There's an expectation in Hollywood that starring in a hugely successful movie - especially if it leads to a franchise - is naturally going to make its leading star one of the most famous working actors overnight. And why not? Surely their contributions are a large part of what made the film successful, fashioning a likeable, entertaining character - most often an every-man - to lead us through this often complicated, larger-than-life world. However, sometimes, for a multitude of reasons, the careers of these familiar faces just never managed to take off; in more than a few cases, you'll likely spot them in a film years later and vaguely recognise them before the penny drops. At which point, you likely ask yourself, "Yikes, what happened?", and wonder how their career trajectory never resulted in a litany of impressive starring roles. Here are 10 leading actors whose careers never took off, and why...
10. Zach Galligan
Zach Galligan's debut role is the one for which he is remembered, as the wholesome, likable Billy Peltzer in Joe Dante's 1984 holiday classic Gremlins. Though starring in a few little-known movies thereafter, it is only really Gremlins and its 1990 sequel where the actor managed to make a mark, and soon thereafter fell off the Hollywood grid altogether, starring in an increasingly forgettable array of films such as Cyborg 3: The Recycler. It's difficult to see why Galligan never made it; he had boyish good looks, charm, and was fortunate enough to star in two extremely popular movies, yet either by virtue of a bad agent or bad luck, he was quickly relegated to D-list status. His most recent starring role was in the unlikely horror sequel Hatchet 3, and though he has received praise for his performance, one can't help but feel like the guy deserves a better fate than that.
9. Mark Hamill
Mark Hamill's career was of course made by his appearing as protagonist Luke Skywalker in the Star Wars franchise, and though it wouldn't be fair to say that he's done nothing since, his cinematic CV is, to be kind, pretty bleak. Starring in a fleet of mostly inconsequential films in the wake of Star Wars, Hamill eventually made a name for himself as one of the industry's most prolific voice-over artists, earning massive acclaim for his brilliant performance as The Joker in a multitude of animated movies and TV shows, as well as some video games. So yes, it's not so much that Hamill hasn't had a storied, solid career, it's just that it didn't end up being in the world of cinema. Still, one has to wonder why the offers didn't come flooding in after Star Wars; perhaps he only received scripts casting him in sci-fi, and he resented this? Or maybe producers realised that, as a live-action actor, the Star Wars films succeeded more in spite of him than because of him (the guy can voice a mean Joker, but his line readings in Lucas' franchise are hardly stellar now, are they?).
8. Keisha Castle-Hughes
Keisha Castle-Hughes blew us all away with her startling performance in the 2002 film Whale Rider, which earned her an Academy Award nomination for Best Actress at the mere age of 12. The expectation was that, as is the hope with most child stars, she would blossom into a similarly brilliant adult actress, though as we all know, that is rarely the case. Castle-Hughes did score a brief role as the Queen of Naboo in Star Wars Episode III, though soon thereafter fell pregnant with her boyfriend's baby, something which garnered huge worldwide media attention (and shamefully, a wealth of ire towards the actress). Sadly, these days her chequered private life tends to garner more press than her movies, and it's been at least two years since she's starred in anything remotely noteworthy (the Australian smash hit Red Dog).
7. Haley Joel Osment
Haley Joel Osment's career trajectory is somewhat similar - minus the whole baby thing - in that he also received an Oscar nomination (for Supporting Actor) in his youth - at 11 years old - and his career took a colossal nose-dive soon thereafter. After a successful effort in Steven Spielberg's ambitious 2001 sci-fi A.I. Artificial Intelligence, Osment's career promptly began to wane, with many attributing it to the fact that puberty caused his physical appearance to change considerably, and he was no longer the cute young boy he once was. Osment is largely relegated now to voicing Sora in the Kingdom Hearts games and starring in a litany of films that nobody watches. His recent run-ins with the law - for driving drunk and drug possession - have no doubt done little to help his career.
6. Linda Blair
At the age of 15, Linda Blair received an Oscar nomination in the Supporting Role category for her unforgettable performance as Regan in William Friedkin's masterful supernatural horror The Exorcist. The problem is that delivering one of cinema's all-time most iconic performances essentially caused her to become typecast, and subsequently she largely played in Exorcist sequels and parodies that required her to provide a cameo appearance. Sure, she has appeared in her fair share of horror films over the years, but none that have fashioned a memorable new character for her; the feeling coming out of it is always, "Oh, it's that girl from The Exorcist." Given that the latest entry on her filmography is a TV film and her first work in 5 years, I think it's safe to say that her star has well and truly faded for good.
5. Max Schreck
Max Schreck was an actor who so perfectly embodied the German Expressionism movement of the 1920s, and though he did in fact work on nearly 40 films throughout his life, there is only one for which even ardent cineastes really remember him, as the villainous vampire Count Orlok in F.W. Murnau's Nosferatu. The film, frequently cited as one of the greatest horrors ever made, relied on creepy chiaroscuro lighting and Schreck's terrifying performance to cement this status. Throughout the remaining 14 years that he continued to work in cinema post-Nosferatu, Schreck never managed to gain esteem with a regard anywhere near that of his signature role, and perhaps this is in part because the role required so much make-up, rendering his actual likeness virtually unrecognisable.
4. Joseph Fiennes
Taking the cake in the "unlucky younger brother" stakes is Joseph Fiennes, who has never been able to escape from under the shadow of his Harry Potter-starring brother Ralph, and has pretty much been relegated to starring in TV shows (albeit a few crackers like Flashforward and American Horror Story). However, his career began promisingly, playing William Shakespeare in the Best Picture Oscar winner Shakespeare in Love. It's a role that naturally should have shot him to the top of the Hollywood A-list, yet all that followed was a supporting turn in Enemy at the Gates, and then a steady decline in notoriety. He was once a BAFTA nominee, and now he's starring in the likes of the shoddy Camelot, which is essentially where movie stars go to die (with the exception of Eva Green, perhaps).
3. Patrick Fugit
There's a certain irony in the fact that Patrick Fugit's only notable starring role is as William Miller in the brilliant Almost Famous, given that the guy seemed to essentially be on the cusp of becoming a hot young star, but then seemed to pretty much completely fall off the map, starring in only a small number of films, none of which were either big box office players nor particularly meaty roles. It reached an all-time low-point when he appeared in the dreadful 2009 horror flick Horsemen in a supporting role; going from a critically-lauded performance in Almost Famous to that? What a shame, and what a waste of talent. Though a supporting performance in We Bought a Zoo was his most high-profile role since Almost Famous, it appears to have done little re-ignite the actor's career; his pending CV does not seem particularly compelling.
2. Peter Billingsley
A Christmas Story is a superb holiday film, in large part because of Peter Billingsley's riveting performance as protagonist Ralphie Parker, yet the young actor was never really able to find a niche for himself as an adult, and his career dive-bombed soon thereafter. It baffles the mind that a youngster so popular - especially with American audiences - could disappear out of the limelight so fast, starring in a litany of uninspired TV shows and inconsequential productions. Nowadays, he appears to have transitioned into the world of movie producing, acting as executive producer on Zathura, The Break-Up, Iron Man and Four Christmases. Furthermore, he also directed the admittedly rather dreadful romantic "comedy" Couples Retreat...
1. Maria Falconetti
Maria Falconetti gives what is frequently cited as one of the all-time greatest movie performances in Carl Theodor Dreyers supremely iconic 1928 silent film The Passion of Joan of Arc, all the more impressive because it relies almost solely on her pained facial expressions. It may not be the most exciting picture ever assembled, but in closing so intimately on Falconetti's face, we're able to feel the anguish of her character's plight; it is an instance of an actress completely throwing herself into her performance. To be fair, Falconetti is one of the few instances on this list who did not seem to yearn for a prolific career; this was her sole major film, and after that she returned to the theater, apparently preferring that method of performance. It's a shame, though; on the strength of this performance, she could have been one of the all-time greats, and her indelible place in cinema history nevertheless is perhaps a testament to how fantastic she is here. Which disappeared lead actor do you wish had a more prosperous career? Let us know in the comments below.