10 Great Movie Characters Who Never Really Existed

Our imaginary friends from cinema's past.

By Sam Thorne /

It's a strange thought isn't it? Fictional, within the fictional? All characters in film ultimately don't exist, their just ideas and concepts portrayed by actors. It's a testament to how much we buy into movies both mentally and emotionally that we still separate the two in our heads of whether one is 'real' or not. However throughout the long and diverse timeline of cinema we've seen several imaginary, and non-existent characters that have still managed to entertain us all the same. Sometimes they appear in the form of a bizarre fantasy. Occasionally they are passing ideas conjured by loneliness, a character summoned by a protagonist's need for a friend. In true psychoanalytical style, there's been a long line of schizophrenic and multiple personality characters that are segmented from the original. Most rationally we could liken this to the several layers of subconscious, the id, the ego, the super-ego and the multiple dissected parts that compose a person, or more accurately a character. Join us as we take a glimpse at our imaginary friends from cinema's past, a nostalgic scope to ten great movie characters who never existed.

10. Humphrey Bogart! - Play It Again, Sam

Wait, what? Wait a second, we can explain. Humphrey Bogart is a beloved symbol of an era, a living ode to noir and classic cinema. An embodiment of where cinema was back in the 1940's in its infancy. It's not surprising that contemporary movies and film-makers like to pay homage to classic stars like Humphrey Bogart. In Herbert Ross's satirical comedy Play it Again, Sam (1972) an apparition of ole bogey himself appears to guide and nurture a lost soul (Woody Allen) into his idea of a modern man. Allan Felix is a man lost in contemporary society who doesn't know how to be a man, how to meet a woman or charm her. His obsession with classical cinema, Casablanca (1942) in particular. Allan begins to hallucinate and imagine the image of his favorite star haunting him. His primary function is to help Allan adapt to the world and help him become Bogart's image of manhood. He offers golden nuggets of contextual wisdom, such as 'I never saw a dame yet that didn't understand a good slap in the mouth or a slug from a .45'. Oh Bogey. Jerry Lacy's nostalgic depiction as Bogart is incredibly authentic, and hilarious. Classic.

9. Ivan - The Machinist

Trevor Reznik (Christian Bale) is a sick man. He claims he hasn't slept in a year, and finds it impossible to. He often nods off throughout the day, not really paying attention to the world around him. Trevor is a machinist in a factory where his focus and concentration is needed. A co-worker named Miller loses his hand after Trevor doses off and hits the start button, causing the machine to latch onto Miller's sleeve. Trevor blames the dismemberment on another worker who he claims was distracting him. The worker in question? Ivan. He claimed he works down in the pits, and took a laid position after Reynolds is taken into questioning by the FBI. The large man speaks in a gruff southern accent, and has a clearly immature psyche. He's usually behind a pair of sunglasses, or the wheel of his beautiful Pontiac Firebird. Trevor hunts Ivan after he goes missing, although unsuccessful. He runs the plates on his car to reveal it's a car Trevor claimed destroyed after he trashed it a year ago. Trevor's confused and malnourished mind conjured the ribald apparition Ivan on a subconscious level. Ivan harasses Trevor into facing his demons and how he became the barely liminal being he now is. Ivan is an essential part of The Machinist (2004) who sets the crooked wheels turning in motion for a harrowing story of dementia and suspense. John Sharian plays the big bad man perfectly, though the film itself was lacking.

8. Frank The Rabbit - Donnie Darko

Frank is a rabbit. Well, kind of. He's a delusion of a paranoid schizophrenic in the form of a rabbit. His interests include predicting the apocalypse, teaching teenagers about time travel, and creeping us right the fuck out. Frank isn't the most relevant character immediately, like some other figments and delusions in movies. However, his whole bizarre existence and purpose as it becomes clear is mind-blowing, making Frank a somewhat unforgettable lynch pin of Donnie Darko (2001). As Donnie (Jake Gyllenhaal) learns about time travel, it becomes clear that Frank is not some bizarre fantasy of his come to live, but a badly translated vision of the future. Although the nature of Frank is still debatable, ultimately. Fantasy? Delusion? or simply a vision of the future that foresaw someone's Halloween costume. Either way Frank came and changed Donnie's world, flipped it upside down entirely. Whoever/whatever he was.

7. Wilson - Castaway

Everybody's favorite sporting equipment turned friend at number 7, WILSOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOON! Now, I know 'Wilson' exists, but clearly the 'Wilson' Chuck talks to in the film isn't a volleyball. If you see what I mean? Wilson's a spherical object, traditionally designed for the sport of Volleyball. During his venture, his package is lost, and discovered by a Cast Away (2000) known as Chuck Noland (I only just realized the irony in that). Chuck and Wilson become good friends, as they somehow manage to survive on the secluded haven. Thematically Wilson was conceived when screenwriter of Cast Away William Broyles Jr. purposely stranded himself on an island for a week in order to properly write the script. A volleyball washed up on shore during his time, and thus Wilson was born! Why is Wilson important? Well first of all he was a feasible way of Chuck's character still managing to have dialogue without the need for a second human survivor which would completely alter the film's mood. In addition it kind of epitomizes humankind's versatility and our imagination. Oddly it almost felt like Chuck owed a lot to Wilson. His sanity somehow remained, and we felt a lot of genuine sadness when it came their time to part. Pretty moving stuff, for a volleyball.

6. Parcher - A Beautiful Mind

Parcher is probably one of the more rational of our characters on this list. Parcher is an FBI agent, who gives remarkable code breaker John Nash top level clearance on a secret project detailing soviet threat. However the project gets out of hand as soviet agents begin to trace and hunt Nash and Parcher. Of course this is all in the mind. The film A Beautiful Mind (2001) is loosely based on the real exploits of mathematician John Nash, and his advent to success in spite of his delusions. Parcher is rather convincing and never really felt fictional, until we saw John break down in public. The covert agent played by the talented Ed Harris, packed quite a punch in his enigmatic form. However the appearance of Parcher, and many other imagined characters lack punch because it's resolved quickly, and ultimately the film doesn't really focus on their significance. While our list so far has been characters with brief appearances, our next 5 are some what a bit more impacting...

5. Mother Bates - Psycho

Mother Bates. What's more scary than the doubting glazing of an ill approving mother? It's not so much the character that's great, but the way it's revealed to us. We hear her cackling screech, feel her presence and rarely see her apart from a few tense and terrifying moments. Hitchcock and his eye to attention, and affinity for suspense makes Mother Bates a hell of a character. Obviously there's an element of technicality in this. Mother Bates used to exist, and obviously this persona conjured by Norman technically 'exists'. The mystery unfolds as our protagonists find the dead corpse of Mother rotting in the bates residence. Followed by the insane Norman dressed in her garbs, clutching the trademark knife scornfully. Mother also encapsulates an era in which psychosis and psychology became open for experimentation in the realm of film making. Her influence took Psycho (1960) to heights of great success, and numerous sequels. In fact, she has quite a lot in common with our next character...

4. Mal - Inception

Mal Cobbs is a spectre, a twisted projection of a former loved one. Dominic and his own inner guilt because of Mal's death caused her to manifest his mind in an altered fashion. She causes incredible danger to the mission in Inception (2010) and threatens to destroy several members of the team. Mal is such an efficient character because there's the duality of who the person used to be, and how this mirror image chooses to portray them. All the while it helps develop Dominic Cobbs as a haunted man, while delving deeply into his back story. Many have commented on her likeness to the convention of femme fatales, a certain breed of haunted and dangerous women usually stemming from the world of film noir. In addition the stunning and classic appeal of Marion Cotillard fleshes out the character perfectly. It's the authentic and regretful nature of Mal that makes her existence both sinister, and tearjerking.

3. Delbert Grady - The Shining

The butler is in. Delbert Grady is the former groundskeeper for the Overlook hotel. He preceded Jack Torrence as caretaker turned would-be killer. However, he appears to Jack as a polite butler who mistakenly spills advocaat on Jack during a bizarre and surrealist fantasy in the hotel function room. 'I corrected them, sir! Just as you should to!' he bellows as the cogs slowly turn in Jack's head. Belgrady slaughtered his wife and twin daughters, the latter of which we see wandering around the hotel in apparition form. We assume Belgrady also is a permanent resident of the mansion. Possibly just conjured by Jack's corrupted mind, it's never truly defined. None of that matters. What matters is the punch of his speech and persuasion, and grip over Jack. As Wendy locks Jack in the food storage room. It unlocks mysteriously after a thorough scolding by the good chap which leads us to believe he holds some mystic power. Either way, Delbert Grady is one butler's service I would gladly refuse.

2. Tyler Durden - Fight Club

I know a lot of you are probably shocked at Tyler's appearance at this position, and most likely coined the enigmatic soap salesman as top spot in this list. While I did personally find it a close competition, I did want to shake the status quo a bit too. Brad Pitt plays Tyler Durden in Fight Club (1999). An exciting and unpredictable anarchistic thrill-seeker who plays opposition to Edward Norton's dull and emasculated, nameless narrator. At first it feels like some sort of statement about being freed from the brainwashing in society, not to be downtrodden by consumerism. A small underground eponymous club based upon the idea of pleasure by pain soon turns into an political movement to upturn society. However it soon becomes evident that Tyler Durden is not our nameless protagonist's friend, but actually an alter-ego adopted by his frail psyche in a quest to adopt some personality. Tyler Durden is conquered by Edward Norton's character (much to the chagrin of the audience) as it suggests the two become one and form a functioning human being. Although, it's far too late and Tyler's plan works and his message of anarchy is still sent. A deep, well portrayed character that's endlessly entertaining. Now I wonder who could possibly top that...

1. Keyser Soze - The Usual Suspects

The Devil's greatest trick was convincing the world he never existed. Keyser Soze is a legend, a myth, a ghost story criminals tell each other. It's hard to believe he's any one of those five men pictured above. Someone that powerful, that enigmatic couldn't really exist could they? While I guess this could be seen as stretching the criteria, allow me to be explain. Ultimately someone is Keyser Soze, someone is pulling the strings behind the big bad wolf exterior, and the hear say. In my own eyes the puppet and the puppeteer are completely different beings. However they aren't a scary Turkish warlord, the stuff of nightmares, Satan himself as people claim. The legend and mystery of Keyser Soze is what makes The Usual Suspects (1995) such an unforgettable film. If the facade hadn't been there, it'd have just been a run of the mill crime movie. The yearning to find out who lies behind the mask is what creates the sheer tension, and suspense that's the driving force of the film. Who really is Keyser Soze? well that'd be far too harsh of me to spoil for those who haven't seen The Usual Suspects, though I suspect many of you have. So that concludes our list, and I certainly had fun writing it. Cheers for reading.