10 Highly Questionable Actions Committed By George Lucas
There are not too many people in the movie industry who are as equally loved and derided as George Lucas. As an up-and-coming filmmaker, George Lucas was part of the American New Wave (aka New Hollywood) that burst out during the late 1960s and 70s, which also included contemporaries such as Steven Spielberg, Francis Ford Coppola, and Martin Scorsese. While attending the University of Southern California (USC), George Lucas became fascinated with the form of cinema itself and worked on numerous short films that were extremely experimental. Many of these films lacked story or character and instead focused on visuals and creating pure emotions with the form. It was a far cry from the endless merchandising of movie memorabilia that he is partially known for today.
After graduating from USC, he made two excellent films: THX 1138 (a futuristic science fiction movie) and American Graffiti (a coming-of-age story set in the early 1960s). These works came from a man who was young, hungry, and full of energy. Then came the career-defining movie in the form of Star Wars. This movie changed the idea of what a Hollywood blockbuster could be and spawned one of the biggest cult followings in the world. From there, things seemed to go downhill.
In contemporary times, George Lucas has gained the reputation of being a money-hungry man who has completely lost touch with his former self. While the original Star Wars trilogy (Episodes IV-VI) is still highly regarded, many think George Lucas has undone his legacy by creating a prequel trilogy of Star Wars Episodes I-III. Over the years, George has made some very curious decisions that have puzzled and angered fans - to the point that a documentary titled The People vs. George Lucas was produced. Lets take a look at some of these highly questionable actions George Lucas has made in his lifetime.
10. Making A Sequel To American Graffiti
The first American Graffiti is somewhat of an American classic. It was highly entertaining, relatable and above all else, seemed very honest with the emotions it portrayed. The film still holds up to this day and was the first big success for George Lucas, bringing in over $115 million at the box office. It made a star out of Ron Howard and Candy Clark, plus featured Harrison Ford and Richard Dreyfuss in early roles before they hit it big. But did you know that there was a sequel to American Graffiti?
The unpleasant truth is that there IS indeed another movie. More American Graffiti was an unnecessary sequel executive produced by George Lucas as an attempt to cash in on the originals success (what, you thought unnecessary sequels were a modern trend?). American Graffiti was a great film that stood on its own and managed to capture lightning in a bottle; more American Graffiti is a sloppy, boring, nearly unwatchable imitation that has thankfully been all but forgotten in the history of cinema. The fact that it only made a mere fraction ($8 million) of the originals box office gross ensured that a third film would never, ever be made.
9. Howard the Duck
Howard the Duck sprung to life as a character introduced through Marvel comics in the 1970s and was known for his stories which operated as biting satire and subversive commentary on how we live life. It has been described as an existential character that gives a different point of view to everyday things, bringing them to the forefront by joking about them. Leave it up to George Lucas to completely miss this point when doing a movie adaptation of this comic series.
George Lucas stepped down as president of Lucasfilm in order to focus all of his energy on producing films with Howard the Duck being one of the first after this decision. Although several other producers wanted Howard the Duck to be an animated film, George Lucas ultimately suggested shooting it in live action so that Industrial Light and Magic could do the special effects for it (and partially because of contract stipulations). This is unfortunate because it would have worked waaaay better with animation; instead, we get a highly unconvincing duck suit with over-dubbed dialogue that hardly ever matches up with Howards mouth.
This was just the tip of the iceberg though as Howard the Duck suffers under pretty much every category. The script is terrible, filled with unfunny humor and completely neglecting the distinctive elements that made Howard the Duck such a great comic series. The acting is cheesy and uninspired and the tone is all over the place- thanks to a director who had no idea what to do with this material. Howard the Duck was a huge bomb for George and friends to the point that just about everyone who worked on the picture tried their best to distance themselves from it. Everyone, of course, except for George, who thought the film was harshly judged and would be seen as a great film over time.
8. Re-releasing The Phantom Menace in 3D
George Lucas is known for coming up with a million ways to milk the living hell out of a single movie. Some may see it as a series of business-savvy moves while others see it as exploitation of a fan base for fast cash. One of the most questionable decisions of recent time would have to be the decision to post-convert all 6 Star Wars films into 3D and re-release each one back into theaters.
Instead of starting with the original trilogy, however, George decided to go in Episode order, which meant fans would have to wait through Episodes I-III in order to get to the real movies that they would potentially like to see in 3D. So the first 3D Star Wars film released was The Phantom Menace, a film that many deem to be the worst of the entire series. Yes, that means fans were dazzled with in-your-face images of Jar Jar Binks and a whiny Anakin Skywalker for more than 2 hours.
Viewers knew what was up and largely avoided it, causing the box office earnings of the re-release to be very underwhelming. After Disney bought Lucasfilm in October 2012, all plans were halted regarding these 3D post conversions. Hopefully, these plans will never be revived. And speaking of Jar Jar Binks...
7. Jar Jar Binks
Do I have to really explain this one? Alright, in case you have devoutly steered clear of the prequels (I commend you!) Jar Jar Binks was a brand new character created by George Lucas who first appeared in Star Wars - Episode I: The Phantom Menace. Not only was he a new character but a heavily featured one at that, popping up in half of the scenes. And man, he has to be one of the most annoying characters in cinematic history.
Jar Jar Binks sole purpose is to provide comic relief to the film...or at least, George Lucas idea of comedy. So as we watch our heroes navigate through the narrative plot, Jar Jar is on hand to trip over things, make loud noises and overall, just screw things up. The characters find him grotesquely annoying and hey, guess what? So do we! He doesnt serve much of a purpose and seems to have been created as a way to appeal to toddlers, the only possible type of humans that could find Jar Jar entertaining.
On top of that, many perceived Jar Jar Binks to be a tad bit racist with many of his mannerisms similar to negative racial stereotypes. The way he talks in the movie is eerily similar to caricatures in the old minstrel shows. Thankfully, George Lucas got the message and cut down Jar Jars role in both Episode II: Attack of the Clones and Episode III: Revenge of the Sith.
6. Casting Hayden Christensen
When the Star Wars prequels were announced, a big question on everyones mind was Who would play the role of Anakin Skywalker, future Darth Vader?. It is the central role that the prequels revolve around and quite possibly the most interesting facet about them. So obviously, this is a huge role that every actor in Hollywood would absolutely kill for, the role of a lifetime for many.
Episode I centered on Anakin as a child and went to Jake Lloyd, who did about as well as he could possibly do given the source material and the fact that it was shot mostly with green screen. But for Episodes II and III, the anticipation was a lot higher since the character would be older and thus, may have a star attached to it. When Hayden Christensen was announced, the world uttered a collective WHO?! that possibly caused several earthquakes and tsunamis. For a relatively unknown actor to take such an iconic and highly sought-after role, you must really have some chops. What we saw on the screen was the opposite of chops.
Haydens performances have been highly panned and rightfully so when you catch even 5 minutes of him as Anakin Skywalker. Hayden is extremely awkward in the role and spews Home Depot-level amounts of wooden acting. His motivations seem inconsistent at times, as if he doesnt know what it is that he is supposed to be doing or feeling. His line readings seem as if he is reading from a teleprompter right outside of the shot. Did he memorize any of the script?
What exactly did George Lucas and his creative team see in him that they couldnt see in ANY of the other actors they auditioned? To be fair though, much of this may be the fault of George given that it is his job as director to shape the performances to exactly how he sees fit. I guess George was too busy playing with his shiny new toys and didnt have the time distract himself with such trivial things as acting.
5. Nuking The Fridge
When Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull was announced, you can bet that millions of fans were excited by the announcement. It had been 19 years since the last Indiana Jones movie and the fan base had never dwindled throughout the years. George Lucas was back on board and tasked with producing a story (more on that later) with Harrison Ford reprising the iconic role and Steven Spielberg directing once again.
When the film came out, critics seemed to go for it while fans were split on the matter. While many facets of the movie have been argued for and against, there is one criticism that is almost universally derided: nuking the fridge. This refers to a scene that has been so lambasted, it is now a modern phrase akin to jump the shark. In the scene, Indiana Jones finds himself at a nuclear testing area and is able to survive an atomic blast by hopping inside a refrigerator. The refrigerator flies up into the sky and crashes down with a 70-year-old Indiana in tip-top shape.
Although Steven Spielberg has tried to take the blame for this scene, George Lucas himself has stated that it was an idea of his that goes back years and years. Too bad Steven didnt just say No to the entire movie.
4. Shooting The Prequels Mostly With Green Screen
George Lucas has always been a proponent of technology, especially when it comes to visual effects. The original Star Wars trilogy certainly moved the baton forward when it comes to effects work, much of which holds up to this day. George has often said that he put off doing Episodes I-III because he was waiting for technology to catch up to his vision. When the realness of CGI finally reached his standards, he moved forward with the prequel trilogy and viewers were curious as to what he would do with all of this new technology.
Well, what we got was essentially devoid of real sets and, sometimes even, characters. George used green screen for the bulk of the movies, opting to digitally create locations, vehicles, and everything else. By doing this, George took away much of the believability of the original trilogy. We are almost always painfully aware that we are staring at rendered models of things instead of thinking Wow, Jabba the Hutt looks grotesque!. And you had better believe this affected performances. It is a lot harder for actors to interact with people they cant see, or run from something that doesnt exist. Yes, it is an actors job to make the imaginary seem real but having something tangible to work with truly does wonders for being in the moment.
To me, the heavy reliance on green screen reeks of laziness. Instead of having to travel around and get back into the swing of, you know, actually MAKING a movie, George thought it would be just as good if they shot in front of green walls and have the computer geeks take care of it.
3. Greedo Shooting First
Han Solo is one of THE most famous movie characters of all time. While Luke Skywalker is the more pure character that we follow, Han Solo is more of the rebel anti-hero type. He is a bit of a criminal and walks his own path (hence, the name) and this unpredictable nature of his personality is what makes him such an intriguing person. This is established in a scene where Greedo (working for Jabba the Hutt) meets Han Solo in order to take him back to Jabba regarding some money than Han owes to him. As they talk, Greedo raises his blaster at Han, getting ready to kill him when, suddenly, Han shoots him first. This is how the scene plays in the initial theatrical release of Star Wars Episode IV.
What fans saw in the later home video releases of the original Star Wars movie was entirely different. George Lucas went back and digitally edited the scene to show Greedo shooting at Han Solo first and completely missing, with Han shooting back in self-defense. This presents Hans character in a different light and takes away from the the mystery of his personality, making him more like Luke than his own person. In defense, George made the claim that he intended Greedo to shoot first all along and that the theatrical version of the scene was edited in a confusing way that made audiences THINK Han shot first. If you watch the original scene though, it seems pretty clear.
It was a questionable act on Georges part because the scene was perfectly fine as it was. Even if George truly wanted Greedo to shoot first (which no one is buying), the erroneous editing presented a scene that played much better than George originally intended. Why undo all of that?
2. The Story From Indiana Jones And The Kingdom Of The Crystal Skull
Out of all the Indiana Jones movies, The Kingdom Of The Crystal Skull has arguably the worst story and you can send a Thank You card to George Lucas for that. Fresh out of ideas after making the third Indiana Jones movie, George was stumped with where to take the story. Eventually, after several years of brainstorming, George Lucas came up with the idea to move the series forward into the 1950s and give it a tone more akin to the science fiction films of that era. What could be better than aliens crossing over into the world of Indiana Jones?
As you would expect, Harrison Ford and Steven Spielberg were not very pleased with this idea when it was first presented to them in the early 90s. The problem is mostly related to the fact that Indiana Jones was a character born out of the adventure serials that played in the 1930s. Therefore, the first 3 Indiana Jones movies had a style and tone that firmly placed them in line with that era. The 1950s sci-fi movies have their own distinguishable features with stories that operate very differently than pure adventure serials. With that said, it is certainly possible to cross the two provided that you make the science fiction elements feel real and vital in the world of Indiana Jones, which requires a bit of restraint.
George Lucas is not known for restraint. Instead, he went overboard with the story, focusing on crystal alien skulls that could provide psychic powers, which the Russians desperately wanted. At a certain point (SPOILER ALERT) the aliens actually show up in the movie and we see a damn UFO rise up and leave. Its jarring because it never really feels like it belongs in the world of Indiana Jones. If George could have found a different way to incorporate these sci-fi themes, it could have been successful but as it is currently, it is a ridiculous and muddled mess.
Oh yeah, we also had Shia LaBeouf swinging on vines like a monkey. Just take a few minutes to process what I said there.
1. Re-Editing Of The Original Star Wars Trilogy
Lets face it: Star Wars Episodes IV-VI rank as one of the most beloved trio of films in movie history. These films have changed the lives of many people throughout several decades and has spread throughout the culture in a huge way. Star Wars is something that has been used to connect people together, from father to son, mother to daughter, lover to lover (look up Star Wars wedding just to get an idea of this). Naturally, when someone toys with these films, it is going to cause outrage by those who hold them dearly to their hearts...and it hurts even more when this tampering is performed by the creator.
Over the years, George Lucas has revisited the original Star Wars trilogy (and to some extend, the new trilogy) and changed dozens of different things. Some of them are small (such as brightening the color of the sun in a shot) while others have completely changed the way we view a particular character (see #3 on this list). Most people agree, however, that these changes are trivial and unnecessary. I would go as far as to say that many are distracting, especially when it comes to the new CGI that has been placed in the older films. Im not sure if he is just bored at this time in his life or if he needs to excuses to justify special edition releases (or both) but its something that seems like it will never end. Even in the blu-ray release of all 6 Star Wars films less than 2 years ago, a handful of things were changed that did nothing to better the films.
Its a shame because when it comes to the legacy that George Lucas leaves behind, many fans may remember him more for ruining the pure Star Wars experience instead of letting the movies shine brightly in their original forms.
Ryan Estabrooks is a film writer/director and photographer. When he is not busy solving mysteries, he can be found working on his feature length film. You can view all of his work at the imaginatively-titled RyanEstabrooks.com