10 Great Superman Stories That Could Save The DCEU
You can always count on Big Blue to save the day..
The DC Extended Universe (DCEU) has had a tumultuous time in the cinematic landscape, with its initial approach in creating an MCU-style interconnected universe yielding extremely mixed results in the seven years it has been around.
The franchise's primary mistakes include adopting a downbeat and somber tone that did not mesh well with the characters' sensibilities. In attempts to correct this, it actively undermined its initial endgame and ignored its admittedly sizeable fanbase.
Arguably the character most affected by the DCEU's radical change is Superman. The Man of Steel has a solid actor in Henry Cavill but he and the character are undermined by a dour tone, character development that was all over the place, and a lack of the hopeful, reassuring spirit that made Superman DC's flagship character for decades.
This mishandling of the character has led to three lacklustre films with Supes as the focal point, that just didn't live up to expectations, building an uncertain future for the Man of Tomorrow. However, hope still prevails, as the film iteration of the hero can be brought back from oblivion by adapting some of his most iconic comic stories.
10. Superman: The Dark Side
A fair number of the most unique and captivating stories featuring the Last Son of Krypton are found in the ''Elseworlds'' line of comics, that were prevalent in DC's publishing circuit from the late 90s to early 2000s.
They place their characters in different settings than the norm, as such is the case in the 1998 comic storyline, Superman: The Dark Side.
The story posits the idea of baby Kal-El's ship landing on Apokolips instead of Earth, leading to him being raised by the villainous Darkseid instead of the loving Kents. Naturally, he grows up to become a force for destruction and fear in the name of spreading Darkseid's agenda across the universe.
Eventually, after a visit to Earth, Superman learns of his true heritage and purpose, and seeks to overthrow Darkseid to undo the chaos he has brought onto the cosmos.
This is an interesting ''What If'' scenario that would flip the script on the classic Superman origin story, and would properly introduce audiences to the Fourth World and its expansive lore.
Furthermore, if done right, it could be an interesting spin on a redemption story and reinforce Superman's status as a hope symbol regardless of the setting.
9. For The Man Who Has Everything
Another interesting scenario in the Superman mythos details him hallucinating a scenario where Krypton survived, with an adult Kal-El that was never sent to Earth, and instead had a relatively normal life on his birth planet.
This story is told in sublime form by legendary writer Alan Moore and artist Dave Gibbons, and is considered to be a seminal Superman story.
The comic is relatively light on bombastic action and diverse settings, as it mostly takes place in the Fortress of Solitude and a small section of the imagined Krypton. Similarly, it only features a few heroes and the villain Mongul, but it's so well crafted you wouldn't really notice much of this.
It also gives the Man of Steel a perfect emotional arc, as he gets to spend a brief but touching moment on Krypton where he is a normal man with a family -courtesy of the hypnotic Black Mercy plant.
Moore is infamous for disliking adaptations of his work, so DCEU filmmakers may need to tread lightly as they bring this story to life. However, with the right cast as well as respect for the comic's spirit, the creative team may craft a unique and emotionally driven look into Superman lore.
8. New Krypton
This 2008 comic, penned by Geoff Johns and drawn by Alex Ross, is a bold and imaginative story that places Superman in a moral quandary due to his allegiance to his adopted homeworld, and the titular remnants of his birth planet.
Following an encounter with Brainiac (that will be touched on in a later entry), Superman manages to restore Kandor City to its original size, and relocates it to the North Pole.
The presence of 100,000 superpowered Kryptonians on Earth unsettles human governments.
Despite the initiation of diplomatic ties between the two worlds, interference by Lex Luthor and a collection of Superman villains leads to the Kryptonians leaving Earth, creating their own planet using Brainiac's technology.
Adapting such a story would give the DCEU a chance to explore and flesh out Kryptonian society with a level of depth that was only hinted at in Man of Steel.
In addition to this, Superman's torn allegiance between his two worlds could lead to compelling character work for the actor that will don the cape and tights.
7. Superman: Red Son
Author Mark Millar's pitch for this story is so incredibly intriguing and full of potential that it's strange that there's been no live-action adaptation of the Man of Steel's exploits in the Soviet Union.
Red Son explores this premise with admirable gusto and introduces radical changes that would take the DCEU to new creative heights.
Superman is reimagined as the ''champion of the common worker, who fights a never-ending battle for Stalin, socialism and the international expansion of the Warsaw pact''. He has traces of his more traditional heroic persona, but also has the capacity to be substantially more ruthless than our conventional Man of Steel.
DC mainstays such as Lois Lane, Lex Luthor, Batman, Wonder Woman, and Green Lantern are also radically reimagined, and cinematic adaptations of these characters would be unlike their previous incarnations.
The story's era and setting means that the superhero genre would be gifted with another period piece, that is thankfully not predominantly set in New York or a New York stand-in.
6. Must There Be A Superman?
This 1967 story is rather brief compared to the more sprawling multi-issue arcs on this list, but it is one of the more contemplative stories to feature the Man of Steel in a leading role.
Following an intergalactic rescue of an alien pod, Superman is taken to Oa by the Guardians of the Universe and shown that his rescues are interfering with humanity's natural progress through time.
Shaken to the core, the hero makes his way back and reevaluates his role in human history. He comes to a conclusion following the rescue of laborers in California and realizes that he should intervene in large scale disasters beyond human control and leave more morally driven issues to humanity.
The idea of questioning Superman's role in the world has been done before in cinema, but an adaptation of this storyline would further explore that question. It would also give the Man of Steel a chance to reflect on his (admittedly self-appointed) role as Earth's protector in a way we haven't seen on the big screen quite the same.
5. Brainiac
The Man of Tomorrow has a diverse catalog of villains to choose from, and it is unfortunate that filmmakers resort to using only Lex Luthor and General Zod to act as antagonists in his films.
However, this can be easily rectified by bringing this 2008 comic arc to life, and introducing one of the more chilling comic book villains with.
A cinematic adaptation would obviously need to be standalone, to allow for various plot points - such as the introduction of Supergirl and death of Jonathan Kent - to breathe without having to stick to the already existing DCEU lore.
This would be worth it, however, as in exchange it would introduce a villain that not only can match Superman in strength and firepower, but also completely outclasses him in intellect, a combination yet to be seen on the big screen.
The scale of the story would be massive in scope and would introduce new worlds (mostly inside Brainiac's ship) for filmmakers to play with.
In addition to a larger scale, the film would be more fast-paced than previous Superman films, due to the race against time component of attempting to stop Brainiac's plan of shrinking the Earth, giving the film a real sense of urgency.
4. Whatever Happened To The Man Of Tomorrow?
Most comic-book inspired franchises are criticised for their lack of finality in their stories (due to that sweet, sweet franchise revenue) but this has been rectified in recent years due to films such as Logan and Avengers: Endgame.
A film adaptation of the classic Superman tale ''Whatever Happened to the Man of Tomorrow has the potential to join the ranks of the aforementioned 'final films'.
The story sees Lois Lane being interviewed ten years after the last appearance of Superman. She recounts the exposure of his secret identity, the ensuing attacks on his loved ones by his foes and his final standoff before disappearing into the frozen wasteland surrounding the Fortress of Solitude.
The film's cast of characters would be unlike anything seen in a Superman film before, and the large assortment of villains would push the Man of Steel to his limits and beyond in a way rarely seen on the silver screen. It could also give the character a sense of finality, should Henry Cavill ever choose to hang the cape and boots.
3. What's So Funny About Truth, Justice And The American Way?
One criticism that Superman often faces is his seemingly infallible nature and black and white mentality in a world that is seen to be more morally complex than his ''simplistic view''.
This is even seen in the DCEU as the filmmakers initially chose to make Superman a morally burdened character who almost constantly struggles with his heroic responsibility.
A perfect response to this criticism is the adaptation of the excellent 2001 story written by Joe Kelly.
The story introduces the Elite, a group of incredibly powerful but violent individuals. The hero and the anti-hero team clash over their contrasting ideologies, and these differences lead to a spectacular clash on one of Jupiter's moons. We sees Superman supposedly use more brutal force than usual, emphasising the importance of restraint, and the dangers of lethal force being employed by such powerful beings.
This story is an excellent highlight of Superman's restraint (something is missing in the recent incarnation of the character) and his unwavering belief in a more idealistic and optimistic point of view for the world he protects.
2. Superman: Secret Identity
Superhero films are gradually becoming more self-aware of classic tropes, and the Deadpool series has shown and popularised the potential of a tongue-in-cheek approach to superhero storytelling. This meta approach to storytelling can be used in a more reflective, but equally entertaining manner.
Enter Superman: Secret Identity, a 2004 story by Kurt Busiek that chronicles the life of a young man named Clark Kent who lives in a world where DC superheroes merely exist in comics and other media.
Following years of teasing due to his name, he suddenly discovers that he has powers similar to that of his namesake and chooses to use them to protect lives, but in a covert manner.
The story is very low-key compared to other Superman tales, and is light on action and more otherworldly elements that define the Man of Steel's adventures.
However, it makes up for this with its clever writing, creative visuals and more thoughtful characterisation of the hero as he tries to live a normal life while still using his amazing gifts for good.
1. All-Star Superman
Often considered to be one of the best, if not the very best Superman story ever told, All-Star Superman is a love letter to the Kryptonian hero's mythology and everything he stands for and protects. It even wears the character's more outlandish elements (such as Bizarro World) as a badge of honour.
Following the rescue of a crew engaged in the exploration of the Sun, Superman is exposed to dangerous levels of solar radiation that will lead to his untimely demise.
However, impending death will not slow the Man of Steel as he seeks to improve the lives of those he loves, humanity as well as a handful of Kryptonian survivors before he passes on.
The story was adapted into a direct-to-DVD film in 2011 and while it was enjoyable and well-animated, the 75-minute runtime really held it back, a disadvantage that a feature-length will not have.
A faithful adaptation of the comic will be unlike anything most audiences have seen in a superhero film, with weird but wonderful visuals, expansive worldbuilding amid an inspiring tale of a man that will not let his mortality stop his heroic exploits.