10 Horror Actors Forced Into Roles They Never Wanted

Wesley Snipes REALLY wasn't happy about Blade Trinity...

By Paolo Carlos /

The horror genre has produced some of the finest films in the movie industry, such as The Silence of the Lambs, Halloween, Psycho, and more. With the medium being so prolific and most of these being huge money-makers, you'd think that any actor would take the chance to be a part of movies like these. But sometimes, not every performer is keen on doing horror films and is forced to do so for two main reasons.

Advertisement

The first and obvious reason is money. While these thespians might find the material poor or below them, even the most reluctant actor can be bought at the right price.

The second and last is due to contractual obligations. Some actors sign multi-picture deals for studios which means they'll have to appear in the film whether they like it or not.

Now both of these reasons can be a huge pain for these big stars and can potentially affect their performances. While some may get through making these movies, others clearly show their disdain. One thing for sure, though, is that the following ten actors did not want to be in their respective projects.

10. Jamie Lee Curtis - Halloween: Resurrection

1998's Halloween H20: 20 Years Later was the triumphant return of Laurie Strode. After being absent since its third installment, Jamie Lee Curtis came back to the series and had a proper send-off by decapitating Michael Myers at the end of the film.

Advertisement

Unfortunately for Curtis, the producers had no plans of stopping the series, as four years later, Halloween: Resurrection retconned the previous installment to explain The Shape's survival.

The actress hated this idea, feeling that her character had a satisfying ending to the previous film. But because she was under contract, she was forced to participate in this dud of a movie. She did, however, make one demand and that was to kill Laurie in the opening. Her request was granted by the filmmakers and our iconic final girl was thrown off a rooftop by Michael Myers.

And who could blame her for wanting out, as Resurrection is considered one of the low points of the franchise, with infamous scenes like Busta Rhymes fighting The Shape.

Of course, Laurie's death would eventually be undone when Jamie Lee Curtis came back in Halloween (2018) and kickstarted a new trilogy.

9. Rooney Mara - A Nightmare On Elm Street (2010)

The character of Nancy is considered one of the most recognizable aspects of A Nightmare On Elm Street. Played by Heather Langenkamp in the 1984 original, she was the first person to beat Freddy Krueger. The actress would then reprise the role in A Nightmare On Elm Street 3: Dream Warriors and play herself in Wes Craven's New Nightmare.

Advertisement

So, when the time came for the 2010 Elm Street remake, you'd think that getting the part of Nancy would be a huge honor. Rooney Mara thought otherwise.

The future Oscar-nominated actress took on the role of Nancy in one of her first mainstream performances. She later admitted, however, that she did not want the part and even tried to sabotage her audition. Her attempts failed because her screen test impressed the filmmakers and earned her the role.

Upon viewing A Nightmare on Elm Street (2010), you can really tell that Mara really didn't want to be there. While actors like Jackie Earle Haley and Kyle Gallner are doing their best with the material, Rooney Mara occasionally sounds bored and phones in most of her lines.

8. Bruce Willis - The Sixth Sense

The Sixth Sense is one of Bruce Willis' most beloved films and launched M. Night Shyamalan's career into the stratosphere. The movie features numerous scares and its twist is considered one of the best of all time, even today. But what some of you may not know is that Willis was only forced to take this role as part of a deal with the Walt Disney Company.

Advertisement

You see, the Hollywood icon was slated to make Broadway Brawler but was allegedly dissatisfied with the crew and even brought in a new filmmaker to replace director Lee Grant. This ultimately ended with the production folding due to half of its large budget being spent.

Willis' actions angered the House of Mouse and he almost faced a $17.5 million lawsuit. To make up for the lost money, the actor was forced to take a three-picture deal with Disney as well as a reduced salary.

The first was 1998's Armageddon, then The Sixth Sense in 1999, and finally The Kid in 2000. Ironically, this means that Willis' bad behavior was rewarded by giving him three hit movies.

7. Christopher Lee - Dracula: Prince Of Darkness

Christopher Lee was one of the most prolific actors in the film industry. Though younger viewers may know him as Count Dooku and Saruman The White, Lee first started off with his decorated military service, spy work, and as a Nazi Hunter. And if that wasn't impressive enough, Lee then transitioned to acting where he collected numerous iconic roles.

Advertisement

One of his earlier ones was Count Dracula during his work with Hammer Films where he lived up to the legacy left behind by screen legend Bela Lugosi. But in Dracula: Prince of Darkness and its subsequent follow-ups, Lee was forced by Hammer to continue as the Count.

For Prince of Darkness, he found the dialogue rubbish, so as a compromise, Dracula had no lines in the film. Lee would even recount that Hammer virtually blackmailed him into reprising the role despite his intentions not to. He said that whenever he didn't want to do another one, the president of Hammer Films would remind him of the people he'd put out of work should he not come back.

This emotional blackmail worked as Christopher Lee would play Dracula seven times from 1958 to 1973.

6. Linda Blair - Exorcist II: The Heretic

The Exorcist was a star-making role for child actress Linda Blair. Her turn as the possessed Regan terrified audiences everywhere and helped the film become the classic it is today. Naturally, Hollywood wanted more of this, hence the sequel, Exorcist II: The Heretic.

Advertisement

Now, both Linda Blair and Ellen Burstyn refused to reprise their roles for this follow-up, feeling that a sequel was a terrible idea. The former, however, eventually relented upon receiving a script she deemed worthy of the original. Blair would later sign on to the film but would regret that decision due to the screenplay undergoing numerous rewrites. By the time she realized how much of a mess the script was, the actress could no longer back out due to her contractual obligation.

If being forced to do The Heretic was bad enough, Blair was also put on the side of a skyscraper without the use of a stunt double during one of the film's sequences. So, not only was she forced to be part of a terrible sequel, but she also had to risk her life to film it.

Understandably, Blair would later call the film "the biggest disappointment in [her] career".

5. Wesley Snipes - Blade: Trinity

In 1998, Blade was released in theatres and started the Marvel Age of Cinema. Wesley Snipes made the title role his own and reprised it four years later in Guillermo del Toro's Blade II. But by the time the third installment, Blade: Trinity, came around, the actor was none too pleased about returning.

Advertisement

His big issue was series writer David S. Goyer taking the director's chair. Snipes was a co-producer on the film and felt that Goyer's hiring was a decision made without his approval. But because he was producing the movie and putting his own money into it, the actor had to participate in the film but became notorious for his on-set behavior.

Snipes refused to interact with his co-stars, changed sequences on a whim, and even had to be digitally altered as he refused to open his eyes in one scene. Even during rare occasions where he'd acknowledge the cast and crew, he only communicated through post-it notes and only replied when he was called 'Blade.'

Things got so bad that, in 2005, Wesley Snipes sued the studio and Goyer, whom he claims cut him out of the filmmaking process and did not pay him the salary he was owed. He also blamed the casting of Ryan Reynolds and Jessica Biel for reducing his screen time.

4. Roy Scheider - Jaws 2

Jaws is one of the most recognizable motion pictures out there. The killer shark, fantastic cast, Spielberg's direction, and the iconic theme, all came together to make a bona fide hit. With success like this, Universal Studios wanted to capture the lightning in the bottle of the original by making Jaws 2. Though Steven Spielberg and Richard Dreyfuss did not return, the film did get lead actor Roy Scheider back.

Advertisement

How they got him back, however, is a different story.

The actor had recently left the production of The Deer Hunter, which was a big project for the studio. This presented problems for Scheider as he was locked into a multi-picture deal contract with Universal and, in order to make it up to them, he was signed on to Jaws 2 whether he liked it or not. Naturally, Scheider was none too happy with this and even pleaded insanity just to not be in the movie, but to no avail.

Even during production, trouble would start as the actor and director Jeannot Szwarc clashed on multiple occasions, which even led to a physical confrontation. Still, kudos to Roy Scheider as, despite his heavy reluctance, he does manage to bring gravitas in Jaws 2, and is the best part of the movie.

3. Sigourney Weaver - Alien 3

Sigourney Weaver as Ellen Ripley is one of the most iconic final girls in horror history. Having played the role in 1979's Alien, she eventually gained an Academy Award nomination for Best Actress when she returned in 1986's Aliens, a rare feat in the sci-fi genre.

Advertisement

But by the time Alien 3 was announced, it seemed that Weaver had no interest in returning to the role.

When plans for the film started, scripts were made to explain Ripley's absence, as one of the writers explained that Sigourney Weaver did not want to come back. The first and most popular script, written by cyberpunk author William Gibson, put Corporal Hicks in the lead role while Ripley spends most of the film in a coma. Eric Red's version of Alien 3 kills our final girl off-screen, while David Twohy's does not even feature her at all.

Eventually, Vincent Ward's story for Alien 3 would become the basis of that threequel, while 20th Century Fox convinced a very reluctant Weaver to come back with a hefty sum of $4 million as well as a co-producer credit. Though she only came back for the money, the actress gave the character a poignant conclusion, fitting for the series.

2. Betsy Palmer - Friday The 13th

Friday the 13th spawned numerous sequels, crossovers, and video games with Jason Voorhees becoming inducted into the pantheon of famous horror movie slashers.

Advertisement

But longtime fans of the series know that in the original installment, Jason was not the killer at all. Instead, it was Pamela Voorhees, played by Betsy Palmer, who sought to keep Camp Crystal Lake closed after the death of her son.

While Mrs. Voorhees is one of the rare female villains in the genre, her actress actually thought little of the project. She did not like the film's script, called it, "a piece of sh*t", and even threw it into the trash. She'd later admit in interviews that she only took the role because she desperately wanted a new car and believed that Friday the 13th would disappear into the annals of history.

Of course, the movie was a huge hit and Palmer became synonymous with the role of Mrs. Voorhees, even returning to film a cameo in Friday the 13th Part II. And while she had low regard for the film, Betsy Palmer eventually warmed up and appeared in conventions and documentaries to talk about the experience.

1. The Cast - The Island Of Dr. Moreau

The production of 1996's The Island of Dr. Moreau was a nightmare, to say the least. Director Richard Stanley was fired and replaced by John Frankenheimer, which led to numerous clashes with the cast and crew. But before filming even began, it seemed that most of its stars were not happy to do the project.

Advertisement

First, there was Marlon Brando, who was the reason why most of the cast signed on. The legendary actor was dealing with his daughter's suicide at the time but could not back out after signing on to do the picture. He also refused to memorize his lines, speaking them only through a radio transmitter.

Then there's Fairuza Balk, who had grown close with the film's original director. After he was sacked, the actress was furious and attempted to leave the project. She only came back upon her agent warning her that her decision would cause her to be blacklisted from Hollywood.

Finally, Val Kilmer was going through a divorce and was not satisfied with the creative direction of the film. But because of the success of Batman Forever, the studio didn't want to let him go and so he was forced to participate due to his contractual obligation.

Advertisement