10 Horror Movie Sequels You Probably Didn't Know Existed

And after watching some them you'll wish it stayed that way.

By Dan Lauder /

It feels like we've been talking about the movie businesses predilection for making sequels since the dawn of time. Every year it feels like there are more and more sequels to successful movies being made, and for good reason.

Advertisement

If you have a successful movie on your hands that made a ton of money, wouldn't you want to make another one to make a ton more money? Of course you would, because everyone likes money.

However, the fact of the matter is, a lot of sequels are pants, and this is no clearer anywhere than in the horror genre. Sure there are exceptions, Annabelle: Creation was a significantly better film than Annabelle, but these are usually few and far between.

Every so often you'll find a sequel made to a film you'd either never expect to get one, or a sequel so bad that they try to forget the fact it even exists. Can you imagine a fate worse than that?

Well, there is one: creating something so bad barely anybody even knows it's actually a thing. It happens, and though not all the sequels on this list are actually awful, many will leave you scratching your head and wondering why.

10. The Rage: Carrie 2

The 1976 adaptation of Stephen King's Carrie has some of the most recognisable iconography of any horror film out there. Seeing Sissy Spacek drenched in pig's blood whilst bringing a school prom to its knees with her telekinetic powers was pretty riveting stuff, even if it came with a side of nightmarish horror.

Advertisement

The film and book have since been remade twice - once for TV and once for the silver screen. Before either of those came to being though, did you know Carrie actually had a sequel that was released in 1999?

Though the film carries the subtitle Carrie 2, the link to the original film is deeply tenuous, as it lies solely in the fact that the lead character is the half-sister of Carrie.Indeed, it seems as though this detail has been added solely to cash in on its fanbase. Of the sequels on this list, The Rage is probably one of the least derided. It even grossed $17 million at the box office.

9. American Psycho 2: All American Girl

Where there's a will, there's a way, is a phrase that is probably the best way to describe the production of American Psycho 2. Originally the film's script was called The Girl Who Wouldn't Die, and had absolutely nothing to do with the superb American Psycho we all know and love.

Advertisement

However, as we all know by now, the horror genre is a creative one. The film's creators managed to shoehorn in a Patrick Bateman subplot into the story, thus allowing them to give the film's title a more recognisable name.

What's odd about all of this though is that even though American Psycho was a moderate success ($34 million on a $7 million budget), it was hardly the home run that warranted a ham-fisted sequel like this.

The film follows an aspiring criminology student who picks her fellow students one by one, as they all pose a threat to her securing a job with the FBI. Unsurprisingly, star Mila Kunis has distanced herself from the film, and American Psycho author Bret Easton Ellis denounced its existence.

8. Jack Frost 2: Revenge Of The Mutant Killer Snowman

No, this is not a sequel to the cuddly family film starring Michael Keaton who comes back to life as a snowman after a fatal accident. This is a sequel to the 1997 horror film also called Jack Frost, that marked Shannon Elizabeth's film debut. Both can be argued are better than the Keaton film.

Advertisement

Released in 2000, Jack Frost 2 understandably flew under the radar as we were obviously preoccupied with more pressing dangers such as the millennium bug, and better films like Gladiator. In one of the most unlikely sequels, to one of the most unlikely films, Jack Frost 2 is as bizarre as they come.

After overcoming the murderous snowman Jack Frost, the hero from the first film, Sam, decides to take a vacation to get away from the stress of it all. A holiday to a tropical cabana follows, but that's not all. After an accident involving the remains of Jack Frost (he got melted to death with antifreeze) under FBI watch, Jack comes back to life and now has a telepathic link to Sam, who is now the target of his revenge. Don't even try to comprehend its insanity.

That being said, don't sleep on this utterly absurd and completely bonkers horror that has a snowman go on a killing rampage on a tropical holiday resort of all places. Don't let the 3.7 rating on IMDB fool you, this film is horror B-movie gold.

7. The Birds II: Land's End

Well, you can't help but admire the tenacity to make a sequel to an Alfred Hitchcock classic a whopping thirty-one years after the original film. In 1963, Alfred Hitchcock did what no modern filmmaker could do, release a serious film about killer birds that was effective. If it were attempted today it would likely be a Syfy film in the same vein as Sharknado. Birdnami anyone?

Advertisement

Well for reasons that we all would love to know, a made-for-television sequel was made, and released, and even starred original actress Tippi Hedren in an unrelated cameo to her original role. In the completely original, never been done before story, a family move to a small island for the summer to escape the memory of a family tragedy. Unfortunately their grieving will have to wait, because there be some killer gulls in the sky.

Director Rick Rosenthal released the film under the pseudonym Alan Smithee, a name used by directors to disown the film they've made, which will go someway into helping us understand why you've never heard of this film.

6. Look What's Happened To Rosemary's Baby

Any horror fan worth their grain of salt has seen Rosemary's Baby, the 1968 all time great that tackles gaslighting, pregnancy, and paranoia. By today's standards the film itself may seem a little dull, but it is a work art; one which can be said to be sadly tainted by the very hands that made it.

Advertisement

Now, do those same horror fans know that it received a made-for-television sequel called Look What's Happened to Rosemary's Baby? No, well you're not alone.

Aired in 1976, the film is broken into three segments, and initially takes place 8 years after the events of the first film, and only one member of the original cast returns (Ruth Gordon). If you're hoping for the same layered themes from the original film, don't hold you're breath. The climax of the first segment has a possessed bus that drives itself. Enough said.

Things only moderately improve when seasoned actor Stephen McHattie (Watchmen) stars as an older Adrian in the latter two segments. What makes this forgotten sequel such a shame, is that it was directed by Oscar nominated editor Sam O'Steen. Unsurprisingly his directing career never did take off.

5. Hollow Man II

At the turn of the century the legendary director Paul Verhoeven followed up his acclaimed Starship Troopers film with another foray into the sci-fi genre, this time infused with horror, in the form of Hollow Man. Starring Kevin Bacon, Elizabeth Shue, and even Josh Brolin, the film was a moderate success raking in nearly $200 million at the box office.

Advertisement

Evidently, that was enough of a reason to spawn a very unlikely sequel in Hollow Man II. After all, lightning occasionally strikes twice. Released in 2006, Hollow Man II has invisible murderous assassins, stars Christian Slater, and has a 4.4 rating on IMDB.

Evidently lightning avoided this movie at all costs, probably due to its convoluted story of experiments gone wrong, ridiculous character decisions, and some stuff about assassinating political enemies and other clichéd s. It's a real shame, because Christian Slater is better than this.

Not content with this unexpected sequel nobody asked for, director Claudio Fäh also went on to direct sequels to another franchise you didn't know existed known as Sniper.

4. I'll Always Know What You Did Last Summer

Scream and its subsequent franchise are responsible for many things in the horror genre, most notably by breathing life back into it, and the slasher subgenre, in the 1990s. Literally the very next year after Scream, we saw the release of another slasher in I Know What You Did Last Summer.

Advertisement

Just like Scream, the screenplay was written by Kevin Williamson, and it went on to be a box office success with over $100 million worldwide. With that level of success, we know what happens next... a Sequel!

But we already know about the sequel that followed, because I Still Know What You Did Last Summer still starred both Jennifer Love Hewitt and Freddie Prinze Jr, and still achieved a cinematic release.

However, despite dreadful reviews and a dwindling box office, a third film was made titled I'll Always Know What You Did Last Summer and was released eight years after the last film. The premise is nearly identical to that of the original, and currently has 0% on Rotten Tomatoes. It's most notable achievement, it appeared to launch the career of Sylvain White, director of The Losers and Stomp the Yard.

3. Lost Boys: The Tribe

The Lost Boys, that campy 1980s classic that everyone adores, and if you don't... why? It had everything you could possibly want. Vampires. Mullets. A topless Tim Capello gyrating as he plays the sax whilst seeped in oil. Don't forget about the killer soundtrack too, and a young Alex Winter pre Bill & Ted.

Advertisement

Though, even after all that amazing stuff, one of the best highlights of the film were the Frog brothers, played by the two Corey's, Feldman and Haim. But did you know that there was such a love for this film and those characters that The Lost Boys spawned not one, but two sequels?

Say hello to Lost Boys: The Tribe and Lost Boys: The Thirst. Sadly, both are instantly forgettable sequels compared to the all time classic they spawned from. Corey Feldman anchors both films, with Corey Haim even making a cameo appearance at the end of The Tribe. If you're a fan of vampire flicks, then you might as well get your teeth sunk into them. Lost Boys: The Thirst even has a holy water grenade launcher!

2. Hellraiser: Judgement

It might feel like it's been two decades since we last had a Hellraiser film, but surprisingly that just isn't the case. Adapted from Clive Barker's novella The Hellbound Heart, Hellraiser became a wonderfully weird addition to the horror genre in 1987.

Advertisement

It wasn't a slasher, it wasn't a haunted house film, it was just... Hellraiser. A horror about pain, pleasure, and a box you should absolutely not play with, unless you want your face ripped open by hooks.

Hardcore horror fans will likely be aware that the Hellraiser franchise was actually 8 films long by the time 2005 came to a close, but I'm not sure many people realised it was now actually a franchise consisting of ten films. That's right, there have been ten Hellraiser films.

The latest being Hellraiser: Judgement released in 2018, which went straight to streaming, and is the second film not to have Doug Bradley playing the iconic Pinhead in the entire franchise. Sad times.

1. Return To Sleepaway Camp

Back in 1983, in an age where slashers were king, came a little horror that took place at a summer camp that was not called Friday the 13th. That film was called Sleepaway Camp, and boy is it a diamond in the rough.

Advertisement

It's got a mysterious killer, a horrific scene with a curling iron going somewhere it really doesn't belong, and an ending guaranteed to leave the speechless. It's a true horror classic.

Like all 1980s slashers, two direct to video sequels followed called Sleepaway Camp II: Unhappy Campers and Sleepaway Camp III: Teenage Wasteland. Fun fact about these 2 films, a one Pamela Springsteen starred as the killer in both films, the younger sister of the legendary Bruce Springsteen.

But alas, they're not the sequels you probably didn't know about. The one you probably didn't know about was 2008s Return to Sleepaway Camp, which had Felissa Rose reprise her role as Angela Baker from the original film. It apparently cost $4 million to make, and currently has a 4.2 rating on IMDB, which probably explains a lot.

Advertisement