10 Films Based On Real Life Serial KIllers

By Clare Simpson /

Serial killers have always fascinated the creative imagination and this has resulted in characters as diverse as Hannibal Lecter and Michael Myers. However, arguably the most interesting cinematic serial killers are those who are based in real life. Do you remember when the Jeffrey Dahmer case broke? Remember all the lurid details of cannibalism and necrophilia? Did you see the cops taking out his refrigerator in which the remains of young men lay? There are many interesting ways that real life serial killers can be portrayed - through documentary, as a backdrop to a story, as a psychological study, as an instrument to shock and horrify, as a comment on society. I have tried to include a broad range of real life based serial killer films. Each of them takes a unique approach to their subjects but they don't offer up fava beans and a glass of Chianti.

10. Gacy (2003)

John Wayne Gacy was an American rapist and serial killer, also known as the Killer Clown. He was convicted of the sexual assault and murder of at least 33 boys that happened between 1972-1978 in Chicago. His victims were lured or inveigled to his home and he would strangle them. He buried 26 of them in the crawlspace under his home, another three on his property and four were chucked in a river. Gacy was convicted of 12 of the murders and spent 14 years on Death Row before being killed by lethal injection in 1994. I doubt very much that Gacy is a piece of cinema verite. I would say it is heavily fictionalised but it is a disgusting sort of replica of the kind of man Gacy was and the heinous exploits he got up to. What got to me in the film was all the maggots. Maggots maggots everywhere and not a drop to drink. Coming up the sinks in his house, all over his crawlspace. And the neighbours cheerily complain about the stink. Little do they know what horrors are going on below Gacy's house. Besides the bugs and the stink, there wasn't much happening. It wasn't a psychological portrait of Gacy - it was too shallow. For example a scene at the start of the movie suggests Gacy is a monstrous killer because his dad gives him a slap up the jaw on a camping trip. Oh woe is me. The direction and acting is pretty terrible and there is too much filler. I fell asleep towards the end of it, it was so soporific. In no way a realistic portrayal of one of the 20th century's vilest figures.

9. Summer of Sam (1999)

David Berkowitz, also known as The Son of Sam, is an American serial killer convicted of a number of shooting attacks that began in the summer of 1976. The murders continued for a year and left six people dead and seven injured. Berkowitz eluded police capture, became a media sensation and taunted the world with a series of boastful letters. He was eventually captured in August 1977, claiming that he was driven to kill by a demon that had possessed his neighbour's dog. Summer of Sam is not a biography of David Berkowitz, it is a slice of drama set among a community of Italian Americans when the shootings were at their most intense. Spike Lee does a great job of capturing the 1976 zeitgeist - the dress, the disco music, the heat, the paranoia. Unfortunately, the story features not very sympathetic characters with boring problems. Berkowitz is nothing but a shadowy presence, occasionally appearing to shoot necking lovers in their car through the head. These scenes are brutal. There is not much psychological examination of Berkowitz, mind you, this is not a film directly about him, rather the effects he has on New York during his reign of terror. There is a goofy talking dog and mafiosa vigilantes trying to figure out just who the Son of Sam is. But mostly the film focuses on pervy cheating husband Vinny (John Leguizamo) and his beleaguered wife Dionna (Mira Sorvino). It is a very sweary film. I swear myself and I'm not particularly offended by it, but this is swearing ne plus ultra. I would rather have some decent action to watch. The only exciting times are in fact when Berkowitz shoots someone and then you have to be bored for a while until he shoots someone else. Well captured era of summer in NY 1976 but bogged down by irritating characters and scenarios. Berkowitz, in his quiet way is the best thing about the film. Woof!

8. Ted Bundy (2002)

Ted Bundy was an American serial killer, kidnapper, rapist and necrophile who assaulted and killed scores of young American women and girls during the 1970s. Bundy denied killing anyone until a decade after his capture when he admitted to the killing of 30 women all across America. The true figure is thought to be higher. The film does a terrific job of showing what a psychopath Bundy was - smooth, charming and debonair - he could have had his pick of women but underneath that facade he was a vicious, sadistic, perverted beast who murdered with great relish. There is no attempt to explain Bundy's pathology in the film - he just is what he is. Thankfully, the film does not go overboard in portraying Bundy's gruesome acts. The film is hard to watch as it is but I must say it is not exploitive or OTT in the gore stakes. The execution scenes at the end are amongst the best in the film as we see Bundy terrified crapless and crying like a little baby. A figure in a black hood pulls the electric chair lever and Bundy fries. The executioner removes their hood - it is a woman. A fitting end for a diabolical monster.

7. Dahmer (2002)

Jeffrey Dahmer was an American serial killer and sex offender. He murdered 17 men and boys between 1978-1991. His murders involved rape, dismemberment, necrophilia and cannibalism. In 1994, Dahmer was beaten to death by a fellow inmate in jail. Jeremy Renner is a fantastic Jeffrey Dahmer. The film focuses on a couple of key points in Dahmer's life and it is more of a psychological study of the man than a chronological sequence of events in his life. There are only two kill scenes in the movie and they are quite restrained. We see Dahmer interacting with family in a disconnected manner, drinking lots of alcohol throughout the movie, trying to come to terms with his homosexuality. We get a sense of Dahmer's alienation and shyness along with his desperate desire for intimacy. The film doesn't focus on necrophile-cannibal-pervert killer Dahmer. It focuses on Dahmer the emotional human being. This could be disgusting and offensive to the relatives of Dahmer's victims but it makes a change from chop happy serial killers that are usually portrayed on the screen.

6. The Boston Strangler (1968)

The Boston Strangler is a name given to a murderer of several women in Boston, Massachusetts In the early 1960s. They have been widely attributed to Albert DeSalvo due to a confession in another court case. However, parties investigating the case suggest the murders may have been carried out by two people. "You can't entangle her from the Boston Strangler" - these were some cheesy heavy metal lyrics I once heard back when I was a rock chick. If anyone can identify the source, please let me know below. The film is famous for its split screen approach to show DeSalvo's crimes and the police investigation, a technique which has rarely been used since. Tony Curtis was not known for his good acting, but in The Boston Strangler he gives an amazing performance as Albert DeSalvo who was schizophrenic. The film is a good study of madness but it shows its age as homosexuals are rounded up as suspects of the murders. Henry Fonda and George Kennedy are a bit stiff as investigating detectives in the first half of the film, but it really comes alive when Curtis makes his appearance. It is a must see film, if only for Curtis' performance.

5. 10 Rillington Place (1971)

John Christie was a notorious English serial killer who murdered at least 8 women (including his own wife) by strangling them at his flat - 10 Rillington Place, Notting Hill in London. When he moved out of the house in 1953 bodies were found in the house, including his wife Ethel - under the floorboards. Christie was hanged after being convicted of his wife's murder. 10 Rillington Place is a very memorable film. Once seen, it is rarely forgotten. This is largely due to Richard Attenborough's fantastic chilling portrayal of Christie as a dangerous, sadistic killer hiding behind a bland, mild, unassuming exterior. The portrayal of post war London looks very effective and the film has a dark, brooding atmosphere. There is no gore and the slow pace may get up some viewers' noses but the film is best seen as a capsule in time of a particular historical period. John Hurt plays Tim Evans - the husband of one of the victims in an excellent performance. He ends up being hanged for his wife's murder which was entirely due to Christie. This injustice forced Britain to re-examine their penal laws and ultimately led to the abolishment of the death penalty.

4. Deranged (1974)

Ed Gein was an American murderer and body snatcher. He gained notoriety after authorities discovered that he had exhumed corpses from local graveyards and fashioned keepsakes out of skin and bone. After police found body parts in his house, Gein confessed to two murders. He was declared unfit to stand trial and sent to a mental hospital. He was later successfully tried and convicted for one murder and spent the rest of his life in a mental hospital. Deranged is maybe not the most accurate of films about the Ed Gein story but it is certainly the most frightening. This is low budget film making at its best - the low budget production values work in the film's favour as they make it look grim and realistic. The direction gives the film a creepy, sinister atmosphere. The murderer in this film is known as Ezra Cobb played by Roberts Blossom who gives a bravura performance and brings Gein's/Cobb's psychosis to life as he leads an existence of extreme alienation and isolation after his beloved mother dies. This is the event that prompted his ghoulish shenanigans. There are many shocking and disturbing moments in the film, but they are done by suggestion and not out and out gore. The film goes along at a steady pace - keeping the viewer riveted from beginning to end. Deranged has a loyal cult following and it is for a reason - principally, it is an excellent film. When you watch it, try to bear in mind it had a $2000 budget - you will be shocked at what it achieves on that budget.

3. Aileen: Life and Death of a Serial Killer (2003)

Aileen Wuornos killed seven men in Florida between 1989 and 1990. She claimed the men were trying to rape her and she killed them in self defence. She was convicted, sentenced to death and executed by the State of Florida by lethal injection on October 9th, 2002. Nick Broomfield's documentary is a follow up to a documentary he made in 1992 about Wuornos. In this documentary, he captures Aileen's declining mental state and the questionable decision over whether she should have been executed due to this. Having watched the film, I think that Wuornos was stark raving bonkers and she should have been locked away for life in an institute for the criminally insane, not executed. By the end of her life, she descends into monstrous paranoia which is hard to listen to in her interviews. Broomfield chronicles her vicious childhood. Listening to it is sobering and you can imagine how such a childhood and adolescence would spit out a creation like Aileen Wuornos. Broomfield is clearly anti death penalty. I am neutral on the subject except when it comes to the mentally ill or deficient. I know that Aileen wanted to die and I can't forget that her crimes were terrible but executing a mentally ill woman is just wrong.

2. Badlands (1973)

Charles Starkweather was a teenage American killer who murdered 11 people during a two month period with his 14 year old girlfriend Caril Ann Fugate in Wyoming and Nebraska. The couple were caught on January 1958. Fugate served 17 years and Starkweather was executed. Badlands! You gotta live it every day! Okay, enough of that. I am not a Terrence Malik devotee, but he did, with his debut film, create a masterpiece of 1970s cinema in a decade overflowing with terrific films. His direction is superb and the photography is wonderful. Each shot is positively sumptuous and captures the time period incredibly well. A film is only as good as its actors. Martin Sheen is Kit and Sissy Spacek is Holly - the two killers respectively. Holly's internal monologue fills up much of the film and is fascinating. We can see how a girl whose background includes her father shooting a dog in front of her, gets caught up with a Kit type character. The choice of music is wonderful and Malik is non-judgemental about his characters. Everything is presented in a matter of fact fashion and we are allowed to make our own minds up about the pair. Fair play to Malik on his first film - a bonafide masterpiece.

1. Henry: Portrait of a Serial Killer (1986)

Henry Lee Lucas was an American serial killer convicted on 11 charges of murder. He claimed to have killed 60 people after arrest, 100 people in court and outside of court 3000 people. He later recanted the confessions but his death toll seems to be at the 350 mark. He was sentenced to life in prison and died in 2001 of natural causes. The Otis that is Henry's compadre throughout the film is a real life person who did kill with Henry. He was convicted of 6 murders and died of cirrhosis of the liver in prison. Less of a portrait of a serial killer - more observation of the serial killer. There is a brief reference to an abusive mother but the film offers up no explanations for Henry's murderous, psychopathic tendencies. It is a bleak and grim film. Henry is totally beyond redemption. This film is violent and bloody with some very disturbing kill scenes such as the home invasion Otis and Henry stage where they kill an entire family and we see them watching it on video. The ease with which Henry is able to kill is quite disturbing. There are no police in the film. Henry just fades into the busy urban life as another nobody. He kills without discrimination - anyone could be his victim and he dispatches of them ruthlessly, without a second thought. Just watch the hooker killing car scene. Featuring a major down beat ending, viewers are usually left shocked and appalled at the carnage on the screen. Heavy, heavy viewing.