10 Insane Changes Movie Sequels Made

You can't accuse these sequels of just doing the same thing again.

By Jack Pooley /

Hollywood quite understandably loves making sequels, because the safest bet a studio can make is just producing more of the successful same, right?

Advertisement

Yet not all sequels are merely content to just rehash the same hit formula again and again, and sometimes they do something so specifically insane you have to wonder quite what the hell they were thinking.

These 10 movie sequels - some of them well-received, others absolutely not - made a change to the status quo so unexpected and ridiculous that it damn-near threatened to alienate the fanbase.

In the very least, you can't accuse these films of just going through the successful motions of what came before, even if many of these creative choices were ultimately intensively divisive with fans.

Whether played totally straight or for wink-wink laughs, nobody saw these sequel changes coming, from shamelessly retconning the narrative, to changing the series' genre out of nowhere, and just going way, way harder than the original ever dared to.

These sequels weren't perfect - and in fact, some of them weren't very good at all - but each at least dared to rock the boat and try something different...

10. Luke & Leia Are Actually Siblings - Star Wars: Episode VI – Return Of The Jedi

In the second Star Wars film, The Empire Strikes Back, Princess Leia (Carrie Fisher) famously plants a rather passionate lip-lock on Luke Skywalker (Mark Hamill) in an attempt to prove to Han Solo (Harrison Ford) that she doesn't love him.

Advertisement

This would be all well and good, except for the fact that sequel Return of the Jedi reveals Luke and Leia to be siblings, making that cheeky kiss seem considerably ickier in retrospect.

It's even more questionable given that, after learning the news, Leia tells Luke, "Somehow I've always known," in turn making the unfortunate implication that Leia knew on some level that she was macking her brother at the time.

In reality this awkward change is simply a result of George Lucas not sufficiently planning the Star Wars trilogy out, as Luke and Leia weren't intended to be siblings during production of The Empire Strikes Back.

But as widely mocked as the familial twist is, the franchise has weathered it pretty damn well considering. Imagine how social media would react to a movie sequel inadvertently introducing incest in this day and age.

9. From A Bus To A... Boat? - Speed 2: Cruise Control

Speed is one of the greatest action films of the '90s - a thrilling, white-knuckle spectacle in which LAPD bomb disposal officer Jack Traven (Keanu Reeves) attempts to stop a commuter bus from dropping below 50mph and triggering a bomb planted by a terrorist (Dennis Hopper).

Advertisement

Speed's phenomenal box office success ensured a sequel was fast-tracked into production, and just three years later, Speed 2: Cruise Control was released.

Though it was unfortunate that Keanu Reeves opted not to return - being switched out for Jason Patric as a new character - what truly killed the sequel was the absolutely deranged decision to slow things way, way down.

Rather than simply repeat the bomb-on-bus scenario again, perhaps with multiple buses this time, the screenwriters opted to shift the action to a cruise ship.

And while a runaway cruise liner is no laughing matter, it nevertheless lacks the frantic urgency of a bus rigged to blow, further unaided by the sequel's unintentionally comical, low energy sub-title, "Cruise Control."

Just rehashing the original concept again would've surely turned out much better than this, and at least not cost Fox an eye-watering $160 million to produce.

8. It's Randomly A Spy Movie - Pitch Perfect 3

The first two Pitch Perfect movies delivered exactly what everybody expected - frothy, silly musical comedies centered around a quirky cast of a cappella singers.

Advertisement

But in a wildly unexpected break from the formula, Pitch Perfect 3 took a sharp left-turn into spy comedy caper territory for a large chunk of its runtime.

The musical elements remain, yes, but the story is considerably more outlandish than its predecessors, with the Bellas eventually being reinvented as quasi-secret agents who face off against a mustache-twirling megalomaniacal villain - Fat Amy's (Rebel Wilson) criminal father, Fergus (John Lithgow).

It even culminates in an epic explosion on a boat, which is surely the last thing anybody expected to see in a Pitch Perfect movie of all things.

One suspects the filmmakers wanted to make fun of increasingly, desperately ridiculous sequels, but without much in the way of accompanying wit or humour it just fell embarrassingly flat.

7. Steve Trevor Returns... In Deeply Problematic Fashion - Wonder Woman 1984

When it was announced that Wonder Woman's (Gal Gadot) love interest Steve Trevor (Chris Pine) would be returning in the sequel despite heroically dying in the first film, fans were intrigued to see how writer-director Patty Jenkins would pull it off.

Advertisement

Ultimately Steve is resurrected after Diana makes a wish with the Dreamstone, and while it would've been absolutely fine and dandy for Steve to just materialise out of thin air, Jenkins misguidedly made the whole scenario twistedly problematic.

As it turns out, Steve is instead brought back to life in the body of another man (Kristoffer Polaha), and given that Diana and Steve appear to have sex after this, it opens a whole unpleasant can of worms about consent and what happened to the man's consciousness while his body was effectively hijacked.

Jenkins naturally attempted to downplay the criticisms, but considering it could've been easily avoided by simply having Steve come back to life out of nowhere, it felt like Jenkins truly set herself up to fail with a totally unnecessary controversy.

It's not even the worst thing in the movie, but it is perhaps the most needlessly gross subplot in any major film from recent years.

6. Nunchucks Become Sausages - Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles II: The Secret Of The Ooze

Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles II: The Secret of the Ooze is considerably goofier and more cartoonish than its grittier predecessor, likely in an attempt to combat complaints that the first film was too edgy and in turn maximise the potential box office returns with family audiences.

Advertisement

As such, the sequel's approach to violence was considerably toned down, perhaps best exemplified by a memorable sequence at the start of the movie where Michelangelo (Robbie Rist) fights with sausage links instead of nunchucks.

This was in part a reaction to the first film being cut in the UK to remove nunchucks and other offensive weapons, the filmmakers understandably assuming that something as silly as sausage nunchucks would be considerably more palatable to the trigger-happy censors.

Ironically, though, the UK's BBFC ended up cutting the sausages from the sequel as well, with the hilariously patronising non-logic that the average child wouldn't be able to tell the difference between the sausages and actual nunchucks.

5. Maisie's Mother Is... Herself? - Jurassic World Dominion

Jurassic World: Fallen Kingdom was a boatload of crazy in its own right, namely when it introduced human cloning to the franchise by revealing that young Maisie Lockwood (Isabella Sermon) was a clone of Benjamin Lockwood's (James Cromwell) daughter Charlotte.

Advertisement

But because this apparently wasn't strange and unnecessary enough a plot line for a Jurassic Park movie, the recent follow-up Jurassic World Dominion gave Maisie's origin story a quasi-retcon that somehow went even more unhinged.

In the film, Dr. Wu (B.D. Wong) explains to Maisie that she wasn't only Charlotte's clone, but Charlotte actually also gave birth to Maisie via asexual conception, effectively making Maisie both Charlotte's clone and daughter.

It's a completely bizarre, head-scratching revelation that only saddles poor Maisie with more character baggage that, even more bafflingly, doesn't have any sort of substantial payoff by film's end.

Making Maisie a clone was surely odd enough, but randomly giving her a convoluted new origin story where Charlotte gave birth to her own clone? To what end? Who was this for?

4. From Slapstick Violence To BRUTAL Violence - Home Alone 2: Lost In New York

The first Home Alone was a phenomenal success primarily due to the fun of watching young Macaulay Culkin outsmart two dim-witted thieves with an array of ingenious traps.

Advertisement

Though we as viewers relished seeing Harry (Joe Pesci) and Marv (Daniel Stern) get repeatedly fooled by Kevin (Culkin), the level of violence largely remained within the bounds of slapstick territory.

And while the sequel largely follows the same formula, director Chris Columbus made one notable change outside of the new setting - majorly upping the ante of the violence on display.

There's a markedly meaner streak to Kevin's traps in Home Alone 2, and it's poor Marv who gets the wince-inducing brunt of it. He's hit in the head with bricks four times, suffers a nasty electrocution, falls large distances numerous times, and is hit by many other objects.

He would've been dead several times over.

This isn't to say that Home Alone 2's violence isn't funny, because it is, but the playful pratfalls of the first film are largely substituted out for genuinely gnarly impact shots like we're rarely subjected to in "family friendly" cinema. It certainly didn't hurt the sequel's popularity any, though.

3. Time Travel & Humpback Whales - Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home

Star Trek III: The Search for Spock resurrected Spock (Leonard Nimoy) through rather silly circumstances, but the fourth film said "hold my beer" and took things to a whole other level of insanity.

Advertisement

Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home is most commonly remembered as "the one with the whales," because the plot revolves around - wait for it - the Enterprise crew travelling 300 years back to 1986 to locate two humpback whales which can respond to an alien probe's signal and reverse its destructive effects on Earth. Yup.

A film almost certainly co-written by cocaine, The Voyage Home is nevertheless an undeniably inventive and entertaining Trek sequel - like most even-numbered entries - albeit one that takes the series in a deeply weird direction that could've so easily fallen flat.

Sadly the series' next foray into deeply strange territory - Star Trek V: The Voyage Home's search for God - didn't pan out quite so well.

2. Vanessa Was A Fembot All Along - Austin Powers: The Spy Who Shagged Me

The first Austin Powers ends with Austin (Mike Myers) and Vanessa (Liz Hurley) saving the day, getting married, and heading off on their honeymoon, but the sequel categorically undoes this happy ending in fittingly absurd fashion.

Advertisement

Austin Powers: The Spy Who Shagged Me opens with Austin and Vanessa still on their honeymoon, just as Vanessa is revealed to have been a murderous fembot controlled by Dr. Evil (Myers) all along.

After attacking Austin, she self-destructs, leaving Austin momentarily distraught before euphorically realising that he's single once again.

It's of course played 110% for laughs, but still comes as a genuine surprise considering how legitimately great Myers and Hurley's chemistry was in the first film, and that audiences expected to see them together again throughout the sequel.

It's a great gag though, so perfectly satirising the James Bond franchise's "revolving door policy" for female characters. Further in that vein, Hurley was replaced as Austin's love interest by Heather Graham's Felicity Shagwell for the rest of the film.

1. This Time... It's Personal - Jaws: The Revenge

Because the third Jaws film going the 3D route apparently wasn't daft enough, Jaws: The Revenge decided to make the killer great white shark sentient, implying that it targets the Brody family in an act of revenge for their prior shark-killing actions.

Advertisement

The Revenge also popularised the infamous tagline, "This time... it's personal," which might've worked were the film positioned as a campy, tongue-in-cheek comedy, but as a serious attempt at a horror movie? Absolutely not.

It was quite a leap from the more straight-laced terror of the first three films, and silly enough that the movie's novelisation attempted to rationalise the shark's vengeance quest as - get this - the result of a voodoo curse placed upon it by a witch doctor who has a bone to pick with the Brody family. Yup.

But the movie itself makes no inference to this, and simply decides to have the shark intentionally target those who killed its forebears. As the plot of a sequel to a film nominated for the Best Picture Oscar, that's especially demented.

Advertisement