10 Great Acting Performances By Musicians

By Marshall Granger /

Being a musician and being an actor can have more similarities than one might imagine. In the case of some of these artists, their stage presence and public personas take much of the same gravitas and attention as committing oneself to a scripted part. Some musicians seem to dip their toes into the rushing streams of cinema in an attempt to capture that parallel challenge. Sinking into the part of a character onscreen has to be nothing but helpful for the artistic minded and performance inclined. Others seem to be drawn by specific projects, or film directors have sought them out specifically and cleverly because of their well-known persona. I need to set out some ground rules for how this list is constructed. There are plenty of artists out there that could qualify for discussion of some form of multi-faceted career. However, the people featured here fall under some specific distinctions: Must be a prominent role. This rules out any kind of short and sweet cameos (i.e Jack White as Elvis in Walk Hard, Chris Isaak in Silence of the Lambs) or even less significant supporting roles like Mariah Carey€™s impressive but ultimately smaller part in Precious. The musician must be primarily a musician. A couple of choices may seem to blur the line, but we will get to that. Basically, the Will Smiths and Mark Wahlbergs of the entertainment business are ruled out, because at this point they seem to have chosen a clear path. These are great performances. I would love to honor the likes of say Aaliyah and 2Pac, but I can€™t say I€™d honestly vouch for their acting performances. Here are 10 carefully chosen lead performances by musicians.

10. Mick Jagger in Performance (1970)

The Rolling Stones always upheld a reputation as more €œbad boys€ than their other world famous Brit Invasion friends The Beatles. Though both bands spent plenty of time doing €œbad€ things, The Stones had no problem keeping an especially wild personality on the frontline. Running back and forth across the stage the past 50 years as a self-proclaimed Monkey Man, Mick Jagger has set the bar high for the likes great performers. Jagger€™s experience with film is best remembered with the Donald Cammell and Nicolas Roeg film Performance. Outside of this film, he held a few notable roles, including the infamous and now denounced Ned Kelly. Jagger also seemed to have a knack for almost being involved with great projects, including Rocky Horror Picture Show, Fitzcarraldo, and A Clockwork Orange. Maybe those almosts strengthened his drive to stay in music, as The Rolling Stones remain one of the most popular bands in the world (now celebrating their 50th anniversary). In Performance, Mick Jagger plays Turner, a mysterious performance artist who watches over a sort-of surreal safehouse in London. Chas, a vicious gangster, comes to stay with him whilst hiding from a massive police investigation, and the two make a bright clash as they identify the €œperformance€ in one another. Though, that sounds a little too cut and dry, because Performance is in itself a performance piece. Turner allows for Jagger to show what he would have probably done well with in both Frank-N-Furter of Rocky Horror and Alex of Clockwork.

9. Tom Waits in Down By Law (1986)

Of all the artists on this list, Tom Waits makes music that resonates in the most cinematic way. From pirate-style tales of perilous sea journeys to destitute portraits of gas station purgatory, his songs easily craft mental landscapes with his knack for unconventional instrumentation and his famously tattered singing voice. One of the best visual accompaniments to Waits€™ music is the opening shots of Jim Jarmusch€™s Down By Law, tracking along paint chipped neighborhoods to the driving rhythm of €œJockey Full of Bourbon€. Generally speaking, Jarmusch evokes the same sense of curiosity in people as Waits, with existential projects like Night On Earth, Coffee and Cigarettes or The Limits of Control. Down By Law finds Tom Waits as an apathetic radio DJ landing in a prison cell with a shady street dealer, played by John Lurie, and a gullible Italian traveler, the great Roberto Benigni. The film follows their paths into the cell and eventually out. Beautifully shot in black in white, Down By Law captures the overwhelming indifference each character has with society, in many different ways, and plays out like one of the classics. Waits has popped up in a wide variety of films, such as Coppola€™s Dracula, Altman€™s Short Cuts and maybe most fittingly as the devil in Terry Gilliam€™s The Imaginarium of Dr. Parnassus. In Down By Law, he is playing a character that fits so well, he could be pulled straight from many of Tom Waits€™ own songs. Jarmusch has a skill for writing in a voice that feels most natural from the singer€™s scratched voice. Because of this, he really leads the trio of characters and effectively brings out their best contrasts.

8. Ice Cube in Boyz 'n the Hood (1990)

Unless you were asleep for the late 80s and early 90s, or have somehow avoided any VH1 special about those time periods, you should know that NWA kind of broke the ice with hip hop and the world. Sure, there were other groups before, they certainly did not invent the genre, but the group took the world by storm with the most blunt, straightforward and hardcore approach. Attention from the FBI only enhances the world€™s interest in NWA€™s debut, €œStraight Outta Compton€, and the United States started to wonder about what really did go on in South Central LA. John Singleton describes his debut film as an illustration of albums like €œStraight Outta Compton€, putting places, names and faces to a part of America people did not really bother to acknowledge. When the film came out, the reality hit hard with both American and International audiences, and Boyz 'n the Hood became one of the most important American films of the century. While much of the cast and crew came from the film€™s actual setting, none had already been telling the story like Ice Cube, whose Doughboy plays out as a wrong-path counter to Cuba Gooding Jr. Boyz 'n the Hood was in many ways biographical for him, but in more than just mere experience. He strove to show to the lives of kids in that part of the country, and just how easy it can be to succumb to an addictive lifestyle. Ice Cube does not enhance the part by simply being from NWA and knowing the world, but his inexperience in the methods of acting really allows him to give a brutally honest performance. A performance that can hold up very strong, 23 years and one too many Are There Yet? films later.

7. Cher in Moonstruck (1987)

Going from the better half of a popular music/comedy duo to an international singular pop sensation, Cher has spent nearly 50 years in the hierarchy of show business. She is not quite an EGOT winner, but she€™s made up for it in other awards including Golden Globes and a Best Actress win from Cannes. Besides, the absence of a Tony does not mean an absence from the Broadway stage. However you feel about Cher as an artist, you have to recognize the diligence of her career. From the iconic rise and fall of Sonny & Cher to the roll and roll persona of the €˜80s and, maybe to some€™s dismay, the Auto-Tune pioneering pop queen of the 1990s, Cher has been a strong force in the entertainment world. Her presence in film has lasted from the beginning to the new millennium with highly varied projects. She€™s worked with some of the greatest filmmakers, whether it be in Peter Bogdonavich€™s Mask or Mike Nichols€™ Silkwood. Cher€™s most successful and critically acclaimed role came in Norman Jewison€™s classic romantic comedy Moonstruck. As Loretta Castorini, she commands a very strong performance that appropriately takes control of the whole film. Moonstruck boasts a fine supporting cast, including a wonderfully smug performance from Nicholas Cage. However, it is Cher that reins the movie in from being too over-the-top in its portrayal of the typical Italian-American family. The character allows her to really stretch out her individualist sensibilities and she comes off as a truly independent person, an image that lends well to Cher after a rather controlled relationship with Sonny Bono.

6. Justin Timberlake in The Social Network (2010)

In a 2010 interview with Fresh Air's Terry Gross, Justin Timberlake commented on the way he has constructed his solo career as sort of a series of characters. In a less direct but similar mindset as artists like David Bowie, Timberlake has approached both his 2006 head-turner €œFutureSex/LoveSounds€ and his recently released €œThe 20/20 Experience€ with complete packages of aesthetic, theme and persona. Fittingly, the pop singer has more and more found himself both TV and film roles where his smooth reputation has lended a positive hand, such as his repeated SNL hosting gigs and even 2011€™s Friends With Benefits. In the days of N€™sync, had the news leaked of an upcoming drama about a popular social website with Timberlake as the founder of Napster and under the direction of Se7en mastermind David Fincher, it would have been pretty unbelievable. First of all, I€™d say €œWhy are they already making a movie about this new Napster thing€, followed by, €œWhen is the next €˜NOW! That€™s What I Call Music€™ coming out??€ Even when the rumors did start circulating, it was very hard to picture. Fincher€™s The Social Network is a rapid fire, Aaron Sorkin-helmed 21st century Richard III that takes on a cultural phenomenon that has changed the definition of €˜friends€™ and yet tells a story about simple human connection. Timberlake€™s Sean Parker is the wide-eyed tycoon that stokes the fire by basically handing Mark Zuckerberg a can of WD-40. He is restricted to the film€™s second half, but absolutely plays a vital role in the story. Timberlake€™s cadence with how he speaks provides strong support for the character. In this film, Parker is the kind of guy who can talk your ear off for just a few minutes and have completely revolutionised your thought process. He is one of many perfect characters in The Social Network for Aaron Sorkin to be scripting, as he is famously known for his overlapping, speed of light dialogue. Justin Timberlake is simply a brilliant casting choice in that the character could just fall back on the His Girl Friday train that many of Sorkin€™s actors have followed. However, there is something sort of terrifying in how Sean Parker speaks with such slippery confidence and dangerous motivation.

5. Eminem in 8 Mile (2002)

The music world kind of blew up when Marshall Mathers came on the scene at the dawn of the new millennium. At least, from the perspective of the televised media, this ruthless, raunchy rapper also happened to be Caucasian, which seemed to make a big difference to headline news. The violence of his music was exploited as some product of a stereotype that he was quick to denounce. Looking back, the big news pundits never zeroed in on any of the serious shit Eminem was bringing up in his songs, including still relevant points on where we throw the blame when mentally unstable kids attack their peers. Taking this loud and angry performer seriously took a long time, but it became easier when 8 Mile hit theaters. Curtis Hanson€™s realist exploration into the journey of an up-and-coming Detroit rapper plays out a lot like the understood story of Mathers€™ life. And really, Eminem is on-screen as basically himself with darker hair. Yet, his familiarity with the film€™s gritty Detroit setting lends to a starkly serious and natural performance. The theatrical qualities that the world had come to associate with Eminem were mostly comical, several colorful, parody-style music videos under his belt. 8 Mile brings out the substance that really runs through most of Eminem€™s discography. The rap battles especially allow for his raw emotion to come through in a context that is nothing short of captivating.

4. David Bowie in Merry Christmas Mr. Lawrence (1983)

Of all rock and roll musicians, David Bowie probably has the most extensive and methodical track record for taking on roles and submerging himself in a character. Leaving out any involvement with the film world, his career has almost always aligned with some kind of over-arching performance, from Ziggy Stardust to the Thin White Duke. He has established himself through the decades as a multi-layered artist. His film career is something of a marvel, taking on roles that compliment his musical personas, like The Man Who Fell To Earth, or roles that draw from his more modest personality, such as his small portrayal of Tesla in The Prestige. If anything shows a more natural sense of charisma from Bowie (other than the magical charisma in Labyrinth), Merry Christmas Mr. Lawrence offers a dynamic sense of Bowie as an everyman. Not to say Bowie€™s performance is average in Mr. Lawrence, he is more of a wild card in his turn as Major Celliers, who is sent to a POW camp in Japan only to confront a dividing community of social views. Bowie is at one moment a speechless figure, constraining the performance to only the face, and at other times a loud, physical animal. Nevertheless, he manages to maintain the presence of a battered, but resilient soldier and still give off his trademark supernatural dominance. While the film's titular character is the more prophetic and admirable of the bunch, Celliers is successfully portrayed as a true symbol for many POWs.

3. Art Garfunkel in Bad Timing (1980)

Nicholas Roeg seemed to set out to bring musicians to the screen for charismatic lead roles, first with 1970€™s Performance then The Man Who Fell To Earth, also with David Bowie, and finally Art Garfunkel in 1980€™s Bad Timing. The previous two utilised musicians are well known for similar affinities toward the performance side of music. Bowie continues to navigate his career in stages of different representation, and Roeg chose to use him when his act was highly theatrical. Mick Jagger has similarly focused his performance, though his is more a craft of the highly captivating rock n€™ roll front man. If there is one thing Garfunkel is known for, being an outward performance artist is absolutely not that thing. Even as recently as a dispute between the main characters in Judd Apatow€™s This Is 40, Art Garfunkel has always been associated with being the background, the support. And yes, in his work with Paul Simon, he usually did provide more of the backing harmony support, while Simon took lead and generally wrote the songs in the first place. Bad Timing, or the sort of over-the-top full title Bad Timing: A Sensual Obsession, has Roeg using Art Garfunkel in a way that smartly puts his reputation to the forefront of his character, allowing for a stirring and explosive performance. Alex Linden is a psychiatrist who appears with paramedics rushing a woman into a hospital after an attempted suicide. Through flashbacks, the film slowly reveals his relationship to the woman and the slowly boiling water that led to this hospital fiasco. This obsessive, controlling psychiatrist is a very complicated character. Linden clearly must be aware of his own deteriorated mental state, even as he plunges further into a black hole of unrelenting abusive behavior. Garfunkel carries out this character with the exact right level of instability. He is so naturally soft spoken and gentle that when his fierce side pushes through it's honestly terrifying.

2. Frank Sinatra in The Manchurian Candidate (1962)

Sinatra championed one of the most recognized singing voices in American music, breaking through the charts with his successful debut album €œThe Voice of Frank Sinatra€. He is arguably remembered most for his music, catchy as hell, and some of the most iconic melodies to date. That being said, Sinatra€™s acting career is no little known experiment. His Oscar nomination for Supporting Actor in From Here To Eternity is among a rather lengthy filmography, which includes the original Ocean€™s Eleven, The Man With the Golden Arm, High Society and Guys and Dolls, where he famously butted heads with Marlon Brando on set. John Frankenheimer€™s The Manchurian Candidate finds Sinatra in the role of a tormented major with re-occurring nightmares that lead him into a mind-bending investigation of his fellow soldier. The film was highly regarded, especially due to the timing of its release at the pinnacle of the Cuban Missile Crisis and only a year before the assassination of John F. Kennedy. Even now the film echoes throughout contemporary stories like Brothers and Homeland. Frank Sinatra€™s performance highly clashes with the code he had carried as an entertainer. The smooth, velvety elegance of his powerful voice is transported here to a shaky fearful speech, ranging in tones from hopeless to panicked. Major Bennett Marco is the leading force in unraveling the tightly wound mystery around what happened in Korea and what has bled back to the United States. He really carries the film along as his main counterpart is continually losing the audience€™s trust. The part is colored by his delightful relationship with Janet Leigh€™s character, who allows for some of the more bright and smooth elements of Sinatra€™s persona to shine through.

1. Bjork in Dancer in the Dark (2000)

Many singers and musicians have found themselves involved with musicals, whether on stage or on screen. This makes sense, as the genre is the most clear synthesis of several major forms of performance, from the aforementioned Cher in the stage version of Silkwood to the beautiful, humble performance from Glen Hansard in Once. Musicals tell visual stories using the power of the song. However, Lars Von Trier aimed to shatter some of the glory typically associated with the musical with his powerful, crushing Dancer in the Dark. A story of an immigrant striving to live happily in the wonderful America she had seen on the silver screen, the film uses the song as an escape from a dark, ugly truth. The truth that is basically everyday life. As unconventional as Dancer in the Dark is, Trier did cast one of the most unique and brilliant vocalist of the time. Bjork€™s portrayal of Selma is heartbreaking and brilliant, as she fails to be crushed by the crippling force of not only being a nearly blind immigrant in the €˜60s, but also how her handicaps allow her to be brutally pushed to a dismal end. Selma is always looking to escape through daydreams of a dazzling Hollywood existence. Bjork succeeds so well in the film because she is so good at showing Selma€™s good intentions, so much that the horrifying second act climax is most tear-jerking because of what will clearly happen to her. Her acting is strengthened by the beautiful musical sequences, where the film takes even the audience to a magical place of hope, despite an everpresent promise to swiftly pull out the rug.