10 Key Changes We Wish Recent Movies Had Made
Pixar should have killed one of Toy Story 4's iconic characters...
Not every creative decision in movies is the right one. From the outside, we fans can usually stop a stinker from a mile off, even when we're not talking franchises or characters with any kind of longevity. And for film-makers not to see where they've messed up and missed out on a way better movie by such a small margin is sadly frustrating.
Luckily, we're here to point it all out, helpfully.
Some of the movies discussed here were still legitimately great, while others would have been massively better with a few different changes, but the good thing about being an "entitled" movie fan in 2019 is we can change what we want in retrospect. Because sometimes it does feel like we know better...
10. Treat Nick Fury's Eye Injury Better - Captain Marvel
The Nick Fury we see in Captain Marvel is a completely different animal to the one we met in Iron Man and beyond. He was more full of energy, more happy-go-lucky, less seemingly cynical and quicker to humour. The set-up seemed to be that he was going to go through something that would steel his mettle and make him the more stoic figure of the future. We even had an answer for what - the same thing that took his eye.
We'd even been ominously teased about it as future Fury had said the last time he trusted someone he lost an eye. How dark and mysterious was that?! And then in Captain Marvel, it turns out his eye is scratched out by an alien cat-like creature as a gag. All that set-up and it's a nonsense, silly answer that didn't in any way tune into why Fury was so different.
It added nothing to the film and robbed Fury of key development that should have been in there in a serious, reverent way.
9. Leave Out The Kids - It 2
It 2 is too long, but that's not the biggest issue with it. It has its moments - mostly around the grown-up Richie and Eddie - but it's a film so intensely in awe of its own nostalgic eye that its focus is entirely uneven. It's not just that that nostalgia is aimed at the Losers Club's past - it's a nostalgia for its own predecessor, which came out less than 2 years before.
So, the weird result is that we get a film that spends way too long retelling the same story as the first - under the guise of exploring memories forgotten to trauma. And while that's a solid enough idea, it comes at a cost as most of the adult cast are under-nourished and feel like second-class characters to their younger counterparts.
The best solution, though a little savage perhaps, would have been to cut the youngsters entirely and focus on them as adults. No matter how good the cast were, when they get in the way of the narrative progress the film is trying to make, that's a problem. It needed a firmer editing hand.
8. Change The Ending - Yesterday
Yesterday is a weird film. Not just because of who made it and when, but because it has some very weird stipulations to its parallel universe that may or may not be an alternate universe at all. Only it must be, but then how can it be? Confused, that seems to be the intention.
Anyway, the biggest issue for Yesterday is the ending, which should have been changed to the better by being a little more conventional. In films like this, where the hero wakes up in an alternate world and learns a lesson, they're usually invited to return to their own reality and live out those lessons. In Yesterday, Jack reveals his Beatles-theft after meeting John Lennon, who gave up his own dreams for love and a boring life and tells him to do the same to find true happiness.
At that point, Jack should go back to the world where the Beatles existed, prompted by Lennon - who should have been the Christmas Carol, Guardian Angel magical figure - because that's a happy ending on two levels. Not only does he get to be happy, but we get a world where the Beatles, Coca Cola and Harry Potter all exist. Sure, John Lennon doesn't survive, but that's what makes Jack's ending all the more impactful and less... nonsensical.
7. Show The Romance - Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes Of Grindelwald
For all of the complaints levelled at the second Fantastic Beasts movie (many of which were entirely off-base), there was a pretty big issue with it that was all of JK Rowling's own making. Her insistence on the romantic relationship between Dumbledore and Grindelwald had painted the Fantastic Beasts screenwriters into a corner, when they demonstrably didn't want the story to be dominated that way.... Or at least not yet.
Funny thing is, though, those screenwriters were JK Rowling herself. She could and should have been brave enough to explore the true nature of the relationship, because she'd been "brave" enough to out them when it suited her in the aftermath of the Potter novels' release. If you hang that sort of thing over a story and make it very obvious how important it is and yet how incidental it SHOULD have been for your politicised motives, then why not explore it properly?
Not showing it for what it was hurt the film in a completely unnecessary way.
6. Kill Buzz - Toy Story 4
Every Toy Story film so far has been about the fear of mortality and yet not one character has died. This being Pixar - who killed Nemo's mother, Bing Bong and Ellie to fit their ideas of living and a loss of innocence - that lack of a kill count is curious. Sure, you could say that Toy Story is more for kids, but again, this is Pixar, who made a movie for kids about the Afterlife. It's not their style to hold back.
Toy Story 4 in particular should have been more brutal in telling the end of Woody's story and it could have served its most underused character - Buzz Lightyear - WAY better by killing him off. For four movies, Woody has been wrestling with a shapeless fear, presented as one of abandonment or redundancy and in the end, Toy Story 4 lets him get beyond that by giving him the tools to be free and live his life to the full.
The only issue here is that one of the things that inspires him is being rejected again, when he's supposed to believe that's a fact of life. Far more clever would have been reminding Woody about the real fear he has - of DYING or being forgotten (they're the same in this world) - by having his best friend, who's been relegated to second stringer by now, killed off. That would have had way more impact and would have made more sense, giving Buzz an ending as well as Woody.
5. Save Walker - Mission: Impossible - Fallout
The performance - or at least one hairy part of it - might have cost Justice League some credibility points, but Henry Cavill's turn as Agent Walker in Mission: Impossible - Fallout was a revelation. Away from Superman's boy scout sensibilities, he was meaner, arguably even more hulking and way more badass and crucially, he gave Ethan Hunt the formidable opponent he's lacked for a while.
Up until then, Hunt had been facing an organisation with interesting subordinates - he'd never really had someone of equal standing to fight and Walker turned up like his answer to Jaws (Bond, not fish). And like Jaws, he should have been allowed to return in another outing, particularly with two more MI movies announced from Christopher McQuarrie.
Walker was the kind of bad guy fans could really rally behind - far more than Sean Harris' Solomon Lane - and having him return with an even bigger chip on his shoulder would have been wonderful. Killing him off was a mistake that could easily have been avoided.
4. Lose The Other Symbiotes - Venom
For all of its success and the praise levelled at Tom Hardy for his performances as Eddie Brock and Venom, the first stand-alone in Sony's Spider-Verse was a mess. The story was muddled, the presentation dull and the supporting characters ranged from boring to superfluous.
Unfortunately, that definitely went for the symbiotes - including Riz Ahmed and Riot, who was presented as the film's big bad. The performance is ok, given the material, but Carlton Drake is a non-character who doesn't really fit the mad scientist mould and using so many symbiotes at once is wasteful.
Rather than shooting that load, the first film should have cut its losses knowing that Venom was going to overshadow absolutely everyone else and just gone with a human antagonist interested in capturing Brock and experimenting on him. Then you leave the appearance of other symbiotes to the sequel, starting with Carnage who was teased in the post-credits.
3. Bring Arnie Back, Substantially - The Predator
The Predator should have been WAY better than it ended up being. In Shane Black's hands, it should have been a nostalgic, knowing nod to the original that cut loose the silliness of some of the lore around the iconic alien hunter and stuck with a pure focus. It didn't do that and it ended up having a bizarre message about autism in it that was distracting and awkwardly fumbled for profundity.
Even that could have stayed in if they'd gone with a third act twist to really dial up the nostalgia. As was revealed after the film came out, Black's team had approached Arnold Schwarzenegger for a cameo, but he'd turned it down because it was too meagre. But what if they'd offered him something proper to do.
The film SHOULD have revealed the Predator Killer suit that was the final revelation of the movie in the run-up to the climax and it should have also revealed it by having Dutch wear it. Imagine the audience reaction to have Arnie back killing Predators for one last time (even if he died in the process). It's the kind of nostalgic sugar this film aimed for and completely fudged.
2. Focus More On Nikki's Diaries - The Dirt
It's pretty fair to say that The Dirt was... unevenly received by critics, but for Mötley Crüe fans, it was a riot. Their story was easily one of the most notorious in the history of rock and seeing that given true reverence, with a good cast and Netflix's power behind it was a real surprising high point. It wasn't flawless by any means, but it was a damn sight better than it's been given credit for.
That said, what would have served it better - just as with most recent music biopics - is a little less mythologising and a little more raw emotion. We get that Mötley Crüe are outrageous legends, because as fans, we lived their legends too, but the real story for Crüe was the darker stuff. We did get to see SOME of that, particularly around Vince Neil, but Tommy Lee's issues were mostly glossed over and Nikki Sixx's struggles with heroin addiction was only engaged with a tiny amount.
For anyone who has read Sixx's haunting Heroin Diaries, there is a far more compelling, far more important story in there that was largely missing from The Dirt, which would have made it infinitely better.
1. Send Bucky Back With Cap - Avengers: Endgame
Avengers: Endgame was almost the perfect way to sign off the Infinity Saga and definitely a great way to end the stories of Captain America and Iron Man, but it still could have been better.
In more than one case, the film pushes important characters aside in order to give its favourites (Cap and Tony) more space - perhaps to ensure we don't run out of emotions for their big moments, or something. That's why we didn't get a memorial for Black Widow and it's also probably why nobody seemed to care that while Cap got the right end to his story - and a return to the life that was robbed from him - Bucky Barnes, a man afflicted with the same thing with an even more brutal twist in the tale - was left in the future.
Endgame should have reunited Cap and Bucky for one last mission, returning the Infinity Stones and then deciding between them to choose to stay in the past. That way, Cap doesn't look so callous for not even caring about Bucky's loss or how much HE might want to live his stolen life too.
What do you think of these suggestions? Which other recent movies do you think should have changed one thing? Share your reactions below in the comments thread.