10 Formally Awesome Actors Who Made Us Forget Why They Were Great

By Jonathan Day /

To quote everyone's favourite suit wearing, whiskey swilling, lady killing (m)ad man Don Draper, "In Greek, nostalgia literally means pain from an old wound". It's a sentiment that rings horribly true on the occasions when you find yourself watching a performance of the staggering, audaciously craptacular variety...finger nails digging into palms as your hands form little balls of rage, stomach ulcers beginning to ferment, jaw tightening with every passing second of screen time being given over to this shlub... when suddenly, a little light bulb memory flicks on in the darkest recesses of your mind and you remember with a growing sense of confusion, horror and impossible sadness, that the actor on screen mangling his dialogue, over egging every expression or simply standing there listlessly, waiting for death to release him from all this exhaustion was once upon a time someone to truly be reckoned with. Then you sit (slump) back down in your tasteful flat (rat infested bedsit), loosen your tie (cheese puff stained string vest) and sink a couple of whiskey's (bottle caps of bleach) to dull the pain and try to kill those old memories of the good days when that fella on screen screaming about bees or waggling a gun around in his neon underpants was something truly special. Like any once golden relationship that has since turned sour, the frustration of remembering just how good things were actually sort of physically hurts. All the squandered potential of what could have been super-condensing and upper cutting you in the groin. The following are (in no particular order) a list of performers that inspire equal parts depression and wild, fist flinging rage at their stratospheric fall off of the "good acting" plinth. *note - you'll probably be expecting most of what's about to come what with being the savvy pop culture fan that you are, so let's try and make this as a sweary and fun as possible why don't we?

10. Nicolas Cage

Before I launch into the tirade that we've all read a million times before I'd like to set one thing straight and give some context. I adore Nicolas Cage. He is an utterly baffling, otherworldly creature capable of such fully transformative performances that when he pulls it off (as he has done many times over his incredibly weird screen career) he is almost without parallel. "Leaving Las Vegas", "Bad Lieutenant" and "Adaptation" all stand as a testament to what happens when he applies his full throttle batshittery to the right project. However, this unencumbered capacity to tear through scenery with such Spartan ferocity combined with an apparent inability to discern good from bad alongside a personality trait that's clinically described as "total insanity", Nicolas Cages...shall we say...spirited approach to performing has many, many a time backfired. In short, he makes god-awful films choices "The Wicker Man", "Season of The Witch", "Knowing", "Next", "Bangkok Dangerous", "Justice".... the list of awful films is as long as his hair is disturbingly strange. But as a result of his necessity to star in ever project he's offered to buy another castle in Bath (it's a lovely town Nic, we'll give you that) rubbing against all that unfettered lunatic energy he just winds up being terrible most of the time. He's like an ultra powerful laser that if calibrated correctly and delicately could be used to cure cancer, but instead you just fart on it, spin it in a circle and use it to superheat a meatball sub....or something. Audible sigh. Nostalgia Rating €“ We can still work it out baby! One more chance! Come on!

9. Steve Martin

For those of a certain generation, Steve Martin is a comedy god. Back prior to his transition over to cinema he was the biggest stand-up comic in the world. He easily sold out entire arenas off the back of a particularly left field and wilfully weird form of anti stand-up. Then he went and made "The Jerk" and instantly became the biggest comedic actor in the world. Indeed, in the years that followed he dropped out classics like "Dead Men Wear Plaid" and "The Man With Two Brains". Films that, to this day, hold up as pretty god damn funny. However, to those of a younger persuasion he's perhaps best known for middle of the road, family friendly crap cannon splatters such as the "Cheaper by The Dozen" movies and a woefully ill-judged turn in the Pink Panther remakes €“ a move which, once upon a time would have seemed perfectly natural considering his parallels to Peter Sellers. The thing is though, he's still an absurdly talented b**tard; his book "Born Standing Up" is possibly the greatest piece of literature about stand-up every written... and he's released some, honest to god, incredible albums of banjo music (seriously...that's not a typo). You go back and watch any of those olds films and compare them to where he's at now and, Jesus, it's just depressing. Martin has always been very frank and honest about his battles with depression, perhaps he just decided to let the beast swallow him up and churn out movies in which he plays an impossibly fertile man who gets into all sorts of hi-jinks. Dennis Pennis had it right when back in the late 90s he cornered Steve and cruelly asked "Didn't you used to be funny?" (Although he's really good in that episode of 30 Rock). Nostalgia Level €“ Eating a stick of deep fried butter to counter act the sadness you feel

8. Mel Gibson

Oh Mel, where in perfect blue hell did it all go so, so wrong? How could a man so deeply imbedded in so many facets of the popular culture subconscious, who holds a handful of performances so striking, so untouchable, so towering, defining and just f**king cool that they resonant out and far beyond they're initial context (we're specifically talking, of course, "Lethal Weapon" and "Mad Max" here), how could he end up falling so far off the deep end into loony bin exile as a Hollywood pariah? Gibbo's (as he prefers to be called) fall from grace is one of such monumental height that it would give Felix Baumgartner vertigo. It's also one that's not focused on the unravelling of any talent per say, nope, he's remained a strong actor and decisive (if polarising) film maker, rather the big brick wall that blocks the memory of his days prior to falling out of public favour is one far more deeply wound into his personality and history. Every since he was caught driving drunk off his big Australian face by a female police officer he then decided to give a border line lethal dosage of misogyny towards he's been on the fast track to the black list. Sure, many in Hollywood have come back from worse singular events, but couple into this out bursts of racism and anti-Semitism exacerbated by substance abuse and a holocaust denier for a father and you wind up with a public and professional persona tarnished so extensively that he's unlikely to ever return from it. No matter how many films Jodie Foster puts him in with puppets. Nostalgia Level - Blocking phone numbers, changing locks, deleting from social media but occasionally looking back through that old photo album of the time you went and set off home made fireworks in an abandoned factory.

7. John Cusack

Once upon a very many years ago, John Cusack was one of the straight up coolest sonofaguns on the planet. I know that may seem like an alien thought, one that jars uncomfortably with what you know to be true now. But stay the course and consider the evidence, he had films like the seminal "Stand By Me", the never not cool "Grosse Point Blank"", the utterly haunting "The Thin Red Line" and bonkers film making weirdness at its very finest with "Being John Malkovich". Indeed, for further evidence consider there exists a photograph where in Mr Cusack is in an open top car alongside Johnny Depp, Hunter S Thompson and an inflatable blow up sex doll. No context needed The man's trademark pithy, mumbley, hyper intelligent, vulnerable confidence was equal parts Robert Downey Jr charm and snark as it was Johnny Depps pouting otherworldliness. He was always a pleasure to watch and you'd feel pretty secure in the knowledge that your eyes were in for an enjoyable performance. Then he just decided to stop being good apparently. Case in point, like to any recent additions to his filmography - things like "2012", "The Raven" and "The Number Stations" as tangible evidence that he's apparently decided a decisive career move would be to become awful and star in terrible movies. Nostalgia Rating €“ The disappointment of seeing a once suave, confident and successful friend pleadingly trying to sell second hand cars to frat boys humming Pitbull remixes of Vampire Weekend.

6. Robert De Niro

An obvious choice, yes, sure, I agree. But to draw attention to the mind boggling decline of Robert De Niro's career from around 1989 onwards would be a bum move in a list like this. But we'll keep this one snappy....ish Everyone knows De Niro's calibre. The pedigree he once operated within, his dedication to the craft of acting, the violent intensity he brought to a handful of performances was of such quality that it's defined his entire career trajectory. So why'd it all go wrong. Why did towering performances suddenly mutate into bad comedy and melodramas that other, lesser actors would have the foresight to stay clear of? Who the hell knows? Maybe he was sick of being a method actor so focused on criminals and psychopaths, occupying that headspace constantly must have been exhausting, and wanted to flex his acting muscles in less strenuous directions. Fine, whatever, but after doing that with the woeful "Analyse This", you should then have enough self-awareness to realise that's a dreadful idea and return to the kinds of characters you can sink your teeth into. Nope, he just kept ploughing on through the crapstorm. Gurning up "Rocky and Bullwinkle", the atrocious Focker franchise, a baffling turn in "Men of Honour", one of the least scary horrors every spunked out in "Hide N Seek"; the list plods on and on defecating all over the once great man's legacy as it goes. We should have known that something as amiss when he started parodying the types of characters that brought him fame in sub-standard SNL skits... Post-Credit €“Sting - Of late however, he seems to have been getting his head together a little better. With strong turns in "Limitless" and "Silver Linings Playbook".

5. Eddie Murphy

It's all about context. From a modern stand point it's almost impossible to see a time when Eddie Murphy was anything other than a total joke (in the wrong sense). Some washed up no one spitting out terrible family fodder and inexplicitly knocking up Spice Girls. But squint really hard and you can see a time, long ago in the distant past, a time when he was a juggernaut - the biggest comedy star on earth and a seemingly unstoppable force of funny. That time was the 80s, which isn't all that different from now really - synth music and silly hair still dominates the music world, and Murphy is still truly shocking, albeit, back then it was for a different reason. He was an angry young stand-up revolutionising the craft of on-stage comedy, his successful leap to the big screen via "48hours" and "Trading Places" made everyone take notice, but it was and) Beverly Hills Cop that turned him into a super star. He was arguably, the new Richard Pryor. Then things went weird. Perhaps it was suddenly finding yourself rich beyond your wildest dreams, living in the little hermetically sealed world of the uber famous that killed Eddie's funny. Comedy arguably needs to be driven by anger or frustration or at least some shared emotional connection to those around you. But disconnected from all this and living in total comfort apparently wrapped his brain into all kinds of ludicrously bad shapes, crystallising eventually in the biggest financial flop of all time "The Adventure of Pluto Nash", a movie that is so compellingly difficult to grasp how it happened you will actually walk away stupider. Nostalgia rating €“ It was a long time ago and too much has happened. Things aren't getting better

4. Adam Sandler

Ok, so controversial choice maybe? Let me preface this by saying I don't think Sandler is a spectacular actor by any stretch of the imagination. No, what he was long ago, was a strong comic actor and writer with an instantly recognisable tone that was, by and large, very entertaining. He then later proved that he actually had substantial acting chops (more on this in a bit). But for the last decade €“ post Click perhaps €“ he's been firing off cinematic turds like it's going out of style. "Jack and Jill", "Grown-ups", "That's My Boy" - if it bills itself as a comedy yet lacks even the most rudimentary of chuckles then more than likely Sandler has had a hand in it. He's just become a schlubby has been churning out middle of the road "family friendly" content stuffed to the gills with cliché, hackiness and Kevin James's enormous waistline. Always the same assembled gang of unfunnies (James, Spade, Schinder et al) falling over, bumping into things, being married to impossibly gorgeous women and learning crappy life lessons along the way, all whilst studio audiences sit stony faced watching these "comedy actors" grin like smug turtles that love the smell of their own farts. Painful But let's remember that Sandler was once a really strong stand up way back whenever the hell it was and films like Billy Madison, The Water Boy and that one about golf may have had the same formulaic approach €“ but at least that approach had some god damn laughs init. Then on top of all that he goes and stars in Paul Thomas Anderson's "Punch-Drunk Love" and suddenly proves that he can f**king act. Like, really act. So what's going on then? WHAT GIVES Nostalgia Rating €“ Once upon a time you used to care man... you used to care.

3. Will Smith

Will Smith is one of the biggest, most powerful Hollywood stars working today. He's a man that from humble roots as a (terrible) rapper and (pretty darn good) sitcom actor has stratospherically ascended the fame machine to become an entire brand. Well, sort of....at least from the mid-90s up until the mid 2000s he was a brand, a sure fire seat filler; a cash cow of the milkiest variety. He churned out smash hit summer, pop corn blockbusters like" Independence Day" (come on you love it) and "Men in Black", then slightly later in his career become a credible acting force with star turns in the likes of "Ali" and (much later) the "Pursuit of Happyness". But something has been going wrong with Mr Smith for sometime now. It started back with the catastrophic miss-step that was "Wild Wild West", a steampunk western/ tongue in cheek action adventure that looked like it could have been amazing but simply collapsed under the weight of its giant mechanical spider obsession and general awfulness (homework, check out Kevin Smith and Patton Oswalt waxing separately about why they hate this movie so much). Before long those previously mentioned successful films seemed to be getting swamped more and more regularly in films like" I, Robot" or "I Am Legend" or" Hancock" - movie pictures that were built as summer blockbusters, but hampered by (amongst many things) and increasingly unlikeable take on Smith's cocksure charms. Maybe it's something to do with becoming king of the Hollywood and then choosing to star in a string of films where by you are effectively the most important person on earth (I Am Legend, Hancock and to a lesser extent Seven Pounds) might lean towards a less than healthy psychological image of oneself....ya know, the kind of rampant narcissism that often causes careers to turn into all shades of s**tty. Oh and then there's the recent "After Earth". Conceived entirely by him and also starring his insufferable offspring and a plot so stupid that just thinking about it has given me a nose bleed. Nostalgia Rating €“ Bring back the Fresh prince.... call Jazzy Jeff or something.

2. Cuba Gooding Jr

Let's blame this one on the Oscar win why don't we. Post-feverish speech for his 1996 win, Gooding JR was an up and comer to keep an eye on. Afterwards, the plane slowly descended and crashed into the mountain due to some, shall we say, erratic choices. His breakout performance came courtesy of a defining turn in" Boyz in The Hood", with further cred-via association due to his part in Oscar nabbing Sorkin drama "A Few Good Men". But then everything changed with the aforementioned Oscar win for his performance in "Jerry Maguire", what was to become his defining cinematic moment. Then everything went weird. Following his Oscar he simply tried to act in ever-conceivable genre going, with diminishing returns on each stab at a new type of film he took a stab at. "As Good As It Gets" (dramatic romantic comedy) bequeath "What Dreams May Come" (weird drama thingy) bequeath "Men of Honour" (WAR) and so forth. But for whatever reasons, he couldn't stop the descent down into the pit of s**t that he'd began rappelling himself towards, ultimately reaching his lowest ebb with the back to back release of "Snow Dogs" (horror) and "Boat Trip"(snuff film), almost causing the apocalypse as he did so. Nowadays he's totally been spat out by the mainstream and loiters around straight to DVD action and comedy fair. Nostalgia Rating - An intense relationship that burned too bright, too fast.

1. Al Pacino

Well we did De Niro, might as well do Pacino right? There was always a parallel between the two screen titans. These massive, imposing, Italian-American personalities, both at home in the same kind of roles and seemingly orbiting one another all the time, never properly clashing on screen (barring the legendary moment in "Heat") for fear that the effect may be similar to crossing the beams in Ghostbusters. The two have been linked inexorably for whatever reasons since their acting inceptions, and as Di Nero travelled further down the path of acting oblivion, so to did Pacino walk parallel to him. Or was it Pacino that went first and Di Nero that felt compelled to follow? That is the great, utterly pointless philosophical question of our times isn't it? I'm going to call the moment that Pacino fell off the deep end as his appearance opposite the world's most handsome piece of furniture in "The Devil's Advocate". A performance of such scene chewing, shouty, shouty, always shouty insanity that the only words to adequately explain it away would be "all of the cocaine". He has a 30 minute speech for Christ's sake?! In fact, he shouted so damn much during that movie that he apparently broke the volume knob off his vocal chords, cursed forever to act at 11, regardless of the role. Since then he's produced the odd gem (he's fantastically knackered in "Insomnia") but primarily focussed his attention on looking more and more like a half-melted wax work dummy and deafening cast, crew and audience with some seriously over egged turns. And then he starred in those terrible Sky adverts too boot. Mark it folks, he's not coming back Nostalgia rating €“ HOO-HAWWWW

Honourable mention €“ Kevin Bacon

Have you seen The Following? Or those British 3G adverts? ENOUGH IS ENOUGH BACON!