10 Great Horror Anthologies You Need To Watch

These creepy horror sagas are worth a revisit.

By James Egan /

Horror anthologies have played a big part in television and film since the genre's inception, offering a chilling cocktail of fear, suspense, and storytelling variety. 

Advertisement

It must be challenging to condense an entire storyline into a singular segment, but the anthology format lends itself well to gutsy, punchy storytelling that can span multiple themes or be tied together through one overarching narrative. Though any genre can embrace an anthological structure, it's ideal for horror since the constant change in tone and style can catch the biggest horror purists off guard.

Ghost stories, murder mysteries, gothic horror - the anthology horror flick has covered them all, as have horror TV shows, which have in more recent years proven to be the main home for the format rather than the big screen.

These frightening sagas haven't just entertained generations for decades, but showcased cautionary tales and what-if scenarios that provoke intense reflection and critical thought. Their influence stretches beyond mere scares, shaping viewers to reconsider how they perceive reality. 

There have been a slew of horror anthologies over the years, but these 10 entries left the biggest impression.

10. Cat's Eye

Based on the work of Stephen King, Cat's Eye stands out for not just being scary, but nerve-wracking.

Advertisement

The first story revolves around a smoker called Dick Morrison, who joins a tobacco-quitting clinic. After becoming a member, he learns the company will torture or mutilate his family if he smokes a single cigarette. With this in mind, it's unbearable any time Dick feels tempted to light up a cigarette, since the consequences are clear if he gets caught.

In the next segment, a crime boss blackmails a man called Johnny, forcing him to walk around his penthouse ledge. This storyline is vertigo-inducing, since Johnny is sure to end up as a bloody stain on the pavement below if he loses his balance.

In the final chapter, a little troll sneaks into a girl's bedroom and attempts to steal her life-force. Since the child is unable to defend herself, it's up to her trusty cat to save the day. Even though the first two stories have comedic elements, the last one is surprisingly emotional, creating a memorable climax that mixes fantasy with nail-biting suspense.

With a tight runtime, tighter pacing, and a diverse range of stories, Cat's Eye is one underrated anthology worth seeking out.

9. Guillermo Del Toro's Cabinet Of Curiosities

Guillermo del Toro has consistently elevated the horror genre for decades, so it was refreshing when the Mexican filmmaker announced he was helming a horror anthology series called Cabinet of Curiosities.

Advertisement

To ensure his passion project packed a visceral punch, del Toro assembled a talented team of horror writers and directors, including The Babadook's Jennifer Kent, Cube's Vincenzo Natali, and The Empty Man's David Prior.

Even though each episode varies in visual style, tone, and themes, the spine-tingling drama maintains del Toro's traditions, including a gothic aesthetic, a focus on practical effects, and spell-binding creature designs. 

Cabinet of Curiosities opens with del Toro himself cryptically introducing each tale, which is a clear nod to classic horror anthologies like The Twilight Zone or Night Gallery. (It's also worth mentioning del Toro has admitted Night Gallery was the main inspiration for this show.)

Although every episode has something to offer, The Autopsy is worth singling out, since it blends body-horror with Lovecraftian lore in a hauntingly creative way.

Guillermo del Toro's Cabinet of Curiosities may have only lasted eight episodes, but it's managed to leave a lasting mark on the genre.

8. Creepshow

Directed by George A. Romero and written by Stephen King, Creepshow is a masterful anthology in its own right, and also serves as a perfect homage to the '50s comics of the same name. Whether you enjoy (or hate) zombies, bugs, or aliens, there's bound to be something here to freak out the most seasoned horror fans. 

Advertisement

What's impressive about Creepshow is how every person who worked on it gave it their all. Romero's direction is bold and stylised, using vivid colours, dramatic lighting, and comic book transitions to make every visual on-screen pop. Tom Savini’s practical effects work is equally impressive, striking a perfect balance between grotesque and cartoonish.

All the stars are top-notch, especially Ed Harris and Ted Danson. Leslie Nielsen may be renowned for his deadpan humour in the Naked Gun trilogy and Airplane!, but he taps into his dramatic roots for his storyline, proving to be a singularly sinister presence.

King's writing is both playful and unsettling, and his cameo as the hapless Jordy is one of the film's most memorable and endearing performances.

Though Creepshow has spawned several sequels and a TV series, none can compare to the original movie.

7. Body Bags

Directed by horror legends John Carpenter and Tobe Hooper, Body Bags started off as a TV series but was reworked into a three-part movie

Advertisement

The campy flick uses a morgue as a framing device, with Carpenter himself portraying a ghoulish coroner, who serves as Body Bags' host and narrator. The Halloween director comes off as twisted and entertaining, setting the tone for the film immediately. 

In the first chapter, a gas station attendant locks herself in her booth after discovering a psychopath is stalking her. Despite the straightforward premise, this segment works well due to its clever misdirection and satisfying payoff. 

In the second chapter, a vain man finds his life turning upside-down when his hair grows out of control. It sounds silly but the body-horror element makes this storyline profoundly unnerving.

The closing chapter follows a baseball player, gleefully played by Mark Hamill, who develops murderous tendencies after receiving the eye of a serial killer.

The horror elements aren't too gruesome, so Body Bags is great for casual viewing. However, purists should have a blast since Body Bags plays tribute to the genre, especially with the horror cameos from Wes Craven, Sam Raimi, and Roger Corman.

6. Tales From The Crypt

Based on the '50s comic book of the same name, each episode of Tales from the Crypt opens with a ghoul called The Crypt Keeper speaking directly to the audience, displaying his passion for macabre puns. Though the show could function without this bit, the gallows humour sets the tone and builds anticipation for the upcoming story.

Advertisement

Although each episode is suitably petrifying or gross, they're also deeply satisfying. Most of the stories are rooted in poetic justice, with wrongdoers meeting their comeuppance in ironic ways, leaving viewers content by the time the credits roll.

Another reason why Tales from the Crypt stood out is its ability to mesh laughs with scares. The horror-comedy finds the perfect balance between the two, often having a light-hearted moment followed with an unsettling visual, catching viewers off-guard.

The series also boasts an incredible ensemble of guest-stars, including Brad Pitt, Demi Moore, Tom Hanks, John Lithgow, Whoopi Goldberg, Joe Pesci, and Arnold Schwarzenegger (who directed the episode, The Switch).

The quality dwindled in its final years, but the first few seasons have some of the funniest, creepiest, and most imaginative stories the genre has to offer.

5. American Horror Story

Unlike other entries on the list, American Horror Story focuses on a new narrative each season rather than self-contained episodes. Using this format, the creative team had more time to flesh out the ensemble and their conflicts, making it more hard-hitting when things inevitably go to hell (sometimes literally). 

Advertisement

Despite having over a hundred episodes under its belt, American Horror Story stays fresh by utilising a different narrative, setting, and ensemble each season. It also looks at a wide variety of genres, including body-horror, vampires, folk, post-apocalyptic, occult, and slasher. Certain plotlines take things further by utilising innovative structures, like how season six uses a documentary style while season eight does a crossover of the first and third seasons respectively.

Even though there are a few familiar faces, Sarah Paulson, Evan Peters, Jessica Lange, and Kathy Bates deserve special mention. Though these talented stars always bring their A-game, they showcase some of their finest (and most disturbing) work throughout this teeth-chattering drama.

Based on the way it explores social themes and develops twisted character arcs, it's easy to see why American Horror Story is directly responsible for reviving the horror anthology genre in recent years.

4. Dead Of Night (1945)

Though The Outer Limits and The Twilight Zone popularised the horror anthology medium, Dead of Night predates both properties by over a decade. 

Advertisement

Released in 1945, the surreal film opens with an architect called Walter being invited to a country house where he notices he's seen all the occupants before in his dreams. Intrigued by Walter's claim, each guest shares a creepy encounter they've experienced.

Despite the fact anthology films were in their infancy during the 1940s, Dead of Night feels ahead of its time in terms of playing with story structure. Each segment offers a distinct flavour of horror, whether it's gothic, supernatural, haunting, or farcical.

Rather than relying on tropes, Dead of Night cooks up several genuinely creative scenarios. In one story, a man is gifted with a new mirror whose reflection doesn't match his own, slowly driving him mad. 

In another, a swindler called George cheats in a game of golf, causing his opponent, Larry, to take his life. Afterward, George struggles to play golf, since Larry's ghost torments him and calls him a cheater.

Also, anyone with a fear of dummies is sure to be freaked out watching the segment involving the erratic ventriloquist.

Although horror anthologies can feel episodic, each storyline in Dead of Night feels like it's steadily builds to something, making the shocking climax all the more nightmarish.

3. Trick 'R' Treat

Trick 'R' Treat is composed of four stories that focus on the residents of Warren Valley one Halloween night. Each segment captures a different facet of the holiday's lore, including ghost stories, pranks, and honouring traditions.

Advertisement

Rather than keeping the subplots isolated, Trick 'R' Treat interweaves each of the vignettes, creating a seamless overarching narrative. The way every chapter intertwines with another is hinted at, so it's rewarding when you figure out how the plotlines align.

Another reason why Trick 'R' Treat has become a cult-classic is its satisfying plot twists. On top of that, these revelations are subtly telegraphed, so Trick 'R' Treat requires multiple viewings to truly appreciate.

Even though the film embraces tongue-in-cheek humour, it's not afraid to go to some dark places. Many scenes switch from being goofy to tragic in an instant or vice versa. Although this decision could be jarring, it makes the comedic parts funnier and the emotional moments hit harder.

What's most impressive about Trick 'R' Treat is that it doesn't have a weak point. Each cautionary tale knocks it out of the park with its performances, script, violence, fear factor, and memorable ending. For this reason, no Halloween is complete without watching this gem.

2. Black Mirror

In Black Mirror's pilot episode, terrorists order the British Prime minister to have sex with a pig on live television to secure the release of a kidnapped princess. This grotesque premise rattled audiences and instantly set Black Mirror apart as a show unafraid to confront taboo topics. 

Advertisement

Rather than relying on shock value, Charlie Brooker's uber-dark drama puts a major emphasis on sharp writing, powerful performances, and inventive dilemmas. 

Like a fine wine, Black Mirror gets better with age, due to its almost prophetic take on celebrity worship, online outrage, and media sensationalism. Though the earlier episodes explore ideas that initially sounded far-fetched or outright fantastical, they now seem eerily plausible, especially due to recent advances in technology. 

But the main reason why Black Mirror still manages to captivate audiences worldwide is because of its emotional impact. Episodes like Shut Up and Dance, San Junipero, and White Christmas are sure to leave the majority of viewers overwhelmingly uplifted or sick to their stomach for days (or weeks or months).

Even though the best horror anthologies can go downhill, the recent season proves Black Mirror has lost none of its bite.

1. The Twilight Zone

It's hard to comprehend how ahead of its time The Twilight Zone was. During the 1950s, TV writers struggled to tackle social issues due to censor-heavy networks. 

Advertisement

Fortunately, The Twilight Zone's creator, Rod Serling, got around this problem by using science fiction and fantasy elements to analyse controversial topics.

Though episodes involving the Cold War and atomic age anxiety are a product of their time, many storylines are more relevant now than ever, especially the ones centred around social conformity, mob mentalities, and humanity's reliance on technology.

Certain premises are so riveting, they could've worked as pure escapism. Instead, Serling ensured every episode was infused with enough thought-provoking content to leave a lasting impression. The Twilight Zone also does a superb job of highlighting the dangers of humanity without coming across as preachy or ham-fisted.

Also, the last-minute revelations are so jaw-dropping, they often make viewers reevaluate twists from iconic movies. Everybody who lost their minds at the ending of Planet of the Apes, The Prestige, Shutter Island, and The Sixth Sense probably weren't aware that The Twilight Zone executed these twists years earlier.

Although Serling's masterful drama has been repeatedly remade and imitated, few horror anthologies if any can top the original Twilight Zone.

Advertisement