10 Great Horror Movies With Multiple Plot Twists
Well, well, well. How the turntables...
Legendary directors in the vein of Alfred Hitchcock, M. Night Shyamalan and Christopher Nolan have built an indelible legacy for themselves on the back of mastering the art of the twist. However, as with all great cinematic flourishes, there is a fine line to be tread - one convoluted, unnecessary instance can irredeemably tarnish the entire film, let alone an unrelenting series of them.
Indeed, it speaks volumes to the stunning quality of the cinematic bombshells produced by the aforementioned directorial greats, that even on second viewing - and with full knowledge of the twist - the film remains an awe-inspiring spectacle. Indeed, many fans frequently laud the experience of revisiting various movies with the knowledge of the shocking revelation to come as even better than their initial impression.
Science fiction, murky thrillers, gritty action flicks; practically every genre imaginable has utilized this magnificent narrative technique to great effect and horror is no exception. However, while other genres often use it to pull a proverbial rabbit out of the hat and save the day to varying extents, horror typically delights in hurling ferocious curveballs designed to sever the last threads of hope and optimism that viewers have been desperately clinging on to.
Are you watching closely? Things are about to get extremely dark. But in a critically acclaimed sort of way.
10. Sleepy Hollow
While often lost in the endless landslide of Tim Burton horror outings, 1999's Sleepy Hollow remains one of the celebrated director's finest, albeit cheesiest, offerings to date.
Endlessly silly and helmed by a charmingly bumbling performance from Johnny Depp, Sleepy Hollow is a riotous watch. Adapted from Washington Irving's classic short story, the film centers around a malevolent spectral entity terrorizing a town by decapitating members of the populace - the appropriately named Headless Horseman. What appears to be a straight-forward horror fantasy spirals into a spider's web of deceit as Depp's Ichabod Crane investigates the murders further.
Revelations of true identities and unexpected character deaths are an integral aspect of the 106 minute run-time as things are revealed to be far from what they initially seemed. Several culprits - including Crane's love interest Katrina - are mooted as potential suspects for the Horseman's shadowy master, serving only to increase the shock factor when the majority are brutally dispatched.
Burton delivers Sleepy Hollow's final twist with effortless panache when Miranda Richardson's Lady Van Tassel re-emerges, having faked her death. Not only is she the true villainous mastermind behind proceedings, her backstory unveils that she is utterly driven by revenge against the film's two centric families for evicting her family during her childhood.
Fortunately Crane manages to break "Van Tassell's" hold over the Horseman and she is duly carried screaming off to hell. Everybody loves a happy ending.
9. Would You Rather
2012's Would You Rather provides a superb mixture of twists, set against the backdrop of a macabrely disturbing plot. While exhibiting many of the tropes one would associate with a horror crap-fest, David Guy Levy's picture is a relentlessly thrilling watch - unless one is of the squeamish variety.
The first and obvious bombshell is that the "game" set up for various desperate individuals to win cash from a maniacal billionaire may have originally been concocted by Vlad the Impaler. It's still Would You Rather, but would you rather be stabbed with an ice pick or slice open your own eyeball with a razor blade? Protagonist Iris finds herself amongst these nightmarish surroundings attempting to finance an organ transplant for her sick brother.
The movie's twists are entrenched within the character's choices across the course of the contest as they consistently buck the trend of what the audience expects from them. Viewers are introduced to Iris as a wide eyed, moralistic character, making it all the more shocking when she guns down a fellow contestant to ultimately win the Hadean contest. Factor in the soul-destroying murder of the party's apparent savior - delivered in unashamedly jump scare fashion - and it's enough to make one's head spin.
Appropriately, the film saves its abhorrent pièce de résistance for a desolating final discovery. Iris returns home only to find her brother's corpse, having committed suicide to release her from her duty of care.
8. The Cabin In The Woods
As Dana and Marty share a joint, awaiting the impending end of the world in the climactic sequence to 2010's The Cabin in the Woods, one can entirely sympathize. Considering the sheer amount of narrative U-turns the film's plot has taken over the course of 95 insane minutes, choosing to lose one's self in a haze of cannabis smoke seems to be an entirely rational decision.
The Cabin in the Woods is an absolutely maniacal, twist-loaded state of affairs - in the best way possible. The film's initial reveal is that the cabin where five friends gather for a weekend away is actually being controlled by a mysterious laboratory. Things only proceed to get more ludicrously deranged as swathes of monstrous beings are released across the course of the film.
Case in point, the movie somehow features reincarnated zombies and a merman without wildly diverging from the certifiably insane plot line. Matters culminate with the revelation of an ancient ritualistic organization that facilitate human sacrifice in order to appease an apocalyptic set of malevolent entities and prevent them from destroying the world, with the five friends unveiled as carefully selected candidates due to their personalities. This was supposed to be a nice weekend away!
The Cabin in the Woods is a truly bizarre picture. It shouldn't work on paper, but the effortless amalgamation of laugh-out-loud instances of silliness, some legitimately scary moments and the movie's unashamedly over-the-top vibe combine to produce one of the finest horror outings of the 2010's.
7. Saw
Horror fans who love a good curveball against the backdrop of a superb horror film could do far worse than Saw's sadistic maiden voyage. Hell, there's even something for those amongst us who love a literal twist in their fright flicks further down the line - avid fans will remember Saw III's bone mangling rack with a wince.
Returning to the events of the first film, it could be argued that being chained to a pipe in a terrifying decrepit room is an abhorrent bolt from the blue in itself. However, factoring in the introduction of a sadistic masked serial killer and the realization that sawing your own foot off is the only method of escape is an appallingly unexpected series of unfortunate events.
The depraved tale produces one bombshell after another as it unfolds, culminating in an unforgettably macabre climactic sequence. Protagonist Adam finds a tape that reveals purported antagonist Zep as a hapless patsy for Jigsaw, coerced into taking fellow captive Lawrence Gordon's family hostage by the Machiavellian John Kramer.
Kramer appears soon enough in shocking fashion - he has been in the room with the pair all along, disguised as a corpse. Tobin Bell's killer delivers the coup de grâce to the viewer's souls by emotionlessly informing the desolate Adam that he accidentally disposed of his means of escape at the the game's onset - draining the bath he initially found himself in flushed his handcuff keys down the plug.
6. Scream
Wes Craven's 1996 slasher bonanza Scream is universally regarded as having revitalized the flagging slasher genre. Providing a much-needed injection of innovation, originality and a willingness to laugh at some of horror's more outrageous tropes, Scream holds beloved status amongst horror buffs to this day.
The late great Craven's picture is also loaded with twists and turns from start to finish. Indeed, the man who brought audiences Freddy Krueger couldn't even wait until the first scene was over to double-cross his audience for the first time.
Many had assumed that Drew Barrymore, the most widely known and recognizable face amongst the relatively obscure young cast, would take the lead in this bold new picture. However, these fans were ultimately left open-mouthed as Barrymore's Casey Becker was sadistically murdered by Ghostface in one of horror's most iconic opening sequences.
Craven's superlative ability to perform a narrative U-turn remains on full, unashamed display as the film continues. Tatum Riley appeared to be a shoe-in to make it to the climactic showdown, only for Craven to whip the rug out from under his audience once again by gruesomely doing away with Rose McGowan's wildly popular non-final girl.
The legendary director finally caps off his white-knuckle offering in unforgettable style with Scream's immortal final reveal - the murderous Ghostface is actually two separate people, psychotic friends Billy Loomis and Stu Macher.
"I wanna play a game" indeed. This is Craven at his masterful best.
5. Absentia
While mainstream audiences weren't introduced to virtuoso Mike Flanagan until The Haunting of Hill House debuted in 2018, die-hard horror fans have been familiar with the stunning work of the director behind Hush and Midnight Mass since his breath-taking feature length debut, 2011's Absentia.
Absentia's central antagonist is a spectral entity inhabiting a bleak concrete tunnel in front of the house where sisters Callie and Tricia reside. Tricia is in the process of declaring her husband Daniel dead in absentia following his disappearance - she also happens to be pregnant with another man's child.
Considering said disappearance occurred seven years prior, the sisters and the audience get one hell of a shock when Daniel reappears, revealing that he was claimed by the creature. Absentia's monster "trades" with those passing through the tunnel, but entirely on its own terms - one never knows what it will offer up in exchange. The unmasking of the mysterious man who had been depositing animal sacrifices as a desperate son trying to retrieve his father from the creature's clutches constitutes another harrowing twist in itself, but pales in comparison to Absentia's climactic sequence.
After Tricia is abducted by the entity, a desperate Callie offers her own life as a trade, prompting Flanagan to deliver his stunning final curveball. The monster produces Tricia's unborn fetus in exchange - a life for a life - before claiming both sisters in an utterly desolating conclusion.
Not too shabby for a partial allegory of a children's fairytale about three goats and a troll.
4. The Sixth Sense
If you say "plot twist" into a mirror three times, M. Night Shyamalan will appear behind you, bludgeon you to death with one of his multiple Golden Raspberry Awards and inform you that you've actually been dead the entire time.
In all seriousness, any list concerning cinematic twists would be incomplete without a contribution from the man who has made narrative curveballs an intrinsic part of his unique directive style. While many of his films have been critically lambasted - with 2008's The Happening standing as a particularly woeful offering - 1999's The Sixth Sense is acclaimed as one of the greatest films of all time.
A brilliantly nuanced and chilling picture carried by striking performances from a stellar cast, The Sixth Sense is a thriller at heart, making the manner in which Shymalan's picture effortlessly blurs the boundary between the aforementioned genre and that of horror all the more impressive. It doesn't hurt that his movie also happens to be loaded with seismic level revelations from the very first sequence.
The epiphany that young lead Cole really can see "dead people" is just the beginning as the ghosts jarringly take on a benevolent role in proceedings. Loaded with clues that become mini-twists on second viewing, The Sixth Sense's iconic ending - revealing that Bruce Willis' protagonist Malcolm Crowe actually died at in a confrontation at the beginning of the film and has been a ghost all along - is frequently lauded as one of the most memorable bombshells in cinematic history.
3. Black Swan
It speaks volumes to the gripping nature of Black Swan's twists and turns that it is difficult to establish which of them are actually based in reality - such is the mind bending nature of the journey that Darren Aronofsky takes his viewers on across 108 devastating minutes.
One of the visionary director's most celebrated works to this day, the film received a whopping five Oscar nominations after the rave reviews flooded in. With Natalie Portman winning Best Actress for her majestic lead turn as Nina Sayers. Black Swan is frequently lauded as one of the finest outings of the century, let alone for the horror genre.
The hallucinogenic, inconsistent depiction of proceedings never lets up throughout the film. Viewers are left almost subconsciously mirroring Sayers' mental unravelling - a testament to the director's uniquely distortive style. While littered with unexpected moments that leave the audience questioning the veracity of the events unfolding, Nina's apparent murder of Mila Kunis' Lily is Black Swan's pièce de résistance. An indescribably shocking twist in itself, the subsequent reveal that she has actually stabbed herself leaves audience's jaws on the floor.
The viewer is ultimately left unsure as to whether Nina's magnificent final performance came at the cost of her own life. Portman's turn in this sequence is Oscar worthy in itself, an otherworldly capstone on a truly exemplary piece of cinema. Black Swan's final melancholic twist is that it offers no closure to the many torturous questions it poses.
2. Get Out
"You know I can't give you the keys, right babe?"
While his sublime offerings Us and Nope constitute worthy candidates for inclusion on this list, Jordan Peele's magnum opus was always going to win out in the twist centric sweepstakes.
Get Out isn't just one of the greatest horror movies of the 21st century, it's one of the most seminal and inspired examples of filmmaking of all time - an effortless blend of nuanced social commentary and razor sharp wit that sends chills running down the audience's collective spine, while somehow still managing several legitimate laugh-out-loud moments.
A key aspect of Peele's expertly engineered atmosphere of unsettling tension is the manner in which the film's plot drops bombshells upon its audience. The Armitage family's abhorrent practice of transplanting brains into subjugated bodies - allowing for a depraved form of immortality - is duly unveiled before the additional head-spinner that the family's "servants" are actually the grandparents having undergone the procedure.
While both events constitute mind-blowing plot-twists in themselves, the masterful director's finest flourish is the introduction of Rose's true villainous nature. The box of photos unmasking Chris' purportedly loving girlfriend as a sociopathic human honey trap was jarring enough, but her sudden shift to emotionless villain as Chris pleads with her to give him his car keys is one of horror's most memorable twist sequences.
An iconic film groaning with quality and loaded with criss-cross moments from start to finish, Get Out reigns supreme over its contemporaries.
1. Psycho
If you thought that the top spot on this list would be occupied by any other director than the one and only Sir Alfred Hitchcock, hang your head in shame.
The undisputed master of the narrative double cross, the legendary late director turned whipping the rug out from under his audience into a form of art. While Lifeboat and Vertigo's jaw-dropping revelations number amongst the most immortal onscreen curveballs of all time, there can only be one when it comes to discussion of his works in this category.
Pyscho's utilization of false protagonist was unheard of before Hitchcock proceeded to blow the world's collective mind, ferociously disposing of the film's purported lead character Marion Crane while breathing life into a cinematic technique that has been employed to stunning effect time and time again.
However, unmasking Norman Bates as Crane's killer simply wasn't enough for the Master of Suspense. Psycho reveals that Bates' mother - who Marion overheard him arguing with - was murdered by Bates years ago. A psychotic spiral of denial led him to assume her identity, resulting in his murderous, cross dressing alter ego while "Mother's" mummified corpse languishes in the basement - an immortal twist in proceedings that remains endlessly imitated and parodied to this day.
Considering the fact that all of this occurred against the backdrop of 1960 society, it is truly incredible that Psycho still stands as the director's most celebrated work. There have been many visionary directors, but there will never be another Alfred Hitchcock.