unbeknownst to Hart, McMahon and a few select higher-ups put a plan in motion that would see the Canadian screwed out of his championship in an event that would become known as the Montreal Screwjob.
For Wrestling with Shadows, it caught this moment in real time, caught the angry reaction to it, and gave wrestling fans a fascinating look behind the curtain.
6. Stevie - The Dark Path Of Stevie Fielding
Helmed by acclaimed documentarian Steve James, 2002's Stevie began life as a basic profile of Stevie Fielding. James had previously worked as an advocate Big Brother to Fielding, and the aim of the film was simply for the two men to reconnect.
But what actually happened was nowhere near as straightforward as that.
Upon reuniting with Fielding, James discovers that the awkward kid he once knew has grown into a troubled young man, but that's not the half of it. The documentary was really flipped on its head when, part way through filming, Fielding was arrested and charged with a serious crime - molesting an 8-year-old girl.
What's more, Fielding would later end up confessing to the crime, before taking that confession back. This entire saga is chronicled in James' fascinating documentary, turning what was supposed to be an intimate catch-up into a much darker study of Fielding, and the self-destructive path his adult life took.
5. Seaspiracy - Suistanble Seafood Is Harming Marine Life
Motivated by his love of marine life, the director of Netflix's Seaspiracy initially set out to make a more celebratory documentary than the one he ended up with.
Along the way though, he changed tact, choosing instead to focus on the numerous ways that humans are damaging the Earth's oceans, such as plastic pollution, overfishing, whaling, and other big topics.
The filmmaking process ended up shining a bright light on the dark secrets of the fishing industry, with many grim moments (including scenes of a bloodthirsty whale hunt in the Faroe Islands) peppered throughout the runtime.
But one of the biggest scoops in the film comes when Mark J. Palmer - associate director of the International Marine Mammal Project - admits that fishermen might actually be killing dolphins in the process of collecting their nets of tuna.
In an interview after the film was released, director Ali Tabrizi stated that Palmer's revelation felt like "a huge betrayal", angry that this so-called "sustainable" seafood might not actually be helping the marine life it claims to protect.
4. Weiner - Anthony's Weiner Ruins Mayoral Campaign
Prominent politicians are always going to make for intriguing documentary subjects, but the directors of 2016's Weiner did not expect their film to be as gripping as it turned out.
The production started by trailing U.S. congressman Anthony Weiner following his 2011 resignation, which was instigated when some raunchy pictures of his own personal weiner were leaked onto the web. The purpose of the documentary was to chart Weiner's comeback during his 2013 New York City mayoral campaign, but as you've probably guessed by now, that isn't exactly what happened.
His campaign efforts did get off to a decent start, with promising evidence that he might even go on to win. However, while cameras were rolling on the film, a new batch of photos - which Weiner had sent under the pornstar-sounding alias "Carlos Danger" - were uncovered, swapping his potential comeback for a very painful (and very public) downfall.
The documentary crew captured intimate footage of Weiner and his family struggling with all this heat, which, understandably, led to his refusal to watch the final product. "I know how it ends" he said. "And it wasn't pretty."
3. Everest - Training Doc Turns To Disaster Doc
While not a "scoop" in the traditional sense, the directors of the 1998 IMAX film Everest certainly encountered a twist in the tale when they set out to make a documentary about the training required to scale the titular mountain.
In a horrifying turn of events, the film ended up being in production at the exact same time as the 1996 Mount Everest disaster, in which eight climbers died after a blizzard interrupted their descent from the summit.
Understandably, this drastically affected the focus and tone of the documentary, with the filmmakers deciding to construct their edit around this great tragedy - and incredibly, the final cut even features footage of the disaster itself.
This wasn't the last time a documentary filmmaker happened to be rolling cameras at the same time a shocking event occurred, either. The 2002 film 9/11 was supposed to be about a probationary firefighter's first day on the job, but ultimately ended up capturing one of the only known recordings of American Airlines Flight 11 colliding with the World Trade Center.
2. Capturing The Friedmans - Clown Show Becomes Horror Show
Capturing The Friedmans is a film that director Andrew Jarecki never intended to make. In the early 2000s, his focus was on a short film titled Just A Clown, which was planned as a "day in the life" of New York-based children's party entertainers.
However, while making this short (which he did eventually finish), Jarecki's research led him to discover a shocking truth - namely, the dark story behind one of his subjects, David Friedman, whose family has a deeply disturbing history.
During the production process, Jarecki learned that David's brother (Jesse) and father (Arnold) had previously pleaded guilty to child sex abuse, which drove the filmmaker to uncover as much about the story as he could. His pursuit of the truth then evolved into the feature-length documentary Capturing The Friedmans, which tracks the Friedman case from beginning to end - from court cases, to prison, to Arnold's death in 1995, and Jesse's release six years later.
Needless to say, it's a million miles away from that initial, much breezier documentary about birthday party clowns.
1. The Thin Blue Line - Death Row Inmate Randall Dale Adams Was Innocent
While in the planning stages of the documentary that would eventually become 1988's The Thin Blue Line, director Errol Morris' goal was to centre his film around psychiatrist James Grigson - otherwise known by the ominous moniker "Doctor Death."
That name was given to Grigson due to the fact that most of the trials he prosecuted in resulted in a death sentence, which is why Morris was drawn to him. But when Morris began to dive deeper into his research, the focus of the documentary was completely flipped on its head.
While interviewing a man called Randall Dale Adams - a death row convict whom Grigson had previously testified against - Morris began to suspect that he was totally innocent, and that he hadn't committed the murder he was being accused of.
And thankfully, Morris' suspicions were bang on the money. Adams was indeed innocent, a massive scoop that Morris uncovered while making his documentary, when he managed to obtain a confession from the real murderer, David Harris.
As a result, Adams' conviction was overturned several months after the film's release - allowing him to walk free.